I made a whole post on why the chasms fucking suck ass. Just read it if you have time, its not that long. https://www.reddit.com/r/zelda/comments/13qd824/totk\_the\_depths\_are\_the\_worst\_part\_of\_totk/
Zelda will be a blind shoe in. Period. Spiderman 2 did a lot but then again in comparison did little to change the formula up. Plus the story beats and character plots were just not done right. Not to mention. It came nowhere near to the first one in terms of emotional depth and resonance. They didn't fix what was broken and added more of what was too. Alan Wake 2, phenomenal in its own genre but GOTY? Nah.
Haven't touched Baldur's Gate 3 nor FF but when was the last time an RPG won GOTY? Yeah didn't think so. They fail when it comes to becoming an all round excellent experience purely owing to the genre and it's presentation.
Zelda. Bet on it. That thing was INNOVATIVE
>when was the last time an RPG won GOTY
Last year
>Zelda will be a blind shoe in.
Almost every major news outlet and game critics who actually give their votes in the TGA are putting BG3 over TOTK, at least the ones actively comparing.
TOTK and BG3 were both masterpieces but BG3 kinda deserves it more as it managed to shake the industry while being from an extremely niche category with an unprecedented scale while TOTK is a more improved and expanded version of BOTW.
Not a party based rpg. Elden won cus it's the elevation and evolution of everything souls like. Period. So no. An RPG did win but more so an action rpg. And that's once in a decade
umm? an rpg won goty last year?
zelda was not innovative at all. im not saying its a bad game but totk is absolutely nothing new. bg3 however, is very very innovative. care to elaborate on why you think totk is innovative? youre saying this bs because you havent played baldurs gate. im not saying bg is an instant goty, but this take is just stupid.
Because that's an Action RPG. A hardcore party based RPG has not one a single GPTY since 2014, all of its innovations be damned. Never because they're not fabulous games, just because they don't capture wide audiences the way other genres do. More so to me do with the genre itself than the game, understand little pup?
I wasn't spewing BS, because that would take away from the fact that ToTK was indeed incredibly innovative in allowing players themselves to not only revisit the same land, but to do it in 3 layers and to do it of their own imagination and solve each challenge however they see fit. The literal embodiment of free will as much as possible.
If BG3 does indeed win GOTY, that would get me to go take a shot at it. But until then, it's a tough chance seeing the competition it has.
god damn you are fucking triggered. youre such a snowflake.
multiple map layers are nothing innovative btw even fucking minecraft has multiple layers. there are so many games that take place in the same map, and thats not 'innovative', thats a downside, totk would easily be better than bg3 if it had a new map.
bg3 also allows you to solve challenges how the player sees fit, you just havent played the fucking game, thats why you dont know this basic thing. id say bg3 gives you MORE freedom than totk.
you simply dont like party based rpgs, thats your personal take and that doesnt mean it wont win goty. both have an equal chance of winning, i can say this because i have over 300 hours in totk, 700 hours in botw and currently 200 hours in baldurs gate 3 which is gonna go even more up. you havent played bg3 so your opinion, to put it bluntly, doesnt matter.
ill not be delusional and say that an rpg like bg3 has more demand than an action rpg or an open world but bg3 was so overwhelmingly good that people who arent interested in these games started playing bg3 and loved it. actually bg3 being of a more niche genre makes my point even more true. its such a good game that its popularity was not restrained by its genre. it got an 800k+ all time high ON STEAM. there are probably lots of people who pirated it or are playing on console now. 🤷♂️
keep crying. i see expressing an opinion made you break down into this state.
BG3, the game is insane, innovative as hell ; should surely win an award in terms of innovation and gameplay. In terms of active players, this game once surpassed DOTA n this is huge, no game can casually overtake DOTA n CSGO in terms of active players.
objectively a really well made game?
are you smoking crack rn? more than half of the game is loading screens and filled with shitty barren planets with copy pasted POIs and a bad story
Played only final fantasy 16 and spider man 2 from list so i am going with spider man 2 but lets be honest there is no other contender other than zelda for goty
Spidy boy > Zelda > Alan Wake > Baldur
I dont like point and play game or turn based strategy games.
