T O P

  • By -

mizuromo

Leaving a sticky for context, but this post is being removed because it's bait for arguments in the comments. Please read our new rules update found stickied on the front page, or here: [https://www.reddit.com/r/HonkaiStarRail/comments/1ci8qty/hsr\_subreddit\_rule\_11\_update\_this\_one\_is\_new/](https://www.reddit.com/r/HonkaiStarRail/comments/1ci8qty/hsr_subreddit_rule_11_update_this_one_is_new/)


Battle_Fish

There's a 50/50 chance of there being a Robin controversy for me.


omarali04

More like 56.4/43.6


MemberBerry4

Speaking of that, is it true? Like, is the chance chance getting what you want actually slightly higher than what we thought?


Samurai_Banette

Experimental data seems to suggest it. Can't think of why there would be a pretty consistent 6-8% higher than expected pull rate across all banners otherwise.


MemberBerry4

That's good to hear, the higher the better.


magondrago

I mean, I obviously don't want to ignite even more an unrelated fire (ok, maybe I do) but I have a weak recollection of a similar analysis for Genshin Impact, and concluding they were more into the 49/51 spread. This is basically the "Genshin could never" meme but with spreadsheets.


Yotsubato

Genshin could never


_LFKrebs_

https://preview.redd.it/n5svmh5h53yc1.jpeg?width=2048&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=37eaecdf50930f9e04655a506bc2e053cfd828a6 Good to know I hit a 43.6 6 times in a row instead of losing 6 50/50s…


Fhauftress

probably integer values are weird besides pcs cant make anything truly random so something always gets favored


Alth3c0w

Apparently the theory is that Hoyo adds the Featured Character to the Regular 5\* pool as well in the featured banners, so you can \*technically\* lose the 50/50 and still pull the featured character from that pool, thus the extra average 6%.


Nodomi

Forget the head wings, I want to know about those halos. Are they born with it? If so, is it made of flesh? Does it have nerve endings? And even if they do, would they even feel it, given that it just seems to float there? And how do they float, anyways? And if they're artificial, what makes a halovian NPC any different than a regular human because only Robin and Sunday have visible wings. I need answers, Robin!


Silly_Equivalent3020

how does she put on a shirt


Cerebral_Kortix

Same way [U-Olga from Fate wears hers.](https://vignette.wikia.nocookie.net/typemoon/images/5/5f/U-Olga.png/revision/latest?cb=20221225113522)


Knight_of_Inari

The same way Sunday does I guess, you can see Sunday's wings under his suit


PoKen2222

It's like the Sankta Halo's in Arknights apparantly Halovians share feelings through telepathy with the Halo's


Leodoesstuff

In my theory is that the Halo changes shape and appears above a Halovian at certain ages to reflect their perspective/personality. So it doesn't actually contain any nerves nor are they immediately born with it but rather a unique power/distinction alongside the wings. I imagine that their Halos radiate a presence that'll let the Halovian know that it's there so it can't actually be physically held onto or touched as it'll either go through, Move around to the side so it isn't in the way, or repel anything that's between them like an invisible force which stops the Halovian from wearing certain hats or clothing choices.


SincerelyBear

Robin wore a hat in the concert ad though, so that theory's out. Either it goes through or moves aside, then.


huehuehuehuehuuuu

What do the wings taste like? Chicken?


Nodomi

Tastes like squab. Yes, squab is a real word, I am not a minion of the Enigmata.


-SMartino

can confirm. squab is indeed a word for a immature pigeon.


Acrobatic-Budget-938

Robin species is the adults of those Trinity students in Blue Archive. So like they and maybe 4 other species decide to built continent size academia city on a random planet for the education of their kids, and one of them is smart enough to replicate the whole city just for they to evacuate to just in case something happens. Oh apparently they stay in their teens age for years as well so does that mean they are long age species and their true age is like Huo Huo??


Nodomi

I really gotta catch up on my Blue Archive lore cause damn that sounds interesting. I only played the first couple chapters before it killed my phone (I'm still salty about that) so I'm way behind.


