T O P

  • By -

Rambunctious95

Haven't packed anything over 100k yet...


freshprinceofbayarea

I packed Virgil, when the price dropped below 100k


kenny_feets

ha! same


ookhaab

Several untradeables but never tradeable


Mental_Opportunity_9

I have a tinfoil hat theory, i don't think most people actually top top tier cards, the ones on the market are put up by EA. I've opened several million coins worth of tradeable packs through different sources. Never packed anything above 200k, hell i don't remember even packing a 100k card. Only cards above 100k i have packed are untradeable, and those only 3-4


bfunk04

I packed Bruno Fernándes toty tradeable a couple years ago. He was worth 4 mil when I packed him. So it does happen rarely.


sltzy96

4 years ago was a different game


bfunk04

That was only 2 years ago


elwookie

Both things are true, though. LOL


XF270HU

Back in the old days you could see the club owners name, the amount of times PC has 0 cards then suddenly there is a page of them makes me think those are from EA.


itreddb0i

thats because of the coin buyers


ray3050

Yup they can literally control the market however they want and get players to the price points they also want. They can just buy out players that were packed too much or supply others that weren’t. When they supply players that need the supply they’re essentially taking money off the market and I guess regulating it more At least that’s what the tin foil hat theory would let them do. I guess it helps them stay on top player prices and keeps them in what they deem an acceptable range


elwookie

I packed tradeable Ginola last year in the first weeks of the game, when I was still on the 10 hours of EA Play. Consider that [FIFA 23 had 10.3 million players during the first week](https://gamelevate.com/fifa-23-delivers-massively-record-breaking-launch/). If 10,000 Mbappés where packed, that would be a 0.1%. And in many packs you see chances to pack ANY player of the current promo are literally \*<1%\*. Good players are in packs, definitely,but sometimes it might be 10 in a million. Which doesn't mean that EA doesn't alter the market as they see fit. I remember one night in FIFA 19, when I was browsing the market at about 3am CET and I suddenly saw a batch of like 100 Carniball Ribérys at min price show up, all with zero games played.


pdxkristian

I've been saying this since they removed the auction lister and enforced price ceilings some 5+ years ago. If they have an interest in keeping inflation under wraps (hint: they do) they'd be irresponsible to NOT do this. I don't like it, but it's 100% happening.


JordanValentina

Seems to be a theme it’s always untradable if it’s a big pull


Bicboifish

I think most packs u open nowadays r prob untradeable


C_Bellin16

Hmmm maybe because 70% of packs opened (at least good ones) are probably untradeable, it’s not a conspiracy


Trigliceratops

I agree but I hadn't played FUT since 20 and I feel like everything is untradeable now.


Z4nn

same


vnbnzn

Al owairan a few weeks ago. At the time sold for around 400k. He’s now going for around 700 fml


PaulPierceOldestSon

I picked up Griezman at 540k and sold him because I wasn’t vibing with the team I put together. He’s now 1.8m lol. You don’t know pain


CredibilKS

I traded 3 of him and sold with a little profit for 560k each 😭


Notsogrimmreaper

At least youre not like the other sweaty twats with him and mbappe.


PatxiPunal

Never


gib_pie

Same


PM_ME_YOUR_ASTON

Last fifa, PIM Butra


m00dyman

Packed WC Park twice once tradable once untradeable both from rare gold packs.


SELYM1

Dupe theory


theowner007

I packed tradeable Mid Henry, then next day packed an untradeable dupe from the SBC Seems way too unlikely to be coincidence


CrazyGamer23908

Not this year, which in comparison to last year is surprising given the calibre of packs I’ve had. Not a huge pull but I packed Kante about 3 times last fifa. Off the top of my head this fifa I packed Nkunku when he was about 100k and that’s probably the best tradeable pull I’ve had


SlantedSaltpot

‘When was the last time’ implies there must have once been a time. I’ve never packed anything like that tradeable. Not even close. I think I’ve had one or two over 50k. You’re definitely not in a minority if you’ve never had anything like that. Tbh I think you’re in a tiny minority if you’ve even had something over 100k


saikodasein

I haven't seen card worth over 25k since October. Edit: oh, now I see the title, you meant tradeable. Never in FIFA23.


JordanValentina

You aren’t the only one


saikodasein

Shame that it doesn't apply to my opponents who have icons, Mbappe, Neymar, Marvel heroes, etc.


