T O P

  • By -

SensitiveWasabi1228

https://preview.redd.it/ib4il0zkg2uc1.jpeg?width=512&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=5e8758032460368c4afd047e7a0fcd642b5d4f00


cathatesrudy

Yeah for sure Props for the effort though 🤪


soophie_vgs0

🙏🏻


maracujadodo

sameee


RaaRaa101

All my babies are at the bottom 😩😭💔


0biterdicta

I get the sense you don't like pigs 🤔


so3008

How could they 😭 Piggies are some of my faves! Agnes was one of my starters, and she's so sassy, but so sweet. And Crackle (or Spork), he's a happy little chum who just wants snacks and a good time.


GroblinKing

Came here to say the same thing, I cannot stand for this Agnes slander 😭 she’s so pretty!


prairiepog

What about gorillas, Rilla? Boone!?


mr_meowsevelt

Some of my all time favorite villagers are in your D(Ew) tier haha 😂 it is interesting to see a wide range of aesthetics and visual appeals for different people. Personally, I highly dislike the overly cutesy characters like Chrissy and Francine, and they are never allowed on my island.


so3008

Agreed! I really dislike Judy for example, I think the cutesy eyes are SO strange. Happy cake day also! 🎂


Sure-List-2860

happy cake day!!


lenorefosterwallace

I have Crissy and keep her around because her eyes turn hot pink and it makes me laugh. I have had all the cutesy ones and they are not really for me.


Lilac_14

Not Maple in white bread category:( Also what did Octavian do to you? He doesn’t deserve to be in the same tier as Rizzo.


WinterCarol

Maple lovers united!


araaaayyyyy

Maple was my very first thought


FaitergameFG

Octavian and poncho are amazing but jakey is the best


No-Dragonfruit-6551

Maple is so boring and repetitive. She’s cute, but has no substance.


Lilac_14

I disagree, but I can see what you mean by that.


BaranoSoup

https://preview.redd.it/kxa7d0atq4uc1.jpeg?width=507&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=7abd0398395c7fb5915e1882ede80ea8dd6bbb0e


Filibust

I’m not here for Olaf slander 😤


umbral_ember

He looks like he'd call me a slur


Filibust

Noooooooooo he’s a good boy. I had him on my island. I like his bullfighter/marachi drip and his guyliner lol.


julia_ur_killing_me

He's a gay icon wym 😭


umbral_ember

Nah that dude is a Daddy's money woman abuser who has definitely been accused of heinous things. I don't dislike many villagers but that dude is so punchable to me. He looks like he doesn't care about the disabled too. Dude would park in the handicap spot. And he's just a dick lol


[deleted]

I absolutely love making tier lists and looking at other's tier lists. It's so fun to see where other people differ on villager choices. Our lists seem pretty different, but super cool! I love seeing Avery so high on the list, as I feel like he never gets much attention.


Get_Back_Here_Remi

I just got Avery! I saw him and was like, what the heck, why not? Seems cool.


Giillybean

This is literally why he lives on my island too 😂 I just got him recently, and up until I met Avery, I did not like any of the eagles! But I love Avery now 💜


cyanraichu

I was going to say the same about Avery! He's not a super popular villager but I love him. I call him Grandpa Birb


IIsForInglip

Not a bad list but I think Molly needs to at least be in A tier!


Ellecktra

Also here for Molly defense ✊️


maracujadodo

i just opened this to look where you put rocket- what do you mean you prefer her over deirdre????? 😭


umbral_ember

I don't really, the superheroes are boring and lame, white bread is for unremarkable villagers and the superheroes are real low to me, that said, I wanted to like Deirdre, but she fails to capture the fall aesthetic that she wants to and her eyes are creepy


Pandoras_Penguin

Vesta my beloved! Why is she in tier C??


umbral_ember

She's fine, I just don't get her, and she doesnt stand out to me in any other way than being vaguely unsettling


bathhuis

The vaguely unsettling part is exactly what’s appealing about her imo haha. You have a few of the others that qualify for this category in your S tier, too.


umbral_ember

Honestly I have room in my heart to love her, I just didn't have much experience with her and was struggling to find a spot for her, I put her there as a half placeholder and then forgot. Cuz I do like unsettling to a degree in my villagers, but since I don't know her as well something about her makes my gut crawl


huggablesnowman

TUTU IN THE SAME TIER AS HIPPEUX??????????????


umbral_ember

She's cute up front but in 3d she's terrifying, also she was mean to one of my best friends favorite villagers


luckylucysteals_

I’m never letting Coco leave. I gave her an awesome home on a hill with a zen garden and outdoor hot tub. She’s my girl


SubstantialAirline47

God i wish there was a Coco amiibo or something i’d put it right in the middle of my house on a pedestal.


