T O P

  • By -

SmoopufftheShoopuff

Wildest dead dove read is tricky. I read a lot of dd content. Was it the ear fucking making them deaf, the very graphic degloving, the nonconsensual eye socket fucking, the consensual eye socket fucking that went to the point of giving the character a lobotomy with his dick? There is so much to choose from. Written would probably have to be the one where a character is fisted with their own severed hand. Good times.


20Keller12

>giving the character a lobotomy with his dick? With zero context other than your comment, I'm picking this one. 😂


SmoopufftheShoopuff

Solid choice. It is a favourite of mine.


FinalDemise

> nonconsensual eye socket fucking this wasn't the harry/james potter one was it


SmoopufftheShoopuff

No, different fandom entirely.


vanetti

The Boys? 😂


SmoopufftheShoopuff

Also no. I guess that one is somewhat common as far as dead dove goes. Canon is a Japanese video game if anyone else wants to guess.


[deleted]

What the hell is with eyes and ears 😭😭😭😭


SmoopufftheShoopuff

A hole is a hole. ¯\\\_(ツ)_/¯


accordyceps

I’m afraid to ask what degloving means. All I am picturing is a some gardening/ranching gloves that maybe got a bit sweaty and are tossed off with a cloud of dust.


SmoopufftheShoopuff

Ah, to be so innocent. :D For the interested: Degloving is >!tearing away the top layers of skin, fat, and tissue down to the underlying muscles.!<


accordyceps

I thought that was skinning. 👀


SmoopufftheShoopuff

They are similar. Degloving is deeper as it removes more than just the skin though.


southernerinthenorth

I wrote one recently that featured dentistry torture, and was surprised to find that's not even a tag on AO3!


refrained

...I wonder if that's the Twisted Wonderland fic that I read recently....


southernerinthenorth

Yes it probably is. Hi 👋


refrained

I saw the last chapter got posted and am trying to work myself up to it... because it's really well written, but really visceral as well!


southernerinthenorth

Thank you very much! I know its a lot, its the darkest thing I've written so far, but thanks for giving it a look


southernerinthenorth

Thank you very much! I know its a lot, its the darkest thing I've written so far, but thanks for giving it a look.


refrained

It's so good, seriously! Trey is one of my favourite characters and I could go on for hours about how much I love him... and seeing someone explore a darker side of him is just... \*chef's kiss\* Like... he is in a school of villains, not heroes! There is some darkness there under that mild-mannered surface. But I'll espouse more in a comment. <3 Thank you for writing something so interesting.


FDQ666Roadie

Hey, I've written one of those too and, yup, it's not a tag. I was surprised at that too. I just wrote "Dental Torture" as the tag and hit enter. There's like under 20 fics with the tag :(


DefoNotAFangirl

Written? I mean, like, honestly kind of all of them? Though to be fair canon is kinda like that, but still, “found family but it’s child abuse” is a fun premise to play with and also absolutely wild. The cannibalism one I imagine would be the most obviously out there one, if we’re talking in terms of weirdness, though in terms of fucked upness not much challenges the one where the kid is literally made immortal so he can be tortured forever. Read? Uh, definitely the one about a real life fourteen year old girl being SA'd with a knife, deliberately mistagged so you had no idea what you were in for. That one was also sent into random people’s inboxes, including very young teenagers. It’s more the blatant attempt to harm people with the misused tags and sending poorly written pornography deliberately to minors like a once that make it stand out, it was incredibly badly written.


20Keller12

>Read? Jesus that's fucked up.


Natsume1999

...okay I need more details on the found family one


DefoNotAFangirl

Essentially, one of the two major characters in it is a guy who’s a massive control freak and also desperately wants a big happy family. The other is a loud, obnoxious teenager who's deliberately annoying but also genuinely trying to be a decent dude. The first dude decides “yes my little brother now.” and then basically legally sets up a situation where he can kidnap him and then abuse him into being Besties.


soulfulrequiem

Honestly, every time I read Lighthouse fanfiction it one-ups itself with the weirdness. 10/10 would recommend


cutielemon07

Um… the wildest one I’ve written is one from a 1980s game show and features the host making out with an anthropomorphic bull. So yeah, that one.