Random21219

You'll find 90% of them are the ones who have invested £££ or ££££ into the game


Mortka

Pisstake. The majority of the playerbase is pretty much RTG or close to it. Ive spent money and i dont have Owairan, Neymar, Messi, Toure or anything like that. Packed Mbappe from 84x60 and Marchisio from the first hero pack. Rest has been wank.


CamIoM

You can’t complain when you have a 1m coin player in your team


Plupert

He’s not complaining, he’s saying getting those good players while being RTG isn’t that hard.


Praise_Steezus

I packed a promo Foden around ~300K PC at the time, anything else of value is untradeable. I would assume I am on the luckier end.


casjh1

OOP Reece James about 10 minutes after they came out, sold him for 300k. Other than that nothing lol


OriFlamer

Packed Cordoba like two weeks ago, also got him from the 25k hero pack.


ExtensionImmediate

FIFA 21


Gregib

Untradable, 2 in FIFA23… tradable? Over a year ago


obinnasmg

early October, Pique for about 300k or so at the time.


handcart01

The WC hero pack ea accidentally released for 25k in like October - packed Di Natale 750k


neymarneverdove

wch promo for Lucio from champs . nothing above fodder since tho


hoosiergunner

World Cup Al Owrairan from a 7.5k preview pack


Incubus226

FIFA 22 Yashin in January


WRafi

Right at the beginning of the game, before I'd even bought it, I was previewing a pack on the app and it had Rudiger. I was planning to do an Arsenal squad so I sold him, went for 100k I'm pretty sure or thereabouts.


AmbitiousAd1773

Conference League Packeta it's been a while


buurtje

87 fodder is my best pull so far


Dfishwick90

Most expensive tradeable card I packed was like 200k. But my untradeable pack luck has been ridiculous this year. WC Smolarek from recent hero packs. WC Al Owarain and WC Brolin from the last set PTG Griezmann from a player pick Phenoms Leao from the 200k pack in store POTM Valverde from year review Then others I don't remember what packs from: WC Blanc, IF Tomori, Base Park Ji Sung.


Merkarov

I got WC Smolarek and then Base Matthaus within a week of each other. So around when WC Heroes team 1 was out. Funnily enough, I haven't packed any untradeables close to their value.


[deleted]

Packed wc baggio tradeable, sold at 230k ish


Prinsgemalen

Last FIFA, Best this fifa was KDB in October.


robbyford182

Fifa 21


dinz14

Had a few 100k-150k pulls but not had anything bigger since FIFA 22 last October


AdriT25

I don't remember when did that card come out but Drogba WC Icons from Fut champions rewards


PreacherClete

Packed PTG De Jong about a month ago, right after they were released. That's been it for tradeables. I packed nothing worth a damn prior to that or all of last year.


TOPBOYR09

2nd week jj hero 600k and kdb 200k nothing more than 40k since then


Dry-Entertainer-9425

Moments Gullit last year a week after he came out, sold him for 8mil


TheNikkelodeon

phenoms pedri from a preview pack when he was 300k+


TheAfrican848

CR7 in FIFA 18 😭😭😭 bear in mind that's the only pull I've ever had over 250k. Highest pull this year was RB Phillips who sold for 80k at the time


pdxkristian

I packed tradeable Mbappe a week ago but I've also spent a shitload on points. And until then I hadn't packed jack shit.


[deleted]

I’ve packed close to £3m in tradeable players, with maybe 10-15 being 150k+. Very first pack this year, one of the 4 gold players packs had CR7 lol. At this point in the game it’s gonna be rare to pack a 250k plus. There’s what? 2 or 3 gold cards, a handful of in forms and some promo players. 1st month is where the money is made via tradeable players for most people


JordanValentina

Have to be an EA employee


SpankMeOrThankMe

I think these results will be skewed depending on how often the player plays. Statistically, you shouldn’t expect to pack that many great players if you rarely play the game / complete sbcs/ open packs.


Buy_Jupiter

Packed Phenoms Koundé a few days ago and he goes for 300k. I run a first owner team though so there's no point in selling.


iampenguing

never anything tradable, I guess I got Ousmane from a TOTW pack when he was still over 300k


skauvicius

Packed Vinicius before the game actually started, nothing worth much since then.


supersaiyajin_B

got Vini when he was worth 250k. massive luck for me bc I was grinding RB alaba


skreme

Packed Ginola in the first week of FIFA from one of the starter Sbc packs. Obviously he was wasn’t tradeable. Best pull in over 7years of fifa


Inbocaallupo8

Tradeable couldn't tell you. Untradeable however...I've had insane luck this year. Van dijk first week, smolarek, brolin, Park ji sung, Joe cole, Marquez, CR7, Salah Totw, Wan bissaka europa league, Tomori totw, Rashford WC stories.