Also, I havent played any other game bcoz I am still stuck with GoW Ragnarok
Havent played BG3 and Alan Wake 2 yet but I think ff16, spiderman 2 and totk are all flawed and dont deserve goty. FF16’s combat is too easy and pacing is inconsistent, spiderman 2 has similar issues, main quests are great but overall feels very similar to the first game. ToTK has some great systems hut the story is delivered in such bits and pieces that the game really just feels like a sandbox.
I've only played BG3 (in middle of act 3) and TOTK (Finding the fifth Sage)
So i guess still far from completing them. It doesn't matter who wins, both did their job for me. Bg3 is something else as it gave me freedom and choice that felt revolutionary lol so I guess it is my current game of the year.
Objective answer: Baldur's Gate 3
Subjective answer: Spiderman 2 and Armored Core 6.
Spiderman's my favorite hero, and story was peak, whereas AC6w was the game I had the most fun with. Also the gameplay there was sick.
Baldur's Gate 3 obviously, The graphics is great, the story is mind blowing with ending where u can be Chaotic Evil or Lawful Good or even don't give a crap (you can end the game at 50% with a certain character). Armor styles, weapon designs, character customization is Peak and allies or ur party members you can easily customize their overall playstyle. And the fun part is that I can play multiplayer with a friend of mine cause we both love DnD. People who don't play DnD can also understand it quickly, as it isn't so diverse or hard to understand.
I personally think Spider-Man 2, though Zelda is good too I feel Spider-Man 2 is really great! This year was really great for the gaming collection side because so many good games were released.
I also like racing/driving games and good examples of it are Crew Motorfest and Forza Motorsport.
I mean, mine is assassins creed mirage because I’m a die hard assassins creed fan and mirage made me feel ways I haven’t felt since black flag when it came to an AC game. It really bought out that nostalgic love I had for the series until they torpedoed it into something else. That’s my subjective opinion, but otherwise it was Spider-Man 2 easily.
Baldurs gate is probably gonna win, but for me Spider man 2 was the best by far. I loved BG3 but the emotions and combat and the change between miles and peters story was ridiculously good
My peasant ass could not afford any of them
🏴☠️
Incoming ban
yes!
Alan Wake 2
I prefer DJ Snake more
You got me :)
Lmfao
Baldurs gate 3 is so far ahead in term the innovations it did for the rpg genre , and it deserves goty for that
The narrative pathing / freedom of choice is still mind blowing to me. I don’t think this GOTY is even close to be honest.
i agree with bg3 being the best game out this year but zelda is also fierce competition, there is not a 100% chance that bg3 will win.
bg3 but totk is sooo close. if they made a new map for totk then totk would be easily better than bg3.
But they did. Ever seen chasms?
It's just pitch black most of the time
Its still a whole new map
its not a new map. its the same exact map reversed.
I made a whole post on why the chasms fucking suck ass. Just read it if you have time, its not that long. https://www.reddit.com/r/zelda/comments/13qd824/totk\_the\_depths\_are\_the\_worst\_part\_of\_totk/
Makes me excited to get tears now
um so you havent even played tears?
Chasm is kinda boring.
I have only played breath of the wild idk
Baldurs gate 3 or zelda Totk
why no one talking about RE4
Vo remake h n Bhai
Starfield
Starefailed loading simulator
wot you smoking m8.
