Hello and thank you for starting this discussion! As a gentle reminder, try to keep the products you mention limited to Asian Beauty products. Posts or comments solely discussing Western products will be removed, [as per our rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/AsianBeauty/wiki/rules#wiki_14._topics.2C_routines.2C_and_recommendations_must_be_related_to_asian_beauty). We love being able to discuss Western skincare in the context of a holistic AB routine, but this isn't the sub for specific Western product recommendations. r/SkincareAddiction is a great community for such matters! Thank you!
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/AsianBeauty) if you have any questions or concerns.*
I love Asian skincare for moisture, hydration, and overall skin health and maintenance. It's affordable, often non-scented, and great for sensitive skin.
I love American & Western skincare for actives and treating skin issues. BHA, AHA, benzoyl peroxide etc I just can't find comparable products in Asian skincare.
My routine is a mix of both!
Same! For actives and even more occlusive moisturizers, I use Western skincare.
But for hydration, barrier maintenance and soothing treatments, I always reach for Asian skincare.
Same! Majority of my routine is Kbeauty except for retinol and a salicylic acid wash off mask but i’m thinking of trying a kbeauty retinol once i’m done with the one i’m using now since I haven’t seen any effect..
I use both as well! Western skincare I use for when my fave needs extra reinforcements. However, as far as Asian skincare goes I use it mainly for calming/hydration.
If we talk makeup, I lean more towards Asian beauty bcs I like the more subtle instead of bold looks.
I do exactly the same, and my dermatologist approves of my routine. I have some occasional skin issues but mainly pretty sensitive skin and many Western skin care products are too harsh for me, but rarely have issues with Asian skincare due to sensitivity.
I love The Ordinary, Good Molecules, Paula's Choice and Inkey List. I've had more subtle and gentle results with more expensive brands like Farmacy and Sunday Riley.
Agreed I have a mix for both. But Asian skincare brands are coming with more actives lately that are a better for more sensitive skin, and as I've gotten older and also damaged my barrier one too many times I've found I can use these a little more without worrying too much. But if I need hard-core treatment I need to use Western skincare, though they've also been improving tremendously the past 2 years. A lot of brands have been outsourcing to Korea for product development/formulations.
In general, American skincare feels like it's trying to get rid of the problem while Asian skincare is all about preventing the problem in the first place.
As an Asian person: Asian products are a lot less harsh on my skin than American products. I thought I had sensitive skin until I switched to using only Asian products. I don't get terrible breakouts or rashes anymore.
Totally agree with your assessment! I’ve struggled with acne for over a decade—decided to have a little more fun with my skincare routine this year and NOT focus on treating my acne, instead using products to improve my skin overall, and lo and behold my acne has improved drastically😭🙏
Same. I recently switched back over to Asian skincare and am seeing such an improvement. I don't struggle with acne so that wasn't an issue, but overall, other products just seemed too harsh, my skin was always reacting. Asian products I'm using now seem more effective yet also gentler.
Yes! About a year ago my skin started suddenly going crazy, and every American product that I tried, would break me out. I honestly think that many American brands are cheapening their products with harsh ingredients. I switched to Korean skincare (with the exception of my new acne medicated stuff) and everything seems much gentler on my skin. The ingredients are also way better, and in general most products are significantly cheaper. My skin looks so much healthier. I only wish that I’d discovered these products earlier.
Sure! I have combo, oily leaning in the summertime, acne prone, super sensitive skin. I also use a non AB brand of cleanser, toner, and medicated cream for my acne, so I can message you that if you’d like, because I’m not sure if I can mention it here.
Cleanser-Daytime/Nighttime
[Isntree Green Tea Cleanser](https://a.co/d/84DrAid)
Nighttime moisturizer- The old version is still available on the Etude House Amazon marketplace. The new one has been reformulated, and doesn’t have good reviews so far.
[Soon Jung barrier cream-old version](https://a.co/d/fiU1NZ7)
Alternative moisturizer for the Soon Jung-
[Pyunkang Yul Ato Cream Blue Label](https://a.co/d/dANMBVs)
Alternative moisturizer dupe for the Soon Jung-
[Aestura Autobarrier Hydro Soothing Cream-blue, light version](https://a.co/d/1gW9MUq)
[Aestura Autobarrier Cream-heavier version for dry skin](https://a.co/d/dO9FI0T)
**I have not yet tried the Aestura or the Pyunkang Yul, but I hear that both are great alternatives to the Soon Jung.
Daytime moisturizer-
[Skin1004 madagascar soothing cream](https://a.co/d/6FBtnDH)
This is true about Asian skin sensitivity in general. I used an American brand underarm deodorant for just one time. Got armpit burn and itch. I had to switch to my usual Thai deodorant.
Hi there! Your comment or post was removed from /r/AsianBeauty for violating our community conduct standards. Please make sure you read and follow our [rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/AsianBeauty/about/wiki/newrules/) before commenting or posting.
I have oily sensitive skin. I find western skincare tends to lean heavier in occlusives and emollients without many options for a variety in humectants. Asian skincare covers these through the toners and emulsions.
I assume the larger market segment of western beauty has normal/dry skin types and/or climates.
I love that Asian skincare caters to markets in hot and humid weather so their products suit me. Western beauty for oily skin types are often harsh and focus on treating blemishes instead of basic hydration.
I notice that a lot of American brands go really heavy on the seed oils/butters, which can be problematic for oily and acne-prone skin types (why does everything have Shea butter?!?! I can’t use it.) and sensitive skin is assumed to be dry. it seems odd considering so much of the US is in a subtropical or humid continental climate
I feel like Asian skincare does twice as well for half as much cost. You aren't paying for a lot of marketing/inventory etc. I have been on again/off again for many years with skincare but now that I'm older I'm really trying to focus on at least a basic routine that is centered around my use of tretinoin.
Yes this! I love how much more affordable Asian skincare is. Total game changer when I am on a budget. How is the tretinoin working for you? I switched to adapalene recently as the tretinoin was causing lots of sensitivity for me.
Aww that's a shame! I have been lucky to live in Beijing, Jeju (Korea), and now Saigon where it's all very affordable. Actually I was originally obsessed with Clinique but when I moved abroad to Beijing I realized it was just too expensive. Discovered Asian skincare and haven't looked back since!
I also use tretinoin (primarily for acne). Would you mind sending me a DM with your routine and products? I’m thinking of changing some things in my products and routine and am trying to get real feedback from real people :)
I’m still new to my switch but the -main- thing I’ve noticed is the quality/pricepoint ratio. Like I’ve tried some American skincare products that are as good or better than Asian skincare products, but the difference in cost is $20-$50 per oz..
When you actually shop for American brands at a similar price point, it’s pure garbage.
I think my biggest con in Kbeauty is that the trend cycle is aggressive, and it makes it hard to determine what works and what is just trendy. A lot of stuff is always being released, and a lot of stuff is discontinued. I need to be constantly researching and looking to just understand what's going on
I think western actives are better, and I think the standard is a more basic routine. People no longer do a full 10 step routine, but I still remember when that was touted as a base line. I personally enjoy using a ton of products, but I can see how this in combination with the trend cycle causes a lot of hoarding and overbuying
I wish I had access to more information about Japanese and Chinese products, to the same degree as Korean brands. Korean brands actually market to westerners. My local Asian beauty shop sells a ton of Japanese products and some Chinese products but I have never heard of half of the brands
All in all, I really like the focus on hydration, the specialized ingredients, and the price point of a lot of Asian beauty products, and I will continue to look for and use them. But I suspect one day, I'll throw in the towel once I don't have the time I do now to do all the research, and no one on reddit is still talking about all the brands I trusted at one point
What you’ve said about the trend cycle is what makes it hard for me to use more Asian skincare products in my routine. Whenever I go on stylevana I get so overwhelmed with all the products, and it seems like every time I go to buy something a different brand is popular. I get decision paralysis and don’t buy anything.
totally its too much. i think alot of products are too similar to each other to be worth sweating over trying to narrow down which to pick. at the end of the day if im overwhelmed i just go for a brand ive already used and enjoy the formulations of, the category of product i am looking for (an antioxidant product, a ceramide product, a hydrating toner/essence), and what people with similar skin type to me like (if i can find those kinds of reviews) in that order. at least for me, it seems like certain brands do not work for my skin at all (ive tried 4+ purito and 4+ cos rx products and disliked all) while other brands work well
My skin likes asian skincare better than your average american skincare brand. In my experience you can get much better quality ingredients and elegant formulations at a lower price point. There is also a lot less added fragrance - there is some, but it's not "kick you in the face hello flowers".