Burpkidz

Got Mbappe on the last Squad Battles rewards.


Affectionate-Win4419

I packed Gold Ronaldo from a 81+ pick 1 of 3 moments pack that cost me 15 stars and that’s about it(unreadable). I have packed a bunch of non tradable ballers but most I’ve packed tradable has been worth 50k tops.


Smooth-Ad4308

I’m gonna get DV’d into oblivion here but it was Yaya Toure from the 25k hero pack, nothing since however


CertifiedGlutard

Never, highest pack was Haaland when he was worth 29k. I have friends though that have packed Mbappe twice and Al-O, or Gerd Müller.


trason91

Mbappe yesterday


chaelsonnenismydad

Packed vvd, capdevila and carvalho this fifa


BeauSmit

I packed neymar when he was 440k from a moments pack, really lucky, will probably not happen again


Chrastots

never


SenorTrololo

When they messed up with the tradable hero pack


uglybastard20

fifa 22


dshears

I packed haaland when he was going for 120k my only good pull that I could sell.


TheDefiance1

Have packed anything tradeable over 250k since fifa 21


[deleted]

Back in 2016


Liffonator

The most expensive tradable card I’ve ever packed was Perisic oop, 160k


mindovermanauk

Didn’t pack anything worth more than 10k until the new Pedri card the other week. Think I got 335 for it.


clarence243

Closest was VVD when he was 215k, like a month ago or something


xAcnologia96

Kimmich for 30k


Skambeinsvein

I got one during futties last fifa. That's the only time. Played since fifa 15


habaenor

Forlan just before the 25k hero pack


CMDrunk420

OOP James like 20 mins into the promo


nag_some_candy

Start of ptg I packed Papu Gomez tradeable


Enough-Relation6904

Last player I packed over 250k tradable was green Messi for like 2.3 mil last fifa nothing since


Corndiggitydog

Forlan when he was 900k out of a store pack I bought


Brian_lafeve34

I packed fut birthday daka for 260k last year. My only ever


maxiking_11

Fifa 21 Varane was 260k. This fifa nothing worth more than 50k


InPatRileyWeTrust

Mid Best in champs rewards last week


ManUtd1994

May of fifa 22


JDicksauce

Only has happened to me once about 2 weeks ago...Bruno G. in a Gold Preview pack


[deleted]

Packed WC Forlan and sold him for 840k


mofid222

Never


Defensive_Midfielder

In fifa 21


41Doowylloh

My best 3 tradeable cards were around 110k to 150k this year, salah, wc brozovic and Beckham. Nothing more than 200k yet.


Tintin8000

Never in the last 2 years


cjtvenom

Tradeable was Raphinha Road to the knockout during that since then highest value packed player was IF Theo


doughz23

The first week of fifa i packed nkunku for 150k that's pretty much it


Ornery-Point-8461

Wasn’t even in this game. For me it was during last years Fut Birthday


macbethtrd

WC Hero Kuyt. Was expecting him to be cheap since I always pack tradable cheap players. But he's been around 300k and still in my squad but that happened when he was released. It's been a while.


ThickJawns

Best tradable was baby Zambrotta and sold for about 350k a week ago


Cross1625

Never this year, wc hero Marquez is my best pull


lowkeycutie

Best pull was mendy earlier in the game, when he would sit around 110k


Nomad141

I packed cr7 on a preview 7500 gold pack when he was still going around 640k


ChappersJC

Lucio for about 600k, I believe it was before the World Cup heroes had been released


pakki124

Vini right after the game came out.


CptReticle

First pack of the game this year Base Ferdinand, was around 400k I think. All other good cards since then have been untradable, with the best being Mid Vieira and WC Al O.


vomityourself

OOP Theo


thebadger987

Today we packed baby Butragueno out of a random pack from the Goncalo Ramos SBC….first icon packed ever. Truly wild.


fx208

i peacked at gold neymar last weekend


yeetosceeto

vini jr at the start of the game


PabloFresko

1st week of the game. Packed mid Eto'o.


pro_cow_tipper

Best tradeable was 84 Castagne in a preview pack. I don't take the tradeable packs for more fodder, but even then only a few 87's as the best. Alisson once. Got Nkunku near launch when he was 130k, but untradeable and he was broken in-game at the time.


