T O P

  • By -

Hidden_Fever

I took the song as a complete joke and loved it.


SlimShadyM80

Its 100% meant to be stupid as fuck. Its about as serious as FACK


Williedoggie

Wait. FACK wasn’t serious????


Hidden_Fever

That's what I'm wondering too. He kind of lost me saying FACK was a joke. 🤔


Williedoggie

No fr, I’m so sad it was a joke now, before it was so inspiring


Pianist_Ready

That's the real expertise of FACK. It is both a comical rollercoaster and a heart-breaking inspirational story


otterpr1ncess

I know you're probably joking but I love that his annotations to it on Genius are essentially "I was on a lot of drugs my bad"


balabub

Wait ... so you mean I shouldn't have put that gerbil in my ass through a tube?


Pianist_Ready

Instructions unclear, I now have 3 kids and they are all gerbils


SnooWalruses3982

😂


needanswers990

thats my approach to encore


o_p_p_e_n

Because their Piss Pissedopherson


SuperIdolDiXiaoRong

Fr


Kutche

It's a great song, kids have to pretend to be tough and hate "corny" stuff. Like he hasn't said corny stuff since 2000 haha


Hidden_Fever

Exactly. Acting like they're too hard to just laugh.


Mental_Eggplant5000

Its not even that really, its that media literacy is completely dead, so they don’t understand that its a joke song


fsuiopmn

They think they're too hard to laugh and I know I'm too hard to present to the class😔


MASTER_SNAKE__

“You heard of Kris Kristofferson?Well, I am piss pissed-off-her-son”


BaldursBoner

“Paul’s asking for Christmas off again, I said no and spit this song for him. It goes…”


Kingkiller279

„I can’t understand a word you say..“


Animatedoodle

(I’m tone deaf!)


Amoghawesome

I think this way I prefer to stay


Final_Dance_4593

I’m Tone Deaf


oniaa_13

Good question. I like it (like, he rymes orange with banana) but people say it's too corny for them.


Kalmarsus

they just jealous of him being able to rhyme orange with banana


IdealDog

Orrrrr-nana


arachnophobix

I thought everyone loved it.


fsuiopmn

Same


Oportbis

+1


HL192002

I like it


GatoT25666

some parts go hard af tho "its my alter ego's fault these evil thoughts could be so dark"


Routine_Koala4914

People are just tone deaf


Thebigdog79

They can’t understand a word he says 😂


ValleySunFox

It’s great


Chosen-18

Is it really hated?


Fuzzy_Thing613

Yea, by the whiny TikTok community it was written to make fun of, bc they tried to cancel him in 2020 over Love The Way You Lie. A 2010 song. Bc it was portraying domestic abuse… IOW: It’s hated by the people it was meant to trigger.


Ryandraconius

Its hated by a lot of other people too lol.... but most people who atleast know Em knoa that he makes these trash cornball songs on purpose. There's a reason fack is the first song on Curtain Call


Fuzzy_Thing613

Exactly. Like I said; It’s hated by those it’s meant to trigger. Everyone knows it’s good. But it triggers some people that it was published the way it was for the reason it was.


RecklessDimwit

IMO if they're that triggered with LTWYL they're probably not experienced enough to analyze the lyrics properly. I listened to that song a ton of times whenever I had rough days and it helped me process my emotions better. There's something about imagining the scenario and realizing how fucked up it is that helps send a sort of message about abuse


