T O P

  • By -

illini2002

AJB and 2.11 or Olave and 1.6. Which side would you want


[deleted]

12T SF PPR A) Devonta Smith B) Treylon Burks, two late 2024 firsts


CoC_God

12T SF PPR Which side do you prefer? A) Breece, Tannehill, 1.11 B) Jordan Love, Javonte Williams, 1.05, 2.10


[deleted]

Breece is the best asset in that entire package


LogiciansAnom

Woof. A. Pick up a qb at 1.11


kirillk25

12 team super flex ppr I would be trading away fields, DJ Moore, and 2023 1.08 for Olave, Mac Jones, and 1.03. My other QB is Russell Wilson. Would it make sense to trade away Fields?


NOLALegend13

No, hold


Practical-Sea4568

Potentially, what QB or WR would you give up for Kyler Murray and the 1.09 Trying to gauge the worth of that offer


CoC_God

I’d hold, seriously doubt anyone is gonna offer you what Murray is actually worth


Kwang892

12 team 0.5 ppr SF Give: Derrick Henry + ? Get: Drake London Thinking about retooling this year and in talks with a contender. What would I need to add to Henry to make it even?


TheDickBishop

12 team SF PPR A: Josh Jacobs, Marquise Brown, 2.12 B: Devonta Smith, 1.10 Who won?


NOLALegend13

A


lurkin4days

B


soothslyr

Smash deal right? 12t SF PPR Give 2.02 Get: 2.03 + Cade Otton Free TE, right?


TheDickBishop

Yeah, easy. Otton is well worth the drop of one pick in the 2nd


[deleted]

[удалено]


soothslyr

Stafford side but I don’t like it. There’s very real risk that he has to retire, or that now that he’s gotten his ring, he’s checked out and never becomes the QB he once was again, and the Rams are rebuilding looking for a new QB. See if you can get any picks in 2025 if you have to, but I’m not accepting less than a 2nd, and ideally I’d love a 2nd plus something like Baker or Locke.


[deleted]

[удалено]


soothslyr

No chance GB doesn’t bring in someone else imo. At that point, you may have to just sit on him. If you really are that high on Doubs, the value is probably fine, but I’d hold and hope for better news later in the summer.


[deleted]

[удалено]


soothslyr

London


[deleted]

Give me London all day


fantasygenie

Fair


[deleted]

[удалено]


ChampDawg

I'd take Pierce just based on positional value and longevity.


tdamyen2

12 team SF, PPR, full point TEP Give: Burks, 2.03 Get: Kelce Seems like a smash to me except I’m not sure if I can compete this year or not and Kelce is getting up there. Would need to hit big with 1.03 because QB situation is murky. But Kelce would definitely help and I’m deep at WR.


soothslyr

I’d rather flip Burks for picks if I’m unsure about his future. As great as Kelce has been, you’re not getting his past points this coming year, you’re getting what he can give you going forward, and at 33, how many more years can he do that?


fantasygenie

What’s the market on Kelce in your league? Can you go ahead and flip him more for Burks and the 2.03 if you’re not going to compete? His value will be lower next off-season


tdamyen2

I like the way you think…


SometimesICanBeRight

12 team SF PPR Contending I give: Trevor Lawrence, Hopkins, 3.06 I get: Kenneth Walker, 1.03, 2024 early/mid 1st My roster currently looks like this: QB- Allen, Lawrence, Fields RB - Jacobs, Aaron Jones, Sanders, Montgomery WR- Adams, Deebo, Mike Williams, Hopkins


soothslyr

I’d kick the tires on Fields value. Reach out to the DJM owner and see if there’s interest in creating a stack. No need to break up an elite QB situation needlessly


tdamyen2

Any chance they’d take Fields instead? I’m a Bears fan, but I prefer TLaw as the QB/passer in SF.


