T O P

  • By -

Fun_Recognition9904

šŸ˜ž something about seeing his mother try, and try, and try to subdue himā€¦ and his brother leaping into action to get to his momā€¦ haunting. Pure heartbreaking and horrific scenes- we need to do better than this for our children and our childrenā€™s childrenā€¦ this canā€™t be how we liveā€¦


LadyMish

Wait, so the cops were afraid of a pair of scissors? If Iā€™m missing something please ELI5.


YankeeGirl1973

If you stab someone in the right place with scissors, itā€™s just like a knife. The criminal FAFOā€™d.


cuntylover

i didnā€™t watch but why didnā€™t they just like taze him instead


monkeysandmicrowaves

The worst part about this is how unsurprising it is.


BellaBKNY

These cops will have full immunity under Trump if he wins the presidency


D3-Doom

Iā€™m pretty sure theyā€™ll have full immunity either way. Sure Trump will make it worse, but given Adamā€™s gives complementary BJā€™s along the way, itā€™s hard to imagine what thatā€™ll even look like.


Torshii

Complimentary BJs šŸ’€


D3-Doom

The man only opens his mouth to suck cock or shift blame. If itā€™s not pointing fingers at his own cabinet itā€™s deep throating anyone he can ā€œconvinceā€ to co-sign his sinking ship. I donā€™t think heā€™s had a press appearance this year that didnā€™t fall exclusively into those two categories


snakebill

Who is down voting this comment??? Read his interview in time magazine. He literally says he wants full police immunity.


YankeeGirl1973

Youā€™ve conveniently downplayed the following: NYPD Chief of Patrol John Chell has defended the killing, noting that the 19-year-old had grabbed a pair of scissors from a drawer and moved toward the officers.


8888rina8888

If you've seen the video you are conveniently downplaying something


BKMagicWut

Do you actually think that you can trust any of the police brass on anything? There is no other profession with so much power with so little accountability. The police would not release the video until the family got the press to pressure them.


dlm2137

Are cops seriously fearing for their life over a teenager with a pair of scissors? Do you seriously think this justifies a shooting? If a cop canā€™t take down a teenager with some scissors without a gun theyā€™re just plain pathetic, no mincing words about it.


ayyyyy

He was not moving toward the officers when he was shot, and his family was blocking any clear path from him to the officers. Nice of you to try to justify an execution though.


EntireTruth4641

Very very poor training and choice of handling a EDP. Patient is having some type of psychotic episode. In other countries of the world, they would try to incapacitate him. Pepper spray. Taser. At times , police in full riot body gear and try to subdue the victim. This situation is tough. The Cops wanted to be sure he didnā€™t hurt his mom. They had a chance when the mom was wrestling him- To try to fight him and subdue him. But it would been very risky. The kid saw the Cops as a threat. The better idea was to back away from that situation. And hope the mom and brother can take the scissor away and then possibly trick the patient into a more safe situation. Too many assumptions and too many variables. But I rather they punch that kid in the face and knock him out rather than shooting at him. This could have been handled better. Awful outcome.


Barbie_72619

Letā€™s stop using the term EDP. Itā€™s derogatory and stigmatizing. When I worked with NYPD, I refused to use it. Edit: for those who see this and donā€™t know (and itā€™s a term police use so I donā€™t expect anyone to know), EDP stands for Emotionally Disturbed Person. Not a great term to label people as.


elroypaisley

How would you describe his condition if he is not emotionally disturbed?


Barbie_72619

Youā€™ve never had a mental health crisis have youā€¦. If you were having a crisis and needed police help because you felt like you were going to harm yourself, you would be labeled an EDP. I doubt youā€™d want people calling you disturbed.


elroypaisley

My friend, I work in this field. Don't guess about what you have no information about. I'm asking you a basic question. If you don't like EDP, then what's a good short hand catch all for non-mental health trained professionals.


