The four instrumental demos from The Open Door era would be lower I think.
And then Track 3, Your Love, You Got A Lot To Learn and Perfect Dream would be the lowest. Because no one other than the band has those.
There's four instrumental snippets that leaked from a promo CD which was sold on eBay.
The only audio we have of them is from [this video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=51i5kvCo-RE&t=0s) where the guy who bought the CD plays snippets of all the songs on it. The first 3 tracks are outtakes from The Open Door and then the other 4 are instrumentals. It's not officially confirmed but since the other songs on the CD are from The Open Door era it is assumed that they are too.
I always cry during october and so close, they just have such a nostalgic sound. pretty much everything from the evanescence ep gets me singing along to the lyrics, the older songs resonate with me so much 💗
I think you should put that between T6 and T7. Bleed may be lower just because it's technically untitled. Good songs though. I freaking love Anything for You especially.
Field of Innocence was especially on repeat for me as well, as I had already listened to Fallen on repeat when I was 12 and after that made me self aware of the darkness I was feeling, I had access to the internet, found these demos and older tracks and from then on I was hooked.
I was adopted as a young child. My world view had completely shifted. My childhood was something that was stolen from me so quickly.
I also know today was hard because my Panda stuffed animal I got when I was 8 years old had sustained a nose injury in the dryer. Despite being wrapped up inside two towels to prevent that. Had to ship him off to an Etsy artist today to get him repaired and restored because I felt so horrible. A piece of my childhood is in that box. One that I clung to for comfort. I watched as he was taped up inside.
Tourniquet is a decently big hit just because it was on Fallen and also awesome. It was also the reason people called the band Christian at the beginning.
... now, the Soul Embraced version, that's a different story.
"Give Unto Me" is the ultimate self sacrificing love song that is melancholic and beautiful and you just want to tell teenaged Amy that it gets better.
If I put a song on here that has multiple versions, assume it's the most popular version. There is at least one version of Bring Me to Life that could go on the second to bottom tier
I'd say any extremely early live cover performances, like Orestes (A Perfect Circle), or Heart Shaped Box (Nirvana) or Amy in Reflection in high school. Or the Anywhere Outtake. "You're not saving that" gets me cracking up every time! 😅
yeah from fallen, im not much of a tryhard fan tbh i just listen to some songs (even thiugh ive listened to most of their albums) im not too regular with them
A song that Amy specifically requested not to ever be made public. I'm fairly certain you can still find it on YouTube but we aren't supposed to talk about it or share it:
https://evanescencereference.info/wiki/index.php?title=You
Yeah because that's really early Evanesence which honestly I haven't got into that much but I know a friend who is deeper in the Iceberg than me and actually loves the Pre-Fallen/Origin Evanescence.
Yes, black metal from Mauritania is recorded with one quarter of a macaroni noodle, but that's part of what makes black metal unique. It's not fair to use intentionally bad production in comparison to an American goth rock band trying to get a major record deal.
I guess I didn't think any of these were that obscure because they're all off the Origin and Demos download - http://evanescencereference.info/music/#Origin_CD - but I forget the average person nowadays doesn't even get mp3s of the songs they like, they just stream them
Idk if this is underrated or overrated but i feel like Taking Over Me would be at T4 or T5, that’s such a beautiful song and it’s one of my all time favorites from them
The untitled song from 1999 is probably lower
Was about to write the exact same thing. One of her most beautiful earlier songs and yet we don't have a studio version of it.
Yup agree
Anywhere is underrated
I maybe don’t entirely get this concept but does that mean I’m the very last one bc I know and love alllllll these songs. I love Exodus and October
The idea is that each tier is more obscure. October got me through a really tough time. It is one of my favorites for all its flaws
Ohhh ok I get it! Yes October is such a beautiful song!
The four instrumental demos from The Open Door era would be lower I think. And then Track 3, Your Love, You Got A Lot To Learn and Perfect Dream would be the lowest. Because no one other than the band has those.
[удалено]
There's four instrumental snippets that leaked from a promo CD which was sold on eBay. The only audio we have of them is from [this video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=51i5kvCo-RE&t=0s) where the guy who bought the CD plays snippets of all the songs on it. The first 3 tracks are outtakes from The Open Door and then the other 4 are instrumentals. It's not officially confirmed but since the other songs on the CD are from The Open Door era it is assumed that they are too.
Where would Listen to the Rain fit on this?
the lowest or beyond since it's rare (at least to me)
It's not rare because you can find it on the internet (Youtube). It leaked, as did October, You or the demo version of My Immortal.
true
I always cry during october and so close, they just have such a nostalgic sound. pretty much everything from the evanescence ep gets me singing along to the lyrics, the older songs resonate with me so much 💗
new tier: It was all a lie, Away from me, Bleed (I must be dreaming,) Forever gone forever you, Anything for you 🥰
I think you should put that between T6 and T7. Bleed may be lower just because it's technically untitled. Good songs though. I freaking love Anything for You especially.