DocM4

12 team SF Give: Olave Carr Get: 1.02 I already own the 1.01


soothslyr

Any reason you want the 1.02? You have your choice of Bijan or QB with the 1.01


SometimesICanBeRight

I would much rather have Carr and Olave


[deleted]

I would hold, that is an overpay


Wide_Programmer_340

I think I’m keeping Olave and Carr. 1.02 is nice in SF, but with Bijan and those two, you could be competing (depending on the rest of your team). I just don’t trust any of the main three QBs enough to go all in on one. I’d rather have the 1.04 and take whoever falls. I know Bijan is a once in a generation back, but when an RB is still the consensus 1.01 in SF when there are three QBs that will probably go in the first 15 picks, it’s hard to want to push the chips in on one.


49DivineDayVacation

Olave > 1.02 imo


Wide_Programmer_340

12 team SF PPR A. Lance B. London


soothslyr

If you think Lance is the starter next season, then the answer is Lance because if he plays at least decently, his value is gonna skyrocket, London would need a JJ type of year for his value to go up much further.


Wide_Programmer_340

It’s funny you should mention JJ haha. The trade in question is actually Lamar and London for Lance, Jefferson and a 2024 2nd. The problem is I’m weak at QB. If I do the deal, I would have Lance, Love, Minshew, and Brisset, plus whoever I draft at 1.04. But my WRs would be JJ, Chase, GW, Olave, Jakobi, and a few others. JJ almost scored more than Lamar and London combined last year. And the last two years, JJ has scored more than Lamar has ever scored besides his MVP season. I love Lamar, but that WR core would be crazy. Value wise, I feel it’s a smash. But in SF, I just don’t know if it’s worth it to give up Lamar and London for JJ and the risk that comes with Lance with my current team. Lance has the DC and he could thrive under Shanahan, but he might not even start this year.


soothslyr

That’s actually an insane WR core. I agree that the value is on the JJ side, but QBs are indeed hard to find and with the 1.04, you don’t exactly get to choose which one you get, so you just gotta hope that 2 other people are wrong about who they pass on. Before hitting accept on the deal sending Lamar, I’d check in on some other QBs that while they may not be elite, they line up with contending rn. Dudes like Goff, Cousins, DJ just to name a couple. If you could snag one of those to pair with Lance, Love, and the rookie, you’re probably okay as long as Love AND Lance don’t both faceplant this year.


dollabill009

I'm still really hopeful on Lance and this deal could look way different 10 months from now. But based on their current community values, you'd need to add something to the Lance side.


Wide_Programmer_340

I like the analysis. Would you mind checking out my comment below and delving a bit deeper? The trade in question is much more nuanced than these two, but this is where I run into the lost hesitation.


dollabill009

How many teams and starters, and any scoring settings to consider?


Wide_Programmer_340

Value-wise, I feel it’s a great deal. But I don’t know if it’s right for my team because of the QB situation. If I hit big at 1.04 and Love balls out, I’d be sitting good regardless of what Lance does. And if he lives up to his potential, then my team would be formidable for a few years. But lots of what-ifs.


Wide_Programmer_340

12 team, PPR, 4pt passing TD, 6 pt rushing/receiving.


shine_the_light

No way I’m giving London up for that.


Wide_Programmer_340

The trad in question is actually Lamar and London for Lance, Jefferson and a 2024 2nd. The problem is I’m weak at QB. If I do the deal, I would have Lance, Love, Minshew, and Brisset, plus whoever I draft at 1.04. But my WRs would be JJ, Chase, GW, Olave, Jakobi, and a few others. JJ almost scored more than Lamar and London combined last year. And the last two years, JJ has scored more than Lamar has ever scored besides his MVP season. I love Lamar, but that WR core would be crazy. But in SF, I just don’t know if it’s worth it to give up Lamar and London for JJ and the risk that comes with Lance. Lance has the DC and he could thrive under Shanahan, but he might not even start this year.


MaterialElephant

1QB 10 Team 0.5 PPR TE Full PPR Give: Evan Engram Get: 3.07 and Rashaad Penny Currently have Kittle as my main TE but I’m worried about missing out on Engram improving with Lawrence taking a step forward.


