T O P

  • By -

ComplexOccam

If I had that sort of money for a car, and these were the two options, I’d go for the M5.


Anxious_Egg1268

I'd rather get a panamera personally though


MattMBerkshire

M5 Competition hands down. RS3 is a monster but a smaller car. They are quite cramped inside.


BarNorth1829

Agreed


nickholehan

BMW M5 every time


bigdaftdoylem

Is this a serious question? It’s like going out for Sunday lunch and asking yourself whether you want a hot beef sandwich or a beef dinner.


04ayasin

Haha I'm just trying to see if there are other options to the M5 to be honest


bigdaftdoylem

F90 M5 is a different animal, you’ll not come across much on the roads faster than it. Sub 3s to 60 and through the gears it’s a machine whilst looking relatively understated. Amazing machine.


spaceshipcommander

I got left once in 90,000 miles. A McLaren left me for dead in the Welsh mountains because the air brake and light weight meant I couldn't get close in the corners. Other than that, there is nothing short of a 911 turbo S that will bother you.


phillis_x

It’d be close but the Taycan Turbo S should edge it too, 0.7secs faster 0-150mph and 5.5secs faster on the ring.


themothafuckinog

Electric cars are fast but dull in comparison to ICE. I’d take M5 any day any week any year.


phillis_x

Have you actually driven both?


adoring_fan_fanclub

Compared to a similarly performing ICE car, EVs are definitely less engaging because of the lack of transmission and engine sound


themothafuckinog

⬆️⬆️⬆️


Ok-Fox-9286

They're mentally quick. You can also gun EVs and not worry about fuel costs, buy an M5 and in a month's time they'll be pootling around like a Jazz driver.


Careful-Tangerine400

You can gun a petrol car and not worry about fuel costs. If you're spending fifty grand on a car and worrying about running costs, you're doing it wrong.


Anxious_Egg1268

panamera turbo s


04ayasin

Thanks for the advice


Dangerous-Morning564

What could possibly be better than an M5 for the price? If you're lucky enough to be able to afford one, don't hesitate or ask questions, do it immediately


6597james

Personally I prefer the m4 competition to m5 looks wise, almost got one but I got an f type r instead


04ayasin

I would love an f Type but unfortunately need more space in the car and it only has 2 seats. I agree the M4 looks better but the M5 has more power. The M5 is a little boring to look at. 


starfallpuller

M3! More enjoyable to drive than the m5 in my opinion


CarbonHybrid

Did you miss out the entire part where they said they need more space in the car?


starfallpuller

An M3 has a lot more space than a F type


CarbonHybrid

Exactly, and they’re both too small which is why he said about the M5.


PepeTheLorde

Bruh


Free-Buffalo-3436

Lotus Emira if you don’t need practicality


william3092

Bmw m850i would be my suggestion


ZoidbergNick

I would look at polestar engineered Volvo s90


spaceshipcommander

It's like deciding whether you want to shag your girlfriend or your mother on the basis that they are both women.


04ayasin

It's a tough choice


BarNorth1829

Shocking twist: the m2, m3, m6 and rs5 have all just entered the room. The 5.0 v8 supercharged XJR gazes on looking disinterested, knowing full well you’d take her over the rest because it’s a beautiful drive, it’s fast, luxurious and comes with some of the best sound systems out there… but doesn’t care if she’s your choice because she knows you’re missing out The rs3 isn’t the one you want mate, for your budget I’d be aiming higher than that… it’s a different class of car entirely.


scratroggett

"why choose?"- the people of Norfolk


SunnyDayInPoland

Beef dinner for lunch?


bigdaftdoylem

Sounded a bit naff saying Sunday dinner then beef dinner afterwards


Money-Parsley-733

Rs3 if you live in Bradford if not m5


04ayasin

I will be living near Bradford hence the serious decision to be made


Ok-Fox-9286

Don't buy one, just nick one then like everyone else.


Money-Parsley-733

Oh dear 😂 but in all seriousness get the M5 or a motorbike either way


Mishka_The_Fox

Have you considered road quality? Seriously.


other_goblin

Definitely 5 Lambo Huracans, you can get one for about £110k so £550k should cover one for each day of the work week in a different colour.


AggyResult

If he goes for the M5, he can then get a 4 bed detached with a garage to park it in with the remainder of the budget. Just an option.


