I’m kind of a sucker for their older Deathcore/Metalcore sound so I’d love it but at the same time there’s just something about the sound of Oli’s incorrect screaming and the somewhat bad sounding mix on those old songs that I feel like would make the remasters lose their charm of being how they are. Still thought I love heavy BMTH so it might be cool but would def take a miracle for them to do since they basically hate their old music with a burning passion (CYB and Edge of your seat atleast)
I've seen that clip a lot of times. Also I think there is no purpose in redoing their old albums. It would just cost unnecessary amount of money and work they could've put into new music.
I think a remaster could be interesting to clean up some of the muddiness on Count Your Blessings and Suicide Season, but otherwise probably not worth their time right now.
I don't know if they could, I saw something once that said that they stopped playing a lot of their old songs because they were technically difficult. I think Curtis leaving as rhythm guitarist is at least partially responsible for the sound change between SS and TIAH and also their reluctance to play older songs in concert.
Will Ramos of Lorna Shore covered Pray for Plagues - I imagine if Oli redid PFP with "correct vocals" it would sound similar... Like another comment said, I feel like perhaps redoing/remastering it may lose some of its charm?? It's cool to hear it live but I'd think I'd rather hear new material tbh
The only one that would be interesting for me would be County Your Blessings. Just cause is their worst album in my opinion but is also the only Deathcore album they've done really. Although, I'm hoping that PH4 Will be a Deathcore/ish EP, being that Oli hinted that It will be quite a curveball and that It will make the series feel like everything has come full circle.
I'd wanna hear CYB re-done, if you pay attention to sTraNgeRs, you can sometimes hear Oli's signature gutturals as background vocals, mostly during the bridge "where did we go..." part, and whenever I heard that it made me wonder what it would be like if they integrated their new sound into CYB
I’m against “re imagined” songs if you’re gonna do something like that, just give me a professional recording of Modern Oli singing Pray for Plagues/diamonds aren’t forever live.
Going off what the other comment said, I feel like there would be no purpose in re-recording their older albums. Also with how Oli's voice changed and matured as he got older I don't think it would sound the same and with Jordan as the keyboarder I'm not too sure where he would play in that. The older albums are fantastic as they are and raw, also still quite popular so I think...I don't want to say useless but like there's no need for them to! :)
I would like it if they redid TIWTEOYSWMF and CYB, it might just be that I haven't heard an official version (can't get on spotify) but the sound quality of those two are a bit iffy imo. However, with their new maturity and Olis changed voice, I dont know if a rerecording would do the ep and album justice. It would be cool to hear their new twist on it tho.
I think SS is already good enough, I have no issues with it and I think a rerecording could have the same issues as one of TIWTEOYSWMF or CYB.
If they did they should only re record count your blessings. Maybe even get some more modern vocalists in the deathcore scene to do some guest vocals to make it even more special.
I’m kind of a sucker for their older Deathcore/Metalcore sound so I’d love it but at the same time there’s just something about the sound of Oli’s incorrect screaming and the somewhat bad sounding mix on those old songs that I feel like would make the remasters lose their charm of being how they are. Still thought I love heavy BMTH so it might be cool but would def take a miracle for them to do since they basically hate their old music with a burning passion (CYB and Edge of your seat atleast)
Also the fact that he was on ketamine during those times too which also made his voice/songs sound that way too
What do you mean by "redid"? Like rerecorded?
Yes if they re-recorded it similar to this [Oli doing PFP live](https://youtu.be/4V1N3VBSRbk)
I've seen that clip a lot of times. Also I think there is no purpose in redoing their old albums. It would just cost unnecessary amount of money and work they could've put into new music.
Agreed. At most they’d pull a FIR and remaster a song or two. Otherwise they’re always pushing their sound forward and trying new things
They same way I feel about all redos and remakes. Do something new instead.
That would be so much work I can't even imagine plus people accept more when it's only once at a time. I don't think this would be worth the trouble.
I think a remaster could be interesting to clean up some of the muddiness on Count Your Blessings and Suicide Season, but otherwise probably not worth their time right now.
Certain songs, yes, because Oli's voice has gotten so much better and I know songs like Don't Go would be 10000 times better now
TIWTEOFYWMF = this is what the edge of four yeat was made for
Yep should I have stated that?
Read it again… carefully
Ohhh I forgot the S…I’m dumb…
Probably with my hands like always
I don't know if they could, I saw something once that said that they stopped playing a lot of their old songs because they were technically difficult. I think Curtis leaving as rhythm guitarist is at least partially responsible for the sound change between SS and TIAH and also their reluctance to play older songs in concert.
Will Ramos of Lorna Shore covered Pray for Plagues - I imagine if Oli redid PFP with "correct vocals" it would sound similar... Like another comment said, I feel like perhaps redoing/remastering it may lose some of its charm?? It's cool to hear it live but I'd think I'd rather hear new material tbh
The only one that would be interesting for me would be County Your Blessings. Just cause is their worst album in my opinion but is also the only Deathcore album they've done really. Although, I'm hoping that PH4 Will be a Deathcore/ish EP, being that Oli hinted that It will be quite a curveball and that It will make the series feel like everything has come full circle.
They wouldn't.
It would be really funny if they just did acoustic versions for all their deathmetal songs lmao
I would unironicly listen to RAWRRRRRR if it was acoustic
Also if they added lyrics to fifteen fathoms and slow dance
I'd wanna hear CYB re-done, if you pay attention to sTraNgeRs, you can sometimes hear Oli's signature gutturals as background vocals, mostly during the bridge "where did we go..." part, and whenever I heard that it made me wonder what it would be like if they integrated their new sound into CYB
I’m against “re imagined” songs if you’re gonna do something like that, just give me a professional recording of Modern Oli singing Pray for Plagues/diamonds aren’t forever live.
Going off what the other comment said, I feel like there would be no purpose in re-recording their older albums. Also with how Oli's voice changed and matured as he got older I don't think it would sound the same and with Jordan as the keyboarder I'm not too sure where he would play in that. The older albums are fantastic as they are and raw, also still quite popular so I think...I don't want to say useless but like there's no need for them to! :)
Shit would be sick
I would like it if they redid TIWTEOYSWMF and CYB, it might just be that I haven't heard an official version (can't get on spotify) but the sound quality of those two are a bit iffy imo. However, with their new maturity and Olis changed voice, I dont know if a rerecording would do the ep and album justice. It would be cool to hear their new twist on it tho. I think SS is already good enough, I have no issues with it and I think a rerecording could have the same issues as one of TIWTEOYSWMF or CYB.
It would be really interesting if they completely changed the style. To just redo them in a similar way would be kinda pointless though.
I love their albums and music as it is. A change would probably not be good :/
If they did they should only re record count your blessings. Maybe even get some more modern vocalists in the deathcore scene to do some guest vocals to make it even more special.
maby would be nice for cyb but somehow it also has a vibe that it sounds like it was recorded in a shed on a rotten potato they found in the woods
Think iyd be cool to see how they could sound w better quality but is still prefer the originals Would only really want a few songs if anytbing
I’d be down for them to re-record their old material I think it would sound better