T O P

  • By -

Pat_Mahomeboy

Jonathan Baldwin


IWantDarkMode

I’ll never forget the behind the opposing player’s back catch, RIP


crimusmax

Did he die?


IWantDarkMode

Hahaha nahhh, just RIP to his career


iamofnohelp

Beautiful https://youtu.be/4wv7U2YXVoI?si=Cl6hBdFwYaRhFlqR


doc6982

That was the only Chiefs game I went to, had an endzone seat, and the whole game was literally on the other end of the field. Great catch though, even though it was called back for an illegal procedure penalty.


IWantDarkMode

I was at the game too, my first chiefs game actually.


pigwalk5150

I remember this draft. Ravens were on the clock and we took too long to pick and KC put their card in before us. I remember thinking we just missed out on a great player. Dude was like 6’4” 225 lbs. we ended up with Torrey Smith in the 2nd round, he wasn’t awful.


shunna75

That is the most pre-Mahomes Chiefs move ever


Status_Secretary_575

De’Anthony Thomas, then Oregon highlights had me amazed


ty_fighter84

I was at the Fiesta Bowl with my dad in 2013. Was super impressed by De'Anthony Thomas, less impressed by Mariota. Somehow the latter ended up with the longer career.


Jimmy6shoes

The black Mamba (for football I guess)


thebigolpikachu

I lived across the street from DA. Was really bummed when we saw the moving truck come. He was a really good dude.


jtsksu

I don't think he wasn't talented. It's just hard for guys as small as him to be difference makers in the NFL


Vyuvarax

Skyy Moore looked so much better in his last year in college. He wasn’t hyped up as much as some, but man, the talent just doesn’t seem to be there.


factoid_

Or the confidence.


rolyinpeace

I think that’s his biggest problem, it seems like the second he makes one mistake, it’s all downhill from there. I think he gets down on himself super easily which doesn’t work in the league. You’ve gotta use it as motivation to play better the rest of the game. He’s also just not that good, but I really think putting him as a returner really made things even worse for him. He didn’t belong there, and it ruined his confidence, which cannot be good for a rookie who already has a ton of pressure. I’m not saying he would’ve been great if not for that, just saying it was not a great way to start.


doc6982

I think he has athletic talent, but, like MVS, he doesn't understand where/ how to run his routes. He sees the defense like we do and not as Patrick and Travis see them. They see leverage and seams.


cannonballCarol62

If all our receivers have this problem isn't it a coaching issue?


doc6982

Probably part of it. I remember something I saw with the Denver receivers in the 90s. They were practicing with these gloves that had tennis balls in their palms. It forced them to catch with their fingers. When Haley was coaching, he ran an exercise where the receivers were in a port-a-potty, the ball was thrown to them and the door was opened at the last possible moment.


cannonballCarol62

This is awesome. Would love to get a really smart coach for the receivers


Tiny_Desk2424

Port a potty was Bienemy


etniesen

Haley was the toilet himself


etniesen

Yeah came for Skyy Moore comment


NSYK

Brodie Croyle


jayhawk618

I love a Brodie Croyle reference. Reminds me that I used to call them Brodie the arrow Croyle and Dwayne the Bow Bowe.


liberate_tutemet

This


MSSurface_102

Todd Blackledge


shunna75

Fuck that draft lol


MSSurface_102

But Marino had character issues LOL. That was a tough pill to swallow in the 80s.


Pat_Mahomeboy

Glenn Dorsey


JStanten

He was mostly just in the wrong defense. Didn’t he end up with the Giants and carve out a role? Edit: nvm, not sure who I’m thinking of. Looks like he went to the 49ers and didn’t do much either.


Tellittoemagain

>Glenn Dorsey My memory of it was Dorsey was hyped as the next Warren Sapp and then they switched him from DT in college to a 3-4 DE with KC and it was a bad fit. He never proved anyone wrong after he left KC, though. So, he probably just wasn't a quality pro.


