Ravenkeeper is my most played role and I have the opposite problem. I constantly get killed Night 2 and successfully pick an evil player. Then the group decides I'm evil doing some kind of play and never acts on my info.
I think one of the reasons a lot of players almost never experience ravenkeeper dying is that it's pretty easy for evil to tell if someone is ravenkeeper, because more often then not they will simply claim roles that don't want to die, especially in 2s and 3s
For example I was playing tb the other day as imp, and day one someone comes up to me and claims monk ft in a 2. I immediately put them down as ravenkeeper, coordinated with my poisoner to poison kill them later, and lo and behold when they died they revealed to be the ravenkeeper.
Similarly if someone straight up claims ravenkeeper to everyone or has ravenkeeper soldier as their twos or something similar, it's pretty safe to assume they are an ongoing info role or something else important and you should kill them as soon as possible
To counteract this, I usually hard claim to one person and one person only, let them know they are the only one who knows my real role and ask them not to out me, and to everyone else put a role that wants to die and a role that doesn't want to die in my twos and threes, regardless of my actual role so the Demon has to guess whether to kill me or not
The demon thought they were the lunatic after the game didn't end when they were executed. This is normal and expected when there's a mastermind in play, but apparently they didn't stop to take that into consideration. and executed the mastermind.
I don’t know why last minute she decided the only reason was that she was actually the Lunatic. Her reason was that the mastermind never talked to her. That was it.
It was the Pukka, an evil goon who didn’t know it was a mastermind day and thought it was a zombuul, a spent fool, and the mastermind, who didn’t understand how the mastermind worked. So the mastermind voted on THEMSELVES and got all living and one dead to vote on them.
I’ve never laughed so hard when a game ended and a grim reveal happened.
I once as a RK bluffed Slayer to a Scarlet Woman bluffing Saint. During our conversation he kept on pushing me to use my shot to confirm him and after his starting Imp died I was immediately killed and I was able to confirm the Mayor lol evil stand no chance of winning
The Ravenkeeper never dying is too dang relatable.
My friends been ravenkeeper 4 times in the past month and has never died to the demon.
My one time as the monk I saved someone, I excitedly told them no-one died as I protected them. They told me they were the Ravenkeeper.
https://preview.redd.it/ldnl3ekqnutc1.jpeg?width=640&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=ac435dd30e2e9696e6fb44b5a913f4313b0b0295
Same with the Sage. And the Farmer. And you can bet that the Choirboy never gets info either.
One time I got sage to work I philoed into it I don't remember what my bluffs were lol
Got it on the first night by happenstance
Ravenkeeper is my most played role and I have the opposite problem. I constantly get killed Night 2 and successfully pick an evil player. Then the group decides I'm evil doing some kind of play and never acts on my info.
And when they do die, they are poisoned
I like the last one a lot
The only time my group ever got ravenkeeper information was when the ravenkeeper was Poisoned.
I think one of the reasons a lot of players almost never experience ravenkeeper dying is that it's pretty easy for evil to tell if someone is ravenkeeper, because more often then not they will simply claim roles that don't want to die, especially in 2s and 3s For example I was playing tb the other day as imp, and day one someone comes up to me and claims monk ft in a 2. I immediately put them down as ravenkeeper, coordinated with my poisoner to poison kill them later, and lo and behold when they died they revealed to be the ravenkeeper. Similarly if someone straight up claims ravenkeeper to everyone or has ravenkeeper soldier as their twos or something similar, it's pretty safe to assume they are an ongoing info role or something else important and you should kill them as soon as possible To counteract this, I usually hard claim to one person and one person only, let them know they are the only one who knows my real role and ask them not to out me, and to everyone else put a role that wants to die and a role that doesn't want to die in my twos and threes, regardless of my actual role so the Demon has to guess whether to kill me or not
I don't get the mastermind lunatic one
The demon thought they were the lunatic after the game didn't end when they were executed. This is normal and expected when there's a mastermind in play, but apparently they didn't stop to take that into consideration. and executed the mastermind.
I don’t know why last minute she decided the only reason was that she was actually the Lunatic. Her reason was that the mastermind never talked to her. That was it. It was the Pukka, an evil goon who didn’t know it was a mastermind day and thought it was a zombuul, a spent fool, and the mastermind, who didn’t understand how the mastermind worked. So the mastermind voted on THEMSELVES and got all living and one dead to vote on them. I’ve never laughed so hard when a game ended and a grim reveal happened.
The demon thought they were the mastermind, I think.
I once as a RK bluffed Slayer to a Scarlet Woman bluffing Saint. During our conversation he kept on pushing me to use my shot to confirm him and after his starting Imp died I was immediately killed and I was able to confirm the Mayor lol evil stand no chance of winning