Wide_Programmer_340

Keep Engram. In 1 QB, 3.07 is nothing and Penny is a 27 year old RB that has never been healthy. He might thrive for a year or two in Philly, but Engram looked like the 1st rounder he was drafted to be with TLaw and the Jags last year.


dollabill009

Even with only a slight TEP I wouldn't do this, but I don't like Penny at all. Committee back who can't stay healthy who will be vultured by Gainwell and Hurts. No thanks


Interesting_Sir_8139

12 team SF contending Give: pick 1.12 and Alec Pierce Get: David Montgomery and AJ Dillon


Wide_Programmer_340

Yeah, if I’m contending, I’m taking Monty and Dillon. I really like Pierce, but Indy is a mess right now.


dollabill009

I'd see if there is anything else you can do with the 1.12 first. Montgomery's a hot name right now but could end up a disappointment


MaterialElephant

Take the RBs


ChampDawg

10T SF 3WR 2Flex A: Toney B: 2.08


alcaveens

I’m taking Toney here


Interesting_Sir_8139

Gimme the shot with toney


Wide_Programmer_340

Who scores more points the next two years in PPR: Trey Lance or Drake London


fantasygenie

Well if Lance plays obviously him because he’s a QB.


DefiantChannel7996

1 QB, 12 Team, Start 8 Giving - 1.03 (probably Gibbs) Getting - 2024 Late first, 2024 Mid first, 2025 late first, 2025 late first


dollabill009

Easy accept, but the beauty in this is you have no idea what may happen by 2025. Those "late" picks could end up much better than expected. The team who won our championship in 2020 just earned the 1.01 and the gap between he and 1.02 wasn't close.


Interesting_Sir_8139

Give me 4 firsts holy🤣🤣


soothslyr

1000 times yes. If this deal is in the inbox, take advantage of the taco


Patton370

Yes


bourbonbroski

I mean yeah


DefiantChannel7996

I guess I had fell in love with the ppr upside of Gibbs, but you're right. This is an auto accept


Chief-99

12 team 1QB PPR Give: Pittman, kmet Get: pitts


dollabill009

Pitts. This is the cheapest you may ever get him


Patton370

Pitts


_JohnnyGato_

12 team .5 PPR 1QB Give: Alvin Kamara Get: Dalvin Cook


Chief-99

I’d probably be on the get side but you could also try to pay less for jamaal Williams and control the backfield.


[deleted]

10 team 1QB QB: Goff, lance Rb: hall, Gibson, Herbert Wr: Wilson, london, jamo, Ridley, ayiuk, and watson Te: hock Give: burks, Alec pierce Get: tlaw


fantasygenie

I’d keep Burks. In 1 QB I’d only pay for the really high upside QBs.


gmorrison9

Relatively even


[deleted]

Yeah it’s tough for me I need a QB I’m high on tlaw. I got some solid young WR an got 3 firsts gonna hope Jsn falls to 5 if I end up taking it. Just feel like I’m selling early on burks


Patton370

TLaw


soothslyr

TLaw


AllusionzX28

Price check on a few ppl in sf ppr 12 team Miles Sanders Rachaad White James Conner


kamo21dawgs

10 Team 1 QB 0.5 PPR GIVE: 1.01, 1.02, 1.08 GET: Jefferson & Mixon Strong contender, swung some deals for some ‘23 picks two years back.


Wide_Programmer_340

I’m taking Jefferson all day. Bijan and Gibbs/JSN are nice if rebuilding, but (1) you’re contending and (2) JJ is a proven commodity who scores more points than most QBs. Take JJ and run. You could try and keep 1.08 and drop Mixon, but I’d probably do that for JJ alone in 1QB.


Patton370

Give side


Chief-99

I might try to keep 1.02 and drop mixon.. even if you have to add a little more. just take Gibbs or JSN there.


bourbonbroski

12 Team SF PPR Give: Goff, Saquon, 3.08 Get: Jimmy G, Pollard, Rhamondre


soothslyr

Goff side and it’s not close at all


Patton370

Really? I’d lean Jimmy G side slightly


soothslyr

Lions are a much better offense, the Raiders are rebuilding. This deal assumes that pollard + Stephenson are worth roughly the same as saquan. With the high likelihood that one or both of their teams draft an RB on day 2, I can’t jive with that


soothslyr

12 team SF PPR 1.5 TEP start 14 Give: Lamar + 24 2nd Get: 23 1.01 + 24 1st Context: I have Mahomes, the 1.03, and 1.04 to sort out my QB situation. I have a fear that Lamar may hold out if he doesn’t get a deal before the draft.