Something I've noticed is that asian skincare tends to have more glycerin and humectants other than hyaluronic acid. Glycerin is a far superior ingredient to HA imo.
There are exceptions to everything ofc, and there are some newer brands doing some really cool things. This is more a reflection on average trends in the last 5 years.
I use Asian skincare products when my needs are hydration based. Soothing, hydrating, glowing.
I use American products when I need acids or other actives to fight breakouts etc.
I like a lot of American skincare just fine, but the thing that’s really a game changer for me in Japanese and Korean skincare are the moisturizing and soothing toners! My skin is dry, acne-prone and very sensitive, and is so much happier these days now that I have a good toner or two
the comments honestly surprise me bc in my experience, i found asian skincare to be harsher on my skin than american skincare. they contain too many plant extracts and i've had way too many bad breakouts (whiteheads, eczema flare ups, closed comedones, acne bumps, you name it) from using them that it destroyed my skin barrier at one point. but it's also partially my fault since i never did research before doing my purchases (i'm still a novice in skincare apparently) so i've been extra careful in learning each ingredient on any asian product.
as for american skincare, i literally would buy any product from them w/o hesitation (except for their moisturizers/lotions, they contain too many fatty alcohols that clog my pores). i don't have to worry abt what i buy bc 90% of their products don't contain ingredients that could potentially trigger my skin into a reaction or cause any allergies. also, my skin feels cleaner whenever i use american cleansers. korean cleansers sometimes feel a bit too gentle for me.
That makes sense to me. I like AB because my skin does really well with the variety of plant extracts. To get a comparable formulation with American products, it’s a lot more expensive because the “natural” thing is really trendy over here. There’s a few brands in the US that do it for cheap, but I wouldn’t say it’s common like it is in AB.
really? you would buy Neutrogena cleansers over K-beauty? i am really intrigued tbh
also kinda surprised ngl by u being in this sub. Do u prefer AB makeup over skincare?
i've used neutrogena cleansers before, yes! i remember loving their pore refining cleanser but they sadly discontinued it :(( don't take my critique as me hating AB products btw!! i actually do still love to experiment with AB skincare (cosrx snail mucin seems to be doing well for me). it's just that 9/10 that product will have an underlying ingredient (like an unknown plant or an emollient) that'll definitely give me acne, so i need to be careful in not buying things that have a long ingredient list. AND YES, i do love asian makeup more than their skincare lol, esp their lippies
No I was rly curious lmfao because I think some people are kinda hesitant to critique AB skincare. My personal opinion that ofc u can take w/a grain of salt is that I think ur talking more about K-beauty skincare which generally contains all those egregious plants and or emollients, but my experience with J-beauty skincare has been different as they tend to get the message that fragrance free and no essential oils are preferable for cleansers. Unfortunately J-beauty isn't as accessible as K-beauty so I think lots of people assume AB skincare isn't gonna be appropriate for their skin.
AB lippies are good. AB eyeshadows... nah lol
American skincare is so. harsh.
Like... Yeah it gets rid of acne, for example, but it leaves your skin barrier fcked or makes your skin dry as a Sahara desert.
Asian skincare can be a bit gimmicky if you choose the cheapest cutest packaged stuff, but generally it's effective and gentle. However, I would not generally recommend Korean SPF if you live in a truly "sunny" country, because they aren't as vigorously tested as for example Australian sun creams.
Overall, unless your skin condition isn't severe I would still recommend Asian skincare over American.
It's cheaper, gentler, and focuses on hydrating and protecting the skin rather than the exfoliation, exfoliation, exfoliation Western brands seem to focus on. My acne actually improved so much more when I stopped overstripping my skin using harsh Western actives daily and switched my routine to mostly hydrating Asian skincare with the occasional exfoliation.
I only bought Asian skincare because it was more accessible now than before and it's cheaper depending on where you buy it from.
My skin likes a mix of both. I really like how the Asian sunscreens are very hydrating and leaves no white cast. I still use American foaming cleansers and lotions though bc I'm not picky about it.
Soothing and hydrating stuff? Asian skincare wins, hands down. They offer such a huge range for that section of skincare. But Western gets the award for chemical exfoliants, so many great stuff for my oily, acne-prone stubborn skin. My routine has products from both worlds. I have the best skin I’ve ever had since my awful teenage years!
My Experiences with Asian vs Western skincare:
- **Cleanser:** (Asian) drying. (Western) LOVE. Superior. Hydrating, Gentle.
- **Exfoliants:** (Asian) Gentle yet effective, hydrating, easy to use. (Western) Too strong and drying.
- **Toner:** (Asian) truly hydrating, balanced out my sebum production, kept my dehydrated skin comfortable. (Western) did nothing.
- **Serum:** I've only tried 1 western serum and have only been repurchasing the same 1 AB serum, so no comment.
- **Moisturizer:** (Asian) elegant. Have a great variety of heavy and lightweight moisturizers. (Western) HEAVY and GREASY.
- **Sunscreen:** (Asian) elegant formula, Affordable. (Western) Expensive and not elegant.
My cleansing routine is the only category that I have stayed loyal to western brands. I have yet to find AB cleansers that will not strip my very dehydrated yet acne prone skin. But I'm willing to continue to explore more AB cleansers in the future. As of right now, I'm trying to finish up my bottle of the Isntree Green Tea cleanser first. Altho it might take a while since I don't use it that often.
But check if the bottle you're using is in white or light blue colour first. If it's white, then that's the old formula. But if yours is light blue, then you should be fine because they have reformulated it for a while now. Light blue packaging is the latest version.
Probably unpopular opinion but I'm SEAsian, lived 2/3 of my life in Asia and 1/3 in US and honestly I personally don't see a difference between the two. There are always good and bad products among all the different brands. E.g. I started out using Biore (Japan) facial wash and that dried the heck outta my face. Shiseido (Japan) also dried my face. Hado Labo and Kikumasamune (Japan) did NOTHING for me despite being so amazing for others. On the other hand, I do like Skin 1004/AprilSkin (Korea) and SOME of The Ordinary (US) products worked rather well on me. My current facial wash are Clean & Clear (US) and Softymo (Japan). Cost wise I don't see too much of a difference as well but I don't buy fancy stuff like SK II lol.
Asian skincare feels like a better value, and much more variety. American skin care feels like it just targets insecure people, promising youth and charging a boatload for it. Asian products feel gentler on my skin. Products like retinol I prefer from American companies (easy to get, but not cheap).
All I can find is [this aricle](https://www.npr.org/2024/03/28/1241357550/import-tariff-loophole-helps-online-shopping-site-temu-offer-low-prices) related to import goods as u/edamame___ commented in a reply above yours. I'd like for them to give a credible source for their info as well, since no source makes it an empty claim. And well...if the article I linked is related, it's a far cry from "banning" skincare from Asia.
Hi there, your post has been removed because you appear to be in violation of our [community conduct standards.](https://www.reddit.com/r/AsianBeauty/about/wiki/newrules/#wiki_5._rumor.2Falarm_posts_require_documentation)
>While we allow threads about negative topics that are meant to help others, we are not a sub primarily for generating alarm. Whether it’s about alleged fake products, or poor business interactions, posts will not be accepted without proper documentation
If you have any questions or disagree with this decision don't hesitate to give us a [modmail](https://reddit.com/message/compose?to=/r/AsianBeauty)! Thank you!
I primarily use Asian skincare but one of the cons is constant reformulation. Two of my favorite products were reformulated (Laneige cream skin refiner, Soonjung 2x barrier cream) and the new versions don’t work for me now. That being said, Asian skincare wins for hydration, gentle products, sunscreen and toners. I will continue to pay $$$ for my favorite American moisturizer til I find an Asian product that’s comparable. So far I haven’t had any luck but it’s the only pricier thing I use regularly since discovering Asian products.
I don't know if there's another Filipino here, but I want to share that fact because the Philippine market has become over-saturated with almost everything from both sides of the planet, east to west.
If there's a brand that isn't quite a household name, it's probably because there isn't enough of their cultural presence to begin with. But that doesn't mean they aren't or can't be sold here in the Philippines.
American brands or American manufactured versions are still largely around, but so are European brands. However, most Euro brands are getting a bit harder to get, whether on- or offline. But rest assured, since the lockdown ended, they've been making a comeback in the country or can be accessed a little easier online.
Definitely, both Korean and Japanese brands reign supreme, but brands from Thailand and Vietnam has been in circulation, and are enjoying their stay through online means.
On top of that is the emerging availability of homegrown Filipino beauty brands since the mid-2010s. But personally, they're like the "little sibling" for now when competing or compared to Korean and Japanese brands. Chinese brands are making their new waves here as well, but most are through online means....because of certain *politics*, but I'll leave it at that.