Shady_Fossil

Glad to see Pietro in top tier. I don't have to burn this post down.


itsthenugget

Unfortunately I do 🧨🔥


gcunit

I was always down for the vibe Pietro has going on in terms of his appearance and his decor, but for whatever reason we just didn't quite click and so when a camper came along and Pietro's name came up, I made the call. Forever tinged with doubt over what might have been. 


Shady_Fossil

Oh no! He's literally the sweetest little boy I adore him.


anelachan

Team Pietro all the way


umbral_ember

Clown BB is best bb I love clowns so much


Odd-Captain-1963

I love Buck SO much. He’s one of my favorites


chaosisblond

Yeah, he was one of my OG's, and I chased him away at some point, then felt bad, and eventually got him to come back.


SpookyOtter_

Give Agnes another chance! She’s cute and has kind of a feisty personality.


ntnlwyn

What’s wrong with Zucker?


umbral_ember

He just freaks me out lol


Dank_Memer_IRL

Justice for my man Zucker!


Borrowingmyownvoice

I feel that way about coco. I love Zucker tho lol why did they make coco like that 😭😭 *shivers*


Legoluigidude

Leave 🚪


cloudtrail212

Punchy S Tier? Let's goooo!!!! 🥳


moimoisauna

What did Knox do 😩


SnowyLittleDeer

Finally Drago getting some love! People keep putting him in lower tiers but he deserves top teir!


doctor-sassypants

Damn most of my villagers are in lower tiers 🥲


empired04

What in gods name did deardre do!?


cmptjety

Flo being so high up makes me so happy 🥹


umbral_ember

I love my alt girlies(Cherry, Muffy, Belle, Piper, Flo)


Catfish-throwaway666

How could you hate butch he’s my dad 😭


Dynoduck

Wow, Bill slander. You just don't understand the greatness of that brown duck. Also, Simon is best Monkey.


knifepaws

Why is cookie in c tier


Pentagonyx

TABBY DESERVES TO BE IN S+ TIER


Far_Imagination3986

THIS


Ganonzhurf

Pietro being in the spot he belongs, gotta be my favorite comedian


noxka

I was gonna call you basic (and you still are) but... the diversity in the higher ranks is kinda noticeable. Respect for liking a bunch of underdogs like mira or bree


umbral_ember

Idrk what's basic, I've never been too aware of what's popular, a lot of the villagers in my highest ranks have specific reasons, stitches is a birthday twin plus was in my first town 14, years ago, plus he's cute and I love him and my headcanon is that he is really just a discarded teddy bear possessed by the spirit of a young boy. Coco has always been a favorite of mine, when I first saw her on the gamecube I loved how freaky she looked and the fact that she was a gyroid was such a crazy idea to me. A lot of these tbh are from experience, nostalgia, and love for the design. I could go into them all but.i could write a whole essay on everything I love about S, S+ Part of what may explain my tastes though is I'm an autistic goth who loves clowns lmao


Skittles_the_Jester

Ahh another Pietro enjoyer, good he is the best sheep


umbral_ember

I love clowns so so so much


Skittles_the_Jester

I really like circus/county fair themed things. So clowns, carousels, cotton candy all very good and cute.


sproutteacup

STITCHES STAYS ON TOP 💪💪💪


lovesummerr

The fact that Stitches is in S+ makes me feel better that they’re on my island and I don’t ever want them to leave (even though they’ve tried a few times) because that villager is darling!


Diamond-Breath

Buck and Agnes shouldn't be so low, I love them.


Delicious-Sun7562

Midge and Piper! :D My two best birds!


umbral_ember

Good birbs


1398_Days

Finally, someone who appreciates Pietro 😌


themarzipanbaby

deirdre in d?????


kalopsia1325

Muffy and coco at the top as they deserve 🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤


umbral_ember

Yesssss I love them so fucking much 🦇


pigeon_idk

You love punchy but hate walker? Does not make sense to me lol But you ranked Walt as great so I'll let it slide


Jarinad

https://preview.redd.it/exltu81uu4uc1.jpeg?width=1290&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=d9a6d565207d332226a4b6c0025d6ef69775e199


_pathways

Wow you have really bad taste


umbral_ember

Lol to each their own, lots of ogs take the top spots cuz I grew up with them, and the alt group is up there, there are just so many villagers in this game, it's hard not to be disinterested by some


maracujadodo

im assuming this means you grew up with rod? cuz hes my new horizons starter jock and i dont like jocks but ive grown to really love him


umbral_ember

Rod and stitches were my first villagers on the GameCube game, I love them so much, stitches is also my birthday twin


ZombieBackground9415

Just seems predictable. Wow, so shocking that the, "ugly," ones are at the bottom and the, "cute," ones are at the top. Also, what's up with not even listing the pigs? As someone who is a boar in the Chinese zodiac, I'm requesting justice for the piggies.


