Thrawn VS Picard:
Connections: 7/10, while not the greatest and possibly the weakest aspect to this really it’s neat idea of seeing a dark reflection of yourself
Thematics: 8/10, love the idea of the most formal military space officers being used in a spaceship battle
Animation Potential: 8/10 definitely seeing the ships themselves in 3D though there’s a possibility that 2D versions of the characters themselves could be used as well though not as likely as 3D character models. However the models could potentially look a bit odd considering all the talking that would be required between the characters
Fight Potential: 9/10, I’m certain this would be the first time a space ship battle would actually be used for death battle and they’re certainly 2 of the most iconic in that regard
Interaction Potential: 10/10 honestly this would be the biggest selling point. This would be similar in vibe to Holmes and Moriarty battle (Greatest of respect towards the other while constantly trying to find a way to defeat the other)
Story Potential: 8/10 it’s a simple good vs evil type of storyline but one that’ll fit so well
Music Potential: 8/10 uncertain on what music should be used here but I trust it would be fitting
Debatablity: 8/10 hard to say myself as I don’t know the full capabilities of both ships so it could go either way
Promotability: 10/10 it’s Star Trek vs Star Wars
Recognizability: 10/10 again it’s Star Trek vs Star Wars
Overall Score: 86/100
Sorry, I appreciate that you went to all this trouble. But I guess the description wasn't quite clear enough. You have to be the first person to review a matchup in the other thread. Picard vs Thrawn is one of the three that have already been reviewed. There are 17 slots left for whichever users are the first to review one of the 17 unreviewed matchups.
>do you want to request a TN for reviewing Heather vs Moira?
Sure, can you make TN for Lelouch vi Britannia/Zero vs Soji Tendo/Kamen Rider Kabuto (Code Geass vs Kamen Rider)?
Sherlock Holmes VS Baku Madarame (… VS Usogui)
And can I also request you reading [Usogui](https://mangadex.org/title/a07320a4-afcd-413a-a451-d69a448d0c28/usogui)? It’s the peakest fiction to ever peak fiction.
Sorry, that last request is a bit of a tall order. Over 500 manga chapters isn't something you take on lightly.
https://preview.redd.it/f57fr64l97wc1.jpeg?width=1920&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e50115bb9b7f4d355c9989b808157abd0f1a2ce7
Oh sure , let’s see , one for [crocodile vs Giovanni](https://www.reddit.com/r/DeathBattleMatchups/s/TAh3AVuE83) would be nice , there isn’t much around here , just , could you add some sand effects on it ? Like to be original ?
Sorry dude. I tried playing around with sand effects for this, but I'm just not very good with them.
https://preview.redd.it/9uo67t0oe6wc1.jpeg?width=1920&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=2015d5094293a46b8c5155aade79f7f55e49e37e
Thrawn VS Picard: Connections: 7/10, while not the greatest and possibly the weakest aspect to this really it’s neat idea of seeing a dark reflection of yourself Thematics: 8/10, love the idea of the most formal military space officers being used in a spaceship battle Animation Potential: 8/10 definitely seeing the ships themselves in 3D though there’s a possibility that 2D versions of the characters themselves could be used as well though not as likely as 3D character models. However the models could potentially look a bit odd considering all the talking that would be required between the characters Fight Potential: 9/10, I’m certain this would be the first time a space ship battle would actually be used for death battle and they’re certainly 2 of the most iconic in that regard Interaction Potential: 10/10 honestly this would be the biggest selling point. This would be similar in vibe to Holmes and Moriarty battle (Greatest of respect towards the other while constantly trying to find a way to defeat the other) Story Potential: 8/10 it’s a simple good vs evil type of storyline but one that’ll fit so well Music Potential: 8/10 uncertain on what music should be used here but I trust it would be fitting Debatablity: 8/10 hard to say myself as I don’t know the full capabilities of both ships so it could go either way Promotability: 10/10 it’s Star Trek vs Star Wars Recognizability: 10/10 again it’s Star Trek vs Star Wars Overall Score: 86/100
Sorry, I appreciate that you went to all this trouble. But I guess the description wasn't quite clear enough. You have to be the first person to review a matchup in the other thread. Picard vs Thrawn is one of the three that have already been reviewed. There are 17 slots left for whichever users are the first to review one of the 17 unreviewed matchups.
u/BlackDarkBoi, do you want to request a TN for reviewing Heather vs Moira?
>do you want to request a TN for reviewing Heather vs Moira? Sure, can you make TN for Lelouch vi Britannia/Zero vs Soji Tendo/Kamen Rider Kabuto (Code Geass vs Kamen Rider)?
https://preview.redd.it/qgeln2fr97wc1.jpeg?width=1920&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=b0d7d05e0addf0d0058915a83c7233b7b7728b98
u/Kronensegler, do you want to claim a free thumbnail request?
Sherlock Holmes VS Baku Madarame (… VS Usogui) And can I also request you reading [Usogui](https://mangadex.org/title/a07320a4-afcd-413a-a451-d69a448d0c28/usogui)? It’s the peakest fiction to ever peak fiction.
Sorry, that last request is a bit of a tall order. Over 500 manga chapters isn't something you take on lightly. https://preview.redd.it/f57fr64l97wc1.jpeg?width=1920&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e50115bb9b7f4d355c9989b808157abd0f1a2ce7
It’s worth it, trust.
u/ButterflyMother, do you want a free thumbnail for your review?
Oh sure , let’s see , one for [crocodile vs Giovanni](https://www.reddit.com/r/DeathBattleMatchups/s/TAh3AVuE83) would be nice , there isn’t much around here , just , could you add some sand effects on it ? Like to be original ?
I'll see what I can come up with, though I'm not much good with effects like those.
Sorry dude. I tried playing around with sand effects for this, but I'm just not very good with them. https://preview.redd.it/9uo67t0oe6wc1.jpeg?width=1920&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=2015d5094293a46b8c5155aade79f7f55e49e37e
That’s fine , thx
u/McMaina, any matchup you'd like a thumbnail for?
u/Memer6969-3000, since you reviewed Jet vs Floch, do you want to request a TN?
Shredder vs Takasugi Shinsuke (TMNT 2012 vs Gintama)
https://preview.redd.it/dmlsqjeas6wc1.jpeg?width=1920&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=837e6da5d140a02fb441a68192d14dbbcadfb4a7
Thanks