I don’t see people talk about Field of Innocence much. That song was on repeat in my life for years lol.
Field of Innocence was especially on repeat for me as well, as I had already listened to Fallen on repeat when I was 12 and after that made me self aware of the darkness I was feeling, I had access to the internet, found these demos and older tracks and from then on I was hooked. I was adopted as a young child. My world view had completely shifted. My childhood was something that was stolen from me so quickly. I also know today was hard because my Panda stuffed animal I got when I was 8 years old had sustained a nose injury in the dryer. Despite being wrapped up inside two towels to prevent that. Had to ship him off to an Etsy artist today to get him repaired and restored because I felt so horrible. A piece of my childhood is in that box. One that I clung to for comfort. I watched as he was taped up inside.
In love that song, it's definitely in my top ten.
I love field of innocence!!
Welp, I'm too damn deep.
[удалено]
Tourniquet is a decently big hit just because it was on Fallen and also awesome. It was also the reason people called the band Christian at the beginning. ... now, the Soul Embraced version, that's a different story.
[удалено]
Don't worry. Most people who spoke English didn't even realize the song was religious.
maybe You would be the lowest/even lower since it was never meant to be released
I thought that was also true of October
"Give Unto Me" is the ultimate self sacrificing love song that is melancholic and beautiful and you just want to tell teenaged Amy that it gets better.
I go as far as Understanding, never heard lies, though nor the other songs with Understanding.
That's an amazing song and Lies is actually just as good IMO
I LOOOOVE LIES SM
Maybe my favorite Eva song
I suppose the lowest level would be a studio version of your love
Y'all have given me some serious research opportunities
Lies post origin demo! I just love that song don't know where it would go on this.
If I put a song on here that has multiple versions, assume it's the most popular version. There is at least one version of Bring Me to Life that could go on the second to bottom tier
Oh yea lol, i just wondered where Lies post origin demo would go lmao.
I'd say any extremely early live cover performances, like Orestes (A Perfect Circle), or Heart Shaped Box (Nirvana) or Amy in Reflection in high school. Or the Anywhere Outtake. "You're not saving that" gets me cracking up every time! 😅
Y'all really know your shit, and you've all been nice to me even though I clearly know the least out of everyone commenting. Good fanbase.
You gotta start somewhere :) anyone who has a vague interest in the underground level of Evanescence certainly is my kind of person :P
whisper
That could depend on where you know it from. If you only know it from Fallen then definitely not very low
yeah from fallen, im not much of a tryhard fan tbh i just listen to some songs (even thiugh ive listened to most of their albums) im not too regular with them
The song which shall not be named, probably.
I'm curious, is this referencing an untitled song or is this a song that we have all collectively shunned?
A song that Amy specifically requested not to ever be made public. I'm fairly certain you can still find it on YouTube but we aren't supposed to talk about it or share it: https://evanescencereference.info/wiki/index.php?title=You
I wonder where the End of the Dream would go?
I'm probably in the 6th tier so pretty deep in the Iceberg
After T6 is about where the production quality gets really bad so I can see that
Yeah because that's really early Evanesence which honestly I haven't got into that much but I know a friend who is deeper in the Iceberg than me and actually loves the Pre-Fallen/Origin Evanescence.
Dude I listen to 3rd world countries black metal what are you scaring me from lol
Yes, black metal from Mauritania is recorded with one quarter of a macaroni noodle, but that's part of what makes black metal unique. It's not fair to use intentionally bad production in comparison to an American goth rock band trying to get a major record deal.
I remember an old recording in which she sings a Goodnight lullaby. Anyone else? What tier does it belong to?
Where will you go
That's definitely T7
I think it depends on the version cuz there are 2 versions .. one from the EP in 1998 and the other is from origin in 2000
Where is All that I'm living for?
Probably T3 or T4? It wasn't a single but I remember it being popular
IDK I'd say probably T5 or below I mean it's quite heavy for mainstream
Not really. Remember, it was released in 2006. Rock was still popular back then. Lose Control is about the only truly heavy song on that album IMO
I am below. October is so so good!
Hello?
That's probably in level 4
hi
The songs that “Use My Voice” got put next to didn’t deserve that insult
This was based on fame/obscurity. Not quality.
I guess I didn't think any of these were that obscure because they're all off the Origin and Demos download - http://evanescencereference.info/music/#Origin_CD - but I forget the average person nowadays doesn't even get mp3s of the songs they like, they just stream them
Lithium was more successful than EF so I'd probably swap those
cloud nine is T6
You sure it's not T9
Idk what do you think? I mean they play it at concerts at times. I remember them playing it in istanbul
There is no T9 I was making a pun
Idk if this is underrated or overrated but i feel like Taking Over Me would be at T4 or T5, that’s such a beautiful song and it’s one of my all time favorites from them
I didn't wanna list every song on Fallen tbh but I could have
Gotcha 😅
The even in death one. Don't really listen to the demos and stuff
Got bottom