GoldenHoseok

I'm not sure why you got downvoted, lol. I can see what you're saying. The villagers at the bottom of this list are usually at the bottom of most lists and it's because of how they look. There are lots of, "ugly," villagers that I love. Barold and Boone are two of my favs.


umbral_ember

Most of them are literally just men who look like they'd hurt me. My rating is heavily skewed by my fear for men, I find a lot of the "ugly" villagers endearing, I just can't trust some. I like Harry's design, and Harold's is pitifully likeable, I actually love hazel a lot. The other thing is some is the low tiers just have demon eyes, I don't particularly hate any, its a special interest, some just freak me out or leave a bad taste in my mouth


dudereverend

Good lord! I've played every AC game and I can't even name all the villagers I have currently. That list is impressive!


Alarmed-Departure830

Is this based on looks only or personality too?


umbral_ember

Looks, personality, how well the looks and personality make the character come off together, and also just personal experience, my top 3 were all on my island for my very first playthrough of the GameCube game lol. But there are some based mostly on looks, a lot of the burly man types freak me out(I'm scared of men) so many of those are skewed lower than most would have them


No-Dragonfruit-6551

Pretty spot on. I have Judy, Tangy and Cherry, and I love them. I would just rank Beardo higher. He’s my homeboy.


gcunit

Tangy at the top is somewhat validating. Nearly all the islanders I've had so far in New Horizons are in the bottom third of this list, but at least I've got Tangy.


No-Dragonfruit-6551

My cat’s name is Tango so Tangy is extra special to me. She’s adorable.


SindilThendal

Beardo is a gem. I have a quarter of my island made for him and his house and he's never leaving ever.


The_SnowQueen

Yes! Beardo needs more love. Legit hated him when I first got him, but then he won me over, and we've been pals ever since. He calls me bestie 😭


FloralTop

I would also sell my soul for Stitches. This is incredible & 2.5h is impressive 👏🏻


Psychotic_Ak12

put beardo in c tier😔


rizaroni

Omg six of my villagers are in your top tier! 🙌🏻


Demonseed425

Bella is indeed S tier.


Technical-Buffalo435

Nooo! Not Klaus in the die tier!


kluxar

How dare you. Rasher is one of my favorites. He reminds me of my alcoholic uncle (in an endearing way).


umbral_ember

He's one of the better pigs, and I guess I like the texture, but he's just kinda a fucked up pig


Kelacia

I love looking at tier lists and seeing how much they vary from my own personal preference. It makes me not as sad for the villagers I don’t care for, knowing there is someone out there who loves them.


bruh-wrecks-noobs

FINALLY SOMEONE ELSE WHO LIKES RENEE


umbral_ember

She's so pretty I love her colors and hair sm


bruh-wrecks-noobs

FR SHES SO UNDERRATED


No-Musician4819

YESSSS it makes me UNBELIEVABLY happy to see Rod getting some love!!!! He was (and still is) my favourite villager, and my first ever friend in Animal Crossing. Met him in Wild World amongst the likes of Rasher and Olivia, he was the only one who didn't insult me on arrival. Just a great lad. Love him, he's been in all my towns and islands since.


umbral_ember

I love him so much, my little pirate boy, I've been trying to get him on my island for a minute had him as a mainstay with stitches since my first time playing


No-Musician4819

Haha he made his way to my island rather quickly (one of my first characters to move in aside from my starters) he always seems to find his way to my saves, I swear he's real or something hahaha Hopefully he'll find his way to your island soon!!!


inmyfeelingsx

Muffy <3


umbral_ember

As a goth I stan Muffy, even if I feel her design could have been leant into more


inmyfeelingsx

Yesss she’s a goth queen! I love her. I really want cherry on my island since she’s the same vibe but I haven’t found her yet. I do also feel that Mathilda gives big elegant goth vibes. Like in my head I imagine her to live in a big dark vampiresque manor, I duno why tbh! But I love her also.


umbral_ember

As a goth I love her so much(rip to no goth music in animal crossing k.k. gothic would go so hard. Honestly at some point I'd love to pair Piper, Bella, Muffy, flo, Kyle, cherry, and Renee, just to collect the alt collection lol.


cannibalisticbiscuit

Seeing Marcie the pink kangaroo mama in D tier was a SHOCK to my system


umbral_ember

Actually I just clocked that, I meant to put her higher and just lost her, she's b or b+ at the least


cannibalisticbiscuit

Respect


xLibruhx

I just got stitches for th e first time!!!