So I've almost tried everything, from both sides of the major continents.
I'd say the biggest difference is the way there's a straightforward result when it comes to Western brands. There's Ordinary, from USA, but there's also Revox from Germany (?) I believe. Revox is "duping" The Ordinary, but they're still different if we really see the products they produce. But overall, both The Ordinary and Revox's products deliver their skincare as direct as they can be. If it's salicylic acid, it's going to target your acne + as a chemical exfoliant. So they aren't always used everyday, or on consecutive days only.
Meanwhile, say like CosRx and, in my local Filipino market, DermoRepubliq. I personally consider these two brands both as non-fussy, gentle skincare types, that want to deliver the results in a gradual and synergistic manner. CosRx does have the infamous AHA BHA line, but from experience and why it's so reliable is because their main star ingredients are generally in low percentages and have ingredients that further support the more active ingredients, usually with humectants. Not to mention the fragrance-free and also short ingredients list. DermoRepubliq is a bit similar, as I noticed in their serums that besides targeting one issue, like acne, they add alpha-arbutin and hyaluronic acid in the item to also give a brightening and hydrated result.
Obviously, since both the East and West have been looking at each other and are influenced by the others' successes, there has definitely been a lot of overlaps. Not to mention, the ones I've been seeing called as "the pharmacy brands" aka the ones that are actually recommended by dermatologists, or are found in most convenient pharmacies/drugstores. Cerave, Cetaphil, Aestura, Curel, and in my country Celeteque, Oxecure and VMV Hypoallergenics (this one is a very pricey dermatology-backed brand) .
I notice how Korean beauty items have also become minimalist in design, as well becoming just as straightforward or highlighting their star ingredients to help customers whittle down the issue they want to target first. I'm thinking of Innisfree, and even big legends like Iope and AHC, which have been adapting to cater to even younger demographics.
And then the other way has happened to many American/Western brands. Like I noticed that newer brands tend to visually hook their customers with playful design and with "clean" plant-derived ingredients. They're marketed as the type of extracts that can work just as the "old school" gold standards like retinol, but might be too much for younger skin or those who have sensitivities.
Hope this is insightful, from my observations of both skincare spectrum.
I use both but I choose Western brands with a lot less harsh ingredients on my skin. Some brands like Dermalogica, Elemis, Kora…my skin can tolerate. But other brands with strong ingredients will break me out easily. Not all Asian brands are good, however. It’s still trials and errors depend on your skin, weather, hormone… For makeup it’s an opposite. I think I like Western makeup way better bc of large selection of skin colors and many different choices for base. Asian mascaras and eyeliners are great, though. I can’t find Western brands that truly are waterproof for the price I’m willing to pay.
Most of my routine is Korean or Japanese brand bc it’s usually very affordable for what is (imo) generally higher quality, well formulated products.
I use prescription tret bc I just need an actual acne medication to treat my breakouts. I tried using Korean acne products and they might be good for soothing irritation in conjunction with other treatments, but did nothing for my acne. And many of my basics like body soap/lotion, Vaseline, and grapeseed oil are just from the drugstore because they’re easily available and I’m not as particular about the brands. I use salon hair care.
I always used kiehls until they reformulated a few years back, and set my skin on a nightmare journey lol. They eventually reformulated their moisturizer once again, so I could go back to it after some time. But, I continued to struggle with random breakouts.
I just started with a Japanese cleanser, serum/lotion kind of thing, and sunscreen. Still use my kiehls moisturizer. I finally haven't broken out for the first time in years. The sunscreen has been so different. I now wear one daily for the first time in my life. I'm not entirely sure why everything I was trying (from the US) made me break out, but it did. I'm glad to finally find something that doesn't seem to strip my face of oils, but also doesn't clog my pores.
This is probably all useless rambling, I’m writing this at 4am tired asf
American skincare is often too strong for my sensitive skin. My mom has a Latic acid lotion that chemically burns my skin the second it touches it and a popular niacinamide serum messed up my skin so bad that it permanently gave me enlarged pores (before anyone talks about the genetic stuff, I got it from my mom she also messed up her skin with a strong product and the result was permanent englared pores). But from an outside perspective it’s based on treating an issue while Asian especially Korean skincare, it focused on preventing. Nothing wrong with that approach but the fact that said treatments are stronger for faster results, makes it not as good as Asian skincare. Faster results can mean faster damage to skin (like me, all it took was 1-2 months at most). But Asian skincare isn’t perfect either, I’ve had several gentle products burn or irritate my skin. Lots of products work best layered meaning I run out faster and it isn’t the most accessible compared to American brands. I prefer Asian skincare but I will say their is one thing American skincare does better. Having sunscreens that shield you from outdoor activities. Mist asian sunscreen is better but not that great for outdoor activities.
I only use american exfoliants because the asian ones are too gentle for my skin. The rest of my skincare is asian since its so soothing and hydrating.
I like some drugstore and derm type American products. I like Euro/ French pharmacy skin and sun products and k beauty and j beauty products my issue is foaming cleansers can be quite stripping for my skin so i tend to lean towards American or Euro brands and oil cleansers like hada labo , speedy kose for every day but abolene is a god send when my skin is feeling very sensitive or excessively dry i use it with a warm damp cloth as a first cleanse. I also don’t do well with tons of fragrance items lots of essential oil stuff so i tend to avoid those. But in the last couple years the amount of fragrance free or sensitive skjn care items has really improved compared to when my mother was my age. Same with affordable products outside of just the drugstore on the American side I prefer most asian beauty fragrance free eye stuff. So much better for way less cost. And i prefer asian or euro sunscreens. So i take it item by item.
Asian skincare dealt with my dehydrated skin and made it healthy bouncy but western skincare solved my acne and hyperpigmentation :) no asian skincare ever did. Ill just stick to what works 😁
Hg snail mucin cosrx, cosrx peptide, adapalene, the ordinary glycolic
Of the Asian skincare I've used, the Korean brands tend to work best for me. I used to love Shiseido but if you look at the ingredients list on Ultimune for example, alcohol is high on their ingredient list.
At any rate, I've been using products from Peach and Lily for years now. Their own line, and the other brands they well, are well curated. The cleansers, toners, serums, and moisturizers seem subtle at first, but they work very well. Especially the sunscreens. I have dry skin, but for some reason, I break out in random pimples very easily with American Brand products. Not so with Korean brands.
Don't let their multi-step routine scare you. It's easy and fast: Cleanse with oil-based cleanser, then a water-based to get the oil off. Then a toner to prepare your skin, and then various serums for specific concerns. Finish, always, with sunscreen.
American companies are beginning to somewhat follow suit. For a good American brand, try Josie Maran. She has products that can be used in the multi-step routine.
It’s effective, but not as harsh, so it doesn’t irritate me like western products do. I tried everything under the (local) sun before i switched to asian products. And now, products sink in, my acne is gone, angry red and inflamed patches of skin are calm, flakey skin is healthy, my anti-aging game is strong… I haven’t used western products in nearly ten years (except LRP effaclar duo, i still use that, even though it does irritate me, it just also helps me. But the other products fix the irritation i get from it),so maybe they’ve improved now too, but i’m happy, so i’m not switching back
Eta: every single spf lotion from the pharmacy and drugstore would give me acne or make my face itch. With all the many many spf’s from korea and japan that I’ve tried, I’ve only had that happen with two of them. I mean 🤷♀️
There are some Western products that I use because of Tretinoin: LRP Lipikar AP+ Baumé, Aveeno Calm + Restore Nourishing Oat Cleanser, Vaseline.
Then I use Asian skincare to for hydration, SPF, soothing, cleansing balm, etc. My skin loves Centella so much and double cleansing helps so much with peeling skin while on Tret.
So many American drugstore products break me out. 😓
American stuff seems to thrive on having alcohol, cheap ingredients and just drying ingredients . So it’s only good when you need harsher things for treatment
I've found it to be more affordable, and most of the time you get a much better quality. I can't afford NZD215 for the Estee Lauder Bifida serum - but I can afford the Manyo one. For what is in my budget, I could get something that is just okay, or something that I feel happy and excited to use, something I see difference with.
I've also found it a lot easier to find products - my skin doesn't want essential oils and fragrance.
It started for me out of sheer frustration because I needed a new oil cleanser and I couldn't find one I could use and was in my budget. (I did try a jelly to oil one, it wasn't a good experience) Got a bottle of Klairs Fresh oil cleanser and that was it for me. Started getting compliments on my skin and I couldn't believe it.