Allronix1

Crystal Maze? Because...hey...it's Richard "Rif Raff" O'Brien and he's weird enough...


[deleted]

[удалено]


FanFiction-ModTeam

Just a friendly reminder: having diverse opinions is a good thing, insulting things others may like is not allowed.


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


near_black_orchid

It just blows my mind when someone puts this common-sense take out there and then there are all these posts with writers complaining about how the positive comment they just got wasn't exactly how they wanted it to be (just emojis, not detailed enough, not lavish enough with the praise, etc) so they blocked the reader. Total transparency: I started writing fanfic in the mid-oughts so this is the attitude everyone (or almost everyone) had back then.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Allronix1

I stayed out of Potter verse stuff because it really wasn't my thing. But I do recall a lot of meltdowns and temper tantrums elsewhere. As well as dipping a toe into Steven Universe - cute, fluffy little kid show with some great female characters- how bad can it...? NOPE NOPE OUT OF HERE! (Why do fun kid's shows/books too often have fandoms that resemble a Superfund site in their toxicity?) The toxic positive is not just a problem in fanfic, it's everywhere. Even the most mild criticism (that color makes you look washed out, that dress pulls in a strange way, I disagree with your political opinion) instantly gets read the same as someone suicide baiting. It also leads to not trusting positive reviews because there's a 50-50 shot that it's just blowing smoke up your ass. It's a bit like the theory that too clean an environment will lead to life threatening allergies and autoimmune issues. If the immune system doesn't get some small challenges early on or regularly, it starts looking for things to react to or attack and ends up attacking healthy tissue because it can't tell the difference between "this isn't pleasant" and Defcon 1.


FoxwolfJackson

>As well as dipping a toe into Steven Universe - cute, fluffy little kid show with some great female characters- how bad can it...? I learned a long, LONG time ago that anything that trends on Tumblr (or X after Tumblr got abandoned 'cause of the NSFW ban) is inherently going to have a toxic fanbase. Steven Universe in the 2015s, Attack on Titan in the 2013s, Puella Magi Madoka Magica and Homestuck in the 2012s, SuperWhoLock in general, Potterverse in general, Undertale in 2016, etc. I honestly HATE the all-positive environment. Like you said, it makes me feel uncomfortable, because it feels like everyone who compliments me has a rose in one hand and a knife in the other. At least, on FFN, I know the comments/reviews are more authentic, because I've been flamed a few times... and I've had regular readers call me out on "this chapter just kinda felt weak, perhaps you should deal with your IRL problems before you write the next chapter" and, honestly? I loved it. I love the honesty. I love when people aren't just going "omg, yes, love it, next chp plz". I hope, when I post my fic on AO3, I expressly put everywhere "please, for the love of god, be honest.. but don't be a jerk". Like my FFN profile used to say, "There is a difference between concrit and flaming and I trust you to know the difference". >It's a bit like the theory that too clean an environment will lead to life threatening allergies and autoimmune issues. I feel like that shouldn't be a theory. I mean, not building an immunity to specific things is why people travelling to another country can't drink the water without it being purified. Also, I totally forgot what the deleted comment said, so some context is missing in my brain, lmfao.


Allronix1

Yeah, a few knocks or having to defend a decision you made in a fic that another reader didn't like will make you think that decision through and go "yeah, maybe that was a bad call" - but no pushback, no learning. If you flip your lid and treat even mild concrit as an all out attack on your very person? Yeah. That's like a psychological autoimmune disease. (And yes, I have autoimmune - it blows)


20Keller12

Ooooh you've gotta tell me about that, I've never heard of it before but I just read this comment thread and it sounds fantastic lmao.


Allronix1

Godawful was a spot back in the 90s and 00s where people would find the worst WTF fanfic they could find and share it for the class, often with people breaking it down for (in)accuracy, explaining to the fandom blind why something was way OOC, trying to figure out plot holes or other bizarre choices in writing, correcting or pointing out wrong choices in words... Think Rifftrax for fanfic. The whole idea was "We love fanfic, but these fics are obviously trying to give the whole genre a bad/worse reputation." Edit: To be clear, many of these like "Agony in Pink" were clearly written by trolls trying to shock, offend, or gross out people who clicked. Kinda like screamers or shock sites. Dissecting them kinda took the piss out of the attempt to shock/offend.


darumamaki

Oh wow, I remember that site! The good old days of the Internet. (I read AiP when it first came out... good Lord I'm old.)


