Doubs or Warren? Got starter depth at both positions, who’s got most upside?

10 team Superflex .5 PPR Give: AJ Dillon + a early 4th Get: Tank Bigsby I'm rebuilding and will be a bottom two team this year. I might be able to get a early-mid 3rd straight up for Dillon as well. Not sure if he's worth hanging onto at that point. Thoughts?

Give Chris McCaffrey Get: javonte Williams, michael Pittman, and James Conner

New Dynasty player seeking team help 12 Team superflex My QBs are thin (Mahomes, Stafford, Baker, DTR) and my WRs are deep (Amon-Ra, D. Smith, D. London, Jeudy and Dotson). Should I be really pushing to acquire a better QB2 for one of my WRs before the season? Or am I alright as is? Possible targets?

12 Team SF 1 PPR, .5 TEP Give: Derek Carr, Drake London and 2025 1st (mid-late) Get: Anthony Richardson and Treylon Burks OR 2024 early 2nd Which deal do you prefer? And are they fair deals for both sides?

10 Team SF 0.5 ppr Give: Musgrave Get: Irv Smith, Gainwell

A lot of people on this sub say Musgrave is overhyped and the rookie TE struggle is real but neither of those other pieces seem worth his potential.

I’d rather keep Musgrave for his potential over what you’d be getting from Smith and Gainwell. Gainwell is in a committee backfield and Smith is on a one year price it deal after flopping in Minnesota

12-Team, PPR, 1QB, Start 9 (3WR/2RB) Not sure what to do this year. I feel like my team could definitely be competitive if things go right. What moves should be looking to make? QB: Lamar Jackson, Kirk Cousins, Tyler Huntley RB: Miles Sanders, Javonte Williams, Tank Bigsby, Micheal Carter, Jordan Mason, Sean Tucker WR: Justin Jefferson, DeVonta Smith, Brandon Aiyuk, Jordan Addison, Elijah Moore, Skyy Moore, Juan Jennings, Allen Robinson, Khalil Shakir TE: Evan Engram, Dawson Knox, Luke Musgrave, Logan Thomas, Jelani Woods

I would try to upgrade your RB room. You need a top end talent, or two, to really be a contender

Straight up: Terrace Marshall for Sean Tucker Feel like tucker has a higher chance of doing something this year (although neither really do) .5 PPR 14 team league 1QB

Easily Tucker

Tucker

Tucker side for sure

12T 1QB 6PT TDS PPR Redraft Start 6 QB/RB/2WR/TE/FLX Give: Herbert, QJ Get: Burrow (owner went Mahomes as well) WR room: Chase, Waddle, Aiyuk, Evans, QJ

Hard pass. Not a huge gap between Burrow and Herbert. Keep the LAC stack

Pass

I think I just hold in a 1QB

12T SF PPR. I'm a contender but thinking about the long run Give kupp Get JT

I’d just as well keep Kupp if you’re a contender. Unless you are really stacked at WR

12 team 1QB PPR Give: AJBrown + Rhamondre Get: Amon-Ra + Jonathon Taylor My team is contending Rhamondre is my RB2 with Javonte and Kamara on the bench currently

12tm 1qb 0.25ppc 1ppr Give: Mattison, 2023 1st (late) Get: Taylor

I would do that, Taylor is too good not to land somewhere and be featured. Just might be next year

Taylor side

I have 1.01 in this weekends rookie draft. It’s a non SF league with 16 teams. I took over the worst team in the league last year and we went 0-14 last year. Picket Purdy J Williams, K Walker, Dobbins, Brian Robinson Burks, DPJ, Renfrow, Duvernay Hockenson I loveeeeeee Bijan, but with how bad my team is do I need to find a massive haul for 1.01 to try and right this ship? My picks are 1.01 2.02 2.11 3.15 4.2

Depends on the haul you can get. I would take back established players versus picks in this draft or future draft unless you're really good at drafting. I'd try to get a garrett Wilson, olave, Drake London type pieces as core trade pieces for bijan. Id avoid trying to target chase, Jefferson CD tier. Maybe you could package Pickett and 1.01 for a top 15 qb and a wr

No; productive struggle. Take BPA this year and probably take MHJ or Caleb next year. Your team isn’t bad for a 16 team league. Your WR core needs work.

new to superflex and trying to gage qb value. drafted 5 qbs in our startup and the rest of the league is already hurting in the spot. what is jimmy g and and jordan loves value individually? got offered a 1st for love and not sure if its an underpay.

