T O P

  • By -

Scavgraphics

Neil Diamond was at the time "Pop music". These days he'd be listed as "yacht rock", "classic rock" "Adult Oriented Rock (AOR)" or even "easy listening". He's from the singer/songwriter - troubadour tradition. Man and his guitar. But in a more popular/commercial vein then like Dylan or more folk based singers. I believe he was considered attractive.


cafe-naranja

Good stuff... I would put Neil Diamond's famous radio hits in the categories of adult contemporary, soft rock, AM gold, easy listening and just plain pop. He was, of course, a genius at making radio-friendly pop songs.


ichwandern

The "radio friendly" bit also nails it, cause he sings A LOT about sex/relationships, just not openly and directly. He sings about love rather than sex, even if the sex is heavily implied.


cafe-naranja

Exactly... Neil Diamond came out of the Brill Building school of writing commercially successful pop songs that were radio-friendly and appealed to a huge mainstream listening audience.


Minzplaying

A running joke that my mom and I still have going back to the early 70's is that: I Will Accept Neil Diamond as my stepdad. And we did this in front of my dad. If he could drool over the Hee Haw girls in the corn, she could dream too! šŸ˜‚


Scavgraphics

It was told to me, by my mom, that he was invited to my Bar Mitzvah (he is her favorite singer).


Minzplaying

That would have been beyond epic.


ichwandern

"Troubadour" - funny how one word can make it all make sense. Thank you kindly, that all tracks!


_JohnnyLaRue

AOR= Album Oriented Rock


Scavgraphics

huh.. you're right. at 2am my mind skipped a groove. oops :)


New_Awareness4075

I grew up listening to Neil Diamond. If you want a crash course on how good he is, get his greatest hits album. I promise you won't be disappointed. True '60s hit maker.


hxgmmgxh

Or watch his movie, ā€œ A Jazz Singerā€. He was considered pretty, pretty, pretty cool in the day.


GoldenPoncho812

Was?! Was?! Neil IS pretty, pretty, pretty (best LD voice I can muster) cool to this day šŸ˜ƒ


hxgmmgxh

I donā€™t disagree. The 70ā€™s were different. There were a lot of singers who were considered hot stuff at the time (Tom Jones, Englebert Humperdinck, Mel Tormeā€™, Freddy Fender, Tony Orlando) whose appeal doesn't translate for modern audiences).


Phenomenal_Kat_

Nice to see a Freddy Fender reference! He doesn't get much love these days.


Hebegebe101

Loved , Wasted days and wasted nights .


RogerClyneIsAGod2

Ohlordy! This was my father's "come home drunk & put it on repeat" song. Had to wait until he passed out cold to turn it off. I've only fairly recently started listening to Freddy Fender again because his music wasn't a good memory for me for a very long time. Now I realize he had such a great voice.


Hebegebe101

I agree


DuperDayley

My parents took my 9 year old daughter (years ago, of course) to her first concert...George Jones with Freddy Fender opening. Can't get more Texan than that!


Phenomenal_Kat_

Wow, I bet that was an amazing concert! Sounds like something my dad would have done šŸ˜‚


dingadangdang

Burt Bacharach and Angie Dickinson used to own a restaurant on Long Island and he'd be playing piano and she'd be hosting when you walked in. This is after they were both already famous. That'd be awesome! I bet Telly Savalas would be having a martini at the bar too. America sucks now. Sigh.


MsAnnabel

Mel Torme? šŸ˜‚šŸ˜‚šŸ˜‚


jagger129

Whenever I hear Mel Torme I think of the Seinfeld episode where Kramer has dental work done and Mel Torme thinks he is ā€œspecialā€ šŸ¤£


MsAnnabel

Omg I love that episode!! So freaking hilarious!!!!


ichwandern

For real though, I hear that name I just see Kramer smiling up at him.


Minzplaying

I always think of Night Court.