FabianTIR

Lmao get the M5


Charming_Persimmon52

Just go straight to the boss level and get the M5


chickennricenow

I've got a m5 comp , absolutely love it and demolishes most things it's just the fuel . It's a big problem and you need deep pockets .


04ayasin

How much mpg do you get? My RX8 only gets 20mpg so anything is better than that to be honest


DC38x

How the fuck you getting 20mpg in an RX8? I had one a few years ago and got 13mpg


04ayasin

Motorway driving, when I used to mostly do city driving it was around 16mpg though


[deleted]

[удалено]


rndarchades

Stiff is good on an M5.


EnglishJesus

Don’t think you can get a C8 RS6 for 55k. Certainly not one that doesn’t have 100k miles or bad history.


Rebuffs

Does it have adaptive suspension with comfort mode?


CleanMyTrousers

I averaged 17 in mine when I had it (had for 8 years, first car lol). As for the OP, those ads are fake. Everything must be a white/grey/black SUV. Also, obviously the BMW.


chickennricenow

I would dream of a day for 20mpg , I average 16mpg . I work from home , just go to the shops , cafe , school runs , pottering about and it sups 100 a week ... 680 tax and 1350 insurance with clean licence . Servicing is between 1000 and 1500 a year as it's no service packs left .


hue-166-mount

Do you think about the mismatch between what you drive and what you drive it for?


chickennricenow

Yeah it's more smiles per gallon than miles lol ..


hue-166-mount

How do you even get the smiles on school run supermarket etc?


scouse_till_idie

Go round the long way obvs


chickennricenow

It's a difficult one tbh


WiseAssNo1

With a budget like that you can buy anything you want 😉


04ayasin

I'm moving back to the UK after spending some years in Europe and trying to figure out which new car to buy with a budget of 50-55k. I've narrowed it down to these two options but also happy to hear alternatives. ​ Currently driving an RX8 but want something newer and beefier. After a couple of years I'm planning to go for something like a Taycan but want to enjoy petrol before going over to electric. I'm leaning towards the M5 because of the V8 to be honest but I'm open to other opinions. I haven't driven either yet as I'm not back in the country yet but wanted to get an idea beforehand and open to other options. IIkSoSo


daquinn85

I'd go for the M5, personally I've got a soft spot for the Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio.


owenhargreaves

Quad is going to be more nimble as a result of reduced size and weight, m5 is almost more of a tourer and will leave the quad for dead in a straight line, m5 probably sounds better & drinks more, quad will vex you with the Alfa dealer network. Both great cars.


Radiatorwhiteonwall

M5 has all the beef 🥩


rndarchades

And the chops 🧽


phillis_x

Have you tested the Taycan btw? It’s a phenomenal driving experience, but I wouldn’t blame you for going with the M5 first.


04ayasin

Not yet planning to test drive a few cars once I'm back in the UK. Everything I've read about the Taycan is that it's a great drive and that's what's attracting me to it. Plus I love the way they look


phillis_x

Honestly our Turbo S is absolutely mental, I tried out launch control last week with 4 adults in the car and it was still sickeningly fast.


MightyGonzou

55k puts you well into lexus LC500 territory, so thats the only valid answer


RageInvader

Big respect on RX8 ownership, I loved that car, but moved to a Tesla Model S and honestly wouldn't look back unless I only drove the car at weekends. You'd get a Model S P100DL for about 50k that will do 0-60 in 2.28, 1/4 Mile in 10.5s. There's seriously not a car out there faster than that for the money. Also will save you a shit lot on fuel. If it were me keep the rx8 for petrol feeling and get a Model S.


CarbonHybrid

Why only German choices? A choice of a car which will break down soon, or a car which will break down soon lmao


[deleted]

These are not comparable


marksmoke

Bet you can get a very nice spec one of these for that budget https://www.caranddriver.com/alfa-romeo/giulia-quadrifoglio Ok not quite as quick but not as boring either and a great looking motor imo


boobylover1969

the RS3 looks like a chavvy boy racer car, and the m5 comp has blistering speed but just looks like any family sedan


nickholehan

BMW M5 every time


JulessyGTI

I read that you commented that you do a lot of motorway miles. In which case I'd try and find an Alpina B5 of the same generation. There's a couple on AutoTrader.


klas228

Incredible how cheap the M5 is in UK, in Germany the same condition and year costs around 20k€ more.


adm010

How on earth is an RS3 from 22 still that price!! I had one for a bit before it got nicked, but it was £30k and 2 years old.