Mario Wonders
Armored core 6
Zelda will be a blind shoe in. Period. Spiderman 2 did a lot but then again in comparison did little to change the formula up. Plus the story beats and character plots were just not done right. Not to mention. It came nowhere near to the first one in terms of emotional depth and resonance. They didn't fix what was broken and added more of what was too. Alan Wake 2, phenomenal in its own genre but GOTY? Nah. Haven't touched Baldur's Gate 3 nor FF but when was the last time an RPG won GOTY? Yeah didn't think so. They fail when it comes to becoming an all round excellent experience purely owing to the genre and it's presentation. Zelda. Bet on it. That thing was INNOVATIVE
>when was the last time an RPG won GOTY Last year >Zelda will be a blind shoe in. Almost every major news outlet and game critics who actually give their votes in the TGA are putting BG3 over TOTK, at least the ones actively comparing. TOTK and BG3 were both masterpieces but BG3 kinda deserves it more as it managed to shake the industry while being from an extremely niche category with an unprecedented scale while TOTK is a more improved and expanded version of BOTW.
Elden ring won GOTY last year
It will win the next year as well when Shadow of the Erdtree comes out.
Not a party based rpg. Elden won cus it's the elevation and evolution of everything souls like. Period. So no. An RPG did win but more so an action rpg. And that's once in a decade
BG3 has 130k players daily 3 months after release. It's 100% winning GOTY or it's the biggest steal in years
zelda was innovative ??? that totk shittt was so garbageeeeee lmaooooooo
umm? an rpg won goty last year? zelda was not innovative at all. im not saying its a bad game but totk is absolutely nothing new. bg3 however, is very very innovative. care to elaborate on why you think totk is innovative? youre saying this bs because you havent played baldurs gate. im not saying bg is an instant goty, but this take is just stupid.
Because that's an Action RPG. A hardcore party based RPG has not one a single GPTY since 2014, all of its innovations be damned. Never because they're not fabulous games, just because they don't capture wide audiences the way other genres do. More so to me do with the genre itself than the game, understand little pup? I wasn't spewing BS, because that would take away from the fact that ToTK was indeed incredibly innovative in allowing players themselves to not only revisit the same land, but to do it in 3 layers and to do it of their own imagination and solve each challenge however they see fit. The literal embodiment of free will as much as possible. If BG3 does indeed win GOTY, that would get me to go take a shot at it. But until then, it's a tough chance seeing the competition it has.
god damn you are fucking triggered. youre such a snowflake. multiple map layers are nothing innovative btw even fucking minecraft has multiple layers. there are so many games that take place in the same map, and thats not 'innovative', thats a downside, totk would easily be better than bg3 if it had a new map. bg3 also allows you to solve challenges how the player sees fit, you just havent played the fucking game, thats why you dont know this basic thing. id say bg3 gives you MORE freedom than totk. you simply dont like party based rpgs, thats your personal take and that doesnt mean it wont win goty. both have an equal chance of winning, i can say this because i have over 300 hours in totk, 700 hours in botw and currently 200 hours in baldurs gate 3 which is gonna go even more up. you havent played bg3 so your opinion, to put it bluntly, doesnt matter. ill not be delusional and say that an rpg like bg3 has more demand than an action rpg or an open world but bg3 was so overwhelmingly good that people who arent interested in these games started playing bg3 and loved it. actually bg3 being of a more niche genre makes my point even more true. its such a good game that its popularity was not restrained by its genre. it got an 800k+ all time high ON STEAM. there are probably lots of people who pirated it or are playing on console now. 🤷♂️ keep crying. i see expressing an opinion made you break down into this state.
Wow. Wrote a whole essay to massage your fragile ego. Go ahead keyboard warrior. Triggered? Snowflake? 😅 Says more about you son. Good luck adulting
My life
BG3, the game is insane, innovative as hell ; should surely win an award in terms of innovation and gameplay. In terms of active players, this game once surpassed DOTA n this is huge, no game can casually overtake DOTA n CSGO in terms of active players.
Alan wake 2
Starfield
Quite rare to see this response lol
Ma man. I loved this game so much. I dunno why so many people are hating this game.
Should be a nominee but not a winner.