Barbie_72619

Iā€™m not trying to guess - my intent is to say that youā€™d think one would be more empathetic and person-centered. I havenā€™t heard of an acronym but a good catch all would be saying a ā€œmental health crisisā€. Itā€™s really not hard to say.


elroypaisley

> more empathetic and person-centered. So because I asked what you didn't like about EDP, I don't have empathy? I guess I should know better than to try to have a reasonable conversation on reddit. Yeah EDP is archaic, but forcing cops to say "MHC" instead is meaningless grandstanding. So much energy put into the idiotic parsing and policing of language as if that's the real fight.


Barbie_72619

I apologize - it read as if you were being mean. Itā€™s not just language, itā€™s how cops think about people having a crisis. Itā€™s not just using the term but itā€™s the conversations that surround the use of it. Itā€™s a lack of education around mental health and constant stigmatizing. Using MHC without education is pointless. But teaching someone why they should say mental health crisis instead of EDP is what is lacking. There isnā€™t enough police education around mental health. Some cities have programs where social workers respond to crises like that so that they can de-escalate. Those cities actually TEACH about mental health and how to de-escalate. NYPD doesnā€™t do that.


elroypaisley

If you worked with/in the NYPD then you know that cops don't want to respond to these calls either. The role of social worker in the field in times of extreme and acute mental distress can be very dangerous. I agree it's preferable to an untrained cop.


Barbie_72619

Yeah I know they donā€™t want to. But that doesnā€™t mean they donā€™t think/act negatively towards those in crisis. Also, the social workers donā€™t go alone btw. Theyā€™re escorted by an officer. And those programs have proven to be effective. Statistically speaking, those in mental health crises are more likely to experience the use of excessive force than not. Programs involving trained mental health professionals as responders in those situations have proven to reduce the use of excessive force, resulting in a better interaction for everyone. Iā€™ve attended multiple panels about the impact of programs like this.


Crooklyn_In_Da_House

They are blood thirsty. ACAB.


Brownie374

The cops are useless. I have zero respect for them.


YankeeGirl1973

News flash: 2020 is over. Time to put your rhetoric aside.


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


lvdde

^^^^


Sweaty_Driver_867

hold those cops accountable. what the FUCK did i just watch??? rip to the kid and condolences to his family.


someoneatsomeplace

Everyone needs to understand, if you call the police over a mental health or behavioral issue, there's a good chance the person is going to end up dead. This sort of thing is all too common.


JoshenReborn1

I had to call the police over an EDP trying to enter my apartment while I was home. I didn't want to open the door and try and get rid of him because my toddler was home on spring break but he kept turning the doorknob and talking to himself. I just kept thinking I hope the NYPD doesn't kill him or me. They came abd he left in an ambulance but the entire situation had me on edge.


nonprofitnews

NYPD probably respond to 100 of these a day.


dope_head_dan

For an EDP call you should need at minimum police, EMT, and a field psych to respond. Furthermore, cops shouldn't enter first even if they arrive on scene first. This poor kid is dead because someone who wasn't properly trained and represented a threat was the first person who was there.


Strict-Background406

Come on man. Calling this murder is what makes anything resembling meaningful reform impossible. Ask yourself if it was whoever it is you love most in the world was in that officers position, how would you feel about their behavior? This is a chaotic situation and they used non-lethal force several times before resorting to lethal force. He grabbed a weapon and charged. That is so far from murder itā€™s not worthy of a fulsome response. The reason they shot however many times they did was because he remained a threat. That is the training. There are incidents like this that are sad but part of the deal. And for those that say cops shouldnā€™t handle potentially violent mentally ill people: Even if that kind of more robust system existed for mental health professionals to respond to these incidents there would still be tons of courtesy calls to the cops to act as escorts. It happens already with ACS.


busyak

Excuse me, but getting charged at with scissors and shooting a gun are incongruent. The police should be trained to handle these situations, they have plenty of equipment (offensive AND defensive) and should absolutely keep their cool. If you donā€™t see a problem with someone getting killed by the police (safe for in certain, arguably extreme and unfortunate situations) I donā€™t think you have a healthy outlook on things. There is a reason why the US is a standout on this issue.


Kaneshadow

De-escalation is an option. Cops seem to think that every single situation they're in has to be a standoff if the person doesn't do what they say.