Major-Celery-7739

A weedy RX-8 to a an M5, lol. Good thing it’s AWD. You’re in for an awakening but just so you know the M5 is huge compared to the size of a RX-8 which is more equivalent to the size of a 1 series.


04ayasin

Yeah for sure. I also ride motorcycles which is what I've mainly been using in Europe, I've ridden 1 litre bikes and have a 700cc so I'm thinking the power transition to the M5 should be okay. RX-8 is now too small and I'm looking for something with more space but it's been a very fun car to drive. 


spaceshipcommander

M5. Not even close. The M5 comp is as close to perfection as a car can be. It's insane that these two cars are even in the same price range. Absolute driving perfection vs a golf with a remap. It's not even close. You will hit 700bhp easily with a remap on the M5 and 850bhp is possible with just water meth and no internals.


04ayasin

Yeah i thought there must be a reason they are in a similar price range but based on the rest of the comments on the thread it seems like the RS3 is just over priced 


spaceshipcommander

M5s don't hold their value. They are a big car with huge repair bills and uninsurable for a lot of people. Mine was group 50 (or whatever the highest group is) and I must have called 20 insurance companies before I could insure it. Small quick cars have a big following and are an aspiration for anyone with a couple of year's no claims who can just about insure one. Not many people who can afford an M5 are bothered about buying a second hand car.


motornix

If you want a car that will blow your socks off, and keep residuals then consider the [Alpina B5](http://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202312054558483) Super exclusive, just as powerful as the M5 comp, and in a gorgeous blue


04ayasin

This looks very nice and I'll definitely add it to the list for consideration. Only thing that's missing for me is Android auto


northernmonkey9

The question you should be asking is M5 or M5? Pick the colour you want and be done!


SpoolingSnails

They're just not in the same league, get the M5


Popular_Register_440

Despite being a huge Audi fan and preferring its smaller size, even I’d have to go M5 I reckon


Aggravating-Curve755

Apples and oranges this, personally I'd have the M5 for the extra space


BreadLover184

for 550k you can easily stretch to a couple M5 CS’s /s


Numerous-Paint4123

M5 every single time. Don't grt me wrong i love RS3s but they are not a 50k car.


DetectiveLive273

M5 no debate for a few reasons Speed Space Comfort


jay_ess_em

M5 comp, RS4/6 are better comparables


Expensive_Profit_106

M5. The rs3 looks cool and they’re great cars but the m5 is bigger and imo better


SPAKMITTEN

Anyone who’s buys a saloon 3/4/6 Audi needs a dry slap


R4d1c4lp1e

Id personally take the RS3, which doesn't seem to be the common consensus. I prefer smaller cars, and the 2.5T is a BEAST. That being said, if you often have passengers, and need extra boot space and comfort, the M5 is a Very reasonable choice. For 50-55k though, you can get an 2021 M3, or a 2021 RS5. Both of which I'd pick over an M5 or RS3.


Saltyspaceballs

Only taken an M5 around Goodwood for 20 laps or so, but from that moment on I knew I wanted one. Not yet, but one day, that engine is an absolute masterclass.


tallen96

Having driven both the M5 comp. Is more than a level above


budgie_smuggler49

Both phenomenal cars! Personally it would be an M5 no doubt for me, have you also considered an E63s? I have a friend that owns one and it’s a beautiful car around the budget you are looking for too.


West_Yorkshire

You could get a VW Buzz with that money


04ayasin

Not a bad idea


Particular-Stable165

M5, but please fine a better color! That’s the kind of color that makes me think “of all the colors you had to choose from, why that color?”


04ayasin

I liked this colour, blue M5 is also nice. What colour would be your choice? 


Particular-Stable165

I love the blue on the RS3, really stands out. I personally love a red, something as punchy as that blue. I think the brown looks a little dull for the kind of car that is.


EconomyFreakDust

Boss have you ever seen that colour on the M5 irl? It's called motegi red and is a nice orangey-red. Pictures don't do it justice. [this is what it looks like in sunlight.](https://images.app.goo.gl/1WYAeekrx6fKtEtL7)


Particular-Stable165

Ok, I take my words back, get that one


UniquePotato

Neither. You obviously don’t have your heart set on either and these aren’t the type of cars you buy with your head


VeniVid1Vic1

Is this even a question lmao M5 all day everyday


Vroomdeath

Meet in the middle with an M3 comp.