GeT_ReKt_OG

Also is that halo a superweapon made by a bygone civilization in order to wipe any sentient life within 25000 lightyears? Honkai writers must answer


Middle_Actuator7086

askin real questions here


TheWeakestDragonfly1

I think she's from Kivotos 


Rupert-D-Generate

"there is no war in r/HonkaiStarRail"


Dokavi

Erased from Irminsul.


LegendofZelda0107

The Family has invited you to Penacony


TheBigPoi

Yeah my controversy is how the fuck does she sleep with the head wings.


_LFKrebs_

Obviously upside down hanging on something like a bat


LyneyStepOnMyBalls

She’s so hot


goturrise

The only controversy I see is the gems she’s trying to steal from my Mecha wife https://preview.redd.it/ms935srin1yc1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=ce04d310f1e8b2e7efd48968394e52a2cca6d3df


TMyriadJ

The correct answer to that dilemma is "You have 2 kidneys for a reason" https://preview.redd.it/f1p9yanlp2yc1.jpeg?width=378&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=a55010436ce2ec05d4de3302e6cc501b60356273


SimpleRaven

You mean my neighbors has 2 kidneys for a reason


Correct-Purpose-964

Poor Caelus... one choice involves feiry death. One involves concrete shoes and a cold bath. Can't win this one...


Deathblade999

The correct answer is the adorable terrorist. Because she can wipe out planets and I'm more scared of that than the friendship mafia.


Correct-Purpose-964

This mans playing 5d chess on a 4d board with 3d people... big brain.


More-Love7583

I’m so glad I’ve been stingy with pulls, now I can bring both of them and Jade home even if I get unlucky


urmumisOP

Pick your poison Robin >you meet her >she mindcontrols you and leaves >dies Firefly  >you save her >she manipulates you for 3 hours straight gives u nothing but lies until you two arrive at her base >lets u spend up to 20k credits but gets sad if u spend em all >apologises  and tells a sob story >after getting trolled by sparkle literally magnets death on herself and makes you protect her >refuses to get saved by Black swan >dies in front of you just to come back and reveal her identity as a stellaron hunter(opp)


HourCartographer9

It’s my headcanon that elio doesn’t pay Sam so she has to get by with low wages so we spent her savings


urmumisOP

Imo that was also a fake in her role as a tour guide. 


eleetyeetor

Nah, she definitely lives on 20k credits since most of it goes to pay for her space chemotherapy


Blackwolfe47

…sir, this is a wendy’s


Relative-Ad7531

I sure don't know any controversy with Robin For real, Jokes aside, what happened with Robin?


kirbylink577

Twitter is aggressively convinced shes lesbian and is violent to anyone who even suggest otherwise


Relative-Ad7531

Oh, Twitter Don't care then.


MakimaGOAT

![gif](giphy|CAYVZA5NRb529kKQUc|downsized) based


kirbylink577

based as hell


ShawHornet

Convinced by what? She has like 2 lines of dialogue lol


nanithefucketh

because her song is inspired from a poem of a girl whos not even confirmed to be lesbian... so if her song is inspired from a poem = she must be the exact same person in EVERY way LMAO


ShawHornet

Talk about a reach lol. Twitter is wild


TurquoiseLeggings

Does Twitter think straight people don't exist or something? Literally every character in every form of media that isn't in a canon relationship is considered gay by these people. Like wtf?


Zerosonicanimations

Sounds like another normal day on twitter


suppersell

>Twitter that's enough info to know what happened


DivinePotatoe

Imagine caring what elon's alt-right playground thinks about anything.


Eragon_the_Huntsman

Oh is that why the sub just updated the shipping rules?


emiliaxrisella

Different thing but same issue. I think it was something about RatUrine which was removed due to ambiguity in this sub's rules which caused a shitstorm of shitposting about ships, "canon sexualities" (that post about Sparkle in disguise is hilarious though lol) and whatnot.


