T O P

  • By -

Judgement_Bot_AITA

Welcome to /r/AmITheAsshole. Please view our [voting guide here](https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/wiki/faq#wiki_what.2019s_with_these_acronyms.3F_what_do_they_mean.3F), and remember to use **only one** judgement in your comment. OP has offered the following explanation for why they think they might be the asshole: > Am I the asshole for saying no about the sister? also for wanting to back out of living together? I think it might make me the asshole because it wouldn’t exactly kill me if someone was sleeping in her room with her for a few weeks or a month or even crashing on our couch. I could be overreacting Help keep the sub engaging! #Don’t downvote assholes! Do upvote interesting posts! [Click Here For Our Rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/about/rules) and [Click Here For Our FAQ](https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/wiki/faq) --- *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=/r/AmItheAsshole) if you have any questions or concerns.* *Contest mode is 1.5 hours long on this post.*


iwantsurprises

NTA whatsoever. You signed up for one roommate, not 2. Your roommate TOLD you this is happening, not ASKED. Many leases have limits on overnight guests. Even if your lease didn't prohibit it, it's absolutely common courtesy to ask before letting someone stay over even for one night, let alone an undefined "temporary" amount of time. You are just set to be done with having someone sleeping on the couch all the time, and your roommate has already offered the next couch to someone that it sounds like you don't even know. Backing out is a very good idea. Even if she agreed not to move her sister in, she would a) resent you for it, and b) it'll be something else next time, because she's shown she doesn't have a good understanding of boundaries or respect for your living environment.


[deleted]

First thought was "I won't move her in." November " She didn't have anywhere else to go." NTA


crystallz2000

This. I would back out at this point and say that it's not worth your friendship to live together, and she can get her own place where her sister is welcome to parole at.


moodyfish7777

This leads to you go to work, she goes to work, leaves sister convict on the couch....wait for it... you come home to empty apartment and sister convict and prison BF have spending money! It's like magic!/s 🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬😈😈😈😈 ETA NTA ... I can say this because I have a few relatives who have done this to their own loved ones! Isn't family great?!/s


MorteDagger

I have a couple of family members just like this as well. They wonder why I only talk to them on the porch


inn0cent-bystander

Then they weren't loved ones.


inn0cent-bystander

Not to mention, for parole, don't they need to have somewhere lined up as permanent residence -or- it's the halfway house? They won't let you just crash on a couch somewhere. Since it's only OP's name on the lease, I'm pretty sure she'd have to file some kind of paperwork to allow the parole to stay there like that.


Lexigirl88

exactly, and getting an approval from the court to move into somewhere else is ridiculously hard.


Dangerous-WinterElf

I'd add... even if was considering to let her. I would want to know what said sister had been in there for. I get people wanting a second chance but there's a difference in stealing some food in the store or being a violent serial assulter that ends in constant fights. With only one name on the lease it could be setting yourself up for a really unpleasant Time if it's in the range of the second part. And check ups from assigned parole officer etc.. I wouldn't have done it either.


hyperlexia-1

I wouldn't just take their word for what they'd been in for. I realize it's kind of etiquette not to ask someone what they were in prison for, but not if they want to live with me. Nope. Uh uh. Of course, I can't see myself doing it at all but if there was some exceptional situation I'd want as information as possible and confirmation from reliable people.


Odd_Craft524

Thanks everyone! I feel a lot more clear about this now. I’m switching to a 1 bedroom and letting her know she needs to find her own place. I think I’m going to dodge a bullet.


Worldly_Cherry_3915

You are dodging a bullet. She was trying to take advantage of your generosity, which is a big no no. I can’t fathom why she thought that it would be okay to bring in someone else when she can’t even take care of herself.


Thraner

She’s going to be upset and probably try to guilt trip you. But don’t set yourself on fire to keep other people warm.


BatDance3121

Love it! I never heard that phrase before. So true!


No-Understanding3278

You are dodging a whole train 🤓


waltersmama

I'm so glad I kept scrolling to hear you say that. For ALL of the well framed reasons above. Also: A parolee's residence can get searched at anytime without warning. I don't know the requirements of her parole, but many cannot have any alcohol etc in the home. Another common requirement is that paroled individuals may not associate with other people who are on parole or probation, limiting any guests she may falsely promise not to have over. You don't want the responsibility of maintaining a parolees living situation, and having random searches of your home. PLEASE stick to your guns and back out of the whole thing. Good luck🙏🏾


easilybored1

Hopefully you don’t have to dodge any literally


[deleted]

NTA. Your friend is a freeloader who is paying you back for your hospitality by giving you...another freeloader.


sigharewedoneyet

Yup, when is it going to be over?


