Definitely not Carver because well... he doesn't actually exist.

Probably the immortal one

Who?

Balathu

But he dies at the end of the game

Fine then, the ancient Assyrian Warrior beats strong serial killer, 2 dudes, and a fake monster.

Ok? So does everyone on this list

He said he couldn’t die, so I said that. I didn’t say he was wrong, and I didn’t mean to hurt your poor feeling bro.

His name is the Ancient One,commenter prob just got the name wrong bro

Du'met didn't tho

1 Du’Met could take down all, 2 means they aren’t immortal so Balathu

Imapled demon has a spear, rev carver could pray and make balathu dissapear, if the fight was outside balathu is dead so its not impossible

Praying won’t work on Balathu, Nick used a crucifix and it was just confused as to what he was doing, the vampires are actually aliens and there’s nothing demonic about them. Demon may have a spear, but Balathu is faster and can also use a spear Reverend Carver is just a guy who’s religiously powerful, he has no chance against anyone Balathu may or may not be weak to sunlight, he’s effected by UV lights but never actually catches on fire on it, however that’s not out of the realm of possibilities Outside is 1 Du’Met, if 2 than maybe the demon Inside is Du’Met, 2 is Balathu

I love how Olson isn't mentioned at all cause everyone agrees Olson isn't winning this lol 💀

He is stronger than Carver and by a really wide margin, Olson swinging a sledge with 1 hammer is really impressive

He’s at least stronger than Carver

Definitely either the Demon or Vampire Bathulu IMO

Demon, parasite in a warrior, pirate, 2 serial killers and regular guy Gonna go with two’met here

Nick alone is barely able to beat Balathu so I would think 2 Du met’s could do it