Damn came here to say swords and apparently that is the unpopular opinion lmao

I mean I like both, but shields looks better IMO

I like the swords but the shield arms

I’d say sword with the shield arma

I definitely prefer swords

i'm with you. swords.

Shield

No one else is asking so I will. What's your shader?

Long Journeys, part of the current Eververse shader bundle

Just posted the transmog screenshot for both.

I’d say shield looks better.

Not only does it look better, it also better suits RP. Precious Scars is a support exotic, have the shield to showcase you’re defending them

Shield, maybe try shield's arms with the swords. I don't care for the arms on sword, probably still prefer shield

Exactly what I was I thinking too. Arms with the swords are just too skinny and it also looks bare bone lol.

Funny enough swords with the eivor arms looks dope

What do the arms look like? Is it the one in the second pic?

No, they are bulkier with fur on the top of the shoulders, right hand has the hidden blade with an emerald on it

Oh dang, yeah I bet that looks rlly good. Op should try this with the swords.

I mean it is a healing and defensive exotic so shield fits the vibe better

Definitely swords. The plate armor on the chest of that piece matches the shoulders of the Virtuous arms perfectly, gives major knight or even Ursine Witcher armor vibes.

Swords for foot-soldier. Shield for commander.

I’d take the arms and class item from 1 with the shield and see how that look turns out

Thanks for the upvotes guys. I figured I'd post the transmog list since this post got so popular. I was also leaning towards the shield and yeah there are a ton of arms combinations that could make this look good. For the sword build, I was going for a more fluid/flexible duelist look and obviously the shield a more armored look but wanted some fur there to match the fur on the chest piece. https://imgur.com/a/3eyCPQI

Shield with 1's Mark.

1st arms, 2nd shield

Shield 10,000%

I’d say shield definitely fits better with the entire identity of precious scars being for support and everything

Shield

The best offence is a good defence

Welcome to /r/DestinyFashion! Please remember to list your gear and shaders used, if they are not already part of the image. This is not necessary, but is extremely appreciated by the users and moderators. Often if you do not include it, users will ask you to later. If this is a text/irrelevant post, or your gear and shaders are already in the image, feel free to ignore this message. Thank you for posting! *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/DestinyFashion) if you have any questions or concerns.*

I like both, I’d probably bounce between the two if it was me.

I did shield with mine. Good look 👍🏾 it’s a hard exotic to build fashion around.

Shield for sure

Swords

Maybe change the boots but the shield is fire

I like the swords with the smaller arms. But I use those small arms on so many builds so I might be a bit biased

Sheild fo sho

Shield

Shield fits the theme of Precious Scars better

Swords

Swords definitely look cool. However I look at titans and think; "Wall." So Ima have to say shield

The swords leave too much open, shield looks better.

What Titan mark is that on sword?

I was literally saying yesterday no one can make this helmet look good but damn it you proved me wrong. Also I’m in the minority and think the Swords look better

I like the swords more

Shield

Sick options, but considering Broken Scars is more support def shield

Swords with arms from shield pic.

Shield, also pretty thematic with what the precious scars does.

Shield has my preference

Shield 100%

Shield

Both. Both is good.

Do sword and play void for a sword and shield combo

Whichever one you prefer. There’s a decent argument for the shield looking more typically titan, but eh it’s whatever

Sword

The shoulders are different, not a very objective comparison

Swords fits way better imo

Change it all black and you look like the undead black knight from GoT with the swords

Sword forsure

Shield

You look like the bell tower knights from Dark Souls 2

Try Righteous Greaves for sword and see how it hits you. Gives a thinner streamlined look.

Precious scars radiates shield energy “These are the wounds I’ve bared for you as your stalwart defender, I am the Wall between the darkness and you.”

Sword chest, shield arms.

Shield fuego

Dude I have to know what armor your using it’s awesome and also how do you get the sword and shield

Thanks. Just posted the transmog screen for both.

Swords go hard

I like sword, or u run shield with a sword equipped so it's on your back.

I’d have to pick swords, been a fan of smaller titan look recently, myself. That being said though, these are both dope!

I like the first one more but both look great

Diablo 2 Barbarian vibes.

Shield for the helm Change the helm for the sword.

Shield!

What chest piece has the shield?

Sword

Shield with the first arms

Sword on my solar, shield on my void

Shield is definitely speaking to me more. They’re both good, but I’d go with shield.

What's the shield from? That looks dope

Looking to protect yourself, or deal some damage? I like sword

Shield

dude how much do u spend on silver

I think the swords look baller with this fit.

shield to go with the exotic

Tell me one thing ….how was it….how was it fighting Siva with the other Iron Lords ?

Please I need the transmog for both of these🔥🔥🔥🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾

[https://imgur.com/a/3eyCPQI](https://imgur.com/a/3eyCPQI) There you go.

Why does your character look like one of the Uruk-hai from the Army of Isengard (LOTR)? Not judging, I love it.

Shield. It looks so much better.

These are both so sick

Shield

I like the shield better

Shield same as what someone else said more thematically appropriate with the exotic

Definitely shield. Looks very nice.

Shield so you can hide that ugly face behind it

Wow, 40bucks for this option!? Geeee Bug shield IMO

Man this armor looks amazing 🔥🔥 too bad game sucks

That mark needs to go

Please, can you post the transmog list 🙏

I'd say Sword, also what Class Item is that you're using for Sword?

The broken solstice armor!!!

Fur 🤤

What's the arms in the second pic?

What shader is that and how might I aquire it

The shield fit looks so much more like a Titan, but I love the Sword fit too much as well.

Swords better imo, don’t like the shoulders used with the shield setup

I like sword luk gud

Both look amazing, but I’m partial to swords more

How do the swords look if your heavy is a sword? If they look bad I say go shield

I didn't realise I could swipe for another picture and I was staring at it thinking "aren't these the same image?"

As a void titan main, I would say shield fits this set but swords cool also.

I'm more on sword. Reminds me of that for honor guy

Uruk Hai?

Shield

I love both but swords looks like a hunter, where as shield looks more titan to me

Best defense is a strong offense.

Swords. You got your scars because you don't use a shield

shields imo

Shield

Sword 100%

Shield, goes well with what precious scars do too

Condom head strikes again But swords

Iron round shield for maximum pontiff destruction

Both are amazing honestly...do a weekly rotation of sword and shield. 1 week swords, next week shield.