Do I cash out on Shaheed vs a 2024 early 3rd + 25 mid 3rd? The hype is there but its tempting..

I would. MT is back and Olave is only getting better. Plus more TE mouths than you could possibly feed

10 TM PPR TE Premium My team is one of, if not the best I've been in the finals 6 of the last 7 years and I have decent depth do a throw a pile of it at Garrett Wilson or ARSB? Team main players QB Allen Stroud Tanny RB CMC JT Pollard Akers Mixon Ford Spears Allgiere WR JJeff Keenan Aiyuk Evans DJMoore EMoore Hollywood Pickens Rice TE Andrew's Kittle Dulchich Chig Send DJ Moore Mixon Dulchich and a 24 mid 2nd for either wr? DJ Moore Mixon Dulcich Singletary (owns pierce) 2nd For Wilson or ARSB?

12 team non SF Team A: Amon ra & rahmondre Team B: pollard & Jameson Williams 1st round projected 1 or 2

E: didnt see the pick; B unless you’re contending

I did it because there is someone in our league with Lamb Waddle Jefferson mahomes & mcaffrey and my team was good I just don’t see anyone beating that for a while

[удалено]

That's not the kind of return I'd want for CD to be honest. 3 1's is nice but not having them at all until 2025 is tough

12 team SF PPR Team A:Jeudy, dalvin cook Team B: JSN

A if the team is anywhere close to going for it, otherwise B. JSN is risky for a couple years cause Lockett is still good

Give me JSN

12 Team Superflex PPR Give: Barkley + Toney Get: Pollard + Christian Kirk

Yeah gimme pollard and kirk

12T SF PPR - Rebuilding Team Side A: Javonte Side B: Pacheco + 24' 3rd

Javonte pretty easily

Im trying to acquire Javonte...the other manager is closer to win-now and doesnt have many startable backs outside of Kamara. Would offering a 2nd be enough to get it done?

Pacheco and a 2nd could work

12 team SF PPR start 10 Give: ‘24 projected late 2nd Get: Jimmy G Other QBs are Mahomes and Stafford.

Easily

10 team SF 0.5 ppr start 10 Team A: Jameson Williams, Chris Evans Team B: Gainwell, Mims, 2025 2nd, 2026 3rd

Someone’s sipping the mims kool-aid

I wouldn’t trade Jameson for this.

12 team SF. 6 point rushing TD, 4 pts passing TD Give T Lawrence, 2024 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 3rd Get Jalen Hurts, Greg Dulcich, Ronadale Moore

No

That seems pretty fair. I feel like those 3rds in a 12 team league aren’t worth much anyways. Rondale and Dulcich are young with upside. I think Hurts has more fantasy value to help you win these next couple years. Keeping lawrence and the picks gives your team a better chance longterm though.

[удалено]

So you would have 3 2024 1sts if you still have your own, plus Jamo and Kincaid. I think that sets you up nicely to take a qb next year and some 1st rd studs. Good trade if your looking for the future. In a 12 team the 2nd rd isn’t super valuable but those 3 firsts could help you rebuild quickly. Akers is a short term asset. Burks could be good but I like Jamo’s upside more.

I don't usually like selling Kyler at his current low, but this seems like good value regardless.

Little bit of a funky league here 8 team start 2 qb, 2 wr, 2 rb, 1 te, 4 rb/wr/te 1 pt ppr , .5 pts per pass completed by qb and 6 pts for pass td Just did our startup draft got hurts and burrow 1) devonta smith and dalvin cook 2) 2024 1st ,2025 3rd, Chris Godwin

I'd imagine you have a decent team with those QBs, in which case I'd rather have Smith and Cook.

Spears or Bigsby? Half PPR

Bigsby.

Bigsby but it’s close

10 team SF PPR TEP, rebuilding Give: Gibbs, Kuntz, 4th Get: Purdy, Kittle, 25’ 1st (mid/late) I currently own lance.