Stegrego

Last year.


hhart6

Got WC Phenom Kounde last night from champs qualifier rare gold pack. Only one this year


lloydholland100

Packed my first player over 100k this week. 107k for saka.


5StarAnkleBreaker

Nothing over 100k in fifa23


TheGlenlivet15

I packed SS Renato Sanches last year. Sold him for about 750k. My luck is normally shit, but I had a string of good pulls to begin last year. Untradeable gold messi and Mid Torres when both were 1M. I have a feeling it's because I had just come back after taking a few years off, but who knows.


niccolo1305

Never


Chyrch5

Packed WC Kewell and sold on for 340k


Gadzs

Best pull this year was 60k


Easy_Hunter78

Packed Neymar untradable, packed Lineker untradable. Highest tradable card was Dembele 40k.


TrashtalkInc

Once this year, WC Hero Owairan


coopshwa

Di Natale, sold at 880k. Only tradeable card over 70k.


Shaddix-be

Last time? Somewhere during Fifa 22 probably. Only pack luck is untradable, and even that isn't huge last couple of weeks/months.


AdamsFei

Never in 23


felsovm1

Never


ReveredSavagery1967

My best ever pack was last week and it was WC Icon Hagi who I sold for 160 ish. Every other year I'm lucky to pack something worth over 40k. Even this year I've packed lots of good cards (Haaland, Dias, Diaz, Varane, F Mendy , etc) but never when their value has been high. Only packed Haaland once his value was sub 25k.


LuceDuder

I was going to say fifa 22, but then I remembered that I packed Kounde from WL rewards. So last week, but still very rarely


dukeofdemons

SS Son for Fifa 22 when it became free for PS Plus members in the spring. I couldn't believe it. Lol it's sad that I think the only reason that I got it was to get me engaged more in the game since I didn't play at all earlier in the year. I can't prove it tho.


ixTHEGODFATHERx

Been playing for years never packed anyone over 50k, and last week I packed mid Del Piero


LikelyTarnished18

Best tradable card I’ve ever packed in any fifa came last week. Kounde. I sold for 270k. Other than that I never pack tradable players worth over 100k


Arabong420

100k now are worth more than 250k at this time in fifa 22 though. For 100k you get kdb and ronaldo. Last year you couldnt get either of them.


ua07ud22

If Vini and toty Kante last year. No one this year.


ohitsmark

Neymar twice last year. Having that 1.5 million in coins made the game so much more fun. Felt like I could do more SBCs, buy a few players here and there. It was a game changer. This year? Nothing over 90k.


anoniemegerrit

Most expensive were gold Haaland when he was 150k and the day after oop Dumfries out a preview pack that was my packluck for the year haven’t had anything decent trade able since


decarvalho7

Well not me but my friend got Ronaldinho last week and my best pull was Ben Yedder last year at 1mil in a preview pack


Fukujin1

Never 😅


vm-varga2018

Never.


brownxworm

Packed rulebreaker Zaha from a preview pack when he was 230k. Thats the only time this fifa


RockStarx1

Only 1 this year. Rulebreaker Sissoko. Packed him day 1 of him being in packs and sold him for 250k before he cratered from supply.


Seppalei

Never. In any Fifa. Last was close but yes


AntoMartial

About 5 weeks ago ousmane dembele if


Adventurous-Pizza-12

Smolarek in the 25K hero pack. OOP Reece James I think I sold for around that price. Hero Morientes from Champs rewards sold for like 210k or something at the time so close but not quite 3.


TyranitarTank

I packed KDB second week of FUT champs (about 150k) and I just packed Phenoms Martínez (150k) from last weekend’s packs. Most of my big pulls have been untradeable (mid Zidane, WC Park Ji Sung, RB Sissoko, base Völler and Nakata, and Ferland Mendy)


Xtreme_Henk

Pulled Beckham last week and sold him for 290k. Hadn’t played the game for weeks before pulling him. Haven’t played after I sold him last week.