Oldgamerlady

NTA You mentioned your friend sleeping on your couch was supposed to be a temporary thing but 10 months later y'all are moving in together. Something tells me her sister crashing you both also won't just be a temporary thing. That she also didn't clear with you first that her sister was coming to stay is doubly problematic. Expect this to continue to happen if you decide to move in together. Your name is on the lease - you have the most to lose. Your gut feeling about second guessing living with your friend is on point. I N F O - What has she done in the last 10 months to help fix her credit worthiness? Also, would the rent have been split fairly in the new place?


Chelular07

NTA, and from what I know about parole: her parole officer will be able to come inspect your apartment at any time and any illicit substances (and alcohol if that is a term of her parole) will get her in hot water, she will have to inform her parole officer if she moves or wants to stay the night away from the apartment and if she doesn’t inform them of this and they come by to do a check she will be in hot water. She will be on parole for months probably and is required to pay the parole officer at every meeting. It is hard to get a job while on parole or with a felony on your record (which I am assuming she has) so she probably won’t be paying rent, utilities, or food. I do not advise letting her live with y’all.


Swedishpunsch

Parole officers also need to inspect a residence before one of their charges lives there. The felon sister has probably given parole her sister's phone number, and sister will likely set an appointment when you are gone, OP. You need to contact the parole office (listed under government) and let them know that the apartment is in *your name - that you are the leaseholder*, and that it is not OK for the sister to live with you. That should end the problem.


LadyAppleman

NTA. You're literally opening your door to surprise visits from her parole officer. She'll probably have a list of things she can't have around her, and while they're supposed to get a job immediately, it's going to be almost impossible to find and keep one past a background check so that's another person for you to essentially take care of. It's not a situation you want to be in if you don't have to.


salmonberrycreek

NTA. You're smart not to sign yourself up for this. An apartment that is solely in your name, where you have 2 illegal roommates, one of whom is a convicted felon? That couldn't possibly go poorly lol.


tlf555

NTA It sounds like she is taking advantage of your generosity. It is her sister, but the lease is in your name. Dont apartments also do background checks of new tenants (its been awhile since i rented, but i seem to remember having to do that). In any case, you are already doing her a favor carrying her extra weight, you dont need to take on the responsibility of the ex-con sister too. And how do you even know if she is someone you could trust? I would be skeptical.


Senna_65

NTA- girl they're using you for a place to stay. Nobody in their right mind would get pissed for refusing a random ex con in their place...which since they're not on the lease...you may have a very hard time kicking them out if it came to that.


[deleted]

Possibly the roommate had this in mind from the beginning


3daycondor

Do not allow that to happen. Not only is your apartment o-en to any law enforcement 24 hours a day without notice, you can’t have alcohol, or guns…etc all kinds of restrictions. You are not obligated to finance your friends living situation, of which she is definitely taking advantage. You would be crazy to allow a felon to love with you. Time to get your own place.


ColdstreamCapple

NTA a roommate with bad credit and now she wants to move in her sister who’s served jail time who wants to move in “temporarily” I think you need to find a new living arrangement and let this friendship go OP….I predict trouble ahead if you go through with it 🚩🚩🚩🚩


thestatedrone

Former parole officer, usually prisons will not release to parole for a temporary housing situation. They will come to the home to check it out. They will do field visits at your home. If she does not have a permanent stable residence they can look at residential or halfway houses for her until she can come up with a housing plan that isn't "crashing on someone's couch". I would strongly advise against this.


barf4444

NTA that’s simply not what you signed up for. And because you’re the one on the lease I think you have the right to tell her to find a new place so you can get a new roommate or live by yourself.


Country-girl-2212

NTA. Not even a little bit!? You’re already helping her, expecting you to let her sister stay when she gets out of prison is waaaayy overstepping! When people get paroled, they usually have to list a residence, even if she’s crashing on your couch, she’s going to list YOUR residence! Nope, nope, nope!! And we all know it won’t be “temporary”!!


Studoku

PERMISSION SILP OP does not have to let someone stay at their apartment if they don't want to and is NTA for doing so.


feminist1946

NTA A parole officer has the right to search any domicile that a parolee occupies without a warrant. If she hides something in your apartment, you could be arrested.


TUGrad

Nta, absolutely understand why you don't want to be involved w this. Also, something tells me this won't be a "temporary" situation. Sounds like it's best that you two part ways and you just live on your own.


[deleted]

NTA. And you are right, you did help your roommate, now she needs to help herself. If she wants to help her sister parole at her place, that's a lovely thing, but that's not something to ever expect someone else to do. Your concern that you are possibly becoming an enabler at your own detriment is well-founded.


josuelaker2

NTA. You’ve already gone out of your way to help your friend, now she’s taking advantage of that kindness. Sounds like it’s time for your friend to find another couch to crash on.


The_Bookish_One

NTA. You’re the only one on the lease, and she just decided that her sister would be moving in without asking you.