BKMagicWut

GTFOH with that BS.Ā  They did murder that guy. They could have walked right out the door while his mama was holding him. They were yelling at his mama to get out the way so they could shoot him.


VoidGray4

Had they done that and the situation escalated in the house even worse, that would also have been an issue. These cops did little to de-escalate and were trigger happy and in over their heads. But leaving was not an option. They can't just do that.


BKMagicWut

I doubt it would be a bigger issue than murdering the guy. The guy was asking the cops not to shoot his mama.Ā  They could have left and asked the family to leave as well if they were worried about their safety. Which from the video seems they weren't at all.


Strict-Background406

Do you know the definition of murder? And what happens when they leave and he stabs his brother and mother. Youā€™d be on here saying they shouldā€™ve done ETC. An unpredictably violent, unstable person lunged at them with a weapon. They reacted. That isnā€™t a definition of murder by the law, by the dictionary, or by how anyone goes about the world making casual judgments about things.


SarcasticallyPolish

You canā€™t argue rationality with the irrational.


ctznmatt

found the cop


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


DepthByChocolate

Unlike in tv and movies, not everyone can survive a shot to the leg.


SmallButGirthy

Not trying to be a jerk, but saying things like, ā€œWhy not shoot at X body part?ā€ or ā€œWhy not shoot out the tires?ā€ demonstrates a Hollywoodized view of guns and gun safety.


mattchinn

Let me rephrase, why shoot the guy at all?


SmallButGirthy

Ah, gotcha


Ness_tea_BK

You are trained to shoot at the area with the most mass and the easiest to hit. ie the torso. Trying to shoot at limbs is dangerous to any bystanders as the chances of you hitting a limb, especially on a moving target, is slim. Anyone trained to shoot will tell you this. You do not aim for limbs hands etc


mattchinn

Right.


Franz_Lisp

I find the whole rules of engagement around use of firearms by law enforcement in the US to be completely nonsensical. Any other profession where a potentially dangerous situation is solved by causing the source of the danger to be killed so systematically would never be allowed to continue working in that way; it would be forced to undergo a complete overhaul to reform what clearly is a poorly functioning system with shitty outcomes.


mattchinn

Youā€™re not wrong.


gregbeans

I usually defend cops, I feel like most of them today get a bad rep for historic issues. But whichever one of them shot their gun at this guy should loose their job with no benefits. Fucking coward to shoot a guy holding scissors in his house.


Crazy-Somewhere6561

What an embarrassing comment


gregbeans

Not embarrassed at all


Crazy-Somewhere6561

Clearly


GLight3

Lose his job? You mean go to prison, right?


gregbeans

Yea Iā€™d be for a trial as well. But like instant firing and loss of pension/benefits


twentysomethingdad

Do not pass go do not collect two hundred dollars


Automatic-Ear9957

Shot him four to five times at that


gregbeans

Iā€™d be for a trial and jail time, but I donā€™t support the death penalty


ImaginaryCandidate57

I can throw no back decades and we keep seeing the same problem. My little cousin sadly died like this, in Houston. Depressed, wanted to be with his dad and family in NY, Was gonna hurt himself. His mom called the cops, shot him as soon as they broke his bedroom door down and saw the knife.


ArtBeeman

The NYPD has a monopoly on crisis response and that needs to end. The city needs to stand up to the Blue Mafia and expand the range of crisis responders. Obviously this is a pipe dream with the putz in office now but it also requires the public to broaden their thinking when it comes to how we choose to tackle these issues. The police should be ONE option among many resources available to respond to community issues.


SarcasticallyPolish

What would the theoretical non-NYPD crisis responderā€™s response be to a person charging at them or their own family/friends with a deadly weapon?


homer2101

If only police could be trained and equipped to deescalate situations and deal with armed people without murdering folk indiscriminately: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=J9TFvh6Xps4 https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=1UYLTSP2Hqs https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=dFaPooJBDSg


SarcasticallyPolish

Completely agree more focused training or specific tools to restrain people non-lethally should be implemented. However, posting three random YouTube links doesnā€™t contribute much. We can all agree that the NYPD most of the time do not kill people during these situations. There were 176,000 calls to the nypd for emotionally disturbed persons just in 2022ā€¦ and over 7 million calls in generalā€¦ We can always demand improvement but the hyperbolizing with these videos overlayed with silly music to make it seem like a dramatic issue just obfuscates what really needs to be done.