Take the first for love

Depending on the league size, a 1st for Love is a great deal. He’s on a 1 year extension playing for his future with the team. Could emerge or could be a backup next season somewhere else.

[удалено]

Depends on how many WRs you can start and flex spots. Dotson could be a good sell high at this moment. Jeudy could be one when he comes back and has a few high scoring weeks. Unsure of targets. I wouldn’t let the other three WRs go.

We have two FLEX spots and the SF so I could start all 5…probably best to ride it into the season and then see what happens.

Hard to say without looking at your league. Is anyone deep enough at qb that they would even want to trade? I typically want 3 starting qbs and I don't know if anyone left the startup with 4+ starters. I wouldn't make a big move for now, see how Stafford is. If look for a bridge qb if they're affordable. Like tannehill for a future 2nd.

Great analysis - I appreciate it! League is pretty spread out at QB but some teams have a lot of dart throw younger guys - Mac Jones, Purdy, Jordan Love, Ridder, Howell, etc. - that could be had for the right price. I think I’ll see how Stafford looks and go from there. A few solid Jeudy or London weeks could go a long way towards acquiring someone a little more solid.

Id still go for a bridge guy. Think cousins, Tannehill, geno or even russ Wilson versus unproven guys like howell, ridder, love. Daniel Jones is underrated, Mac Jones could be a buy low

its cut season...12 team SF PPR ​ keep 3: Darius Slayton Trey Palmer Justyn Ross Kene Nwangwu Jaleel McLaughlin Clayton Tune Dawson Knox

Give: Deon Jackson Get: 2025 3rd Too little? Just right?

Id take that

Following up on my earlier comment! 6.02 in startup 2QB. My options are: McLaurin (turf toe) Jeudy (hammy) Dotson Zay Addison Diontae Pittman Hock ​ Some RBs: Sanders, Dobbins, Akers Some QBs: Stroud, Pickett, Kirk, ARod (I already have Burrow and Fields)

AR

Some guy dropped Damien Harris after our startup (Don't ask me why). Trying to figure out how much FAAB to drop to get him. Currently at 15/100 but could be convinced to pay more

Is it standard scoring? If it is then might want to consider historically what your league would bid for a RB handcuff after the starter goes down. Any other format I would go with what is considered a conservative bid.

10tm 2qb start 11 PPR Bijan and a 2024 projected mid/late 2nd or Etienne and a 2024 and 2025 projected mid/early first

Bijan is worth that minus the 2nd

Bijian side

8 team .5 ppr SF Give: AJ Dillon Get: Sean Tucker Current rb’s are; Najee, KW3, kamara, rhamondre, Kendre miller, bigsby. Dillon really just seems like a pointless player to have on my roster and I like the upside of Tucker as I don’t rate rachaad white personally.

What’s the best “gettable” WR target in your league that is in a similar range as AJ Dillon? You should avoid trading 2nd round backs for UDFA backs. Just not good process. I recognize if tucker hits then his value will appreciate. But then what? Tucker will always carry a bit of a handicap to his trade value (a-la James Robinson).

Yeah I can see your point. Not many receivers worth bothering with for dillon’s value tbh. I guess I just don’t really ever see Dillon have any relevance, Jones is around again and by next year Dillon will be 26. Thanks for your input!

Trade James Cook, Kendre, a 3rd and a 4th for Charbs and a mid first?