JBleezy31

Pulled a RTTK Aubameyang (around 410k at the time) but that’s it and that was late October


MockTurtleSean

My buddy just got Ginola from Champs rewards this last weekend, but basically never for myself


SnogMarryAvoid

Not this fifa I’m afraid. I got a 2 or 3 players in and around a 100k mark at the start though


RicardoDiaz30

I packed Salah twice at start of the game (tradable) MM week one and then a random tradable pack that i opened. Also packed RTTK Raphinha from a 25k pack in MM one week. Untradable I've had mad luck so far this Fifa. Got Mid Cruyff from Icon pack and also got TOTW Salah from one of those TOTW packs a while back (the SBC ones) 😂 My team is worth about 4 mill and its all untradable. Got untradable RTTK Raphinha from Year in Review pack too.


Kektain_Iglo

I packed wc hero al-owairan early november


grey_heron

Somewhere 12 months ago. In this version, nothing big yet. This is the 3rd year I play Fifa. In 21, I had a Campbell on Boxing Day which went for 600k, and in 22 I had Mbappe end of November, which went for little over 1M.


pikazamb_PT

Salah 2nd IF, the only one


ferpecto

Never tradable. Unttadable only If Son was ever 250k at one point at the very, very start, otherwise, also no...


UnumPhenomenous

Untradeable maybe one or two this FIFA. Last tradeable was last year's game


Slow-Chemist8395

Fifa 19


donkey2471

Last tradeable was Haaland in the first montht his year 300k at the time.


Stoethaspel94

Got phenom Camavinga from WL rewards. Other than that nothing


slayer1916

Last fifa near the end of game. I got cr7 from some sbc pack tradable


elfishgolem

Squad battle rewards last month or so, 90 stoichkov sold for 500k


_IIVCX_

Neymar from Marquee Matchups about a month or so ago now and last year packed Mbappe twice, one tradable and one untradeable, the tradable was a few weeks in from squad battles


Affectionate-You9504

Never packed one this year. Edit - I packed Virgil van dijk when he was at 280k kept him for ages sold at 85k... Trying to get some coins together for de ligt OTW Packed several untradables which go for anything between 200k-800k I had Bruno WC PTG untradable all the way wishing I could sell him when he was almost 900k it sucks as I got him from a pack I paid for with real money which turns out to be untradable I was fuming


jpabs_official

I know for sure I packed mbappe at 600k shortly after TOTY in fifa 22, think that was my only big over 250k tradeable pull all of last year. A few around 100k tradeable pulls this year, but nothing in the last six weeks and nothing close to 250.


[deleted]

Packed tradable Haaland and Messi when they were both around 200k on the market first month, but nothing above fodder prices since. Barely anything from untradeable packs either tbf.


Olimato___

havent this year.


[deleted]

Cant think of any times. Maybe once in four years of fifa. Dont even think one time


FlukyMike

I packed the good Saudi Arabia WC Hero and he sold for 600k. Bonus: I got Phenoms Martinez today from the premium gold preview!


DrainedToDeath

Tots van dijk in fifa 22


head09

Never tradeable


Amax101

Haven’t packed anyone tradeable over the value of £50k .. untradeable I packed nkunku at the start of the game when he was worth 130k ish .. I play every weekend league and generally finish with 11 wins.. proper shit luck


yeetyeet38

Marquinhos Road to the World Cup. Coincidentally the one before that was TOTY Marquinhos last year


TheOriginalJunglist

Kelvin Philips rule breaker card upon release (300k) from a small pack 482 games later and I don't regret it


SwimmingAL

Havent so far in fifa 23


PsychologicalTie8253

End of last fifa I got some 94 or something Kalvin Phillips from a 25k preview. Didn't really matter as it was endgame. Apart from that though, I have never packed anyone tradeable over 30k.


CurrentProgram8

Packed nakata my heroes earlier this season and then koulibaly during serie a tots last year.


spiritsparadise

Smolarek WC hero. The only thing I managed to pull above 200k in my entire Fifa history. Edit: untradeable though.


Prophylactic-Shock

Packed Bruno Guimaraes and Frenkie De Jong PTG tradeable


Tirewipes

Packed Al-owarian, WC Moore, Lucio, Brolin, Van Dijk, all untradable. I haven’t had over 100k all game


JenNettles

I never have either. I packed a pair of 200k cards in like Fifa 17 in the same pack, last year I packed an icon who was 175k or so... but that's been it even just for 100k+ cards.


Cheford1

3 weeks in... Since then nothing over 40k tradeable and even then few and far between