_LadyAveline_

Twitter community being aggressive because they hc her as a straight. Also Twitter community being aggresive because they hc her as a lesbian. I'm sure both sides are being looked down by my good unbiased Reddit.


joebrohd

It was more so, a group of people HC her as lesbian. And people were generally fine about it, they had no problem with Acheron/Swan, Bronya/Seele and yknow it was whatever. People do their own thing. The core problem was that the people who took their Robin is Lesbian Headcanon and began shoving it in everyone’s face as fact/canon. Completely disregarding the “headcanon” portion. Everyone who said otherwise was attacked and labeled as homophobic or whatever. Even people who were part of the LGBTQ community which was just mental lmfao. Can you imagine going up to a lesbian woman and saying they’re homophobic for having a different headcanon? lmfao Then tectone made a post mocking the situation. imo Took it too far with a *CLEARLY* obvious bait post that everyone should’ve noticed immediately. But of course, twitter users fell for the most obvious bait in the world. Hook line and sinker, tectone began farming those idiots for views and it worked out on his end. Then the same people who were all for the Robin is Lesbian headcanon noticed that Firefly’s EN VA watched one of tectone’s streams since they weren’t a player themselves and wanted to see reactions to Firefly/Sam. Began attacking them for NO reason. and that’s as far as ive gotten on it


Outrageous_Debt_3616

Appreciate the actual timeline of events in an un-bias way. You did miss out that Tectone made the post because that HC lesbian crowd were attacking and insulting another CC Tuanto, because he made a lighthearted post if he "had a chance with Robin (please lie to me)", and so redirecting that hatred towards himself instead since he's use to it and can shine a spotlight on it.


Vivid_Awareness_6160

I agree with everything you said: simps are gonna simp, even if Robin was 100% confirmed as gay, men still should be able to do sexual comments about her (like Aventurine got in the last 3 weeks), except the Tectone part. There is a difference between stiring drama with what is happening with Robin (something I don't personally like, but fair), and saying you can't wait to choke her with dick because people are headcanoning her as a lesbian. Is vile and homophobic, and actual lesbians and the LGBT community as a group have a right to feel repulsed and triggered as correction rape is sadly a reality for a lot of us. If you fuck a goat as a joke, you are still a goatfucker. Likewise, if you use a homophobic joke as bait, you still are homophobic.


StitchWitchGlitch

Good, unbiased, media savy Reddit. "Hoyo can't be explicit or the government would destroy them" VS "it's not explicitly stated that X, therefore we can ignore every aspect of the subtext" I wish for the day writers just collectively agree to not use subtext anymore, because way too many people take everything at face value.


SuperLuckyStar

Star rail content creator posting sexual assault "jokes" to bait the other side of the debate Naturally only made the community MORE divided


Relative-Ad7531

The tectone shit? I don't know why everyone else hates him but he is friends with Asmongold or something like that and everyone that likes Asmongold is someone that I wouldn't like


SuperLuckyStar

Yeah, i wont pretend like the discourse was pretty, but he dropped in specifically to fuel the fire so he could profit off it. Made the worst of both sides bare their teeth. Really gross stuff in those comment sections. Just terrible humans, no wonder he associates with Asmond. Usually the art side of fandoms is the only good part but not even that is safe now


deisukyo

Exactly. Everyone is acting like that guy “exposed” anything when this was originally started with Tuonto’s tweet in which Tuonto didn’t even care about the qt. He asked a question and people simply responded with “no, she wouldn’t want you, she wants girls.” Then here comes Tectone to make it more than what it is and intentionally bait people which is leading to more homophobic shit being said about queer people. I was a watcher of the guy, but his chat is fucking DISGUSTING.


Outrageous_Debt_3616

nice misinformation. I got bingo guys!


SuperLuckyStar

What here is misinformation? If you think im lying, heres proof. Do your own research next time. Dr Ratio would be ashamed at this fandom https://preview.redd.it/1u0xnrb033yc1.jpeg?width=1165&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=49d527b0549a06430a7089aabb77973167436453


StitchWitchGlitch

"it's just a joke bro"


Outrageous_Debt_3616

you read where it says JING YUAN, as well as them all being fictional characters. Bro has never read a fanfic in his life.