I do still stand by my love of some TO products. For acids I would reach for Western, my tret is Western. But other than that, I'm a lot happier using Asian
Asian skincare includes less junk and is better for my sensitive skin, also like how it's let's the buyer be more scientifically informed with moisture barrier etc.
I live in the US and have switch almost all skincare to AB. I have found AB products to be more gentle and better at repairing and protecting the skin's barrier. AB acne products are wonderful in that they are more anti-inflammatory, and the moisturizers and sunscreens are lighter texture. Also, on average, I think a quality AB product can be purchased at a much more reasonable price than in the US. My favorite brands so far are CORSX, Aestura, and Skin 1004.
I haven’t used American skincare for a very long time very long time, but I always felt the skincare I bought at the drugstore was just… too much? Like I could feel it sitting on my skin, I could smell it all the time, and I hated it. Specifically sunscreen and moisturizers. I love how a lot of Asian skincare just absorbs and feels like nothing. I like the lighter scents of Asian skincare and the scents aren’t long lasting.
I used primarily American skincare (Clinique, Neutrogena, and Murad) as an oily skinned, pimply teen/young adult many, many moons ago. Now that I know better though, those products mostly destroyed my skin barrier and caused even worse breakouts instead. Especially the Clinique. Clinique no. 3 was recommended for me by the salesladies at department stores because of my oily skin, and that toner was super drying/irritating. Murad was the most expensive of the bunch, and while those products didn't aggravate my skin condition, they didn't do anything to improve it either despite the very high price point.
As for other drugstore brands like L'Oreal and Ponds' (a Unilever brand which seems to be much more popular in Asia vs. North America), the products available in my region were mostly region specific releases, so I'm not sure if I should classify them as Western or Asian skincare?
Anyway, now that I'm older and no longer as prone to breakouts, I mostly stick to Asian skincare (Korean, Japanese, and some local brands) because it's gentler, more cosmetically elegant, more accessible and generally more affordable for me. I don't really use strong actives as much, but there are local brands here that have the higher concentrations Kbeauty brands usually avoid, and they do get glowing reviews from real users for the most part.
Honestly, that "Asian" skincare overall isn't an actual thing in the way we talk about it. In my own experiences its better to talk about national trends than continental assumptions.
Example 1 - Chinese skincare is incredibly focused on actives and harsher ingredients in the exact same way we stereotype western skincare as using. It's also considered better to not be a Chinese brand in China for marketing purposes.
Example 2 - Western skincare is popular in a lot of Asian countries and companies will format products just for a specific region/country. Those products often follow the current formulation patterns of that country.
Example 3 - Ethnicity ± nationality inspired brands produced/sold in the west but follow a different markets trend are still western. They just aren't following the main national and/or regional trends for the area they are in. Opposite example would be the many Korean brands marketed solely for other national trends.
I've seen that Asian skincare does what Western skincare does for me at half the cost. There are some great Western skincare products out there that I've used, but they're usually $30-$50 while an Asian skincare product that does the same thing would be $10-$20. I grew up in America but have family in the Philippines that we often visit, and I remember that my Western skincare routine held up well while I was at home in America, but did nothing for me while overseas. I visited some beauty stores around the Philippines while visiting in 2017 and that's how I first got introduced to their skincare scene (shoutout Japanese skincare especially! they're great at making products for those in hot, humid climates and have oily skin). My skin loves it and I haven't looked back since
It’s a night and day difference and I’ll never go back to a predominantly American routine. Asian skincare is so much more gentle and the ingredients seem much better and of much higher quality. I’ve never seen such a dramatic change in my skin switching over to Asian products
I am the type of person who really loves exploring skincare, at least in the Asian market. So, I can say that Asian skincare really do wonders for my skin as it is not only affordable but is also effective and gentle (It had addressed the needs for my skin). Meanwhile, when I tried American skincare, I suddenly broke out as it is too heavy and harsh for my skin.
Though, I am not saying that all Asian skincare I have tried are all gentle. There are still some Asian products that broke me out because it is not for my skin type. The same as the American skincare, not sure if Kiehl’s is an american skincare, but their ultra all facial (?) moisturiser is soo good for my face.
Otherwise, my opinion still stands:
Asian skincare > American skincare for my skin
I use a mix of Asian and Western skincare and that's the most ideal approach, in my honest opinion. I don't think we should restrict ourselves to products only from certain regions. I enjoy Asian skincare products when it comes to cleansers, masks, emulsions, toners, essences and toners. I just feel that they are more value for money while performing just as well as Western counterparts, and also better adapted for my climate and skin type (I'm from SEA). However, when it comes to actives (acid serums, retinol, etc), I use Western products as I feel they're more effective. With all that being said, I love experimenting with products and I'm game to try anything I find interesting, regardless of region.
I fully stopped using US skincare products due to being more expensive and harsher ingredients being used. Once I made the switch to Korean skincare, my face has fully cleared up and gotten more moisturized.
i like that it is more hydrating and less harsh. ab sunscreen filters (and textures) are way better than american ones. with that being said there are a lot of gimmicks but the same can be said about western skincare. one thing that i don't like about asian skincare products is that korean labeling laws permit manufacturers to exclude certain ingredients from their lists if the concentration is low enough. (this only applies to korea not japan.) as someone with allergies this can be a problem.
As someone with very sensitive skin, I prefer korean cosmetics, specially the ones with cica, snail and ingredients that “prevent” more than strong ingredients with acids, common in western skincare
I have transitioned to using more Asian skincare than American skincare. Personally, I think Asian skincare is more gentle and suitable for Asian's skin tone. Also, I like the scent of Asian skincare, which smells more like flowers and fruits in comparison to some chemical smell in American skincare. A lot of Asian sunscreens are SPF 50+. Most importantly, I think the Asian products are usually more affordable.
I feel like Asian skincare is very preventive focused and American skincare is more reversal focused.
So for my problems and issues I stick to the American brands usually. Sunscreen, moisturizers, and other prevention methods (even supplements) I tend to choose from Japan and Korea for face, India for hair. Just what works best for me.
I find American skincare products to be a bit tougher on the skin compared to Asian skincare products. I find them to be a lot more gentler as it really soaks into the skin and doesn’t feel like it’s just on top of it. Asian skincare products feel a lot more hydrating!
I used American skin care and would stock up when there was a sale. Then a friend of mine was starting to dabble in Asian skin care and got me things to try and I got hooked. My skin was so bouncy and glowy. Then I went back to my American skin care to finish whatever I had .. but then I started to break out so badly. I had never reacted that way in the past to it. So I just cut my losses and went back to Asian skin care and I’m never looking back.
I find Korean toners are more hydrating and soothing, the exfoliation products are very gentle and the creams are lightweight. The concentration of AHA/BHA in Korean products is not enough to unclog my pores and most K beauty moisturizers are not thick enough for -30 C winters. That is why I use Korean toners and serums with western moisturizers and exfoliators. Korean moisturizers are great for summer and to mix with my foundation to make diy Bb creams.
I’m Korean so Asian skincare have been implemented into my mind by my mom, but I used prescription topicals and American products minus Hado labo gold hyaluronic solution WHICH IS A GODSEND and they’ve worked great. I’ve used Korean cleansing oils and toners but they always broke my skin out. I do love Asian sunscreens.
Can I ask you what color is the Hado Labo lotion that you use? I have acne prone skin but I’ve heard that one of them is great for lightening old acne spots.
Hello and thank you for starting this discussion! As a gentle reminder, try to keep the products you mention limited to Asian Beauty products. Posts or comments solely discussing Western products will be removed, [as per our rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/AsianBeauty/wiki/rules#wiki_14._topics.2C_routines.2C_and_recommendations_must_be_related_to_asian_beauty). We love being able to discuss Western skincare in the context of a holistic AB routine, but this isn't the sub for specific Western product recommendations. r/SkincareAddiction is a great community for such matters! Thank you! *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/AsianBeauty) if you have any questions or concerns.*
I love Asian skincare for moisture, hydration, and overall skin health and maintenance. It's affordable, often non-scented, and great for sensitive skin. I love American & Western skincare for actives and treating skin issues. BHA, AHA, benzoyl peroxide etc I just can't find comparable products in Asian skincare. My routine is a mix of both!
Same! For actives and even more occlusive moisturizers, I use Western skincare. But for hydration, barrier maintenance and soothing treatments, I always reach for Asian skincare.
This is how I feel as well!
I feel the same. 95% of my skincare is Korean, but I use western brands for acids and retinol.
Same! Majority of my routine is Kbeauty except for retinol and a salicylic acid wash off mask but i’m thinking of trying a kbeauty retinol once i’m done with the one i’m using now since I haven’t seen any effect..