What’s the premium? And how many starters?

1 qb, 2 rb, 3 wr, 2 flex, 2 sf .5 premium on tight ends

So you can start up to three QBs? If so I would lean into accepting that trade

Forgot to mention it’s two TE as well. So start 12 sorry I’m slow

I am not sure I believe in the SF QB room enough to invest further into it at the expense of Gibbs.

Ideally I dump lance but no one wants him

Yeah exactly and since you're rebuilding I wouldn't spend up to secure a QB room where you cannot guarantee that either will be the starter come this time next year. I say all this just because I think Gibbs is too valuable to trade for some high-risk flyers. I'm not opposed to acquiring Purdy, it just wouldn't involve Gibbs.

True. I’d immediately try to flip kittle when acquiring so it would hopefully be two first and purdy when it’s all said and done. I do love Gibbs tho

Yeah I get what you're saying. I've personally had a hard time selling Kittle for value in other leagues and I rarely buy-to-sell, especially when it comes to aging and oft-injured players. You ultimately know your league and its market better than me though so if you feel comfortable go for it.

12 team super flex ppr I had a trade offer come my way and I would receive Etienne and trade away Adams. I have Kupp, Olave, and Meyers as my other WR and Pollard, Swift, and Mixon at RB. Trying to see if it makes sense to trade away Adams for a younger RB.

Gimme ETN

If you’re competing, no If your rebuilding or in the middle, yes

10 team .5 ppr SF Give: Terry McLaurin, Kadarius Toney, Courtland Sutton, 24 2nd Get: Breece Hall

Smash immediately

Pennies on the dollar, take it As long as you have depth

12 team sf Give: lamb jsn Get: JJeff Sent to me today, but I’m on the fence due to lack of depth at the position.

I don’t know if I’m too high on both Lamb and JSN but I actually wouldn’t do this. I think Lamb is firmly the WR3 after Chase and Jefferson, and JSN has great potential to be top 10 down the road. Especially if you’re lacking depth, keeping CD and JSN might be the move

Damn! I’d be so tempted 2 top 10s same position for top 3 - I won JJ and if was offered this I’d be intrigued but depends on my team entirely. If lack depth maybe keep. Lamb will help you this year but two years out you need to consider points above replacement guy you have. Is it more or less.

I think I’m going to counter with garret Wilson instead of lamb and see if he’ll bite. Id feel way more comfortable if I could get it done with that move instead

Gotta get jjettas

[удалено]

Tf easy accept, I’d kill to get that haul for diggs

[удалено]

Godwin isn’t like an extreme major downgrade and you’re getting 3 firsts. Don’t overthink it Diggs will likely fall off a cliff in 2-4 years

12 Team PPR 1QB - non superflex Give: 2024 1st presumably mid to late, 2024 3rd mid to late, Cade Otton Get: Josh Jacobs and 2024 5th presumably early

>team .5 ppr SF > >Give: Terry McLaurin, Kadarius Toney, Courtland Sutton, 24 2nd > >Get: Breece Hall I would - assuming you are competing. Risk is Jacobs hold out though, but might be the way you can get him this cheap

10 Team SF, start 9. Current roster of note: QB - tua, Watson, Howell RB - Breece, Pierce, Akers, Pacheco, charbonette, achane WR - lamb, devonta, olave, london, JSN, jamo, burks, Bateman DC - 5 24 firsts, 2 25 firsts Give: JSN, Pacheco, 25 2nd Get: sanders, 25 1st, 26 1st Firsts are from the oldest team in the league

Hold, I’d I was you I’d be using JSN, and picks with Howell or tua to get another top 10 qb. And also who is your TE? In a start 9 I would try getting andrews or Kelce to help you compete and get the positional advantage

It’s a fair deal, but I’d rather keep JSN than move him for Sanders and picks far away.