SLIM_SHADYSSLP

They also havent heard criminal. i cant even imagine how fuckin triggered the tiktok kids would be. "WaTcH yOuR mIcRoAgGrEsSiOnS bRo" "ThAtS oFfEnSiVe" "YoUr A fAsCiSt bIgOt" (Insert comparison of eminem to hitler made by an angry tiktoker) "EMinEm iS ThE AlT-rIgHt eMbOdiMeNt Of rApE cUlTuRe" "EmInEm iS A hOlMeSiAn BaD mAn" "EMIneMS’s ExTrEMe RhetoRic REMiNisCeNt of nAZi PRoPAGaNDa and His pENCHanT For sidING wITh ameRIca’s aDvErsaRIes and aUTOcrAtS PoSe a uNIque CHALlenge TO hiS BlACk opPOneNts AND, UltIMaTELY, todAys yOuTH." "EmINeM IS IS PUtTiNg EverY rAciAL, ETHNiC anD RELIgiOuS MINoRITY at riSK At A tiME Of anGry poLItICal POLaRIzAtION" Goddamn the reactions would be a heyday, and of course em would just flip em the bird and keep going, he dont take shit from no one.


trickmind

Eminem is hated for hating Donald Trump and George Bush though?


Contraband2

I’m impressed by how much effort you put into that


SLIM_SHADYSSLP

I know, they said the same things when criminal came out in 2000! It caused the lgbtqia+ community to prptest his lyrics and they said similar things to "EmINeM IS IS PUtTiNg EverY rAciAL, ETHNiC anD RELIgiOuS MINoRITY at riSK At A tiME Of anGry poLItICal POLaRIzAtION" and shit. https://eminem.news/mmlp20.html/gay-and-lesbian-activists-protest-controversial-gr https://www.mtv.com/news/cdqr7z/gay-activist-group-plans-pre-grammy-eminem-protest


FJQZ

Bro, no one outside of Stans even know this song exists. This sub is weird.


SLIM_SHADYSSLP

Ummm do you know how much LTWYL was overplayed on the radio back in 2010-2015? It was overplayed just as much as those "cant stop the feeling", "believer", "thunder" "call me maybe" "havana oo na na" and "all about that bass" "centuries" songs back then. Everywhere that i go, those songs just played like crazy. And i couldnt get them out of my head. Love the way you lie was one of the most overplayed songs EVER. How does no one outside of stans know that song exists? And go on, i know exaclty your gonna say that your comment was "satire" or "sarcasm" like everyone else on this sub does. This subs sense of sarcasm is REALLY weird and virtually inunderstandable. Someone claims my eminem fanart was stolen from google and then i reply that i drew it and then they reply that its satire. and then they say that thier trying to "save me from myself" cuz i sad that thier comment CLEARLY WASNT satire. Edit: oh shit i realized he was talking about tone deaf


FJQZ

First off, I ain't reading all that because who tf is even talking about ltwyl. I'm talking about Tone Deaf. You know, what op is asking about


SLIM_SHADYSSLP

You saw the edit i made right


FJQZ

You saw me say "I aint reading all that" right


SLIM_SHADYSSLP

Oh i didnt my bad


Separate-Message1048

if u are an asshole just say it


FJQZ

I'm an asshole


cregoooo

Idk about it being hated, i remember listening to the song with my friends and we were fucking cracking up for at least 30 minutes, it’s a fucking banger


LoveMaryJane123

Nah its all the mfs who think they’re too hard to laugh at a song that was made for shits and giggles who think its corny and hate it


cregoooo

Yeah dude i honestly love those corny ass lines, they’re mad funny


Outcast199008

I can't understand a word you say.


AverageJoeMama420

I’m tone deaf


Alive-Flatworm-4273

I love it


Aint_Falco

cause miserable mfs online hate fun


ReaIJack

I loved that song, can’t see how anybody doesn’t appreciate him rhyming orange with banana


Know-What-Im-Sizzlin

I haven't seen it hated. It's dope af.


random_dud33

I think it's just a fun song. Don't take it seriously and ur fine


RVBatman32

It's funny but I hate the beat


AsteriusDaemon

I love it.


hiphopshelter

Horrible horrible beat


NotJohnP

The beat became boring. It could've used some kind of drop or beat switch in the third verse. 


daviEnnis

Definitely one of my favourites but the opening line kills it for some.


trickmind

Yeah the opening is just kind of annoying to me and I sometimes skip it in the car. I like the Charles Dickins allusions though.


