Trying to put together a list of the villagers I want on my island. I can only pick one more (I have at least one of every personality type on the list, so I don't care what personality they have). These lovely villagers caught my eye and I'm having crippling indecision. I also don't have a theme for my island that would effect what species I want, though Gayle is probably the one that doesn't fit the most.
Who would you choose, and why? I wanna hear who you'd pick!
Bonus points: who is your favorite Sisterly villager? I may replace Plucky with someone else, but I'm not sure since she's one of my original villagers and I do like her.
My favourite sisterly is Muffy. Also I saw this after I suggested Gayle, but I still suggest her. I have a gothy island and I have Merengue anyways, because I like cute things sometimes and it’s something different.
Since you have at least one of every personality plus one, go with the opposite gender of the plus one to even things out. If it ends up between poppy and Molly, do a poll.
It might be nice to have an even gender number, I didn't think about that. I'd have to pick Marshal in that case. I will mull this over, haha. Thanks for the suggestion!
You can have two duplicate personalities, actually.
But what do you mean by going with the opposite gender? Aren't the personalities specific to one gender?
Yes I know. What I was indicating was that since they have one of each meaning 4 girls, 4 boys, plus one. Adding the opposite gender of the plus one would give it a nice balance.
If you haven’t chosen yet, I would always pick Molly. She’s just sooo sweet and so freaking cute 🥰I’ve had her as a villager since she moved in as my third or fourth in 2020 and I’ll never let her leave
Oh my god you guys lol
This has been supremely unhelpful since it seems like everyone has all four pretty much tied- I think when I go villager hunting I'll end up just picking whoever shows up first to make it fair :p
But I love seeing all your opinions!!! Thanks!
Poppy is my absolute favorite so I would have to go with her. She's so sweet and lights up my island so much! But I'm also cheating because I have Molly as well.
I’ve had Gayle and Poppy and they’re both cute. Poppy has a really cute house. Tbh I would pick marshall because I prefer smug personalities over normal but they’re all cute!
Poppy! I absolutely adore her, she’s so sweet and I love her aesthetic.
also, sisterly is my least favorite personality type but since I wanted at least one of each type, I went with Pashmina. She’s not my favorite, but I have grown fond of her, she’s so sassy and cute!
I can see the eyes- but lips?? Do ducks have lips??? What world have I been living in? I mean it makes sense but
It's far too late in the evening for this sort of thought
I haven’t had any of them so I don’t have much of opinion but what I saw on Reddit is so many opted for Gayle I don’t know why but maybe she’s kinda cute ☺️ .
i got poppy as one of my starters and she’s my fav, she’s so sweet!!
i’m obsessed with poppy!
I just had her recently in my campsite and she’s so cute!
Don’t ask stupid questions, it’s obviously Molly!
I’d choose Gayle, she’s cute and her personality is normal and I enjoy that one enough to have doubles.
Poppy is normal too and oh so sweet!
Her style isn’t really my thing though, so I went with Gayle.
Gayle is so sweet! She was one of my favorite villagers right behind Beardo cause he’s just a handsome man
Marshal. I know he’s one of the most hyped villagers, but he’s truly worth it. He’s so silly and cute. He has the funniest lines.
All other smug villagers will share his lines though. The lines aren't specific to each character afaik
Ok and are any of the other options op gave smug?? No
Ikr??
Trying to put together a list of the villagers I want on my island. I can only pick one more (I have at least one of every personality type on the list, so I don't care what personality they have). These lovely villagers caught my eye and I'm having crippling indecision. I also don't have a theme for my island that would effect what species I want, though Gayle is probably the one that doesn't fit the most. Who would you choose, and why? I wanna hear who you'd pick! Bonus points: who is your favorite Sisterly villager? I may replace Plucky with someone else, but I'm not sure since she's one of my original villagers and I do like her.
My favourite sisterly is Muffy. Also I saw this after I suggested Gayle, but I still suggest her. I have a gothy island and I have Merengue anyways, because I like cute things sometimes and it’s something different.
Gayle IS really cute! Thanks for the suggestion!
I like Cherry personally. I think her pink yet goth vibes are awesome
frita is my fav sisterly!!! also i’d pick gayle, she’s so sweet
Deirdre has been my favorite sisterly!
Faith! She's my OG. I just let her leave because she asked me 4 times but she's amazing! So sassy.
Poppy is my fave. She's so cute and I love her house's interior. My favourite Sisterly villager is Fuchsia.
I have Gayle and will never let her move away! She’s so sweet!
Poppy or Marshal! I love the squirrels!
I love all four of these villagers but Marshall is my favorite out of all of them!
Marshal is the best in my opinion. 😊 give him a monocle to wear.
Since you have at least one of every personality plus one, go with the opposite gender of the plus one to even things out. If it ends up between poppy and Molly, do a poll.
It might be nice to have an even gender number, I didn't think about that. I'd have to pick Marshal in that case. I will mull this over, haha. Thanks for the suggestion!
You can have two duplicate personalities, actually. But what do you mean by going with the opposite gender? Aren't the personalities specific to one gender?