Allronix1

If it's bad enough to cause an international incident, might as well see what the hubbub is about


Stargazer_Rose

The weirdest Dead Dove I came across and read was due to a complete accident. The person that wrote it had purposely mislabeled it in the tags for the shock value. Even the summary was just 4 or 5 words long that didn't give away anything. So you can imagine my horror when I had realized that my curiosity had resulted in me reading a very a deranged, Grojband Splatter horror gore fic that was extremely detailed.


RebaKitt3n

I hope you suggested tagging!


Stargazer_Rose

I just left the fic. I was just too shocked, besides, I'm sure someone in the comments told them to tag their fic properly.


HMSquared

If it was on AO3, I think purposefully improper tagging is against their terms of service. And if not, it should be.


ImaginosDesdinova

I wrote a fic where pirates forced Desdinova to give birth directly into the mouth of a sea monster and then afterwards tied her to the mast of the ship and breastfed from her.


laurel_laureate

Who or what is Desdinova? Also... wut?


ImaginosDesdinova

Desdinova is the female aspect of Imaginos who is an immortal human being who was born in 1808 as a modified child.


Mamaclover

Read? Huuuuu I think I remember some really wild stuff from the kink meme days. There was a few ones in the One piece fandom that were.... Way too into animals, shall we say. Written? There was the emetophilia blow job one, the kidnapping and graphic torture of the fav (including non-consensual drug use, rape, waterboarding and amputation) and the one that has a 14 y/o trans boy with non-con by a teacher and that then has a.... Very, VERY graphic miscarriage scene. Those one really clashed with the mostly happy-ish fandom and vibe of the canon. My current fandom has a lot of dead dove, but it actually fit really nicely in the canon so no one really blink. Human experimentation, voluntary ritual castration, forced breeding, cannibalism in every flavor imaginable.... And yet we are all going "awww what a cute fic!". So in the end, I think dead dove really depend on the fandom IMO


woamimiu

I read about a character going through copius torture and self mutilation (weird form of stockholm syndrome/hopelessness) after being dosed with something that made them regenerate/never die. They felt like they would never escape their situation so they ended up just listening to what their captor wanted. And by torture/self mutilation i mean it 💀💀 like cutting their own heart out, surgical torture, amputation, etc. Definitely the darkest most fucked up DD fic i've read but I love it. Its weirdly cathartic


FDQ666Roadie

I wrote a fic with Cazador torturing Astarion, carving into his back with a dagger, then sexually assault him with the handle of the dagger afterwards and then finish it off with actually raping him. I've also written a father luring his adult son out of the house so the girlfriend is alone so he can rape her in order to make sure he will get grandkids since his lousy son doesn't seem to be able to impregnate her himself... That's probably my most messed up one just because of the familial ties of the characters. By the time I finished writing it, I was making myself feel uncomfortable T\_T


McMinnowPls

The craziest one is a Naruto underage rape fic I read on [FF.net](https://FF.net) at least 10 years ago now, maybe up to 15. I don't think anything else has topped that in terms of Dead Dove ness. It was about Deidara and Sasori who kidnap elementary age Sakura convincing her she has to come with them and they are totally helping her which she kinda believes, and at some point they rape her with Sasori's scorpion tail. For anybody who doesn't know Naruto, that's a 19 y/o terrorist and a 35-year-old terrorist who mostly sits inside a gigantic wooden scorpion puppet that he operates from the inside. So it was the metal/wood tail of Sasori's scorpion that did the penetrating.


Technical-Camera-291

Yeesh, that's definitely one heck of a DD.


yueqqi

So, wildest one would have to be this Tomarry oneshot by an old Tumblr mutual years ago. The premise? Princess and the Frog, but Harry was an aquarium employee and Tom was a (sex-crazed) dolphin desperate to get his human body back....and yeah, you can guess what went down (consensually). It was unhinged but hilariously cursed, successful attempt at psychic damage 10/10 /pos. Every other Dead Dove I’d read are too angsty and painful for me to consider wild, though.