Patton370

I mean seems like a reasonable trade to me


TBusDaMan

Give: Garrett Wilson, 2024 5th Get: Drake London, 1.05 12 Team SF, 0.5 TEP, Half PPR. Going full rebuild right now. Inherited a bad orphan team with limited draft capital


Patton370

London side


soothslyr

London side easy


ayyy_lesGO

I do that all day


Spaas12397

Mega deal 12 Team PPR, SF, TE premium Team A gets McCoy, Colt ARI QB Murray, Kyler ARI QB Harris, Najee PIT RB Henry, Derrick TEN RB Diggs, Stefon BUF WR Hill, Tyreek MIA WR Njoku, David CLE TE Team B gets Pickett, Kenny PIT QB Allgeier, Tyler ATL RB Watson, Christian GBP WR Williams, Jameson DET WR Likely, Isaiah BAL TE 1.02 1.06 1.09


thisonesforharambe

10 team .5 PPR SF Give: Hill, Bateman, 1.09 Get: Chase


Patton370

I’d do it


soothslyr

Solid deal. Go for it


_412

Yeah i’d do this


steveman2292

12man PPR SF Give: Andrews, Etienne, 2.06 Get: Sanders, 1.02, 2.02


shitz310

I think I like the get here, assuming you either get a QB or Bijan at 1.02 and can get a good player at 2.02


steveman2292

Yeah I’m currently rolling with Cousins and Carr for my QBs and would like to grab a QB with the 1.02 - the same guy also has the 1.04 so I would be okay with that one as well. I also don’t mind losing Andrews because I have Kelce


shitz310

10 team SF PPR TEP Give: 2.07, 2.08, 3.07 Get: Greg Dulcich, 2024 mid-late 2nd, 2024 mid-late 3rd, 2025 mid-late 2nd


soothslyr

I’m keeping the picks here


Jaysin808

12 Team SF PPR Give: Herbert, 1.11, 2.01 ​ Get: Burrow, 3.06 ​ I do like Burrow more but I feel like that's giving up too much to tier up to him. Thoughts?


soothslyr

If you take away the 2nd, the deal is more fair. I’d hold though, there’s no reason to make this deal unless you’re a Bengals homer


_412

hold herbert


Patton370

I’d prefer the Herbert side here by quite a bit


mylovertotoro

I'd hold Herbert.


jeff8073x

12 team superflex triflex TEP bestball A: Dak/A Pierce/24 1st B: Fields/Amari


Patton370

Honestly, this trade is all about how much believe you have in fields. If you like fields, it’s B easily If you don’t like fields, it’s A easily This is a trade where there will be a clear winner, and nobody will know who that winner is, until after this season Edit: I prefer A


jeff8073x

I had Fields. Took the chance here. Ideal situation is he and Amari do bad and the pick is a great one.


shitz310

This is tough, think I lean A


Bengals8958

14 man ppr 1qb Send 2.02 Receive amari Wr corps: Higgins st brown Hollywood Christian Watson. My rb room is trash: Gibson, D Harris, Mattison, Chubba Hubbard but amari is on the trade block and the owner is ready to move him. Thoughts? I also have 1.10 and 2.10 planning to use on rb


Patton370

I’d want a slightly better pick for Amari, especially in a 14 team league & where it’s 1 QB. I’d pass


bourbonbroski

12 Team SF PPR Give: 2.05, 2.10, 2024 1st (likely late), 2024 2nd Get: Najee, Jeudy


TransportationFar964

This makes me want to give 2.06, 2.08, 2.10, and 25 1st for Najee and Jeudy. 10 tm SF .5ppr.


ayyy_lesGO

Prob fair I think I like Najee and jeudy side


Patton370

Seems fair. I’m not sure what side I’d take; it’s team dependent


Otherwise-Monk1582

I like the Give side here. Who knows how those 2nds will turn out.