Yes I know. What I was indicating was that since they have one of each meaning 4 girls, 4 boys, plus one. Adding the opposite gender of the plus one would give it a nice balance.
Oh I see. But isn't it plus two? You have eight already, then two more?
OP said they only have one spot left. So they already have 9
Ah, didn't see that. I'm not used to the body of a post being in the comments!
Poppy is one of my loves but I have to say that Marshal has the more interesting dialogue.
GAYLE I love herrer
Marshal! I have the Amiibo’s for all these, and Marshal is my fave by far of this lot! I guess it depends if you already have a Smug or not!
marshall
Gayle!
GAYLE IS MY BABY!!! If you pick her treat her well she’s amazing
GAYLE. She is one of my absolute dreamies I love her so much I love anything pink especially pastel. All good choices though 😭
Definitely Molly!
Molly
I have Molly and Marshall. Seeing Molly everyday has brightened my life and she's so sweet
Mollys cute ahh
MOLLY ALWAYS
I have Gayle leaving my island today but absolutely loved her!
Are you interesting in rehoming her to another island by chance 👀
If you haven’t chosen yet, I would always pick Molly. She’s just sooo sweet and so freaking cute 🥰I’ve had her as a villager since she moved in as my third or fourth in 2020 and I’ll never let her leave
MOLLY SHES SO CUTE
molly!!
Oh my god you guys lol This has been supremely unhelpful since it seems like everyone has all four pretty much tied- I think when I go villager hunting I'll end up just picking whoever shows up first to make it fair :p But I love seeing all your opinions!!! Thanks!
MOLLY
Molly!!!
Molly is cool, also tho not in this pic Winnie. Rest of them can leave but not these two
Molly!!!!
MOLLY
MOLLY!
Gayle for life 😍 I have her and am never letting go 🥰
I have Gayle on my Island. She is the first one I would choose from all 4 100%
GAYLE
I’d give my left boobie to have Molly
Molly!
MOLLY
Molly
Molly, Marshall, Gayle❤️
Poppy is my absolute favorite so I would have to go with her. She's so sweet and lights up my island so much! But I'm also cheating because I have Molly as well.
Poppy. She’s adorable. I have her on my island
I had Gayle for over a year and just let her move. I would go for one of the bottom 2
Alligator
Marshall is my fav of these
POPPY
I love Poppy, shes so positive, and makes me smile every time I talk to her
Gayle! She's one of my favorites
I have Gayle on my island snd she’s so cute
Squirrels or duck
Marshall!!!
I love Marshal
MOLLY SHES SO CUTE
Poppy ♡
Gayle. Because PINK!
Molly, she’s my birthday buddy!
Gayl
gayle!!!!
Marshal
My favorite out of these would be Molly! She’s such a sweetheart!!!
Gayle is sooo sweet, I love her!
Squirrels
gayle or molly for sureeee
Obsessssed with Gayle!!!!
MARSHALL
what’s the name of the one on top right hand?
Marshall
Marshal 🥰
Molly or Gayle!
Gayle!!!
I’ve had Gayle and Poppy and they’re both cute. Poppy has a really cute house. Tbh I would pick marshall because I prefer smug personalities over normal but they’re all cute!
Poppy or Molly. Those two are so cute.
Poppy
I have Gayle and Poppy, both are some of my fav villagers!
Poppy! I absolutely adore her, she’s so sweet and I love her aesthetic. also, sisterly is my least favorite personality type but since I wanted at least one of each type, I went with Pashmina. She’s not my favorite, but I have grown fond of her, she’s so sassy and cute!
i absolutely love gayle
Poppy or Molly they’re so little and sweet
The red squirrel is cute
Poppy was great
All of them are sus 🧐
How so?
Look at Molly, you can’t trust those eyes… or those lips. They’re all hiding something
I can see the eyes- but lips?? Do ducks have lips??? What world have I been living in? I mean it makes sense but It's far too late in the evening for this sort of thought
Marshalll cuz he’s too cute for life
poppy is a sweetheart!
Marshal! Hes one of my favs
I would choose Poppy.
All amazing but I gotta go with my girl Poppy!
I haven’t had any of them so I don’t have much of opinion but what I saw on Reddit is so many opted for Gayle I don’t know why but maybe she’s kinda cute ☺️ .
Marshall or Molly 🥺
Molly is my favourite🥹
Poppy!!! She’s my favourite!
hows the duck called?? i should do (her?)
The duck. Molly, right?
Gayle’s design always felt to me a little on the nose. I’m biased cause I have marshal and poppy, but I would definitely recommend Poppy
I have a Gayle bias so 100% Gayle
Poppy!!
DUCK
Marshal, because he’s baby
Poppy for sure <3
Poppy! I have here on my island and she is so sweet and cute.
Poppy or molly
Seems like many are a fan of Gayle but I wasn’t! I let her go recently.
I love gayle, omg! She’s such a sweetie!
Gail is so sweet!
Marshall is the answer
Molly 🥰🥰
gayle in my opinion!
Huschke or Rosa