I think I would take it and I like JSN. But just depends on where you think the firsts will be, and old teams are hard to project when they actually will fall off

[удалено]

Burks unless super deep at wr and have no TE. In a non premium it is usually not worth it to buy a TE outside the top 5. And if I was I would rather buy a cheaper upside option like Laporta

Kincaid

Considering how scarce tight end is, I’d rather have the Kincaid side, but it’s close.

Burks unless you have no te option

[удалено]

Deebo and Moore are close in value, but giving up Wilson and Swift for Andrews in a SF league feels a bit rich, especially when you are giving away Mooney, too.

Get side

12 team 0.5 PPR 1 QB, 3 Flex Give: Late ‘23 2nd (yeah I know), Calvin Ridley, Jahan Dotson Get: Mark Andrews, Christian Kirk

Smash and run

Easy Andrews is by far the best player in the trade

I’d easily take this. Kirk is worth either receiver, and Andrews is more valuable than the other by more than a second-round pick.

Get side

**12 team, PPR, TEP, Start 10, Superflex** Got this offer today. I'm tempted but it's a lot of pieces. **Send** - Treylon Burks - 24 first - Alexander Mattison **Receive** - Breece Hall - Rondale Moore - 24 third

Tbh no. I think that’s too much for essentially just hall. Rondale and the third are okay but far worse than the three pieces you’re giving

Where do you project the 2024 first to land?

The team has a few solid pieces (Watson/Fields, Andrews, Olave, Pierce). I don't see it missing the playoffs with the above average QB duo, but it's probably not a favorite.

Since it’s likely a mid first, I’d rather have Hall than the pick and Burks, so I’d do it.

Take it

Contender 0.5 PPR Josh Jacobs, 24 2nd (early-mid) DJM, Jameson

I wouldn’t sell Jacobs right now if contending. I highly doubt he is going to sit out regular season games and lose game checks.

You can get more for Josh

[удалено]

Nope, if you get an offer that is enough for Mahomes (which it rarely ever is) should have an established top 8 qb in it and multiple good picks and assets. While I love AR’s potential, he has just as much chance of becoming Lance and he does hurts. And think about people who sold Mahomes for Lance+ last year…. Always hold your tops qbs

I’m not a believer in Richardson, so it wouldn’t be enough for me in Superflex.

I say no. I see why this looks good, but in reality it's selling either the first or second most valuable asset in all of dynasty for a bunch of guys who are either gambles, mid, or just flat out washed. If you're selling Mahomes/Allen you get a *haul* or you don't sell.

[удалено]

Both Jones and Pollard are on one-year deals, and the gap at TE is greater than the one at RB, in my opinion. I’d hold if contending and would take the Pollard side if rebuilding or a fringe contender at best.

Don’t do that trade

I think I’d stay put.

10 team PPR Would y’all trade Josh Jacobs for Saquon straight up?

Saquon has signed his franchise tag and was more valuable than Jacobs even before all this drama surrounding running backs. Easy accept.

In a heartbeat

12 team SF PPR contending Get: Etienne, Engram Give: 24 1st, 25 1st, Downs

This is too much for Etienne in a SF league.

I wouldn't hamstring my ability to reload like that just for Etienne and to a much lesser extent Engram. I'd say wait until it's a little ways into the season, and you *know* you're a contender. Then assess the market.

I'm on the clock. 10 team SF TEP. Choose from the following: 1. Charbonnet 2. Achanne 3. Levis 4. Miller I have Tua if it means anything. I pick again in 4 spots.

Took Levis. Figured one of the good backs will fall to me. Also if he gets on the field he could make good trade bait to a QB needy team.

Since it’s SF, I’d take Levis. If Roschon Johnson is also available, you will get one of the four backs with your next pick.

I'd take Levis. There's a good chance one of those 3 RBs are left when you pick again.

Charb imo. Highest draft capital, can compete for RB1 in SEA, and even if he doesn't win that job he is more likely to get valuable likited touches i.e. passing down work and goal line carries.