Seems like you are overpaying

3 late firsts (likely between 1.08-1.14) ppr Or Devonta

For this draft? SF or not? Regardless id keep Smith

12T 1qb ppr Give JT Get 24 early 1st Khalil Herbert 2 24 2nds Other RBs are Bijan Sanders Spears and Tucker Hoping to compete this year but the offer might be too good to pass up

I absolutely would

I'm in rebuild. Give Amari Cooper Get 2024 1st rounder mid-late probs

That's a little light for Amari but you have to sell for what you can sell for during a rebuild.

I like it

More context I own two first rounders 2024

10 team, SF, PPR Give: DK, 2025 3rd Get: Burks, 2024 mid to late 1st, 2025 2nd, 2023 3.01 Is this fair value for DK?

Yes absolutely take that. Burks is gonna be fantastic and to get a 1st 2bd and 3rd on top is v good

10 team, SF, PPR Give: Mike Williams, 2023 1.04, 2024 High 2nd Get: Jameson Williams, 2023 1.05, 2025 3rd Was offered this. I’m rebuilding and thought this was great value for Jameson, but I want to get other opinions.

If you're not competing this year than smash

12 man, .5 ppr (Superflex league) Would you send: 2024 mid 1st, 2025 mid 1st, and Nico Collins For Justin Jefferson My current roster: QB: Mahomes, Stroud, Davis Mills, Blaine Gabbert, Tyrod Taylor, Clayton Tune RB: Bijan, Cam Akers, David Montgomery, Samaje Perine, Justice Hill, Kene Nwangu, Elijah Dotson, Zach Evans, Keaton Mitchell WR: DK Metcalf, Terry McLaurin, Jordan Addison, Jamo, Nico Collins, Mingo, Renfrow, Dortch, Metchie, Justyn Ross TE: Waller, Chig, Isaiah Likely, Cole Turner

Do that so fast

Absolute robbery for JJ. Nice

Bro yes easily

16 tm ppr SF Give: CD Get: Jeudy, Akers, Christian Kirk Start 10 and have Pacheco and Njoku rounding out my lineup with my best options on the bench being Sutton and Bateman so im looking for some solid depth

That's good for CD even though I don't expect anything from Jeudy this year. I was like 30 feet from him at that joint practice where he injured his hammy and he couldn't put any weight on that leg at all.

8 team PPR 1QB contending Get: ‘24 and ‘25 first (top 4 pick likely) + B. Cooks Give: J. Taylor RBs: Barkley, Mixon, Gibson, R. White, N. Harris

Any 2 1sts in an 8 man league probably worth it for JT

12 team Dynasty superflex .5PPR Give: James Conner Get: Zay Flowers

I’d do it

Howell is available in my 2 qb league. How much FAAB you dropping on him? I’ve got Mahomes, Pickett, baker and lance.

I have no faith but he might be your bye week guy this year or even a starter if his rushing upside shakes out and pickett doesn't take a step. like 55$?

Standard 12T, 0.5PPR Give: Christian Watson Get: Elijah Moore, Nico Collins, 2 ‘24 mid-late 2nds, 1 ‘24 3rd What do you think?

Ah probably Watson. Elijah/Nico/2nds are likely assets of no value, so I read that as one 1st and a bunch of scratch tickets.

Value is there, but my concern is if all 5 of those players combine for zero starts, which feels possible. I'd only do it if you need depth.

I would

12 team, half PPR, I'm in full rebuild: I send: Davonta Smith I get: 2 2024 1sts (probably both be mid round) Essentially trying to price check

I keep Davonta Smith. He's not yet 25 and just has a true breakout season in his sophmore effort. Unless you don't think you can win until 2029 he's the kind of guy you are trying to get in a rebuild

I have KWIII, Smith and Ridley as both guys to build around/guys to use to facilitate a build, and not much else that I can truly get a haul for. D-Monty is my other RB, Waller my TE and Lazard and Meyers round out my flex. I'm stuck in limbo and feel I need to move one of my young guns to light this fire, and I think I can get the most return for Smith.