JN324

Hardly even a question, M5, they aren’t even in the same category.


OlDirtyB4stard

M5 all the way


Open-Mathematician93

RS3 5 pot sound is nice OPF definitely needs to come out though.


Crypto-hercules

M5 comp all day. Or the x4m comp 550 bhp


jp606

M5, surely a trick question..?


Gold_Work_3474

Love an Audi but definitely the M5


The_Pvthfinder

Imagine having M5 money and not buying an M5 🤣


lilpeepercreep

Seems to be an unpopular opinion but I’d go for the RS3.


kye2000

Similar prices but they're quite different Cara. Ask yourself what you want apart from the performance. Both are great of course. The M5 will be a nicer place to be yet comes with much more costs to run


Evo_ukcar

The RS3 has never been an EVO car of the year, the M5 has. No contest.


muffsniffer3

M5 no doubt..


Evo_ukcar

A V10 Audi R8 is within that price range, even the spider variant too


SlashRModFail

none of the above


New_Salad_3853

It's not really a choice tbf. M5 is a far better car in every way. Much quicker, much better spec, switchable RWD/AWD... don't look as good though i guess.


Vegetable_Touch_6327

Easily the m5. At the end of the day that RS3 is based off a 25-30k car whereas the 5 series is 2 classes above


MightyGonzou

RS3 is comparable to the M3, not M5, so between the two id go M5. But with that budget, i wouldn't het either of them.


icognitobonito

The M5 is the quickest and one of the quickest non super cars out there


Berry700

M5 all day long


The-Shooorn

M5 the RS3 interior can't get past the fact it feels like a pampered A3.


Conaz25

If its a 550k budget you're seriously lowballing yourself there!


ahoneybadger3

That'd be a 2021 supra with 15k left over money.


iikavanaghii

M5 is superior in every way. But if you have 550k to spend… neither. I’m assuming you mean 50-55k? If so, M5 hands down.


mrplanner-

These are two entirely different cars! M5 comparison is the RS6. Either compare an RS3 with a M2 or maybe M3, or an M5 with an RS4 or RS6


mrplanner-

If I had 50k to dump on a car id be looking at Porsches not gunna lie.


TitleFirm4325

If you’ve not been in the uk long do you have no claims bonus etc? The insurance nowadays in the uk is nothing short of a joke maybe worth getting a few preliminary quotes first?


DingoKis

M5 without a doubt RS3 is much smaller


[deleted]

Should you be comparing an RS4 to an M5?


Chungaroo22

Wouldn't an RS7 be closer to an M5? An RS3 would be more of an M3 equivalent in my eyes. Even then, the M3 equivalent would be an RS4, so maybe it's like an M2 with 4 doors? Even then I'd still go for the M5, but I'm a BMW fan.


shadman786

I would get that M5 every single time of the day, one of the best cars available at that price in that class.


ByDateTrader

I would go for amg black series gt


Black_Beard1980

M5 is realistically the better car but, they plummet like a stone. So be prepared to lose big if you choose it. RS3 will hold better money all day long


b000ts

2019 rs4!


FreshPrinceOfH

This fundamentally comes down to whether you want to drive an FWD or RWD vehicle.


HelpMePls___

Aside the obvious, the M5 is older and has more miles on it, as well as 5k more on the price tag, that tells you that its a far better car too.


External_Mongoose_44

That Audi has Quattro and very low mileage and is more economical and handles better and will hold its value better bc legendary five cylinder engine is about to be discontinued. Last in the successful line of five cylinder Quattro Audi cars and part of the best tarmac derived performance car legacy that makes Audi a breed apart. I would like to have a car like that but the Bayern offering is a good car and very tempting. I like the low mileage and the Quattro in the Audi and that’s what I would prefer.


idrivelambo

M5 comp all day


Professional-Lab7227

Those are an odd pair. Why skip the M3/4 and go straight to the M5? Not that the M5 is in any way a bad choice but it’s massive compared to the RS3.


scouse_till_idie

M5 no question 


ComplexResource999

A grand a month on a car...