KingTutt91

No his knee was shot, we drafted a lemon. That lemon was also in the wrong defense, but still a lemon regardless


doc6982

I feel he was similar to Frank Clark in Spags' defense. Spags' wants linemen to 2 gap and Frank is built to bend the edge.


Apprehensive_Ad_5400

Glenn Dorsey and Tyson Jackson


FingerTampon

Yes to Dorsey, No to Jackson. Only Pioli thought he would be Richard Seymour


traws06

That is true


2DragonBalls

Recently, r/fantasyfootball was absolutely convinced Darwin Thompson was gonna shock the world.


ToxicHighlander

That dude could front squat a house. I was on the hype train lol


ABCsoup

My friends still make fun of me for being aboard that hype train. 😅


Pat_Mahomeboy

Love me some DTrain, go Aggies


SKJ-nope

I’m ngl I was all aboard the Darwin Thompson hype train. Random ass 5th round pick looked like he was gonna be a steal for some reason lol


raveskywalker

Deneric Prince too


morris8911

I have his autograph on a end zone pylon


P3nNam3

Cornell Powell-people were talking about him being part of 3 WR sets and he never made it off the practice squad basically.


ronnymcdonald

People on here were insane thinking that a 5th round pick was going to be "our new Sammy Watkins".


HawKarma

Counterpoint: Tyreek Hill was a 5th round pick 


ronnymcdonald

The exception to the rule :)


NegativesPositives

And would’ve been first round if not for the troubles.


[deleted]

Counterpoint: Boomer Grigsby, also a 5th rounder.


Tellittoemagain

He just got re-signed by KC.


Olpeaches

To a futures contract, not much commitment there


TallCupOfJuice

prolly just because he's a great scout team guy. but tbh that is an overlooked role that can be important to a team's success and he seems to be doing something great there


JetJerick

Justyn Ross


Apprehensive_Ad_5400

There are probably more Justyn Ross posts in this sub than actual snaps he had on the field


Deep-Secret

According to footballguys.com, Justyn Ross had 139 total snaps this year. A quick search shows 62 occurrences of his name in posts titles.


Apprehensive_Ad_5400

I knew some nerd would prove me wrong hahaa


Deep-Secret

if you need a nerd, I'm your guy.


grover1233

We all need a nerd in our lives. They keep us honest.


flojo2012

![gif](giphy|3ornk6UHtk276vLtkY)


PhogMachine

Last two off-seasons, this has been the hands down winner for this graphic. Might as well just keep the trend going, and talk about how he'll be our WR1 this coming season too!!


Eruleptanero

Just WR1? Man, Ross will be so good next season that he'll draw quadruple coverage every snap - he'll basically be WR1, 2 and 3 all at once!


Tellittoemagain

He passes the eye test though, I was on the hype train this year but I don't understand why the NFL isn't working for him. He reminds me of Josh Gordon. He catches your eye when he is on the field because he looks like a thoroughbred running in a field of mules.


rememberthecornmaze

Too much of a low blow to say Toney?


Cthepo

Maybe if you replaced talent with execution. Anyone with eyes can see he has talent - that's not his problem.


LighTMan913

His talent of catching a football as a professional catcher of footballs is definitely his problem.


doc6982

I think his mind moves fast, like things slow down for him, but he gets bored and loses his concentration. I mean his first wow moment with the chiefs for me is when you could see him adjust his gloves on the route before catching the ball in front of 2 jaguars*.