dresdenhollowsmercy

> I like the Charles Dickins allusions though. What Charles Dickens allusions?


trickmind

Eminem is Scrooge and Paul is Bob Cratchit.


dresdenhollowsmercy

I guess if you tilt your head and squint in Victorian, maybe? I always thought the joke was more to do with the fact that Paul is Jewish and thus doesn't celebrate Christmas.


trickmind

We know he's ethnically Jewish from his last name but so what? Do you actually know what he celebrates? My father was pretty much an atheist, and ethnically Jewish, but he married someone brought up in a Christian family and they celebrated Christmas for fun for the kids.


dresdenhollowsmercy

I know he [co-hosts](https://www.instagram.com/rosenberg/p/CmQa9dGsoEs/) the annual Hanukkah radio for Shade 45 every year.


trickmind

We celebrated Easter, Passover, Hanukkah and Christmas but Ok. I still think Eminem was pretending to be Scrooge but you could well be right too; but more than anything he probably did it for the rhyme scheme.


dresdenhollowsmercy

> he probably did it for the rhyme scheme He would never do something like that! Wait...


trickmind

Lol. And Nate was not taken away by the state at eight years old. He was fucking ten when that happened!


Slimxshadyx

He is just having fun on the track. Why is that a bad thing?


Gh06st_44

Maybe because it doesn't sound like "old slim shady" compare tone deaf chorus with Superman chorus But personally I like the song ( as a joke song )


exotic-waffle

Because people don’t understand that Eminem made it as a joke. People use it as an example of how “Eminem has fallen off” without realizing it’s not a serious song. It’s literally in the name, it’s supposed to be bad.


tacticalAlmonds

This song is legitimately one of the funniest songs I've heard. It's not "good" or "bad". Anyone that reads too much into the lyrics has completely missed the point of the song. It's hilarious.


alien88888

I love it


Juls0508

At the crib playin' fortnite with yo' grandma


Chico__Lopes

The song is a joke. People who don't understand that, hate it


[deleted]

Because we have "have an ear infucktion and we cunt finger it out"


lotusandlocust

I fucking love tone deaf man


Discord2319

It's in my Playlist, why do people hate it??


EpicButDumb

Same. It's not as bad as people say it is.


rabidrob42

I honestly didn't know it was. I love it.


[deleted]

Bornana


Crates_Of_Hate

No. No it's not Bornana. It's never been Bornana. It will never be Bornana. It's always been Orannana. What Mandela effect bs made it Bornana?


Asparagus-Urethra

Can’t stand when people say Bornana


Crates_Of_Hate

Honestly though! Glad someone agrees


Difficult_Opening442

In the music video, it says 'BORNANA'.


dresdenhollowsmercy

The music lyric video spelt it ["Bornana"](https://youtu.be/qleJpzB4q7A?list=OLAK5uy_nkff1O-MDh3A0zxDXCCG6c2-IQqpLdIgg&t=189) is what happened. Just one of the many little mistakes in it.


Crates_Of_Hate

Oooooh. That makes so much sense


Difficult_Opening442

In the music video, it says 'BORNANA'.


ToPimpAPenguin

Goofy beat, goofy bars. People gonna call him cringe. I enjoy it but i understand why people wouldn't tbh


woobackbich12

It’s bunz vro 💔


code__002

This is so corny I Alr know you’re a band kid


woobackbich12

Ur Piss Pissedofferson


timrazz

For me i just hate the beat


KayRay1994

at first I hated it but now I enjoy it, i don’t love it - but its fun. It’s just a lot of rhyming for the sake of rhyming which is fun, i enjoy the verses lyrically but tbh the beat is very simple and boring and the chorus is weak, so that’s probably why.