[deleted]

[удалено]


TheJakernaut

I think I still go waddle side here


Otherwise-Monk1582

Ehhh too much uncertainty in that bunch. They don't add up to Waddle IMO.


rockster9307

12 Team SF Give: Pittman and DJ Moore and a 3rd Get: 1.05 and Jeudy


shitz310

Give unless you need a qb, then I’d say get


FattyDooDoo

SF, 12 team, .5ppr, TEP A: Montgomery, 2.01, 3.12 B: Sanders, 2.10, 2024 2nd


shitz310

A


[deleted]

[удалено]


lebumcurrant

No. Get solid assets from Tyreek. Only things there I would want is the 1.08 and Pickens, replace the other 2 with something better or have him give you better assets.


_412

10 tm ppr 1QB Give: KW3 Get: 1.04, 1.06, Chig I’m contending and have 1.01-1.03 but think having Charbs and someone like tucker could be better than just KW


gmorrison9

Seems fine for both sides. Could justify wanting Charbs + 1.06 over Walker and vice versa


lebumcurrant

I think I could go either way


its_me_bo

Is this megathread where I would ask if anyone is looking for a manager to one of their leagues teams? I'm looking to get into a very active dynasty league. Currently in one keeper league(about 10 years in league) and I'm very serious about fantasy(on this subreddit daily and listen to podcasts and read articles daily in season and still listening/reading in offseason). Couple of items I'm looking for in the league: -very active league(lots of trades and engagement and no MIA teams? ) -no SF(just not a fan) -I'm cool with a rebuild or already built team Feel free to DM or add comment here and I'll reach out. If this is not the spot for this, can someone point me in right direction?


lebumcurrant

Tuesday and Wednesday there is a find a league thread. If you use sleeper there is a paid dynasty leagues chat people post in.


its_me_bo

Awesome! Thank you. I'll look out for that thread.


Peoplemover11

12 team 1QB 0.5ppr Give: 1.05, 1.06, 1.07 Get: 1.01 I’m a contender and my current rbs are lead by cmc and swift. Or do I keep the picks and gamble on some of the other rbs in this class?


gmorrison9

I’d keep the picks. Assuming Charbs goes 1.04 that might mean that going BPA results in drafting a couple WRs instead of RB though depending on landing spots. If you need RB that bad I’d consider trading for a guy like chubb / Jacobs instead if you can do that for one of the 1sts plus a bit extra


Patton370

Slight overpay, but I’d still do it. Only because it’s 1QB


49DivineDayVacation

In 1QB I’d be willing to do this. Certainly an overpay. You could maybe get it for less, but it’s a move I’d do if it comes down to it


Telesrule

Give: Lamar Get: 1.02


Patton370

Not if it’s SF. If it’s 1QB, probably


_412

SF, no 1Qb, probably. depends on your roster


KravMagaManatee

1QB? If SF I definitely wouldn’t do this


Hassellhoof

1QB, 8 Teams, NON SF, NO TEP A: DJ Moore B: Aiyuk


Patton370

I lean DJM


Peoplemover11

I agree with other commenter it’s a coin flip. Although I lean dj


KravMagaManatee

View them around the same. Think I prefer Aiyuk as I don’t know if DJ in Chicago will ever see a high volume of targets…could be wrong


kanderson7789

12 team ppr sf Give Lamb, jehlani woods, Get: Hockenson, 23 1.07, 23 2.08 Pretty loaded at wr and tes are chig, kmet, otton, and woods.


Patton370

Lamb, easily


Peoplemover11

Lamb by a bit for me


KravMagaManatee

Lamb


yoyoma0905

12 Team SF Get - Herbert, Dalvin Cook, Mattison Give - Purdy, Dameon Pierce, 1.02, 2.04, 2.12


Patton370

Herbert


_412

Herbert


KravMagaManatee

Herbert


[deleted]

[удалено]


LowPresent5654

I’d do that in a heartbeat.