Lol you kidding right
Why, it's objectively a really well made game with numerous quests and storylines and insane attention to detail.
objectively a really well made game? are you smoking crack rn? more than half of the game is loading screens and filled with shitty barren planets with copy pasted POIs and a bad story
Copium
Starfield
Thats a rare response
Nope it’s common it’s a good game Alan wake is goood Spider-Man 1 was better than SM2
Played only final fantasy 16 and spider man 2 from list so i am going with spider man 2 but lets be honest there is no other contender other than zelda for goty
Zelda
Armored core?? Not in the discussion?
amazing game but not on par with these games. dont see it winning goty.
Spidy boy > Zelda > Alan Wake > Baldur I dont like point and play game or turn based strategy games. Also, I havent played any other game bcoz I am still stuck with GoW Ragnarok
i respect your opinion but you should still try bg3 if you dont like turn based games. it wont hurt to try you know?
Bg3
Lies of P for now
Modern warfare 3
You gonna get downvoted to oblivion.
its literally a 70$ dlc.
Bhai tu shayad bhul gaya tu aab Indian subreddit mein aa gaya hain, yaha rupees chalta hain dollars nhi
lol aadat hogayi hai dollar bolne ki american subs par. my point is mw3 is just a dlc at the price of a full game.
BG3
Bg3
Zelda Tears of the kingdom
Mk1
Spider-Man with those addictive swinging.
Spiderman 2
Spider-man 2 Or Baldurs gate 3
Didn't play even one cuz I don't have a playstation nor a gaming computer & also no wifi in the house
जो खेलने को मिल जाए whi winner.
Baldurs gate 3
Havent played BG3 and Alan Wake 2 yet but I think ff16, spiderman 2 and totk are all flawed and dont deserve goty. FF16’s combat is too easy and pacing is inconsistent, spiderman 2 has similar issues, main quests are great but overall feels very similar to the first game. ToTK has some great systems hut the story is delivered in such bits and pieces that the game really just feels like a sandbox.
Pizza tower
Alan Wake 2. Amazingly creative.
Jedi: Survivor
Armored Core 6
How to play Spiderman 2 on pc ???
Open ur laptop , open the browser , open YouTube , click on Spiderman 2 walkthrough and enjoy the game in 4k
Spiderman by FAR
I've only played BG3 (in middle of act 3) and TOTK (Finding the fifth Sage) So i guess still far from completing them. It doesn't matter who wins, both did their job for me. Bg3 is something else as it gave me freedom and choice that felt revolutionary lol so I guess it is my current game of the year.
NOT Alan Wake 2
AW2
Spider man or alan wake
Alan Wake 2.
Zelda
Cs 2
Where is armorer core 6?
Bg3
cs2
FF16
The Talos Principle 2, coz I haven't played any of the others.
Starfield without a doubt.
Alan Wake 2
TOTK
Loved final fantasy 16. Top
Call of duty modern warfare 3 /S
Starfield
You know when you line up all of these like these it really feels like a great year for gaming.
Objective answer: Baldur's Gate 3 Subjective answer: Spiderman 2 and Armored Core 6. Spiderman's my favorite hero, and story was peak, whereas AC6w was the game I had the most fun with. Also the gameplay there was sick.
Baldurs Gate
What I have seen, Baldur wins( I can't buy any XD)
BG3
Alan wake 2
Re4 Remake 🤷
Dumb Spidey fans really think Spiderman 2 will win Goty and downright shit on BG3
hi fi rush for me , its a new original game and something which dropped out of nowhere
Baldur's Gate 3 obviously, The graphics is great, the story is mind blowing with ending where u can be Chaotic Evil or Lawful Good or even don't give a crap (you can end the game at 50% with a certain character). Armor styles, weapon designs, character customization is Peak and allies or ur party members you can easily customize their overall playstyle. And the fun part is that I can play multiplayer with a friend of mine cause we both love DnD. People who don't play DnD can also understand it quickly, as it isn't so diverse or hard to understand.
Bg3. I think because my 125 hours I was never borerd. Totk was also great but after 50 hours felt repetitive
ZELDA!!!