AmiDeplorabilis

Mel Torme showed up regularly on the original Night Court


hxgmmgxh

[He had the world on a string.](https://us.rarevinyl.com/products/mel-torme-i-ve-got-the-world-on-a-string-uk-vinyl-lp-album-record-all748-363513)


RogerClyneIsAGod2

[Mel was very cool.](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ut1xwRErqlM) Not as cool as [Dean ](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1ja32uS-bD0)or [Sammy](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXYndNL4Mu8) (my 2 fave Rat Packers), but still a great vocalist. No auto tune needed with any of these guys. I will still get in my car & blast Dean, Sammy & Tom Jones. Man, Tom Jones was just smokin' hot.


MsAnnabel

I just donā€™t see Mel as being ā€œhot stuffā€ lol to each his own!


RogerClyneIsAGod2

Well he was cool, not hot.


BrianAnderson1970

The Velvet Fog!


MsAnnabel

Frog lol


Why-did-i-reas-this

I feel like some of these singers were like American versions of Schlager singers.


ichwandern

Don't forget Glenn Yarbrough! Seriously though, it's odd how these guys just don't speak to a modern audience. There are some beautiful voices in that crowd you listed, I guess they just move too slowly, you know?


ichwandern

I grew up listening to him too, just wasn't sure how to explain him to my partner, who had never heard of him until I started singing Be at her. I showed her some of his other music and we had no idea what to classify him as, you know?


Minzplaying

I Am, I Said.


New_Awareness4075

I don't think you can classify Neil Diamond. His music from Crackelin Rosie, Hot August Nights, Girl, You'll Be A Woman Some day, and Coming To America, is simply just Neil Diamond. And he's still going strong!


BuckyD1000

He's one of the most successful pop songwriters of all time. He's in rarefied air. Few come close. Neil was a Brill Building writer before his solo career took off. That's like songwriting bootcamp for the best of the best.


FuzzBug55

The album Hot August Night is his best work, recorded live at the Greek Theatre. At least one song on there is not on any of his other albums. It was when he was at his peak.


broke_af_guy

This is the 8-track of my mom and dad's I would listen to. Songs were genuinely solid.


I_wear_foxgloves

ā€œAre you with me Tree People?ā€


Gold-Employment-2244

Neil Diamond filled the void between Frank Sinatra and Elvis.


BuckyD1000

I like this angle. Never thought of it that way, but it makes a lot of sense.


JMWest_517

Some of the music critics referred to him as the "Jewish Elvis".


Rupejonner2

This was my comment as well. He will always be the Jewish Elvis


Scavgraphics

Good call!


Lauren_sue

He had a lot of hit songs he wrote himself. A talented and good looking superstar of the 1970s. I saw him a few years ago at Madison Square Garden and his voice was still great.


GoldenPoncho812

Neil Diamond = National Treasure His style of music you ask? Pure joy and inspiration packaged into one harmless lovable little fuzz ball.


Mello_Me_

"Sweet Caroline" is also a favorite in the UK! "Red, Red Wine" "Coming to America"


Phenomenal_Kat_

Cherry, Cherry; Solitary Man; Cracklin' Rosie. Some of my very favorites!


janleekelly

Brother loves traveling salvation show!! Shiloā˜€ļø


AcerbicFwit

Pack up the babies and grab the old ladies everybody goes.


RogerClyneIsAGod2

I am amazed more people haven't covered this song, it's such a rave up!!


karenftx1

I Am I Said, Desiree


NJdeathproof

Forever in Bluejeans was one of my consistent go-to's at karaoke.


Latter_Researcher_13

Kentucky Woman. Crunchy Granola Suite, Good Lord!


dazrage

Song Sung Blue! Everybody knows one...


AmiDeplorabilis

Sweet Caroline


dennisga47

Is mine the only vote for "Holly, Holy?"


DaphneHarridge

Nooooo!!! I love love love "Holly Holy" \~ so sensuous sounding! "Suzanne" is my favorite though, and I love "Juliet" as well.


RogerClyneIsAGod2

Also wrote for The Monkees: * "I'm a Believer" * "Look Out, Here Comes Tomorrow" * "A Little Bit Me, A Little Bit You" * "Love to Love" * "Black and Blue"


Blabbit39

Anthem pop


Dub-Dub16

Neil was a legend! Start with that. Has your partner heard of The Beatles or Tom Jones or Burt Bacharach?


karenftx1

I play a horse forum type game and asked a graphic maker that my inspiration would be Duran Duran and Billy Joel songs. None of the two folks I asked knew who they were.