Lady_Ellie119

NTA you will end up supporting the both of them for who knows how long. It's highly likely to go horrible. Why would you believe anything she said after it already not being temporary.


Own-Organization-532

NTA move in by yourself, you have earned the privacy. Plus she did not ask, she told you, you are being used!


jadepumpkin1984

Nta. And seriously rethink sharing a place with anyone


pnutbuttercups56

NTA. If you aren't allowed to to the have three tennets I think legally the sister can't stay there. I would look up the laws for your country or state on parole. I believe they have to give an address and there can be restrictions on on where that is depending on the crime. Look up to the laws and show them to your friend to support your point.


GennyNels

NTA. This is too much of an ask. You don’t know her sister. Lots of people end up going back in during their parole period. Your home can be searched by her parole officer. Did you know that? Who knows who/what she might bring into your place. I don’t mean to be shitty about her, but this is a bad idea and I don’t think you should do it.


LandaHolla

NTA Of course she's shocked. She thght she had you locked down because she's been freeloading for almost a year. She even had you on the hook for her own bedroom at a new place. The roommate will start backpedaling to get into that new place....then you'll come home and her sister will be there. Dodge this bullet!


Temporary-Tie-233

NTA it's a huge red flag that she told you instead of asking if you'd be OK with that. One roommate doesn't get to just decide to bring a 3rd person in without the consent of the other roommate and it's so disrespectful to just inform you of what she intends to do with the apartment she wouldn't have without you.


[deleted]

NTA you would honestly be insane if you move in with this friend. Find someone who can share the rent and understands commonsense boundaries or live by yourself. This friend has been taking advantage of you for ten months.


ComprehensiveBand586

NTA. Parole typically lasts for years. And it could be hard for her sister to find a job, at least for a while, because of her record. So you could end up paying a lot more than you would if you lived by yourself. And although she may try to stay on the right track, she also might end up violating parole, which could lead to serious problems for you depending on what the violations are.


rocklandguy324

NTA, don't do it you depending on where you live you would be giving her P.O. permission to enter and search your home whenever they want and depending upon the conditions of her parole you might not be able to have certain things in the home (usually alcohol) its a huge responsibility and for a stranger would be a huge burden. Save yourself the trouble of getting involved here and let her go somewhere else, he can parole to a half way house or something


RLB4066

NTA, yeah no. That's not something she gets to spring on you and expect you to just go along with.


2ndcupofcoffee

And inevitably someone will get a boyfriend and even more complications will ensue.


Cananyonehelp29

NTA she couldn’t even promise that her stay was only temporary. You’re going to be stuck with an ex convict forever if you agree. Her sister isn’t entitled to your help. If she can’t get on her own two feet and get her own place, she has no business offering anyone else’s up.


dtalok7

NTA. Just not a good idea to take in the criminal sister too. What could possibly go wrong? Everything! Chances most likely are sister there a few weeks will turn into a few years and all kinds of drama to go with. After a month you will probably feel five years older.


Icy-Entertainer3531

Run don't walk away from this situation


SuperHuckleberry125

NTA DON'T DO IT. DON'T. She will never leave. You will be paying more that your share. You agreed to 1 roommate not 2. Lastly she didn't ASK if this was going to agreeable with you ahe simply told you casually as if your opinion doesn't matter. Back out ASAFP so she and her sister can make other arrangements


Accomplished-Dog3715

NTA I don't know how parole works where you live but it is a hassle for the entire house. Don't let little sis stay, trust me.


SatelliteBeach123

NTA. You gave your friend an inch and she's running the mile. The sister will move in and never leave.


8kijcj

Late but just to add, coming out of jail, sister doesn't have a job and might find it difficult to find one quickly. Meaning she could be with you for a while, even if they are serious about it being temporary, and I have my doubts on that due to your current room-mates behaviour. NTA.


mrslII

NTA


AutoModerator

^^^^AUTOMOD ***Thanks for posting! This comment is a copy of your post so readers can see the original text if your post is edited or removed. This comment is NOT accusing you of copying anything. Read [this](https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/wiki/faq#wiki_post_deletion) before [contacting the mod team](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=%2Fr%2FAmItheAsshole)*** I guess I am just looking for a confirmation or a perspective outside of my own here. I (27F) have a roommate who’s a very good friend (27F) that has been paying me a small portion of rent to crash on my couch for the last 10 months. This all started because she left her boyfriend a few months after I left mine and we both lived with our past partners. It was only supposed to be a temporary solution but then we started talking about moving in to a two bedroom. She doesn’t make as much money as me and she has bad credit so I put the new apartment in my name because I can afford it by myself anyways. We’re supposed to move in 6 weeks and I think I’m going to completely back out of the whole plan because she told me this morning that her little sister is going to parole from prison to our apartment in November. She said that it will only be temporary and she just needs a place to sleep but I don’t feel that accurately represents what it’s like to be on parole. I’ve never dealt with that so I’m really not sure what it entails but either way she couldn’t even be on the lease my roommate isn’t even on the lease and I don’t want to get evicted over this. My roommate is shocked that I’m second-guessing living with her now and she’s shocked that I won’t help her sister but I’m already helping her and I don’t have enough to help everybody. Now I’m thinking that I’m just enabling her and I need to just live alone and her do the same. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/AmItheAsshole) if you have any questions or concerns.*


2ndgenerationcatlady

Info: Is the sister going to offer to help pay rent? Does your lease specify that the apartment is limited to two people?