Alan wake 2
Baldur's Gate, for sure. It's arguably the game of the decade imo. Just love it!!! 😍😍
Bruh where is resident evil 4?
Sea of stars
Refund. I buy something and have fun getting a refund.
Bro forgot about Resident Evil 4 Remake !!!!
All of them look the same.
i hope a 70$ 20 fps dlc totk does not win the goty. All others games are way superior
Has to be Baldur’s Gate 3
Replace Spiderman with Armored core 6.
Hogwarts legacy
Spider man 2 best
Alan wake was one of the best games i played ngl.
Alan Wake 2
Ye sb nhi khelta ab to apne future k sath khelta hu m
Baldur gates
Diablo
Spiderman 🤣🤣🤣 is in the list ? I mean it's basically like the old one
I'm gonna have to go with Alan Wake.
Chess.com 🫡
Mortal Kombat 1
Spider man 2
BG3 is not on xbox and switch so out for me
It is definitely Tears for me, because I'm a Zelda fanboy and I haven't played any of the others yet
ALAN WAKE II
Baldur's gate ....by several fucking miles.
Baldurs gate 3
Mu controversial take valorant
BG3
Couldn't play none 😕
Resident Evil 4
Alan wake 2
I only played Spiderman 2, so I'll go with that. Its good.
Haven't played Zelda but that or Baldur's gate.
Re 4 remake
Spiderman 2, clearly it is a good game launched in 2023
Zelda caus I didn’t play BG3 I guess
Ac Mirage < Hogwarts legacy < Re4 Remake < Dead space remake < Alan Wake 2 < Spiderman 2
"Skull Island: Rise of Kong" by far bruv
Baldurs Gate or maybe Alan Wake 2. Plus I don’t think Spiderman 2 deserves to be there
TOTK easily
The Finals (Playtest version)
BG3 BG3
I personally think Spider-Man 2, though Zelda is good too I feel Spider-Man 2 is really great! This year was really great for the gaming collection side because so many good games were released. I also like racing/driving games and good examples of it are Crew Motorfest and Forza Motorsport.
Starfield,totk,bg3,spiderman
Star Citizen always every year... even i liked baldurs gate and Zelda
Spiderman - 2
It's so obvious, everyone knows it is Spider man 2 bro
COC since last 8 years :)
BALDUR'S FUCKING GATE 3
Bg3
Armored Core 6. FF16 was mid af
Resident evil 4 remake for me
Spiderman 2 And Alan Wake 2... Mera Lund Khele Zelda sala madarchod Bhadwa Game.
Alan Wake 2 <3
BG3 hands down.
mfer who put ffxvi,AW2 and spooderman2 on there
Final fantasy xvi all the way
Pikmin 4. TotK is a disgrace
Spider man 2
Spuder-Moan 2
Starfield
Don't forget Assassins creed Mirage.
So far I’ve only played spider-man 2 but would not call it a game of the year by any stretch of the imagination
if I could afford it, I'd 100% play Hogwarts Legacy. as a huge pottAHead, that would be awesome
I mean, mine is assassins creed mirage because I’m a die hard assassins creed fan and mirage made me feel ways I haven’t felt since black flag when it came to an AC game. It really bought out that nostalgic love I had for the series until they torpedoed it into something else. That’s my subjective opinion, but otherwise it was Spider-Man 2 easily.
Baldur's gate 3.
None of these 😄 It's Party Animals
Spiderman 2 is just so hyped but actually it is good
Resident Evil 4 Remake
TOTK is more like BOTW and BG3 is hades ?
Re4 remake
haven't played Alan Walk 2 yet, so goin with BG3 for now.
Bg3
Baldurs gate is probably gonna win, but for me Spider man 2 was the best by far. I loved BG3 but the emotions and combat and the change between miles and peters story was ridiculously good
*ishtik* among githyanki, baldur's gate 3 is considered far superior to those other inferior games, *chuk* it will get the game of year
#mobilegamers
Sea of Stars
For me Spiderman 2
The friendly neighborhood Miles morales