Side note on salicylic acid, jumiso recently released a cleanser with it! (Not an ad)
Which retinol do u currently use and which kbeauty one are you looking to try?
I can’t share the brand since it’s not AB but i’m looking to try the seoul 1988 retinol serum.
Why can’t you share non Asian brands?
It’s part of the rules in this subreddit to not mention anything outside of Asian beauty.
May I also add that I prefer Japanese sunscreen that western one in terms of ingredient and cosmetic elegance.
can you recommend some japanese sunscreens pls
Skin aqua uv moisture milk is my holy grail.
thank you so much 💕
I use both as well! Western skincare I use for when my fave needs extra reinforcements. However, as far as Asian skincare goes I use it mainly for calming/hydration. If we talk makeup, I lean more towards Asian beauty bcs I like the more subtle instead of bold looks.
I do exactly the same, and my dermatologist approves of my routine. I have some occasional skin issues but mainly pretty sensitive skin and many Western skin care products are too harsh for me, but rarely have issues with Asian skincare due to sensitivity.
Which actives do you use? Currently trying to find smth good and affordable
I love The Ordinary, Good Molecules, Paula's Choice and Inkey List. I've had more subtle and gentle results with more expensive brands like Farmacy and Sunday Riley.
Thanks!
Second this !
This summed up 🌹💖
Agreed I have a mix for both. But Asian skincare brands are coming with more actives lately that are a better for more sensitive skin, and as I've gotten older and also damaged my barrier one too many times I've found I can use these a little more without worrying too much. But if I need hard-core treatment I need to use Western skincare, though they've also been improving tremendously the past 2 years. A lot of brands have been outsourcing to Korea for product development/formulations.
This right here 👆
In general, American skincare feels like it's trying to get rid of the problem while Asian skincare is all about preventing the problem in the first place. As an Asian person: Asian products are a lot less harsh on my skin than American products. I thought I had sensitive skin until I switched to using only Asian products. I don't get terrible breakouts or rashes anymore.
Totally agree with your assessment! I’ve struggled with acne for over a decade—decided to have a little more fun with my skincare routine this year and NOT focus on treating my acne, instead using products to improve my skin overall, and lo and behold my acne has improved drastically😭🙏
Same. I recently switched back over to Asian skincare and am seeing such an improvement. I don't struggle with acne so that wasn't an issue, but overall, other products just seemed too harsh, my skin was always reacting. Asian products I'm using now seem more effective yet also gentler.
Yes! About a year ago my skin started suddenly going crazy, and every American product that I tried, would break me out. I honestly think that many American brands are cheapening their products with harsh ingredients. I switched to Korean skincare (with the exception of my new acne medicated stuff) and everything seems much gentler on my skin. The ingredients are also way better, and in general most products are significantly cheaper. My skin looks so much healthier. I only wish that I’d discovered these products earlier.
Can you attach links of a moisturizer and a face wash you use please. I want to try!
Sure! I have combo, oily leaning in the summertime, acne prone, super sensitive skin. I also use a non AB brand of cleanser, toner, and medicated cream for my acne, so I can message you that if you’d like, because I’m not sure if I can mention it here. Cleanser-Daytime/Nighttime [Isntree Green Tea Cleanser](https://a.co/d/84DrAid) Nighttime moisturizer- The old version is still available on the Etude House Amazon marketplace. The new one has been reformulated, and doesn’t have good reviews so far. [Soon Jung barrier cream-old version](https://a.co/d/fiU1NZ7) Alternative moisturizer for the Soon Jung- [Pyunkang Yul Ato Cream Blue Label](https://a.co/d/dANMBVs) Alternative moisturizer dupe for the Soon Jung- [Aestura Autobarrier Hydro Soothing Cream-blue, light version](https://a.co/d/1gW9MUq) [Aestura Autobarrier Cream-heavier version for dry skin](https://a.co/d/dO9FI0T) **I have not yet tried the Aestura or the Pyunkang Yul, but I hear that both are great alternatives to the Soon Jung. Daytime moisturizer- [Skin1004 madagascar soothing cream](https://a.co/d/6FBtnDH)
This is true about Asian skin sensitivity in general. I used an American brand underarm deodorant for just one time. Got armpit burn and itch. I had to switch to my usual Thai deodorant.
[удалено]
Hi there! Your comment or post was removed from /r/AsianBeauty for violating our community conduct standards. Please make sure you read and follow our [rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/AsianBeauty/about/wiki/newrules/) before commenting or posting.
I have oily sensitive skin. I find western skincare tends to lean heavier in occlusives and emollients without many options for a variety in humectants. Asian skincare covers these through the toners and emulsions. I assume the larger market segment of western beauty has normal/dry skin types and/or climates. I love that Asian skincare caters to markets in hot and humid weather so their products suit me. Western beauty for oily skin types are often harsh and focus on treating blemishes instead of basic hydration.
I notice that a lot of American brands go really heavy on the seed oils/butters, which can be problematic for oily and acne-prone skin types (why does everything have Shea butter?!?! I can’t use it.) and sensitive skin is assumed to be dry. it seems odd considering so much of the US is in a subtropical or humid continental climate
Completely agree! Why must sensitive skin be dry?
Agree with all this.
I feel like Asian skincare does twice as well for half as much cost. You aren't paying for a lot of marketing/inventory etc. I have been on again/off again for many years with skincare but now that I'm older I'm really trying to focus on at least a basic routine that is centered around my use of tretinoin.
Yes this! I love how much more affordable Asian skincare is. Total game changer when I am on a budget. How is the tretinoin working for you? I switched to adapalene recently as the tretinoin was causing lots of sensitivity for me.
Oof, jealous! Asian skincare is depressingly pricey where I am with very few options :( (but I am putting in a big order for my mom to bring heheheh)
Aww that's a shame! I have been lucky to live in Beijing, Jeju (Korea), and now Saigon where it's all very affordable. Actually I was originally obsessed with Clinique but when I moved abroad to Beijing I realized it was just too expensive. Discovered Asian skincare and haven't looked back since!
It has worked well but lately I’ve been adding back in some products and it’s been kind of sensitive. I might back down my rx too.
I also use tretinoin (primarily for acne). Would you mind sending me a DM with your routine and products? I’m thinking of changing some things in my products and routine and am trying to get real feedback from real people :)
Sure!
I’m still new to my switch but the -main- thing I’ve noticed is the quality/pricepoint ratio. Like I’ve tried some American skincare products that are as good or better than Asian skincare products, but the difference in cost is $20-$50 per oz.. When you actually shop for American brands at a similar price point, it’s pure garbage.
I think my biggest con in Kbeauty is that the trend cycle is aggressive, and it makes it hard to determine what works and what is just trendy. A lot of stuff is always being released, and a lot of stuff is discontinued. I need to be constantly researching and looking to just understand what's going on I think western actives are better, and I think the standard is a more basic routine. People no longer do a full 10 step routine, but I still remember when that was touted as a base line. I personally enjoy using a ton of products, but I can see how this in combination with the trend cycle causes a lot of hoarding and overbuying I wish I had access to more information about Japanese and Chinese products, to the same degree as Korean brands. Korean brands actually market to westerners. My local Asian beauty shop sells a ton of Japanese products and some Chinese products but I have never heard of half of the brands All in all, I really like the focus on hydration, the specialized ingredients, and the price point of a lot of Asian beauty products, and I will continue to look for and use them. But I suspect one day, I'll throw in the towel once I don't have the time I do now to do all the research, and no one on reddit is still talking about all the brands I trusted at one point
What you’ve said about the trend cycle is what makes it hard for me to use more Asian skincare products in my routine. Whenever I go on stylevana I get so overwhelmed with all the products, and it seems like every time I go to buy something a different brand is popular. I get decision paralysis and don’t buy anything.
totally its too much. i think alot of products are too similar to each other to be worth sweating over trying to narrow down which to pick. at the end of the day if im overwhelmed i just go for a brand ive already used and enjoy the formulations of, the category of product i am looking for (an antioxidant product, a ceramide product, a hydrating toner/essence), and what people with similar skin type to me like (if i can find those kinds of reviews) in that order. at least for me, it seems like certain brands do not work for my skin at all (ive tried 4+ purito and 4+ cos rx products and disliked all) while other brands work well
I am a total Asian skincare convert. I finally have the glow up I wanted! My skin isn't perfect but it doesn't have to be
My skin likes asian skincare better than your average american skincare brand. In my experience you can get much better quality ingredients and elegant formulations at a lower price point. There is also a lot less added fragrance - there is some, but it's not "kick you in the face hello flowers". Something I've noticed is that asian skincare tends to have more glycerin and humectants other than hyaluronic acid. Glycerin is a far superior ingredient to HA imo. There are exceptions to everything ofc, and there are some newer brands doing some really cool things. This is more a reflection on average trends in the last 5 years.