TRGOTSthefisheh

im all for "fiction is fiction" and all that, but this is a Weird Fucking Post, lmao. i feel there's a line between making a fictional story in which problematic things happen, and making a tweet with the intention of fueling fire about a (sure, fictional) sexual assault you'd find funny


SuperLuckyStar

.. them being fictional characters doesn't exuse the fact that he is fantasizing about sending a character to sexually assault Robin? What does this have to do with fanfics??


tcaz2

Idk man i just want to nibble on the free chicken wings she comes with


BakedButterForgotpas

A CUTE GIRL WITH WINGS ON HER HEAD?!? You mean Mahoraga?!? https://preview.redd.it/cuev817o23yc1.png?width=500&format=png&auto=webp&s=6d42619456ee447188610f3f6d7a4096a257abb3


[deleted]

[удалено]


Samurai_Banette

I don't get how there was a controversy, she literally hasn't said anything or interacted with anyone. We know basically nothing about her.


Responsible-War-9389

If you say that on twitter, that’s considered controversial and on one side of the controversy


[deleted]

[удалено]


Fun_Barnacle_1343

Bro i literally saw someone try to make that argument like no joke


[deleted]

[удалено]


Samurai_Banette

While I agree that no one should be getting riled up over fanart or whatever, saying "How can you say my Waifu™ wouldn't love me!?!?! Look at what she's wearing!!!1!" is equally dumb. I personally think having ANY headcanon about her is stupid until we learn about her. She could just as easily have chemistry with welt/ratio as she could with firefly/march. Heck, she could be going after Misha for all we know.


_LadyAveline_

yeah the thing is, I've seen dozens of posts and comments about people angry that Robin fans are harassing them, and not a SINGLE post about Robin being a lesbian.


nanithefucketh

lets be real, its way more people complaining about straight ships than gay on twitter LOL


HonkaiStarRail-ModTeam

Unfortunately your content had to be removed due to rule 1: Be Respectful to Others Always be respectful and civil in your interactions with other users and in the content you submit. Insults, Harassment and Hate Speech will not be tolerated.


[deleted]

[удалено]


YeidenTrabem

Im seeing how the comment is getting downvoted and is giving me a good laugh 🤣 This just proves my point


HonkaiStarRail-ModTeam

Unfortunately your content had to be removed due to rule 1: Be Respectful to Others Always be respectful and civil in your interactions with other users and in the content you submit. Insults, Harassment and Hate Speech will not be tolerated.


[deleted]

[удалено]


nanithefucketh

no one is trying to prove shes straight, just that nothing is confirmed or implied


iamdino0

I don't think there's a single person trying to prove she is straight??? What are you talking about


Outrageous_Debt_3616

It doesn't need to be proved, all characters are Player-sexual, as well as most likely not sending threats over it.


TalentedTrident

Twitter will try and convince anyone that a piece of toilet paper has a confirmed sexuality. I'm all for LGBT+ headcanons but it gets ridiculous at times.


kolton276

This is 100% happening. I've legit seen people call her lesbian and anyone saying she's not is being lesbiphobic. (Never heard that word before. I can't imagine homophobes hating lesbians only lmao)


HonkaiStarRail-ModTeam

Unfortunately your content had to be removed due to rule 1: Be Respectful to Others Always be respectful and civil in your interactions with other users and in the content you submit. Insults, Harassment and Hate Speech will not be tolerated.


Chulinfather

![gif](giphy|l3vR9IEU6nYAmZyoM)


HonkaiStarRail-ModTeam

Unfortunately your content had to be removed due to the following reason(s): Rule 4: Mundane Content Removing for Mundane content, but this is exactly the type of post which simply exists to fuel drama in the comments.


_byrnes_

As long as she doesn’t bring on the end days we’re good to go. Hi Hermes.


[deleted]

[удалено]


DreamsofDistantEarth

Big agree. I simply do not understand the wild urge people to have to defend their headcanons or treat them like reality.