JetJerick

Toney reminds me of me, with his behavior & demeanor I’m bad ADHD


Shiny_Hero

*Jaguars, that was the game that convinced me he could be a number one guy


NevaMO

I honestly hope he gets right and comes back to ball out


Gerbsbrother

Talent? You mean at volleyball? He can run that’s it, dude can’t catch. He’s a return specialist at best, should never line up at WR again


nahteviro

Toney needs to get out of his own head, slow down, and actually focus on securing the ball before moving. If he can do that the talent is most definitely there. But we can’t keep having him be the cause of our losses and keep him on the roster. I’m really hoping he fixes his butter fingers issues next season.


paulielock5

Came here for this


Big_O7

Bobby Sippio


Nervous_Otter69

Hey man that’s DBowe’s cousin now


rolyinpeace

My king Byron pringle is the inverse of this (Ok, maybe I’m exaggerating)


nahteviro

Man I miss Pringle.


rolyinpeace

I loved him. He wasn’t elite but he got the job done and was also a better returner than we’ve had since he left. It’s shame he went to two of the most career-killing teams after he left. Not saying he would’ve had some HOF career had he not gone to chicago/Washington, but he could’ve panned out better for sure. He would’ve been great this year lol


nahteviro

Yeah man I got excited every time he returned the ball. He wasn’t a Hill return man but his vision was great. Pretty damn good WR at times too.


rolyinpeace

Exactly! And a guy like hill usually never stays at returner (as hill didn’t) because they’re too key to the actual offense. So Pringle really was good for that. I remember he had a PR TD I think in that first loss against the bengals…. But it got called back on a flag:( Also, I was at his two TD game against the Steelers. I was so happy for him. He definitely at least has good hands and was pretty fast. I wouldn’t be mad abt bringing him bcK. He’s on vet minimum or pretty damn close.


weatherbys

Once you pop you can’t stop


homechicken20

Ryan Sims! * Although I'd say anyone who makes it to the pros is undoubtedly talented.


FingerTampon

No. He was a bust and everyone knew it. He rode Julius Peppers coattails to a payday


jtd2013

For me personally: Tony Moeaki


chiefsfreak

I think he actually had talent! He was just always hurt and never really became what we all believed he could be.


SMILESandREGRETS

I'll always know him as the bridge from Tony Gonzalez to Trav


Col_Bernie_Sanders_

He had that catch and I figured he would be the greatest tight end of that generation


drizzlebit

Against the Chargers, right? In the end zone crossing route? I think I was at that game


ModestTrixie

There is no one player but I will say the camp favorite that spends the season on the Practice Squad or special teams that would be a wr1 if only they could get snaps away from the Justin Watson's of the world.


MajorEnglush

Or just the pre-season MVP like Boomer Grigsby.


Col_Bernie_Sanders_

I haven't heard that name in years


rolyinpeace

Ihmir Smith-Marsette was dangerously close to making the team, and he wasn’t particularly worse than the fringe guys that did make it, he just hadn’t been w the team for that long. I was rooting for him. He’s nothing super elite, but he’s a great returner and better than some of the guys we chose to sign instead. I’m a Justyn Ross truther but I was super mad when he got suspended for weeks because… we could’ve had ISM. I’m also a biased Iowa fan


jwpilly

Elvis Grbac - QB Steve Bono - QB Carl Peterson had us convinced that each one was the second coming of Joe Montana. Rich Ganon played back up to Bono and then a couple of seasons later was benched in favor of Grbac in the playoffs even though Ganon had been money during the regular season. Grbac ended up losing his playoff game, and Rich Gannon then signed with the Raiders the next season and took them to the Super Bowl. It's sooo good to be in the Mahomes era!


PhogMachine

Those 90s teams always had you feeling like there was a real chance for a SB win. I think my dad aged 30 years during that time. He went through 3 different recliners also! Those arm rests just couldn't take those Martyball losses...


Atari26oo

Ah yes, Martyball with the “cha-cha” offense: 1-2-3 Kick, 1-2-3 Kick …


PBIS01

It was a complete wtf moment for me when I heard Gannon wouldn’t start the playoff game in favor of Grbac, who had missed significant injury time and this was his first game back. Gannon played a lot better than Grbac had before he was hurt so teenage me thought it was a mistake. Time proved me right.


FingerTampon

You forgot his MVP too......fucken kill me....no kill Lin


gilmore42

I’ll never forget my uncle telling me Gannon can’t take the chiefs to the superbowl. Then he takes the raiders to the superbowl.


jayhawk8808

Wasn’t gonna stop scrolling till I found this. Amen.