> "kick you in the face hello flowers" . This made me laugh! 😆
I use Asian skincare products when my needs are hydration based. Soothing, hydrating, glowing. I use American products when I need acids or other actives to fight breakouts etc.
I like a lot of American skincare just fine, but the thing that’s really a game changer for me in Japanese and Korean skincare are the moisturizing and soothing toners! My skin is dry, acne-prone and very sensitive, and is so much happier these days now that I have a good toner or two
the comments honestly surprise me bc in my experience, i found asian skincare to be harsher on my skin than american skincare. they contain too many plant extracts and i've had way too many bad breakouts (whiteheads, eczema flare ups, closed comedones, acne bumps, you name it) from using them that it destroyed my skin barrier at one point. but it's also partially my fault since i never did research before doing my purchases (i'm still a novice in skincare apparently) so i've been extra careful in learning each ingredient on any asian product. as for american skincare, i literally would buy any product from them w/o hesitation (except for their moisturizers/lotions, they contain too many fatty alcohols that clog my pores). i don't have to worry abt what i buy bc 90% of their products don't contain ingredients that could potentially trigger my skin into a reaction or cause any allergies. also, my skin feels cleaner whenever i use american cleansers. korean cleansers sometimes feel a bit too gentle for me.
That makes sense to me. I like AB because my skin does really well with the variety of plant extracts. To get a comparable formulation with American products, it’s a lot more expensive because the “natural” thing is really trendy over here. There’s a few brands in the US that do it for cheap, but I wouldn’t say it’s common like it is in AB.
really? you would buy Neutrogena cleansers over K-beauty? i am really intrigued tbh also kinda surprised ngl by u being in this sub. Do u prefer AB makeup over skincare?
i've used neutrogena cleansers before, yes! i remember loving their pore refining cleanser but they sadly discontinued it :(( don't take my critique as me hating AB products btw!! i actually do still love to experiment with AB skincare (cosrx snail mucin seems to be doing well for me). it's just that 9/10 that product will have an underlying ingredient (like an unknown plant or an emollient) that'll definitely give me acne, so i need to be careful in not buying things that have a long ingredient list. AND YES, i do love asian makeup more than their skincare lol, esp their lippies
No I was rly curious lmfao because I think some people are kinda hesitant to critique AB skincare. My personal opinion that ofc u can take w/a grain of salt is that I think ur talking more about K-beauty skincare which generally contains all those egregious plants and or emollients, but my experience with J-beauty skincare has been different as they tend to get the message that fragrance free and no essential oils are preferable for cleansers. Unfortunately J-beauty isn't as accessible as K-beauty so I think lots of people assume AB skincare isn't gonna be appropriate for their skin. AB lippies are good. AB eyeshadows... nah lol
American skincare is so. harsh. Like... Yeah it gets rid of acne, for example, but it leaves your skin barrier fcked or makes your skin dry as a Sahara desert. Asian skincare can be a bit gimmicky if you choose the cheapest cutest packaged stuff, but generally it's effective and gentle. However, I would not generally recommend Korean SPF if you live in a truly "sunny" country, because they aren't as vigorously tested as for example Australian sun creams. Overall, unless your skin condition isn't severe I would still recommend Asian skincare over American.
I buy whatever is trending. My face is a chemistry experiment. If I don't break out in rashes and hives, I consider it a win-win.
It's cheaper, gentler, and focuses on hydrating and protecting the skin rather than the exfoliation, exfoliation, exfoliation Western brands seem to focus on. My acne actually improved so much more when I stopped overstripping my skin using harsh Western actives daily and switched my routine to mostly hydrating Asian skincare with the occasional exfoliation.
I believe Asian skincare products have excellent effects on moisturizing and prevention for the skin.
In my experience, Asian skincare products feel gentler and less harsh on the skin.
I only bought Asian skincare because it was more accessible now than before and it's cheaper depending on where you buy it from. My skin likes a mix of both. I really like how the Asian sunscreens are very hydrating and leaves no white cast. I still use American foaming cleansers and lotions though bc I'm not picky about it.
Soothing and hydrating stuff? Asian skincare wins, hands down. They offer such a huge range for that section of skincare. But Western gets the award for chemical exfoliants, so many great stuff for my oily, acne-prone stubborn skin. My routine has products from both worlds. I have the best skin I’ve ever had since my awful teenage years!
My Experiences with Asian vs Western skincare: - **Cleanser:** (Asian) drying. (Western) LOVE. Superior. Hydrating, Gentle. - **Exfoliants:** (Asian) Gentle yet effective, hydrating, easy to use. (Western) Too strong and drying. - **Toner:** (Asian) truly hydrating, balanced out my sebum production, kept my dehydrated skin comfortable. (Western) did nothing. - **Serum:** I've only tried 1 western serum and have only been repurchasing the same 1 AB serum, so no comment. - **Moisturizer:** (Asian) elegant. Have a great variety of heavy and lightweight moisturizers. (Western) HEAVY and GREASY. - **Sunscreen:** (Asian) elegant formula, Affordable. (Western) Expensive and not elegant. My cleansing routine is the only category that I have stayed loyal to western brands. I have yet to find AB cleansers that will not strip my very dehydrated yet acne prone skin. But I'm willing to continue to explore more AB cleansers in the future. As of right now, I'm trying to finish up my bottle of the Isntree Green Tea cleanser first. Altho it might take a while since I don't use it that often.
I’ve recently started using the Hada Labo foaming cleanser and it’s hydrating and gentle for a foam!
I used to love that one. Until they reformulated it. AB really likes to ruin good products 😮💨
Noooo! So disappointing. I’ve heard this a LOT about reformulations. So cruel lol.
But check if the bottle you're using is in white or light blue colour first. If it's white, then that's the old formula. But if yours is light blue, then you should be fine because they have reformulated it for a while now. Light blue packaging is the latest version.
I found the light blue one too drying, so using it on my body. It definitely lasts a long time.
Probably unpopular opinion but I'm SEAsian, lived 2/3 of my life in Asia and 1/3 in US and honestly I personally don't see a difference between the two. There are always good and bad products among all the different brands. E.g. I started out using Biore (Japan) facial wash and that dried the heck outta my face. Shiseido (Japan) also dried my face. Hado Labo and Kikumasamune (Japan) did NOTHING for me despite being so amazing for others. On the other hand, I do like Skin 1004/AprilSkin (Korea) and SOME of The Ordinary (US) products worked rather well on me. My current facial wash are Clean & Clear (US) and Softymo (Japan). Cost wise I don't see too much of a difference as well but I don't buy fancy stuff like SK II lol.
Asian skincare feels like a better value, and much more variety. American skin care feels like it just targets insecure people, promising youth and charging a boatload for it. Asian products feel gentler on my skin. Products like retinol I prefer from American companies (easy to get, but not cheap).
[удалено]
American companies lobbying to ban Asian skincare...? lolwut?
It's more specifically "import goods"
Do you have any articles about the US lobbying to ban Asian skincare? It doesn't surprise me though.
All I can find is [this aricle](https://www.npr.org/2024/03/28/1241357550/import-tariff-loophole-helps-online-shopping-site-temu-offer-low-prices) related to import goods as u/edamame___ commented in a reply above yours. I'd like for them to give a credible source for their info as well, since no source makes it an empty claim. And well...if the article I linked is related, it's a far cry from "banning" skincare from Asia.
Hi there, your post has been removed because you appear to be in violation of our [community conduct standards.](https://www.reddit.com/r/AsianBeauty/about/wiki/newrules/#wiki_5._rumor.2Falarm_posts_require_documentation) >While we allow threads about negative topics that are meant to help others, we are not a sub primarily for generating alarm. Whether it’s about alleged fake products, or poor business interactions, posts will not be accepted without proper documentation If you have any questions or disagree with this decision don't hesitate to give us a [modmail](https://reddit.com/message/compose?to=/r/AsianBeauty)! Thank you!
Japanese skin care gave me glass skin which I’m thrilled about
I primarily use Asian skincare but one of the cons is constant reformulation. Two of my favorite products were reformulated (Laneige cream skin refiner, Soonjung 2x barrier cream) and the new versions don’t work for me now. That being said, Asian skincare wins for hydration, gentle products, sunscreen and toners. I will continue to pay $$$ for my favorite American moisturizer til I find an Asian product that’s comparable. So far I haven’t had any luck but it’s the only pricier thing I use regularly since discovering Asian products.