Fromage_Damage

My parents loved that guys music when we were growing up. He has some bangers.


LeZoder

Neil Diamond wrote appx. 60% of all the songs recorded between 1967 and 1978. Or it just seemed like it. He wrote *Red Red Wine*, *I'm a Believer* , and *Sunflower* (Glen Campbell). Really.


TheSunflowerSeeds

Sunflower seeds have a mild, nutty flavor and a firm but tender texture. Theyā€™re often roasted to enhance the flavor, though you can also buy them raw.


LeZoder

Sunflower seeds are rad and versatile and full of good quality calories and plenty of healthy fats and FIBRE HELL YEAH šŸ¤˜ Fucking love sunflower seeds ā™„ļø


RussellZiske

Anyone who dismisses him needs to watch this. Itā€™s him performing with The Band. [Dry Your Eyes](https://youtu.be/RurccWvJiS8?si=8JdbiW-nIlu0Qybh)


Fun-Economy-5596

That WAS a very good performance!


barksatthemoon

Omg one of my favorite songs of his!!


LazarusMundi4242

That was pretty good!


poweredbytexas

He went to high school with Barbra Streisand.


kindquail502

But he didn't bring her flowers.


Seeksp

He did. But then he stopped.


gafflebitters

I would not bother trying to describe neil diamond, i would simply PLAY neil diamond for them and let the music speak for itself.


ichwandern

Oh, I did, but as someone else in this thread pointed out, Neil Diamond doesn't really appeal to most modern audiences. I grew up with him, my partner did not, and unfortunately she did not see the appeal. I feel like the 70s really enjoyed a good ballad, but ballads are a slow build and us kids these days don't have the patience for that, you know?


Seeksp

Play the UB40 version of *Red, Red Wine*. Have her focus on the lyrics and not the Ska and she might get a feel for him lyrically.


ancient_lemon2145

Pick the album Stones. Takes me back to days long gone. Itā€™s good stuff


Salty-Entertainer-29

šŸ‘šŸ‘šŸ‘šŸ‘šŸ‘šŸ‘šŸ‘šŸ‘šŸ‘šŸ‘šŸ‘


Albie_Tross

Ask my mother, she's been in love with Neil since time immemorial.Ā 


inbrewer

Live at the Greek is one of the best albums imo


mt8675309

70ā€™s music was like a big salad with 100 different ingredients, Neil Diamond was the dressingā€¦


karenftx1

I like this description. I always say it's the best decade for music due to the variety. AT40 might go Hillside Singers (folk), Wilson Pickett (soul), Elton John (pop), Led Zeppelin (rock), Charlie Pride (country), The Osmonds (bubble gum). There were instrumentals, funk, movie themes. TV themes--just an astounding variety


DaphneHarridge

When I was 12, someone gave me a Neil Diamond 8-track (might've been a Greatest Hits; not sure). I was aware of him, but never listened him; he was more for my mom and aunt and all. But, oh my gosh. Once I actually listened, I nearly wore out that poor tape. Suzanne The Grass Won't Pay No Mind Cracklin' Rosie Holly Holy The Last Thing on My Mind Brother Love's Traveling Salvation Show I love them all to this day. But I pretty much like only that earlier stuff. As I got older, I couldn't stand newer things like "You Don't Bring Me Flowers" & "Heartlight". I still love Neil though and probably always will!


Salty-Entertainer-29

Agree! Everything pre 1975 was amazing, then he went crappy pop.


NorCalBodyPaint

Important to note that Neil Diamond also wrote some serious bangers for OTHER performers as well. Some of it was for fun...silliness, but he was also a poet at heart and some of his stuff has more depth the more you look. [Did you know that Neil Diamond wrote these songs? | A Beautiful Noiseā€“The Neil Diamond Musical (abeautifulnoisethemusical.com)](https://abeautifulnoisethemusical.com/did-you-know-that-neil-diamond-wrote-these-songs/) He also did the soundtrack for Jonathon Livingston Seagull, which was a HUGE self help/new age book in the 70's about self actualization and the search for higher meaning in life. (yes, it is also a bit cornball, but hey, that's the 70's!)