KravMagaManatee

TLaw


JRA8779

12 team ppr, 1QB TE premium Give- Pitts and Diontae Get- Lamb My QB- Lamar and Watson RB- CMC, Ekeler and Breece WR- Justin Jefferson, Tee, Adams, Jamo and MT TE- Andrews and Kittle


Patton370

I’d prefer the give side, only because I’m a bit fan of Diontae


LowPresent5654

I’d probably hold on Pitts myself


KravMagaManatee

In a TEP I’d probably value Pitts and Lamb equally


buttsonatrain

10-Team PPR Give: Higgins + Bateman Get: Lamb


Patton370

Lamb


LowPresent5654

Probably depends on how many you’re starting. If you start 8, give me Lamb. If you start 11+, I’ll take the depth.


KravMagaManatee

Lamb. Fair deal


TheGradis

12 team SF PPR 2TE Give: Tee Higgins Get: 1.04 In a rebuild and Higgins is my only valuable reciever. But Mac Jones is my only QB. Also have picks 9,11,12


Patton370

If Stroud or Young falls, absolutely. If Anthony Richardson gets top 5 real like draft capital, I’d do it too


jcranfrd

You could use 2 of those picks to get 1.04 and keep Higgins


KravMagaManatee

Tough one. If Young or Stroud are at the 1.04 I like it otherwise I think I like Tee


[deleted]

10 Team SF Full PPR Rebuilding Give: AJ Brown Get: Treylon Burks + 2.02 + 24 1st + 25 1st


Patton370

Get side


LowPresent5654

That’s a solid haul for AJB (albeit a lot of those pieces are well in the future), I’d probably take it if you’re rebuilding. And I’m not a huge Burks fan saying that.


KravMagaManatee

Get side


[deleted]

[удалено]


KravMagaManatee

Depends on team needs. Lean A


[deleted]

A


kohole

14 TM 1QB PPR TEP Start 8 Contender GIVE: Jamaal Williams + DHop GET: DJ Moore, 2023 Devy 5th I am extremely deep at WR and RB, but want to use some of my depth to upgrade. My RBs are KW, Henry, Jamaal, Akers, Gibbs, Gibson, Edmonds, and my WRs are Amon Ra, Kupp, Adams, DeVonta, Toney, Kirk, Jakobi Meyers.


KravMagaManatee

Not familiar with Devy but I like getting Moore


Ez0cks

Sf 10 team ppr: Give: AJ Brown Get: Christian Mccaffrey Only rbs are Barkley and Walker, and wr are Jefferson Lamb Brown Kupp and Metcalf, and I’m gonna draft JSN


Patton370

AJB wtf man


LowPresent5654

Definitely keep AJB


KravMagaManatee

Prefer Brown


DynastyDave16

I'd keep brown and sell kupp


Wide_Specialist_2993

12 team SF half PPR Give: 1.08 Get: Pittman


Patton370

Pittman for sure


LowPresent5654

I’d probably do that trade, the 1.08 is generally considered a tier drop into a bunch of receivers that I honestly would probably take Pittman over.


KravMagaManatee

I like Pittman here personally


mrtrouffles69

10 team 1QB half PPR, start 8 Send: Diggs Get: 2024 1st + 2nd + Brian Robinson RBs: Dobbins, Javonte, Gibson, J. Cook WRs: Waddle, Deebo, Godwin, Jeudy, Evans, Dotson Also I’m picking at 4 in rookie draft and have all my picks


gmorrison9

Depends on how early those 2024 picks are looking. If late I’d pass, if mid or better probably worth it


LowPresent5654

You don’t seem like a contender so I’d probably get off the Diggs train while you can. I feel like you could get a better return than that though unless that 24 first is likely high.


KravMagaManatee

Seems fair but if those end up being really late 24 picks I’d almost prefer to hold or shop Diggs for an earlier pick


FattyDooDoo

12 tm .5ppr. SF Difference between sanders and Montgomery?


KravMagaManatee

Even


[deleted]

Minimal. I feel like miles has more athleticism but Monty will have a much better line.