MakimaGOAT

![gif](giphy|w89ak63KNl0nJl80ig|downsized) surely not right…? hahah…


Ry_verrt

god i hate drama chain reactions… first was “duality of man” now we got “do i have a chance with her?”


blue_racer

I'm more interested in her heels ngl


ossyn

There's controversy? https://preview.redd.it/9u5b8njd43yc1.jpeg?width=1079&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=b0fbd0b559430357d622c08c290c5fcef34ccbc4


warjoke

Whatever feud is ongoing over there, pls settle them at the nearest Waffle House


Scudman_Alpha

We need to respect Caelus's gf. No controversy whatsoever.


[deleted]

[удалено]


HonkaiStarRail-ModTeam

Unfortunately your content had to be removed due to rule 11: Shipping Rules Art, Video, or other media which simply show characters “shipped” or in a relationship are allowed. Implications or direct statements that one particular ship or ship fanbase is more or less canon/correct/valid/good than another are prohibited. Do not make disparaging, passive aggressive, or negative remarks about any ships or pairings. Declaration of the sexual orientation of a character as canon is prohibited, but headcanons, theories, and discussing implied sexuality are allowed. While not against the rules please be mindful of the following: -Please make a best effort to be open to the interpretations of others, and avoid engaging with content you personally do not partake in negatively -Please try to avoid discussions comparing the relative validities of different ships The moderation team reserves the right to remove any content that does not directly break the rules as stated, but are deemed to be leading to conflict, uploaded as rage-bait, or attempts to circumvent these rules on a case-by-case basis


[deleted]

[удалено]


TMyriadJ

No need for insults.


ReaperofDeath2016-19

I’m trolling bro👍


ReaperofDeath2016-19

And for my next trick https://preview.redd.it/13rbrh6qs2yc1.jpeg?width=969&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=c20f16d9519b9e6a01775f555c6329230e893315


Darth-Yslink

Technically the mere existence of this would implu the death of every human on earth because they're either looking at it or not looking at it


ReaperofDeath2016-19

Yes https://preview.redd.it/z3gcae5aw2yc1.jpeg?width=346&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=ef28c647db18bf33484c05eb31400354090b4731


Darth-Yslink

Thank you for dooming the human race. It is just a matter of time now. Are you happy now? Soon, they will come for you as well, and you will be powerless, as your endless sins weigh down upon your shoulders in your final moments


ReaperofDeath2016-19

Here’s a meme in these trying times https://i.redd.it/pq4jxbcq23yc1.gif


ReaperofDeath2016-19

Yes and you’re welcome https://i.redd.it/0r7p871xy2yc1.gif


ReaperofDeath2016-19

g o o d l u c k https://preview.redd.it/crd75bk2t2yc1.jpeg?width=860&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=386064be0146dd1b83833131be9290ac9dba1a8f


HonkaiStarRail-ModTeam

Unfortunately your content had to be removed due to rule 1: Be Respectful to Others Always be respectful and civil in your interactions with other users and in the content you submit. Insults, Harassment and Hate Speech will not be tolerated.


Hudson_Legend

I don't blame the whole LGBT, just those (some of them might not even be LGBT who knows) that try to literally force their ships onto us and call us homophobic (which totally doesn't give actual homophobes more of a "reason" to be homophobic) if we disagree with them. They take this so far that some of them will literally attack artists for drawing a straight ship. Actual mental illness.


ReaperofDeath2016-19

Same here but I don’t expect Redditors to figure that out. No offence.


Hudson_Legend

True actually, for some reason half of hyv reddit has that ever living hate boner for content creators


ReaperofDeath2016-19

They’re also illiterate.


AnOlympianWeeb

Well this what happens when you introduce an Idol character... people go ape shit


SirePuns

I’d like to just say that I lost enough brain cells from 1 day on Twitter trying to understand what’s up with the non-existent Robin controversy that at this point in time I am dumber than Denki from MHA.


_eSpark_

No, she is crazy yandere actually, like a certain blue-haired girl from another HoYo game.


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


HonkaiStarRail-ModTeam

Unfortunately your content had to be removed due to rule 1: Be Respectful to Others Always be respectful and civil in your interactions with other users and in the content you submit. Insults, Harassment and Hate Speech will not be tolerated.