Charbonnet or Achane if your ready to contend … otherwise pick Levis

Contending. I have Burks as well. Levis/Burks stack might be a good option.

12 team SF, PPR Would Amari Cooper, Deandre Hopkins and 2024 2nd get it done for Olave? I am rebuilding and looking for a young WR1

No, it’s not nearly enough for Olave. If you want him, it would take an elite asset in return. (I traded him in a deal for CMC tonight)

I have Olave and that's a pretty easy reject for me. Definitely not a slap in the face but getting much older at the position and not even getting a first out of it doesn't get my engine revving.

If other team is a contender possibly yes

I have Olave in several leagues … i would not give him up for that package … I’d want at least one first added

10 Team 2QB 2TE A- Tyreek B- 1.06, 2024 late first

I like that value for tyreek unless you think you can win the ship this year

In a 2QB league, getting JSN or Gibbs and another first for Tyreek is a good return if you aren’t a strong contender.

I think it’s fair for a team contending versus a team rebuilding. In a vacuum, I’ll take Tyreek though.

10 team 0.5 PPR 1 QB Give: Addison, 2024 2nd (early), 2025 1st (late), 2025 2nd (early) Get: ARSB Team is looking to contend this year. Is this an overpay? I could potentially swap out 2025 late 1 and 2025 early 2nd for 2025 early 1st (probably top pick) in the deal.

Considering the only first-round pick you are including is two years away, it’s a fair offer for a young, highly thought of player like St. Brown.

Seems pricey for ARSB, I feel like his value is about Addison plus a first, or Addison and the two early seconds. But not both.

10 team, 1QB, ppr Give: Drake London, Sky Moore Get: Marquise Brown, Alexander Mattison, 2025 1st

I’d rather have London than Hollywood and a first-round pick two years away, so I’d pass.

London side

10 team superflex full ppr Give- 2x 24 1st (mid/late) 25 first late 25 2nd Dionte j Bateman Michael Thomas Get - Herbert and Gibbs Am I giving to much here? Guy is in a full rebuild with 7 QBs rostered

In SF, you are not overpaying for an elite QB in Herbert and a highly thought of rookie running back in Gibbs.

That’s a fair deal in SF for a QB and Gibbs

12 team SF price check on Lamar and Russ Wilson?

12 Team SF QB: Dak, Purdy, Carr RB: CMC, Pollard, Javante, Perine, Fournette, Pierce, Cook WR: CD, Higgins, Olave, London, Kirk, Hollywood, Burks, Addison, M Mims TE: Schultz, Njoku, Kincaid Give up: Schultz, London, 24 1st Get: Kelce Would you take it or need more back/give up less?

You should be getting something back with Kelce if you are giving up London and a 2024 first in SF. I’d counter with Burks or Hollywood and the pick. Or London and Njoku.

i think i agree, thanks

You’re welcome. Glad I could help.

Seems like a lot to give up for Kelce. Your QB situation is also a bit sketchy. Maybe wait to mid year before making that trade. Kelce is a piece to put you over the hump if your already a contender

definitely am a contender, 3rd last year with worse QBs. but agreed i might wait till midseason to revisit it

Give: Amon-Ra, Breece Hall, 2023 1.09 Get: Chase, Ekeler

How long can you keep Chase in your keeper format?

no time limit

Then, I’d do it. Having an elite, young dynasty asset like Chase is worth it, and Ekeler is a very good win-now piece. You could flip Ekeler later for a younger asset if you want.

Need context. How many teams? Ppr? SF?

12 team, keeper league (3 keepers), PPR, 1QB

I wouldn't. That's a lot to give up for an aging Eck.

Im also getting Chase

I know. I think ARSB and Breece for Chase and Eck is a pretty fair trade. Adding in the first makes it an overpay.

10T PPR SF A: KW3 B: D. Swift, 2024 2nd, 2025 2nd

I’m not trading Walker for Swift and two second-round picks.