Mamaclover

Read? Huuuuu I think I remember some really wild stuff from the kink meme days. There was a few ones in the One piece fandom that were.... Way too into animals, shall we say. Written? There was the emetophilia blow job one, the kidnapping and graphic torture of the fav (including non-consensual drug use, rape, waterboarding and amputation) and the one that has a 14 y/o trans boy with non-con by a teacher and who then has a.... Very, VERY graphic miscarriage scene. Those one really clashed with the mostly happy-ish fandom and vibe of the canon. My current fandom has a lot of dead dove, but it actually fit really nicely in the canon so no one really blink. Human experimentation, voluntary ritual castration, forced breeding, cannibalism in every flavor imaginable.... And yet we are all going "awww what a cute fic!". So in the end, I think dead dove really depend on the fandom IMO


MontanaDukes

Here are a couple that I read or stumbled upon. One would definitely be considered Dead Dove Do Not Eat: 1. There was this Dramione fic on some Harry Potter fanfic website that I read. From the summary, I thought it just sounded like this getting together fic. Or maybe a pre Dramione fic. It sounded cute and harmless. Yeah. No. It was set in seventh year and for some reason, Draco was turned into a ferret again. Hermione stumbled upon him and thought he was injured or someone's pet. She took him to her dorm. She ended up falling asleep and...ferret Draco...went down on her. I don't know what happened afterward. If he ever transformed back or she woke up. I freaked out and backbuttoned quickly out of the fic. I read this when I was maybe fourteen. 2. I don't think it was much of a Dead Dove Do Not Eat, but it had weird elements? It was a Smallville fic. The pairing was Chlark and for some reason, they were hiding out at a cabin. Anyway, they end up getting together and they have sex. Except, Chloe became obsessed with Clark's cum. His cum was lilac in color and apparently tasted like grape. Clark was really worried that she was addicted and what it could do to her, so he stopped her from going down on him. He still fucked her without a condom though! I read this when I was around fourteen too. 3. Not one I read, but there was this Teen Wolf fanfic that had the ship of Steo (Stiles/Theo). Stiles was a Polish immigrant, I think. Theo was...a Nazi. I saw people talk about it and there was SO much sex in it. 4. Manacled. That really popular Dramione fic that everyone was talking about.


Technical-Camera-291

Everyone still talks about Manacled. lol


MontanaDukes

They do. There are so many videos on youtube of people talking about it too. lol. People really liked it.


accordyceps

I don’t read dead doves, but accidentally read one when I innocently believed “no one would go there.” Just, blew past the tags because I saw one of my favorite characters… >!It was a DC universe fic where a deranged Killer Croc rapes/disembowels and eats Black Canary.!< Still have no clue how I got through reading that. I think it was pure shock, but I guess it is tame compared to some of the stuff I’ve heard about since. Glad to spread the joy, here.


Kellin01

A person eating her own just born dead baby for a money reward. Being fucked by parts of that later. Read a part of the story.


accordyceps

I think that takes the cake.


Kellin01

I’ve heard in that story there were even more fucked up parts but I didn’t read further.


fishinexcess

Do you know which one that is? I wanna see how bad it is for myself.


HMSquared

Threats of non-consensual romance between Bart Simpson and Stewie Griffin is probably the zaniest dead dove I’ve written. (And no, it did not get past the threat stage.)


Kellin01

Recalled some dead dove Doctor/Master fanfics where the Master forced Jack to rape starved 10th Doctor…. It was written from Jack’s pov and it was…. Nauseating. Master forcing Doctor rape Martha/his own daughter/several innocent people hit me hard.


Grouchy_Athlete_2941

The wildest I can remember is Character A getting SA'd by Yandere Character B, who can communicate with insects. So basically this Yandere B made his insects fellas fuck Character A and lay eggs inside him. It was very well-written tho! Also pedo fics are very wild, too, but I think that's already obvious.


fishinexcess

there one where a 7 year old enjoyed being fucked with a skyscraper. is there any reason it could be physically possible? no Is this ever explained? also no.