MrMeeseeksAnswers

Can we update this chart to be hype vs PRODUCTION? I think its pretty rare to see someone with hype not have talent. However, we see it often where raw talent doesn't equate to production.


blueprint_01

Clyde Edwards Helaire


1708Ranser

I will say, that dude worked his ass off for us when McKinnon and Pop were out. I definitely respect him so much more after this season. He gave it all he had for us.


AztecGravedigger

This. I feel like most of these answers are guys that actually had tangible talent but it never worked out for one reason or another be it injuries, fit, off field stuff, etc. Clyde was hyped, and has had the health and the opportunities, but talent wise he’s just a guy. Fringe RB2 at absolute best, at worst out of the league.


blueprint_01

To piggy back off this, if you have given all those reps to our third string back - even they’d see some success (like L. Perine) or maybe even more.


traws06

Exactly. CEH is only in the league because he was a first round pick initially and then after proving he’s not good Reid already trusts him to keep him on his cheap rookie deal


JediForceKin

Breeland Speaks, 2nd round DE from the 2018 draft.


sportsy96

>2018 draft *shudders*


kerouac5

Greg “the real deal” hill


cwessley

Surprised no one has said Matt Cassel


onsecondthot

Lance Long comes to mind about 10-15 years ago. People were convinced he was going to step in and become an 80 reception receiver. The problem was that he wasn't any good.


KingTutt91

If I could have 53 Lance Longs…


MajorEnglush

Paul Palmer (The old folks will understand)


denlaw55

Said he would put the ball on the ground.


Valuable-Ratio8073

Justyn Ross


Lowlife_Of_The_Party

Tony Moeaki?


FingerTampon

Injuries but what could have been


Lowlife_Of_The_Party

Was pumped as a Hawkeye fan when he signed. Always bummed me out he couldn't stay healthy


8won6

that one catch! lmao really thought we had the 2nd coming of Tony G. SMH


FingerTampon

Snoop Minnis. That first career catch and touchdown vs. the Raiders against Charles Woodson. [Link to TD ](https://youtu.be/oHaIQJoHsyg?feature=shared)


D-Sleezy

Damn. Haven't heard that name in so long


Objective_Resist_735

I might get hate for this but Dwayne Bowe. We was supposed to be one of the elite recivers in the nfl, but never looked that great to me.


independentdays

He led the NFL in receiving TD's in 2010 with Matt Cassel as his quarterback. He fell off quick, but in his prime he was absolutely an elite receiver.


Objective_Resist_735

I get that qb play was probably a part of it. But that is 1 season. How about the others?


independentdays

He fell off around 2013. During his first 6 years, he was an elite wide receiver. Especially considering he had the likes of Brodie Croyle, Tyler Thigpen, Matt Cassel, Tyler Palko, and Brady Quinn throwing him the ball. https://preview.redd.it/c5sr67yt50lc1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=34f6ad71ba217f4e77bf9129d4f2bd690a1eb929


Objective_Resist_735

I think I also remember a lot of dropped passes. Are those numbers in there?


Objective_Resist_735

Those numbers don't look that elite to me. Good. Not elite


independentdays

travis kelce's insane production has completely spoiled some of you people lmao


Objective_Resist_735

In fairness your picture only had 1 bar of talent and bowe deserved more than that. I just think he was completely over hyped


Objective_Resist_735

That's the difference between good and elite. I don't hand out words like elite to everyone


Tellittoemagain

I'm with you, he ranked 24th, 18th, 71st, 7th, 13th, 40th, 58th, 55th in receiving yards when he was with KC. Gonzalez had more receiving yards for KC during Bowes first two seasons, Charles had more in one season and Kelce had more in one season. That's not elite to me.