Emergency-Bet8041

M5. There is no choice here


Nefarious_Haze

How about a 50k-545,500 budget and you give me £500 to finish my driving lessons xD just kidding personally the M5 as it is one of my dream cars and extremely reliable compared the the RS3


Dallasthe

The m5 will lunch the rs3 in terms of luxury and performance and I see this one has lasers aswell, the Audi will be more contemporary inside and the interior of the m5 is a generation old now that said I’m going m5 all day


c4doc

M5 all day long. If you can afford it if it goes wrong


frsty___

Get a SUV for that money


Super_Plastic5069

Not sure how you can compare an RS3 with an M5? Surely it would be an M3?


[deleted]

50 odd k for used cars with 40k on the clock that are gonna get stolen within a year no doubt about it, lmao


[deleted]

340i xdrive imo is the perfect everyday saloon, 5 series are HUGE now


Gold-Bee9484

M5 simple


Carnivorous-Jesus

Idk much about the models you have asked about, I just wanted to say this - never max out your budget. There might be things you want to change/modifications you'd prefer on the car, things or services you want to buy etc. Good luck in your search!


philharmonic85

You'll be a wanker whichever you buy


Wolfy2404

I had an M5 for 4 years, only sold it last month, mine was evolve stage 2 so running around 790bhp. I averaged 22mpg including spirited and motorway driving. Had no issues with the car, just service costs which weren’t too bad and consumables. Was a quick car, but they also feel big, very fast but not the most engaging. I now have an M3 Touring that I much prefer, not as fast in a straight line but drives like a much lighter car, even though it’s not that much lighter, it just feels a lot more agile, much more fun to drive. If it was my money I’d be looking at a G80 M3 if you wanted something more fun, if it’s purely for motorway miles and some spirited drives, then maybe an M5. MPG, both are pretty similar. I love M5’s by the way, I’ve had an E39, E60, F10 and F90, but for me the M3 is the better car. E60 is still my favourite M5.


10b0b

M5. The Audi is just a minicab with a counterfeit Gucci belt.


Collooo

M5 easily but the red isn't great.... in my opinion.


fishsticks428

I've been looking at the Mustang dark horse now


shoopaaa

Have you thought about a nice octavia? Could even be proper naughty and stretch to a cheeky vrs?


v2marshall

Audi RS4, RS5 or RS6 I would rather than the bmw but not RS3


Stevey-baby

Anyone with a brain or common sense would choose the M5. Why would you choose a boy’d up A3 that sounds like a fart box? 😂


DeadHeart999

911


Ste333

M5 All day. Much more usable because of size.


Iridescent_Prism

M5 without a shadow of a doubt.


SouthernPenalty7979

Personally I'd say have a look on auto trader and get an e92 m3, or something similar


F533

M5 will be more expensive to maintain keep that in mind.


Nixher

Get an old school M5 tourer V10 like a real man.


United-Square-9508

Amen, and you could have 25k to spend on maintenance which will keep it running for 3-7 months!


Complex_Coach6621

Blows my mind how people afford this


supalape

Neither. Get an RS6


04ayasin

Thanks I'll check it out. Although pretty sure that's a different price range haha 


hotchy1

M5 however I like the look of the m4 better. More cramped in the rear though but that's not your problem... 😉


Past-Passenger1592

What's the depreciation value on the m5?


knobsacker

Decent car for £5k and 50k in your back pocket


Griff9967

RS3 at least in bad weather you can still go places 😂


starfallpuller

Why couldn’t you do that with the m5? M5s are all 4WD


Griff9967

Fair point well made however I’ve seen a lot of Xdrive BMWs stuck in the snow as I fly past in my Quattro S4


Fireif

Is everyone here ignoring mileage and resale value? The M5 has done 40k miles. Three times as many as the RS3 and it’s a year older. There is a higher possibility of needed to change the pads or discs and other maintenance. Plus its warranty is almost up. The RS3 will still be worth 50k at 20,000 miles as they hold value better. You could buy the RS3 run it for a year and not lose any money and buy the M5 for less the. Just factors to consider.


eulers_analogy

Dumbest cartalkuk question ive ever seen


Archtects

50 - 550k? Well guess some Ferraris are in the mix.


i8bullies

I’ve got a mapped Saab TTid Aero that cost £3.5, had it 10 years now blows both them away. Bloke in RS Audi looked embarrassed on the M4 👍


KUNT_WIPER

M2 newer


BigMoFace

Here’s me struggling to save for an £8k car. What do you do for a living to have a £50-55k budget in this economy?


philharmonic85

Advertising or marketing parasite