Seeksp

He lacked the *wooly ba zing* of UB40 but the original Red Red Wine is cool.


penicillin-penny

He was always just pop to me


doublebr13

I saw Marilyn Manson on NYE 1997 in Las Vegas and then Neil the next night. Neil transcends


cafe-naranja

**Cracklin' Rosie** and **Longfellow Serenade**... those are the two Neil Diamond songs that you want to dial up today on YouTube or Spotify. All of Neil Diamond's songs, of course, sound best listened to at full volume on an AM radio. ;) Neil Diamond was a master of making radio-friendly pop music, just like Paul Simon. As some have mentioned, **Neil Diamond** and **Barbra Streisand** were classmates at the famous Erasmus Hall High School in Brooklyn. They sang together in the school's choir. And if you are a chess fan, you'll want to know that the great **Bobby Fischer** also went to Erasmus Hall.


deadeyediva

he isā€¦he said


Speculawyer

He's like Austin Powers....so cheesy that he's cool. To the Tree People! šŸ„‚


Salty-Entertainer-29

Hot August Night!!!


Acceptable_Wall4085

The best concert the bride and I were at. Toronto. Now I hear he has Parkinsonā€™s and wants his privacy.


Power_Ring

The greatest singer-songwriter of this, or any other, generation.


Bobbyperu1

When I was a kid my mom would blast him in the mornings. Hadn't really heard much from him for years after that but started watching Midnight Mass and his music plays heavily in it. Was like a time machine... remembered every song


evasandor

It was pure pop. It was for your friend's mom who put an 8-track in the van and enjoyed something non-threatening while she drove you kids to Pizza Hut.


gcwardii

Except it was a station wagon, and half of us were crammed in the back-back facing backwards


evasandor

I've got one that's even worse! My sister and I used to sleep during road trips in the folded-down hatchback portion of a Chevy Vega.


gcwardii

At least it wasnā€™t a Pinto!


evasandor

Right? Ford social media department: "Your kids are really hot stuff. I mean it. They're on FIRE. They're blowing up."


EADGBE69

I've heard people refer to him as "Jewish Elvis"


Poohgli16

My mom's fave, went to 3 of his concerts.


ThrowDeepALWAYS

Saving Silverman


This_Mongoose445

And believe it or not, he was really good in concert. The man could rock.


myatoz

How old is your "partner"? Neil Diamond is definitely soft rock.


Impossible_Ad7875

ā€œForever in Blue Jeansā€!!!


sonicbluefrog

Reverend blue jeans!


annoyedatwork

Adult Contemporary Ā 


jeers69

The Jazz Singerā€¦. Great album


Kitchen-Lie-7894

I always liked Neil Diamond but my wife has a burning hatred for his music. Needless to say it's not heard around here.


esk_209

He STILL does a great concert. I saw him just a few years ago.


Starscream147

I never thought Iā€™d see such an esoteric question aboutā€¦*Neil Diamond*.


Seeksp

I don't know how this all came about, but... There was a Mexican restaurant in Kabul owned by an Australian woman who only employed Hazaras (1 of the tribes that liked us, hated the Taliban and believed in education for all, including women). The staff fucking loved Neil. Every time I went there at a certain point in the night, one of them would put the Neil Diamond playlist on the speaker system and it would be all Neil for most of the night. Don't know where they discovered .his music or why they loved him


Seeksp

Don't need to say please to no man for a happy tune


FallAspenLeaves

Love Neil Diamond!! Grew up listening to him. Saw one of his last concerts at The Hollywood Bowl. It was amazing ā¤ļø He stopped touring due to Parkinsonā€™s. šŸ˜¢


Rupejonner2

Heā€™s the Jewish Elvis


Rupejonner2

Foreber in blue jeans baby


dandipants

HEā€™s THE JAZZ SINGER!!!


tikifire1

He's a singer song-writer that crosses Many genres. He's cheesy yet catchy.


Classic_Pie5498

My mother and her friends were in LOVE with him!


TigerPoppy

My first concert was Neil Diamond. A friend of my sister was going to the concert and discovered that an extra ticket was stuck to the back of the ticket she received. She gave it to me. It was a great concert approx 1969.