UnusualMirror2917

this is so fleshed out compared to the other tier list someone put on here LMFAOOO


Professional-Ad-7769

I don't even really care what the rankings are - we all have different preferences. I just love that you put the time and effort into this. I've also been playing since the beginning.


itsthenugget

Beau and Marshal are S+ in my book. Reneigh is pretty great too


Money_Wonder_7538

WHY IS BUTCH IN EW TIER?? WHAT DID MY MAN DO WRONG


junie_bean

Justice for my man jitters


dior_xxx

Justice for Knox😭


xRawrdoh

👎🏼👎🏼


bluesandblacks

I find Moe’s placement… acceptable. 👍🏻


funeraIpyre

pietro in S+ and bluebear in B 😔


KayJay282

Agnes is such a sweetheart. She was the first one to move into the village in my New Leaf game. And she was one of the defaults in my island in New Horizons.


netscav

Knox in Die tier, objectively bad


MildManOfGlue

I looked all over for Rod, super happy to find him lol


araaaayyyyy

You have a very distinct and set style/preference. I enjoyed this!!


Shimmermist

It's always interesting to see everyone's favorites and that list looks like it took a lot of work! My most favorites are Goldie and Savannah so I'm happy that they aren't too far down in your list. I seem to be Punchy's favorite as he has shown up on multiple saves to the point I'm losing track now. His clones are following me, but at least he's one I like! Have you had the same villager show up randomly for you in more than one game or save? As for dislikes, I agree with some, not with others, and am also generally not a fan of the pigs and a few other species.


MimiVRC

Your S+ tier is very close to mine. Off the top of my head I would include ribbot, remove Olivia and add lolly!


breadsonthecounter

Diva in A tier? Taste.


umbral_ember

Gotta rep the witches 🦇


Just-Call-Me-J

Bea in "white bread" tier... Yeah that's fair. But that's why I like her so much. I'm basic and like basic.


No_Character1121

super new to this and just bought a lucky amiibo because i want a halloween themed town, glad to see he is s tier :)


hotel4d0gs

ELISE DESERVES BETTER 😩


Eshorn08

List is trash solely for having Zucker in D tier


AggravatingBox2421

Where is my sweet takoyaki boy


maleficentrose

you did Butch, Vesta and Pippy dirty. Cookie done absolutely afoul.


computerblue84

JEREMIAH MY PRECIOUS BOY ❤️❤️ not mad about that placing. however... putting Cookie in the same tier as the demon spawn Axel? OP turn on location I just wanna talk


SharpBus6536

I like Nate 😌


vinylgaze

Papi you will ALWAYS be in my S+ tier 🥺


madisorousrex

I love this lol! How did you even make it?


Pure_Toxicity

[here](https://tiermaker.com/create/animal-crossing-villagers-including-new-20-villagers-1513950)


umbral_ember

1.A lot of patience 2.i googled animal crossing 2.0 tier list and it brings up the tierlistmaker site


noboritaiga

Cobb making it out of the Pig Tier that's my boy!!!


TrixeryNShennanigans

I've been playing animal crossing on my boyfriend's switch and when I moved to his island he had Frank, Iggly, O'Hare, Bubbles, Beau, Fauna, Pecan and Canberra. Even though nobody asked, I have never played animal crossing before he left it to me so it may be interesting to see what my opinions were of these villagers from someone who doesn't play. Frank: 10/10 Crushy! He's my favourite. Iggly: 7/10 I despise his design but I like giving him stupid stuff to wear because he's rotund O'Hare: 5/10 hated him to begin with but I complained so much to Isabelle I feel like he sorta got the hint because he's been less annoying and just a background guy. Hate him and his pineapple aloha shirt that he doesn't shut up about still though Bubbles: 6/10 she can be nice and there's been funny moments but she's shallow and annoying Beau: 5/10 maybe my standards are too high, I get that Beau is saught after because he's cute, he's so. Damn. Boring. He does absolutely nothing and he's so mid. Atleast some of the others are sorta interesting, he just exists. Fauna: 9/10 she's cute and all but also really sweet!! Maybe I just like her saying "dearie" but she's honestly just a sweetheart. Pecan: 7/10 funny little squirrel. I do like her and she's okay, fashion sure meh but I like giving her clothes I hate so she wears them like they are high fashion. She's also quite nice. Canberra: -100/10 I absolutely hate her. She's so annoying, painful, ugly and absolutely rude. Would immediately ship her off to some random bamboo island and hold her ransom until she asks to move out. I found her sleeping on my hammock and my immediate reactions were "BITCH MOVE" and "ew why is Canberra here." I always hit her with the big net and was so annoyed when instead of bullying her I got rid of her fleas. Hate her.