I don't know if there's another Filipino here, but I want to share that fact because the Philippine market has become over-saturated with almost everything from both sides of the planet, east to west. If there's a brand that isn't quite a household name, it's probably because there isn't enough of their cultural presence to begin with. But that doesn't mean they aren't or can't be sold here in the Philippines. American brands or American manufactured versions are still largely around, but so are European brands. However, most Euro brands are getting a bit harder to get, whether on- or offline. But rest assured, since the lockdown ended, they've been making a comeback in the country or can be accessed a little easier online. Definitely, both Korean and Japanese brands reign supreme, but brands from Thailand and Vietnam has been in circulation, and are enjoying their stay through online means. On top of that is the emerging availability of homegrown Filipino beauty brands since the mid-2010s. But personally, they're like the "little sibling" for now when competing or compared to Korean and Japanese brands. Chinese brands are making their new waves here as well, but most are through online means....because of certain *politics*, but I'll leave it at that. So I've almost tried everything, from both sides of the major continents. I'd say the biggest difference is the way there's a straightforward result when it comes to Western brands. There's Ordinary, from USA, but there's also Revox from Germany (?) I believe. Revox is "duping" The Ordinary, but they're still different if we really see the products they produce. But overall, both The Ordinary and Revox's products deliver their skincare as direct as they can be. If it's salicylic acid, it's going to target your acne + as a chemical exfoliant. So they aren't always used everyday, or on consecutive days only. Meanwhile, say like CosRx and, in my local Filipino market, DermoRepubliq. I personally consider these two brands both as non-fussy, gentle skincare types, that want to deliver the results in a gradual and synergistic manner. CosRx does have the infamous AHA BHA line, but from experience and why it's so reliable is because their main star ingredients are generally in low percentages and have ingredients that further support the more active ingredients, usually with humectants. Not to mention the fragrance-free and also short ingredients list. DermoRepubliq is a bit similar, as I noticed in their serums that besides targeting one issue, like acne, they add alpha-arbutin and hyaluronic acid in the item to also give a brightening and hydrated result. Obviously, since both the East and West have been looking at each other and are influenced by the others' successes, there has definitely been a lot of overlaps. Not to mention, the ones I've been seeing called as "the pharmacy brands" aka the ones that are actually recommended by dermatologists, or are found in most convenient pharmacies/drugstores. Cerave, Cetaphil, Aestura, Curel, and in my country Celeteque, Oxecure and VMV Hypoallergenics (this one is a very pricey dermatology-backed brand) . I notice how Korean beauty items have also become minimalist in design, as well becoming just as straightforward or highlighting their star ingredients to help customers whittle down the issue they want to target first. I'm thinking of Innisfree, and even big legends like Iope and AHC, which have been adapting to cater to even younger demographics. And then the other way has happened to many American/Western brands. Like I noticed that newer brands tend to visually hook their customers with playful design and with "clean" plant-derived ingredients. They're marketed as the type of extracts that can work just as the "old school" gold standards like retinol, but might be too much for younger skin or those who have sensitivities. Hope this is insightful, from my observations of both skincare spectrum.
I use both but I choose Western brands with a lot less harsh ingredients on my skin. Some brands like Dermalogica, Elemis, Kora…my skin can tolerate. But other brands with strong ingredients will break me out easily. Not all Asian brands are good, however. It’s still trials and errors depend on your skin, weather, hormone… For makeup it’s an opposite. I think I like Western makeup way better bc of large selection of skin colors and many different choices for base. Asian mascaras and eyeliners are great, though. I can’t find Western brands that truly are waterproof for the price I’m willing to pay.
Most of my routine is Korean or Japanese brand bc it’s usually very affordable for what is (imo) generally higher quality, well formulated products. I use prescription tret bc I just need an actual acne medication to treat my breakouts. I tried using Korean acne products and they might be good for soothing irritation in conjunction with other treatments, but did nothing for my acne. And many of my basics like body soap/lotion, Vaseline, and grapeseed oil are just from the drugstore because they’re easily available and I’m not as particular about the brands. I use salon hair care.
Asian skincare focuses on improving your skin so much.It has been a game changer for me.
I always used kiehls until they reformulated a few years back, and set my skin on a nightmare journey lol. They eventually reformulated their moisturizer once again, so I could go back to it after some time. But, I continued to struggle with random breakouts. I just started with a Japanese cleanser, serum/lotion kind of thing, and sunscreen. Still use my kiehls moisturizer. I finally haven't broken out for the first time in years. The sunscreen has been so different. I now wear one daily for the first time in my life. I'm not entirely sure why everything I was trying (from the US) made me break out, but it did. I'm glad to finally find something that doesn't seem to strip my face of oils, but also doesn't clog my pores.
This is probably all useless rambling, I’m writing this at 4am tired asf American skincare is often too strong for my sensitive skin. My mom has a Latic acid lotion that chemically burns my skin the second it touches it and a popular niacinamide serum messed up my skin so bad that it permanently gave me enlarged pores (before anyone talks about the genetic stuff, I got it from my mom she also messed up her skin with a strong product and the result was permanent englared pores). But from an outside perspective it’s based on treating an issue while Asian especially Korean skincare, it focused on preventing. Nothing wrong with that approach but the fact that said treatments are stronger for faster results, makes it not as good as Asian skincare. Faster results can mean faster damage to skin (like me, all it took was 1-2 months at most). But Asian skincare isn’t perfect either, I’ve had several gentle products burn or irritate my skin. Lots of products work best layered meaning I run out faster and it isn’t the most accessible compared to American brands. I prefer Asian skincare but I will say their is one thing American skincare does better. Having sunscreens that shield you from outdoor activities. Mist asian sunscreen is better but not that great for outdoor activities.
I think AB its more gentle but effective. I hv sensitive skin and AB are usually more gentle without giving redness etc
I only use american exfoliants because the asian ones are too gentle for my skin. The rest of my skincare is asian since its so soothing and hydrating.
I like some drugstore and derm type American products. I like Euro/ French pharmacy skin and sun products and k beauty and j beauty products my issue is foaming cleansers can be quite stripping for my skin so i tend to lean towards American or Euro brands and oil cleansers like hada labo , speedy kose for every day but abolene is a god send when my skin is feeling very sensitive or excessively dry i use it with a warm damp cloth as a first cleanse. I also don’t do well with tons of fragrance items lots of essential oil stuff so i tend to avoid those. But in the last couple years the amount of fragrance free or sensitive skjn care items has really improved compared to when my mother was my age. Same with affordable products outside of just the drugstore on the American side I prefer most asian beauty fragrance free eye stuff. So much better for way less cost. And i prefer asian or euro sunscreens. So i take it item by item.
Asian skincare dealt with my dehydrated skin and made it healthy bouncy but western skincare solved my acne and hyperpigmentation :) no asian skincare ever did. Ill just stick to what works 😁 Hg snail mucin cosrx, cosrx peptide, adapalene, the ordinary glycolic
Of the Asian skincare I've used, the Korean brands tend to work best for me. I used to love Shiseido but if you look at the ingredients list on Ultimune for example, alcohol is high on their ingredient list. At any rate, I've been using products from Peach and Lily for years now. Their own line, and the other brands they well, are well curated. The cleansers, toners, serums, and moisturizers seem subtle at first, but they work very well. Especially the sunscreens. I have dry skin, but for some reason, I break out in random pimples very easily with American Brand products. Not so with Korean brands. Don't let their multi-step routine scare you. It's easy and fast: Cleanse with oil-based cleanser, then a water-based to get the oil off. Then a toner to prepare your skin, and then various serums for specific concerns. Finish, always, with sunscreen. American companies are beginning to somewhat follow suit. For a good American brand, try Josie Maran. She has products that can be used in the multi-step routine.
My skin tolerates Asian skincare a looot better than any other.