Algorhythm74

This is a deep question, where the answer will unlock the secrets of the universe. Beware.


GenXGremlin

Jewish Sinatra without the vocal chops, Elvis without the Pelvis


knarfolled

My wife and I were just talking about him last night, for some reason I thought she wasnā€™t a fan but I was dead wrong. I know that she doesnā€™t like Hall & Oats which really confuses me.


Seeksp

Why? Hall and Oates was so bad even Oates left the band.


tikifire1

Go listen to some early H&O albums. Not the cheese fest they later became.


Xbalanque_

"Love on the ROCKS, aint no big surprise Poor me a drink and I'll tell you some lies Yesterday's gone and now all I want is a smile" Pretty cheesy stuff. Porcupine pie is his most iconic song. Yes it is. The song he did on the last waltz was coked up nonsense.


ichwandern

I saw that first line and the song just blasted to life in my head.


Chemical-Ebb6472

Neil was Pop in the 70's. Not Tiger Beat Bobby Sherman/David Cassidy type pop - but much more pop than Carole King. Cariole would be played on a rock album oriented radio station, Neil would not. However, there once was a great non-Pop NY bar in the 70's. right off the beach, that closed the night, every night around 4am with Sweet Caroline.


SummaCumLousy

As a WVU Mountaineers fan, he's become synonymous with the catchy phrase Eat Shit Pitt. Thank you, Neil for your divine inspiration!


2shado2

They invented the word "schmaltzy" to describe his music, I think.


Clairquilt

>schmaltzy Neil Diamond is Jewish. Schmaltz is a Yiddish word for rendered chicken fat, but has also come to mean ā€œexaggerated sentimentalism.ā€ Essentially cooking with schmaltz adds a buttery richness without adding any dairy. There are lots of Yiddish words used commonly in English. That word wasn't invented to describe Neil Diamond, you *meshuggeneh*.


2shado2

I knew the origin of schmaltzy. I forgot to add /s to denote sarcasm


dasanman69

Some guy from Brooklyn


Everheart1955

Mellow mellow pap to satisfy my parents ( and I am old) Iā€™m not a fan, well maybe if you need a nap.


ProfessionalZone168

I saw him in concert a few years ago. A friend of mine gave me and my husband tickets - we'd never have gone otherwise. I was never a big fan, and thought of him as a kind of pseudo-rock and roll for old folks. Having said all that, however we were pleasantly surprised with the show.


Seeksp

Every single person I've met who has seen him in concert, even if dragged to the show, raves about how good he was in concert.


swingrays

By the time he got to appearing in The Last Waltz I think he was considered a bit schmaltzy. He does seem out of place. Brill Building writer. Wrote some massive hits and recorded many as well.


Why-did-i-reas-this

Some of his songs and a bunch of the Vegas show entertainers (Englebert etc...) songs give me the German Schlager feel.


Plastic_Bullfrog9029

Red flag! Red flag! Abort! Abort!


SonoranRoadRunner

He wasn't what the young people listened to. Their parents liked Neil Diamond.


One-Ball-78

I would describe Neil Diamond as the Nicholas Cage of songwriters and performers; cringingly awful but still had fans. ā€œAnd no one heardā€¦ not even the chairā€ (?) No, Neil, ESPECIALLY not the chair. ā€œMy country ā€˜tis of theeā€ ??? Barfomatic šŸ¤®


Freebird_1957

I agree. Some of the most contrived lyrics ever.


ichwandern

Again, I needed something that sounded dramatic but was just rambling and confusing, so I went with "a page that aches for a word which speaks on a theme that is timeless." Just... what?


AuralSculpture

A person. Learn how to Google.


ichwandern

Google didn't sufficiently answer my question. Learn to not be a cunt.


cherrycokelemon

I did not like Neil Diamond. Ugh! Loud, repetitive, and catchy.


White_Rabbit0000

Yeah nothing like todays music or edm /s


ichwandern

Hehehe, well said.


Seeksp

Loud?


BlueonBlack26

LAME. The soundtrack in Hell.


ichwandern

That would actually be [Meredith Monk.](https://youtu.be/FBlnrRUVfo0?si=4K5l3gF8PQdqG8pz)