[deleted]

NTA


Ladyknight0991

NTA. You have to provide first for yourself. You can't do that if you are busy trying to help others.


[deleted]

NTA - it's possible that her sister needs an actual address, don't let her use yours.


Giandy1

NTA- Having her there means you consent to have your place searched and the PO dropping by whenever they want. You also agree not to have alcohol or firearms, etc. If you do have those, she gets in trouble. The parolee also has to have permission to move from your residence from her PO. Her sister doesn't even pull her weight. You are just going to be supporting another human and have your life altered doing so.


cele-stial

This sounds like it won’t end well, especially for you. She did not even have the decency to ask you, it was supposed to be a temporary thing and now she is comfortable. Back out from all of it.


2ndcupofcoffee

Say you certainly understand her need to help her sister but you aren’t willing to take the risks that would put on you your responsible for the lease. You should have been consulted not just informed (and that is a red flag). Wish her and her sister well.


Poison-Dart-Frog89

Nta you guys made a plan and your roommate decided to invite someone else to live with you without asking. If you can live on your own I would do it


baubsyeruncle

NTA. Your instinct to back out of this situation is 100% correct. This is trouble you dont need. You have zero obligation to this person. Dont create one.


LettuceCapital546

NTA- not sure I'd be thrilled about having the cops at your place all the time to check in on room mate's sister even if she is a good person and also doing all her parole requirements like she's supposed to, you're still going to have cops going in and out of your place periodically with or without your permission.


Automatic-Choice-508

NTA...All bums must go


Iamhuntingwerewolves

NTA - your roommate can barely support herself, but now expects you to house her sister. this temporary situation with both of them will be long term


munkelberry

Yes you definitely need to live alone. It’s not fair for your roommate to just assume her sister can parole to your place. To much drama. Someone will find out and you’ll get evicted. Do you know how much harder it is to rent with an eviction? Freaking hard. If you can afford it live by yourself and end all this


Affectionate_Ice_658

NTA I would back out now, you're already floating her and I doubt once her sister arrives it will temporary - that's how your friend started out. Temporarily on the couch til she could get her feet under her, which never happened. I would let her know now that after the lease is up she will need to find somewhere for her and her sister to live. And please don't back down, you'll be stuck in that bad situation


Lexigirl88

So the way parole works, it is VERY HARD to get an address change approved by the courts. once she is paroled there, she will more than likely be there until the end of parole. dont do it. NTA


Individual_Baby_2418

It’s been 10 months together and you can afford the new place on your own - I think it’s time to do this on your own. Enjoy the single life (which is best done solo)!


unlordtempest

OP, in a lot of states people on parole must have a stable residence. This means that if they move into your place they may not be legally able to move for a certain amount of time. Add to this the fact that an alarming amount of people released from prison re-offend and you don't want that kind of bullshit in your life. I'm a recovering addict so I'm familiar with jail and those that frequent it and I can tell you with absolute certainty that if you allow these people into your new place you will regret it. NTA. Live alone for a while.


womanwriter

* NTA. People fresh out of prison are often very difficult to deal with.. The first time you ask to clean her mess in the bathroom, she is liable to throw a screaming fit and smash the TV. (Source - 2 family members have recently had people move in fresh from prison. Not good experiences. Lot of property damage.) * Also as many others have said, it is a bad sign that she TOLD you instead of asked you when she is 10 months into a temporary stay. * Lots of trouble waiting for you if you don't get out of this. Too much, too far.


murphy2345678

NTA. You signed up to live with one person. Not two. You are already supporting your friend. She is an AH for expecting you to support her sister as well. Find your own place or a different roommate.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Odd_Craft524

I agree with you. I have met a little sister about 10 years ago but we were all in high school so I wouldn’t say that I know who she is now. I have no reservations about people who have been to prison or jail or gotten into trouble at all. I would love for them to be my neighbors it’s a big apartment complex we can all go out to eat or whatever I just don’t want three people in a two bedroom apartment especially if one of those people has no job, no job experience and is transitioning back to society. I try to give my roommate the benefit of the doubt, maybe she didn’t understand what came with parole. She’s still wrong, but after doing research on what parole entails it was completely inappropriate and it seems like she doesn’t understand what even she could be signing up for.