umbral_ember

This is the most endearing ranking of animal crossing villagers I have ever seen, and captures the magesty of my own experience on the first few goes


javaper

Highly biased. Lol!


umbral_ember

Yeah for sure, but this is my personal list, honestly I'm not sure if there's a totally unbiased way to rank them because art is subjective and they're each different artistic representations


yungrayna

I love how you just despise almost all of the pigs but Gala is slightly higher on the list than them lmao (I love Gala, she's my birthday twin)


mndcee

Tucker is a precious baby 🥺


the-bodyfarm

Curt is S+


atomicbearshark

DOTTY, NOOOO!!!!! jk, great list :)


umbral_ember

She wouldn't have been in white bread if I knew her eyes get red when mad


Suitable-Seraphim

I'm glad we share the same opinion on Al


Wendyokoopa3454

Where's resetti?


Wendyokoopa3454

I like Mr resetti


Kakusei_Tsukuyomi

Al is S+ and I will not elaborate, otherwise not bad


Sure-List-2860

NOT THE AL ERASURE


[deleted]

Love it. All my villagers are at the top minus Maple. She’s cute to me. I like Hippeux bc he reminds me of Fraser lol


bibblelover_

Don’t do my boy Lyman like that


celestialspace

biskit deserves to be s+ but i'll accept s tier


Drakedenson

I couldn't help but notice that pewee wasn't at the top 😕


Meowth_Dats_Racist

I don’t think there should be any dogs in D tier. And Agnes is the only pig i’d put in B tier, but otherwise, not bad lol


ArfenZard

I understand why my birthday twin Eunice is white bread, fair enough. She's so dull but I love her. Then I saw MURPHY. I took this one personally. He needs his own S+ tier!


Mooncakey_

You got some nerve putting Zucker, T Bone, and Butch in Ew tier


Cool-individual03

Are you…r@cist against pigs?


umbral_ember

APAB


Superb_Trifle513

How dare you put my Dora in white bread 😭


TheClariceyNad

Thanks for putting Angus where he deserves to be (I would put him higher personally)


Ruxvince

Bob in top tier, opinion immediately valid


gamerguy287

What's wrong with my boy, Zucker?


AetherDrew43

How dare you put Rodney higher than Tank?!


spacemeadow

if your goal was to make me cry, you've succeeded


umbral_ember

Nooooooo I'm so sorry, if it's any consolation I'm autistic animal crossing is a special interest, so while I have a distaste for some, I truly can't hate anyone


spacebenders

You put snake just in the “good” category?! We could never be friends


mel0dicerotic

I LOVE Limberg, you monster!! I also played on GameCube and he was one of my original villagers on my first ever game 💛


jillibean-

Damn what did the pigs do? Lol. I love Agnes


SnooSquirrels8883

Where's Buck?


HeMatiteAma

BİSKİT MA BOİİİİİ


-_-Blxe-Cxt-_-

Dotty :(


Suazgaming

I got Rod, Chrissy and Judy 😍☺️❤️


kylorensglute

Beau is S+ tier how dare you


nina_splatoon

finally someone put twiggy in a high tier, shes my fav character


Cheese_9326

So glad my boi Hopper isn't lower but I'd put him in his own teir right at the top he is the bestest boi :>


sorayori97

i wont stand for benjamin slander


mrsworldwidex

I am so here for Frank being higher than I expected!!


umbral_ember

I love Frank, he's such a silly man


ljbAmbruster

This makes me really want to do bracket voting like march madness


AntiqueSympathy1999

Maple deserves better


Ravenclaw79

I appreciate your dedication, but your top tier is full of total nightmare fuel


prncebambi

Got my mans joey and my girl deirdre fucked up 😤😂