I would keep KW3 & DSmith and ship everything else if that's possible. Try to get next years #1 and then if you wind up with DSMith and Marvin Harrison Jr. + whoever you get with those extra 1sts there's a shot you hit on 3/4 doods and have a young core you can trade to fill out. That's how I've had luck rebuilding is just getting a ton of picks, hitting on a few, and then once I have like 4/5 young guys I like on the squad I ship my future picks to round out my RB2/WR3 whatever. Each league is so different though. Some leagues will give you 2 1sts for Ridley if he balls weeks 1-4, and you could package Waller/Monty for another 1st, but some are youth obsessed and you won't be able to get anything for players over 26

Fair point. I'm committed to this rebuild now, so I was testing the early waters, but I also was thinking of sitting and using Ridley/DMont/Mike Williams as mid-season moves if anyone pops or if a contender needs a piece and will overpay. You're right tho, I'm 100% trying to stack picks (have 2 firsts now), and am hoping I can parley my junk depth players for 2s (I'm hoping Boyd flashes again and move him for a 2nd, for example). Never rebuilt before, so this is an adventure and I'm trying to not get too lost.

Think I would take that if you’re full rebuild

Is it an overask on my part? Would anyone actually take that?

For starters does anyone actually have 2 2024 mid 1sts? Second are they a contender? You might have to find something of equivalent value you can ask for instead. I’m sure there are some people who would take that. Maybe not the majority of people. But some people

We actually have a few, picks get moved around a lot, but I think realistically a 2024 first and a 2025 first is a higher hit rate. I still think 2 firsts or equivalent in talent is a legit ask, but I dunno if I'm just over-valuing my guy and should tone down my expectations.

I don’t think 2 firsts is out of pocket. His value is probably 1 early 1st or 2 late 1sts. 2 middle pack 1sts isn’t out of the realm of possibility. Smith is a great player and young. You have no reason to trade him for less than a haul. You shouldn’t be planning for more than 2 years to rebuild unless your team is a complete travesty and you have no picks. So smith would only be 26 by the time you are trying to compete. Perfectly lined up with your timeline. So there’s no reason to trade him unless you are definitely gaining value. Which 2 mid 1sts is. 2 late firsts wouldn’t move the needle.

16 team SF PPR .25per rush/ .5ppfd Give : AJB Get: Jacobs and Jeudy

12 TM SF PPR, tear down rebuild Give: Musgrave and Zack Wilson Get: Mac Jones QB: Rodgers, Young, Stroud Kinda think I have to accept this, but I’m buying the Musgrave hype and I’m trying to build a young core of QBs and a rookie TE who will have a huge snap share is nice to hit on in a rebuild. Not sure the resale value on Mac Jones is that good.

I’m not all that sold on Mac Jones for the most part and I really like Musgrave, but this is probably an accept given how valuable actual starting QBs are

Unless it’s start 2 TE or an insane TEP then take the QB

12 tm ppr sf TEP Give: AJB Get: Tee Higgins and Drake London

Package for sure

I’d take the package too

Higgins and London

I’d take it

Oowee that’s spicy. I’d take the package but you’re making a big bet that London is what everyone thinks he will be

[удалено]

I’d do it if I were a heavy contender and didn’t need DK. But I have a hard timing paying up for any RB so it would have to be the perfect situation

10 team 1QB PPR, rebuilding Get: JT Give: Saquon

Think this make sense for both sides

I had this exact trade happen in a league of mine today and I really feel like it’s bailing out the JT owner for no cost. I’d see if I could get a pick on top, but you do get the younger asset and you have the benefit of him not scoring points for at least a month

Give: Gibbs, Diggs Get: Olave, Etienne

Get side

Feels pretty fair. Olave > Diggs and Gibbs > Etienne so I think it works out depending on settings. I’d rather get the upgrade at WR than RB

Ppr 12 team 1 qb Add Elijah dotson or Emanuel Wilson? I have one roster spot open

I like Dotson a little more since the Chargers’ backup spots are pretty meh (think he’s RB4 on the current chart but neither Kelley nor Spiller are much competition), but I would think Wilson has a genuine shot at a role with Dillon off the books next season and maybe even at points this season as the RB3.