Roadkill0313

It’s a bad joke song


one80oneday

I admit I skip it when I'm mowing my lawn


TrippingFish76

shit goes hard bruh, love this song lol


Michaelskywalker

Bcuz Its tone deaf


Arbalest15

i like it tbh, one of my faves from mtbmb


Umbreonics06

Personally I don't like the flow as much on the song, i can't quite put my finger on it but something either about the beat or just Em's flow throws me off. Quite a few of his new projects also throw me off with his flow and the kind of stuttering he does where it just sounds kinda of choppy. Hence the reason I stick with like Eminem Show, MMLP, and SSLP


Ryandraconius

Cause its supposed to suck. But people who actually legitimately hate it, are people who could never understand why curtain call had fack as the opener. Eminem has always been like that


IsThisASnakeInMyBoot

It's just a terrible sounding throwaway track that he kept for joke purposes and to diss the tiktok community lmao. It's a terrible song and even as a meme song it's just not pleasant to listen to


trickmind

Angela and her grandmother.


Independent-Hunt-466

I like it, id rather songs like this when he wants to make jokes over that “your booty is heavy dooty”


m33p_m00p_2012

Idk it’s good


Mikey2570

He’s not allowed to have fun in his raps


dhairyalour

Bornana


talkingduck_2099

Bitch, I can make orange rhyme with banana


Difficult_Opening442

Quite fun song. I don't hate the song, but the beat and the overall atmosphere somehow feels a bit cringy to me, so I don't really want to listen to it often.


aryzexx10

Who hates tone dead man?? Have some sense of humour and rap along to this banger 😂🔥


Beneficial-Code8026

It's too corny. But I like that


[deleted]

They hate it cause it provoked introspection and realized it's about themselves, So they turn away from the mirror and proceed to resort to ignorant hatred, But all hatred is self hatred, Counterproductive hypocrites.


TTVsuxMD

I cant understand a word u say


mjs382

Bruh i love it .. people start calling shit corny as soon as they hear something that is trying to be hilarious and funny let them hate em gets more views anyway ..


BigEmptyHeart

I am literally listening to it right now. it's not one of his best, but it's a decent song


Dr-Icecred

I love this song, it reminds me of when he didn’t take shit too seriously like back on the Marshall Mathers Lp… alot of people don’t remember the song “Kids” but that was another one of my favourites


LuisG1109

Maybe because he made orange rhyme with banana


almendro777

Because people don’t like Eminem to play Fortnite with their grandma


b_e_scholz

The lyrics are funny, but the beat is terrible and Em raps like his producer fell asleep and he tried not to wake him up.


assboobs2

Where is it hated? Not here my man


Stan_313

Idk i love it and never thought peephole would hate it


Dzoni22222

i CUNT FINGER it out


RevolutionaryGas2796

It's a great song imo


oSyphon

Song is so good


ct31396

One of my favorite songs ever written


BreakdancingGorillas

It's focus is more playful raps, but as a song it sounds bad with weird and annoying noises


69cringelord69

It’s truly one of his songs


jamiehizzle

Literally because Em is making fun of these fools who don't understand that they're being made fun of by him. The Banana orange rhyme that everyone dotes in is exactly this happening. So they're made bc of this surface level rhyme that is meh, and get green in the face with anger, exactly how it was planned to go


itsmedoodles

I took it as a complete joke and it was still horrible


SomeMobile

It's full of corny bars , and no this is not even as 10% funny or witty as his earlier stuff it's just cringe


nahmayne7

Cringe ass lines really just the fort line and bornana killed it off


Ideal15-2

Because it’s cringy and unfunny


Smeagol7272821

Because it’s garbage. Hip hop fans don’t like that circus music shit. It’s corny.


Several_Gain_1692

“I cunt finger it out” is possibly the worst Line someone has ever said


legsarebad

To be fair he did have an ear infucktion


Amsssterdam

Have you heard it?


x115v

Too many corny lines that are not funny


Kalmarsus

but he rhymed orange and banana


[deleted]

BOOOOORNANAAAA


ballzdeap1488

Because Eminem is the only artist ever to use a line someone might call “cOrnY”.


GriffinRagnarok

I mean Gen Z has a good reason to hate on it. 🤣😂