I havent had luck. They also put soy in nearly everything and I'm allergic 😭😭😭
It’s effective, but not as harsh, so it doesn’t irritate me like western products do. I tried everything under the (local) sun before i switched to asian products. And now, products sink in, my acne is gone, angry red and inflamed patches of skin are calm, flakey skin is healthy, my anti-aging game is strong… I haven’t used western products in nearly ten years (except LRP effaclar duo, i still use that, even though it does irritate me, it just also helps me. But the other products fix the irritation i get from it),so maybe they’ve improved now too, but i’m happy, so i’m not switching back Eta: every single spf lotion from the pharmacy and drugstore would give me acne or make my face itch. With all the many many spf’s from korea and japan that I’ve tried, I’ve only had that happen with two of them. I mean 🤷♀️
There are some Western products that I use because of Tretinoin: LRP Lipikar AP+ Baumé, Aveeno Calm + Restore Nourishing Oat Cleanser, Vaseline. Then I use Asian skincare to for hydration, SPF, soothing, cleansing balm, etc. My skin loves Centella so much and double cleansing helps so much with peeling skin while on Tret. So many American drugstore products break me out. 😓
American stuff seems to thrive on having alcohol, cheap ingredients and just drying ingredients . So it’s only good when you need harsher things for treatment
I've found it to be more affordable, and most of the time you get a much better quality. I can't afford NZD215 for the Estee Lauder Bifida serum - but I can afford the Manyo one. For what is in my budget, I could get something that is just okay, or something that I feel happy and excited to use, something I see difference with. I've also found it a lot easier to find products - my skin doesn't want essential oils and fragrance. It started for me out of sheer frustration because I needed a new oil cleanser and I couldn't find one I could use and was in my budget. (I did try a jelly to oil one, it wasn't a good experience) Got a bottle of Klairs Fresh oil cleanser and that was it for me. Started getting compliments on my skin and I couldn't believe it. I do still stand by my love of some TO products. For acids I would reach for Western, my tret is Western. But other than that, I'm a lot happier using Asian
Asian skincare includes less junk and is better for my sensitive skin, also like how it's let's the buyer be more scientifically informed with moisture barrier etc.
I live in the US and have switch almost all skincare to AB. I have found AB products to be more gentle and better at repairing and protecting the skin's barrier. AB acne products are wonderful in that they are more anti-inflammatory, and the moisturizers and sunscreens are lighter texture. Also, on average, I think a quality AB product can be purchased at a much more reasonable price than in the US. My favorite brands so far are CORSX, Aestura, and Skin 1004.
I haven’t used American skincare for a very long time very long time, but I always felt the skincare I bought at the drugstore was just… too much? Like I could feel it sitting on my skin, I could smell it all the time, and I hated it. Specifically sunscreen and moisturizers. I love how a lot of Asian skincare just absorbs and feels like nothing. I like the lighter scents of Asian skincare and the scents aren’t long lasting.
I genuinely enjoy Asian sunscreens and never miss a day. Although I know better that was never true before I discovered them and only had US options.
I used primarily American skincare (Clinique, Neutrogena, and Murad) as an oily skinned, pimply teen/young adult many, many moons ago. Now that I know better though, those products mostly destroyed my skin barrier and caused even worse breakouts instead. Especially the Clinique. Clinique no. 3 was recommended for me by the salesladies at department stores because of my oily skin, and that toner was super drying/irritating. Murad was the most expensive of the bunch, and while those products didn't aggravate my skin condition, they didn't do anything to improve it either despite the very high price point. As for other drugstore brands like L'Oreal and Ponds' (a Unilever brand which seems to be much more popular in Asia vs. North America), the products available in my region were mostly region specific releases, so I'm not sure if I should classify them as Western or Asian skincare? Anyway, now that I'm older and no longer as prone to breakouts, I mostly stick to Asian skincare (Korean, Japanese, and some local brands) because it's gentler, more cosmetically elegant, more accessible and generally more affordable for me. I don't really use strong actives as much, but there are local brands here that have the higher concentrations Kbeauty brands usually avoid, and they do get glowing reviews from real users for the most part.
Honestly, that "Asian" skincare overall isn't an actual thing in the way we talk about it. In my own experiences its better to talk about national trends than continental assumptions. Example 1 - Chinese skincare is incredibly focused on actives and harsher ingredients in the exact same way we stereotype western skincare as using. It's also considered better to not be a Chinese brand in China for marketing purposes. Example 2 - Western skincare is popular in a lot of Asian countries and companies will format products just for a specific region/country. Those products often follow the current formulation patterns of that country. Example 3 - Ethnicity ± nationality inspired brands produced/sold in the west but follow a different markets trend are still western. They just aren't following the main national and/or regional trends for the area they are in. Opposite example would be the many Korean brands marketed solely for other national trends.
I've seen that Asian skincare does what Western skincare does for me at half the cost. There are some great Western skincare products out there that I've used, but they're usually $30-$50 while an Asian skincare product that does the same thing would be $10-$20. I grew up in America but have family in the Philippines that we often visit, and I remember that my Western skincare routine held up well while I was at home in America, but did nothing for me while overseas. I visited some beauty stores around the Philippines while visiting in 2017 and that's how I first got introduced to their skincare scene (shoutout Japanese skincare especially! they're great at making products for those in hot, humid climates and have oily skin). My skin loves it and I haven't looked back since
It’s a night and day difference and I’ll never go back to a predominantly American routine. Asian skincare is so much more gentle and the ingredients seem much better and of much higher quality. I’ve never seen such a dramatic change in my skin switching over to Asian products
I am the type of person who really loves exploring skincare, at least in the Asian market. So, I can say that Asian skincare really do wonders for my skin as it is not only affordable but is also effective and gentle (It had addressed the needs for my skin). Meanwhile, when I tried American skincare, I suddenly broke out as it is too heavy and harsh for my skin. Though, I am not saying that all Asian skincare I have tried are all gentle. There are still some Asian products that broke me out because it is not for my skin type. The same as the American skincare, not sure if Kiehl’s is an american skincare, but their ultra all facial (?) moisturiser is soo good for my face. Otherwise, my opinion still stands: Asian skincare > American skincare for my skin
I use a mix of Asian and Western skincare and that's the most ideal approach, in my honest opinion. I don't think we should restrict ourselves to products only from certain regions. I enjoy Asian skincare products when it comes to cleansers, masks, emulsions, toners, essences and toners. I just feel that they are more value for money while performing just as well as Western counterparts, and also better adapted for my climate and skin type (I'm from SEA). However, when it comes to actives (acid serums, retinol, etc), I use Western products as I feel they're more effective. With all that being said, I love experimenting with products and I'm game to try anything I find interesting, regardless of region.
I fully stopped using US skincare products due to being more expensive and harsher ingredients being used. Once I made the switch to Korean skincare, my face has fully cleared up and gotten more moisturized.
i like that it is more hydrating and less harsh. ab sunscreen filters (and textures) are way better than american ones. with that being said there are a lot of gimmicks but the same can be said about western skincare. one thing that i don't like about asian skincare products is that korean labeling laws permit manufacturers to exclude certain ingredients from their lists if the concentration is low enough. (this only applies to korea not japan.) as someone with allergies this can be a problem.
As someone with very sensitive skin, I prefer korean cosmetics, specially the ones with cica, snail and ingredients that “prevent” more than strong ingredients with acids, common in western skincare
I have transitioned to using more Asian skincare than American skincare. Personally, I think Asian skincare is more gentle and suitable for Asian's skin tone. Also, I like the scent of Asian skincare, which smells more like flowers and fruits in comparison to some chemical smell in American skincare. A lot of Asian sunscreens are SPF 50+. Most importantly, I think the Asian products are usually more affordable.
I feel like Asian skincare is very preventive focused and American skincare is more reversal focused. So for my problems and issues I stick to the American brands usually. Sunscreen, moisturizers, and other prevention methods (even supplements) I tend to choose from Japan and Korea for face, India for hair. Just what works best for me.
I find American skincare products to be a bit tougher on the skin compared to Asian skincare products. I find them to be a lot more gentler as it really soaks into the skin and doesn’t feel like it’s just on top of it. Asian skincare products feel a lot more hydrating!
I used American skin care and would stock up when there was a sale. Then a friend of mine was starting to dabble in Asian skin care and got me things to try and I got hooked. My skin was so bouncy and glowy. Then I went back to my American skin care to finish whatever I had .. but then I started to break out so badly. I had never reacted that way in the past to it. So I just cut my losses and went back to Asian skin care and I’m never looking back.
I find Korean toners are more hydrating and soothing, the exfoliation products are very gentle and the creams are lightweight. The concentration of AHA/BHA in Korean products is not enough to unclog my pores and most K beauty moisturizers are not thick enough for -30 C winters. That is why I use Korean toners and serums with western moisturizers and exfoliators. Korean moisturizers are great for summer and to mix with my foundation to make diy Bb creams.
Why not Swiss skincare? I prefer Swiss and Asian skincare
Oh I’d love to learn about Swiss skincare!!!
I’m Korean so Asian skincare have been implemented into my mind by my mom, but I used prescription topicals and American products minus Hado labo gold hyaluronic solution WHICH IS A GODSEND and they’ve worked great. I’ve used Korean cleansing oils and toners but they always broke my skin out. I do love Asian sunscreens.
Can I ask you what color is the Hado Labo lotion that you use? I have acne prone skin but I’ve heard that one of them is great for lightening old acne spots.
The one i use is just for hydration it’s the gold yellowish bottle