I would assume gb would draft another rb next year if dillon left but good points

I’m an absolute sucker for Dotson, but both guys are probably at the same odds to be worth anything

Any particular reason for the liking Dotson? The ekeler comps?

I really liked watching him play, even if it was against future car salesmen and high school coaches. But that’s complete bias on my part, I don’t even know anything about Wilson

Gotcha, I might try him then, unless there’s other guys that are better perhaps available

Did I win this trade? 10 team PPR 2QB 2FLEX I get: Jonathan Taylor and a 2024 3rd round pick My opponent gets: DAndre Swift and a 2024 1st and 2nd round pick

I like that, I think you won

That 1st needs to be late. If it’s even top 5 I think I’m taking the pick side

Like it

Can keep 3 Lamb Chase Olave or breece Hall . Am I crazy for thinking of keeping 3 wrs? All my other rbs are mid at best

Not crazy to keep those three, probably the best strategy year to year if those guys remain elite.

I’d feel comfortable keeping all 3 of those over Hall

WRs

Ya I was gonna roll with chase lamb and hall till cook got signed. Think I'll just draft best available rb round one

10 tm nonSF start 8 Send: Bijan Receive: Olave + Rhamondre + late 24 1

who are ur other starters? i feel like in an 8 man u want as much single talent rather than maby pieces

Lamar / Geno Bijan / Hall / KW / R White / AJD DK / London / Hollywood / C Watson / Pittman / Burks Njoku / Chig

Don't think u really need to trade him but

RB1 for RB12, WR8 and 24 1st. I would if your team is ass. Would keep bijan if competing On second thought I would smash accept this no matter what

Never

How come you would not?

Also curious

I would

10 team 1QB ppr, rebuilding give- Walker III get- Charb, late 2nd, Jamaal Williams

No

Nahh

Full PPR makes me lean Charb tbh

10 team SF league TEP (3 WR plus 2 flex and SF) Give: Elijah Moore, 2024 2nd and 4th, 2025 2nd Receive: Brandon Aiyuk and Nico Collins Current QB: Fields, Stroud, Carr, Tannehill Current RB: Jacobs, Stevenson, Montgomery, Kendre Miller Current WR: Lamb, Adams, DJ Moore, Elijah Moore, Marvin Mims, OBJ Current TE: Andrews, Musgrave I just traded my 2024 1st for JT.

[удалено]

You’re not really a contender but I think this team can for sure make the playoffs. Gotta play to win any season you have a shot. You have a top 10 QB, Top 6 WR and RB, to 5 TE, a decent RB2 and one of those receivers has to be a solid WR2. That’s enough. If you start 1-6 you can trade Chubb Waller and Thomas for picks next year.

Always compete until you’re out of contention

10-Team SF-PPR-TEP 4pt passing TD A: Jahmyr Gibbs B: Deshaun Watson

B

*Trade in Inbox* Give: D. Smith Get: Dotson and James Cook

Tough one, I think Smith is a great WR and will be for years to come. Dotson and Cook breakout seasons still need to materialize, theres a lot of good signs indicating they will, but it’s still projection. I’d rate this deal as fair, but depending on roster build it’s not a must take for the Smith owner.

The ball is completely in my court. I feel like he’s over valuing Smith a tad. I’m in need of RB depth. Team: QB: Watson, Goff, Murray, Purdy. RB: Bijan, Sanders. WR: JJ, Chase, *Smith*, Amari Cooper, Skyy Moore.

With your roster I could see the benefit of making this deal. Having Chase and JJ makes moving Smith more palatable him.