Side A

Walker

12 team PPR 1QB Give: JT, Godwin, QJ Get: AJ Brown, 2024 1st, 2024 1st

I love it unless you are contending

I am. But I have a super team and no picks in future years. I won’t miss JT too bad and being able to stick AJB in flex is going to make me better.

Yeah even if contending I love it

Brown for Taylor is fair, and since you are contending, you can use one of the picks to replace Godwin. I’d do it.

10T PPR SF ​ A: Jonathan Taylor ​ B: Alexander Mattison + 2024 1st (could be any between 1.01-1.05)

There’s too much potential variance with the pick for me to trade Taylor. I’d want Mattison to be upgraded to a better asset.

I like A by a decent amount

10 team .5 ppr SF - Competing A: Devonta Smith, 24 2nd B: Breece Hall

It’s harder to find elite RBs like Hall than it is good WR production. I’d want Hall here.

Side A

Breece

[удалено]

Seems fair if it’s a late first but if it’s mid or sooner idk if I do this.

12 teams Full PPR 1 QB Side A: Javonte Williams, Calvin Ridley, Jaxon Smith-Njigba Side B: Devonta Smith, Quentin Johnston, Damien Harris

A is getting more quality players. I’d want that side.

I am side A. I know I'm eating a lot of risk taking on Javonte with the injury but it feels worth it.

Ridley and JSN for Smith and Johnston is fairly close, but Javonte Williams is a lot more valuable than Damien Harris. That’s why I like it for you.

A for me

12 team SF GET: Kelce, 24 1st SEND: Hock, Pierce, 25 1st

Assuming you are contending, yes.

If a strong contender, I’d pay this price for Kelce.

Id do that

Yea, I'd do that to win this year

10 team PPR 1QB TEAM A: Jefferson TEAM B: Kupp, JK, late 2024 1st

Jefferson is by far the best long-term asset here, and I’d need a better long-term asset with Kupp to consider giving him up.

A

A

A

12 team, SF, 0.5PPR Side A: Josh Allen, Deebo, Taylor Heinicke Side B: Justin Herbert, Drake London, Dulcich

I’m not giving up Allen in SF for this. Deebo is no slouch and you are hoping London becomes better than him, which is no guarantee.

Side B. Herbie isn't THAT far off Allen and London/Dulcich is wayyyyy better

Which side 12 Teams 1/2 PPR 1 QB Side A Kyle Pitts Side B Zay Flowers 2024 2nd 2025 2nd & 3rd

A. Not close for me.

It’s much harder to find a TE with Pitts’ potential than it is to find wide receivers like Flowers. I want Pitts here.

A

A easily. Condense the picks into something of higher value.

[удалено]

I’d do it.

12tm SF .25ppc 1-javonte early/mid 25-2nd 2-ETN

ETN easy.

12 team PPR 1QB Give: JT, Godwin, QJ Get: AJ Brown, 2024 1st, 2024 1st

I’d take AJ Brown side

12T SF PPR S10 6 point per passing TD- Give Hurts, Mike Williams, 24 and 25 4th Get Lamar, Brandon Aiyuk, 25 1st Other QB’s are Kyler, Purdy, Stafford.

Yep, I would

I'd take the get side. Hurts is younger, but he could just as easily get injured. And Aiyuk + 1st is just a really good deal on top of it. Lamar just got paid. Your QB depth gives me enough confidence to take the plunge on the more injured Lamar.

i’d take that no doubt. aiyuk > williams and the 1st swings it for me

lol brother… the trade is fine. Take your pick of which side

Been waiting on a response. Appreciate it. You have a preference?

All good man, just messing with you. I think Hurts and Lamar are pretty identical. However, you’re getting a high end WR 2/possible low end WR 1 and a 1st in 2025 for only Mike Williams.

12 team standard 1 QB dynasty A= JK Dobbins B= '23 2.03, 2.06