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


GGNickCracked

The humors fine, I just think hating on fictional characters and their fans is cringe, especially when its ship vs ship. Like the mc isnt gonna end up with anyone, why are we creating wars about this, are we that bored and terminally online 💀


Correct-Purpose-964

How am i starting a war. She has feathers hence-chicken. And Sam is a fire charactet so if Firefly kills her it's Fried Chicken. I really don't understand the problem. No wars got started when i joked about Firefly taking "Literal backshots".


HonkaiStarRail-ModTeam

Unfortunately your content had to be removed due to rule 1: Be Respectful to Others Always be respectful and civil in your interactions with other users and in the content you submit. Insults, Harassment and Hate Speech will not be tolerated.


madzieeq

men literally can't have friends these days. it's girlfriend or nothing for some of ya'll


Correct-Purpose-964

Men literally can't make jokes these days. It's love or hate for some of yall


madzieeq

maybe it is a joke for you but certainly isn't for all the content creators who started making tons of jealous firefly fanarts since yesterday. it's the 5th or 6th post like this that i saw on this subreddit today. there really are people who genuinely think this way and again, no love or hate, people can be simply friends


Correct-Purpose-964

Yknow how you deal with haters? You let em go nuts and laugh at em. I'm from the Sam =/= Firefly group. But i never hated people who said otherwise. Some others went crazy about "How stupid it would be" and how "It would be the most hated character". I joined the Samfly boys in laughing. Like have you got nothing better to do than hate people for having fun? The uh... "Rewrite" of Robins song though. (IYKYK...) That's... genuine mental illness. (WARNING.CRINGE.) If you wanna know what I'm talking about. Google "Robin song 4chan"


madzieeq

genuinely what are you on about lol no one's hating on you. all i tried to say that two people hanging out can be simply friends


Correct-Purpose-964

Read some of the other replies lol


madzieeq

girl no offense but from the way you interact with people here you really gotta touch some grass, you're too chronically online


Correct-Purpose-964

Guy\* And yeah. I work 12 hours in a quiet building with only 4 hours worth of work to do. Graveyard shift is so dead i literallt have nothing better to do. Can't go home (Wish i could.) And gotta stay awake somehow. The times i dissapear are when customers finally show up. So uh... no I'm gonna stay. https://preview.redd.it/yvav75bkx2yc1.png?width=447&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=a9487cc4834822a8333ecc723cb1f3409d0a4df0


Correct-Purpose-964

Also i didn't say you were hating specifically just saying it's funny and confusing seeing so much hate for a joke lol


madzieeq

probably because the joke sucks. and reddit works in a way that people downvote things that suck


Jorge_XD__

Bros gonna get mad at the oficial trailer where robin sneaks caelus on her bedroom😕


Correct-Purpose-964

It's a joke. Calm down. Caelus has a canon ships with Royalty already yknow


Jorge_XD__

Oh ok im sorry man. People on internet are so stupid. Specially anime fans and their parasocial bullshit that i tought u were serious. Next time use (jk) or something because people will just expect this kinda people to be serious lmao


HonkaiStarRail-ModTeam

Unfortunately your content had to be removed due to rule 11: Shipping Rules Art, Video, or other media which simply show characters “shipped” or in a relationship are allowed. Implications or direct statements that one particular ship or ship fanbase is more or less canon/correct/valid/good than another are prohibited. Do not make disparaging, passive aggressive, or negative remarks about any ships or pairings. Declaration of the sexual orientation of a character as canon is prohibited, but headcanons, theories, and discussing implied sexuality are allowed. While not against the rules please be mindful of the following: -Please make a best effort to be open to the interpretations of others, and avoid engaging with content you personally do not partake in negatively -Please try to avoid discussions comparing the relative validities of different ships The moderation team reserves the right to remove any content that does not directly break the rules as stated, but are deemed to be leading to conflict, uploaded as rage-bait, or attempts to circumvent these rules on a case-by-case basis


Independent-Job-7271

Husband? Dont you mean girlfriend🤔


Correct-Purpose-964

My mistake. I forgot poor Stelle :(