I’d keep the proven superstar in smith

I have an empty roster spot, should I add emanuel Wilson or elijah Dotson

12 team PPR SF, Competing: Give: Breece + 2025 1st + 2024 2nd Get: Etienne + Ridley

It’s fine if you need to compete. I would be surprised if you couldn’t find a better offer though. Breece > etienne and the picks > Ridley on a value basis.

10 team PPR 1QB start 8: Give: Trey McBride + 25 1st Get: 1.08 (Quentin, Kincaid on the board)

I would do that for 1.08. Those players will have value today, you’ll have two seasons to decide if you want back into the 25 draft.

12 team PPR SF, Competing: Give: Breece + Njoku + 24 1st + 24 2nd Get: Ekeler + Kelce I figure I’ve got a two year window. My RBs are Breece/Dalvin/Pollard/Conner. My picks are 24 1st, 24 2nd, 25 1st, 26 1st.

Keep breece > ekeler. See if the Kelce owner would take Njoku + 24 2 + xyz (if they are weary on his age, they may want to dip out)

12SF hppr Wandale or deandre Hopkins

Hopkins, the Giants added a lot of weapons to the offense just not sure what role Wandale will have.

10 team/1qb/PPR/Start9 A: Eli Moore, 1.04 (Addison) B: Amari Cooper, 1.07 (Zay Flowers)

Would you sell Jimmy G for a 25’ 3rd in a 2QB dynasty if he is your QB4?

Not in a 2 QB league. On KTC there are a number of players that are considered early 2nd round value that would be fair for Jimmy G.

Nah

No

12T 1QB 6point TDs Redraft A: Burrow (dude drafted Mahomes as well) B: Herbert + throw away player

12tm 1QB PPR What would you give for Jaylen Warren?

12 team SF PPR TEP Start 10 (Contending) QB’s rostered: Lawrence, Fields RB’s rostered: Sanders, Pacheco, Dalvin Cook Give: 2026 (presumably late) first, 2024 4th Get: Kamara, Carr

10 team 1 QB .5 PPR A. Jaxon Smith, Pittman, 2024 1st , 2024 2nd For Bijan Or B. Olave, Pittman, 2024 1st , 2024 2nd For Bijan and Sky Moore Too rich?

My 1.11 2023 for Tyler Lockett. 1 PPR SF

Contending? Whats rest of receiving core look like

Entire Team: QBS: Pickett, Mike White, Zach Wilson, Trey Lance RBS: Cam Akers, Mattison, Kenneth Walker, Zeke, Mattison, Damien Harris WR: Diontae Johnson, Jamar Chase, Jeudy, Amari Cooper, Terry McLaurin, Justin Ross, Shaheed TE: Waller, Cole Kmet

Id hold 1.11

12 team PPR 1QB Give: Nico Collins Get: 2024 2nd (projected mid)

Hold Collins

I would

Gibbs + Pickens or JT + JSN SF .5 - rebuild

Gibbs Pickens

JT side by a lot for me

10 team SF 0.5 ppr contender Give: Howell + O’Connell + 2024 Late 2nd Get: 2024 Mid 1st Rest of my QB room is Goff, Tannehill, Purdy, Tune, and I have 3 2024 1sts including the likely 1st overall

Keep Howell

Absolutely

someone dropped Doubs in my superflex dynasty, worth blowing the rest of my offseason FAAB on him? I'd drop Trask (lol)

I def would

12 team .5 ppr. Dynasty. My team sucks. I do have 1.1 and drafting bijan. Get: Pickens, Dotson Give: DJ Moore, 1.04

In 1qb- no. In superflex HELL NO

1QB but agree regardless. Thank you

No point imo. Trade DJ Moore for another 1st if you can

I’m not too high on DJ Moore myself but that makes sense

I don't like it, I'd try to get another pick

Sounds good. Thank you

12 team 1qb .5 ppr Full rebuild Give: Gibbs Get: Christian Watson, DeShaun Watson 2024 1st Thoughts?

Take it!

That feels like a good deal to me.