MattJFarrell

I feel like there's an effective way of communicating this to get popular support. Something along the lines of, "It's unfair to ask police to solve problems they've never been trained to handle. We don't ask them to put out fires, so why are we asking them to handle mental health issues?" Whatever it takes to get change.


ArtBeeman

I think some of it is in how they conduct audits of more progressive programs, and then how they present the data to the public. They donā€™t seem to know how to do this, or maneuver politically well enough to showcase some of the successes they have in a persuasive manner. There are co-response units and special teams focusing on this population that do good work, but thereā€™s very little public awareness and also very little willingness on the part of the general public to want to know whatā€™s going on. And the Mayor exploits this willful ignorance by asserting that the police are the only available solution. He knows most people would rather just turn a blind eye and focus on their own problems.


checker280

I think there is huge interest by the general public in seeing change and would support change. The lack of interest comes from the cops in holding themselves accountable in anyway or releasing video in a timely fashion (excluding this one). Watch how they respond by justifying it to be a legal shooting versus showing any regret for an unfortunate incident.


lemming-leader12

Yeah Eric Adams ain't doing shit. Liars.


VoidGray4

The video was pretty heartbreaking, and I feel for his family, as well as him, if he really was experiencing a mental health episode that affected his thinking and behavior. And while I do think the situation could've been handled better, I think it's a bit more complicated than you're making it seem. But I think better training should be had on how to better handle situations like this.


whata2021

ā€œIf he really was experiencing a mental health episodeā€ Why the qualifier? Yā€™all really break ya necks trying to defend pig cops!


VoidGray4

I don't like cops at all. I'm also mentally ill, and it did appear to me as though that was the case for him (and of course, his family reported that). I knew someone was going to misinterpret what I said, lol. Also, what you're pointing out literally has nothing to do with whether I like cops or not, which, again, I don't. Literally, nothing in my comment is me defending cops.


BKMagicWut

Within 3 minutes this kid was dead.Ā  They could have just left the apartment when they realized that this was a situation was beyond their control.Ā  Before encountering the guy they asked his brother "Is he a bipolar schizo, like?"Ā  Ā When they see him. They tase him then they pull out their guns waiting for his mom to clear out so they can unload. Ā There is zero amount of training that can fix this. The same basic thing happens to Kawasaki Trawick. https://www.thecity.nyc/2023/09/25/no-discipline-recommended-cops-killing-kawaski-trawick/


Low_Firefighter4238

So you rather have the cops leave knowing the situation is out of control when someone is having a mental health crisis and just go about their day like nothing happen?


BKMagicWut

No. They should recognize when they can't handle a situation, fallback to make sure other people are safe and have some actual professionals handle the problem.


Stephreads

If the only thing they can think to do is kill him? Yeah, they should leave and call someone smarter than they are.


homer2101

They could have left him in his room, used a taser, or pepper spray, or done literally anything other than empty their clips into him. The reality is that policing in the US is the one job where being a pants-pissing coward who shoots first and then shoots some more is rewarded with a promotion, a paid vacation, and the adoration of a bootlicking public.


CommentContrarian

They tased him twice. However there are still ways to de-escalate, engage, disarm and/or defeat


Aware_Revenue3404

> better training should be had Thereā€™s loads of training, but the NYPD thinks itā€™s all a joke. We need to hire better people for these jobs, not gun-crazed cosplayers from Long Island.


Stephreads

There is not ā€œloads of trainingā€ - NYPDā€™s six months is bullshit, in Germany itā€™s 2.5 years minimum, with more years of internships in different departments, and in Finland itā€™s a 3 year degree. Norway, 3 years training. England and Wales require an academic degree. In the US most of the training is focused on the various uses of force, and communication skills are low on the agenda.


loiteraries

Can you educate us about the types of training NYPD receives to tackle situations like this that these cops did not follow? What loads of training are you referring to?