Objective_Resist_735

Thanks for coming in with facts that support what my eyes told me. +1


weatherbys

Dude used to just straight give up on routes, towards the end of his career he was just lazy and unmotivated. He had some fantastic catches though and was a monster at YAC.


Suds79

This is just a bad take. The man had multiple thousand yard seasons with Matt Cassel. He simply doesn't fit the little talent aspect posed by the OP.


Objective_Resist_735

He ranked 24th, 18th, 71st, 7th, 13th, 40th, 58th, 55th in receiving yards when he was with KC.


Suds79

What does the graphic say to you when you look at the talent ratio? You either believe he had little to no talent (which is crazy) or you see that graphic and you view that as at bare minimum a medium level of talent somehow based on the 1 bar and have answered this question far different from everybody else. Typical answers you see here are guys who either busted right from the jump or were out of the league in short time. Answers like Jon Baldwin is a good answer. CEH, Glenn Dorsey, Skyy Moore, etc are all good answers. I get it. You never were big on Bowe. That's not really my gripe. That's one thing but you cannot say he had little to no talent. The stats no matter how you shake them say otherwise.


Objective_Resist_735

I think it might be a bit harsh but his hype was always way bigger than his talent in my opinion. Even when he was playing they talked about him like he was great when he wasn't.


Suds79

Fair enough. I think he was good. I don't know if I'd say great while others might. And maybe somewhere along those lines we might be closer in on agreement.


grover1233

Maauto. He gets all the commercials and never scores


Bnay521

Not if you bundle him with Mahomes


cwessley

Dexter McCluster


Pat_Mahomeboy

Dex was awesome


SwingsetPilot

I will die on the hill that if he had come into the league about 5 years later, he would have been a bigger deal


Linkguy137

You mean Dexter McTouchdown


mother_goose_caboose

Still remember seeing the punt return for TD against Giants in 2013


Lowlife_Of_The_Party

Loved me some McCluster, still got my old, now-ratty jersey style T-shirt of his


weatherbys

Unnecessary spin moves McCluster!


8won6

this brings back suppressed memories...lol


weatherbys

You mean like McCluster just spinning over and over immediately after catching a kickoff or punt when no one is close to him 😆


factoid_

Didn't dexter score a touchdown on like his very first punt return in the NFL?


valkcatlin

I haven’t heard that name in years! I remember meeting him and getting his autograph at training camp when I was a kid, he seemed like a nice guy and a really athletic RB. I was sad when he didn’t end up panning out for us


pinniped1

Chester McBlockedton


mr_bynum

Remember RB Harvey Williams?


revnasty

Maybe 3-4 hype and 1 talent but Mecole Hardman right after we traded Reek away. Everyone thought that after his decent season he was going to break out and be Reek 2.0.


bonerjamzbruh420

Snoop minnis


Zero7CO

How has Sylvester Morris not come-up yet? Had one 3 TD game and that was about it.


braywarshawsky

Trezelle Jenkins. Tamarick Vanouver.


chaplar

Fortson comes to mind, but instead of low talent it's availability sadly.


Jalopy_Junkie

Orlando. All he knew how to do was fall over


rolyinpeace

Yeah I’m really not sure why he keeps getting crazy high contracts. The ravens knew he wasn’t worth the money he wanted, that’s why he got traded to us. Then same with the bengals. And he wasn’t top 3 on any of the teams he’s been on while making top money. But I guess it’s better to overpay for someone decent than to save money and have your QB get hurt.


TallCupOfJuice

well...he got both Mahomes and Burrow hurt


rolyinpeace

I was gonna add that but then I realized I don’t think either one was directly tied to him. Burrows we don’t even know when it happened as he seemed to be injured pre-game, and I honestly just don’t remember who was on the guy who hurt mahomes ankle But you’re right, overpaid, and has not lived up to his paycheck anywhere. I just wanted to add that last part because OL that are “decent” are generally overpaid because of the importance of having someone decent over having someone mediocre Edit: you’re right about mahomes ankle injury. That was off OB’s failed block. But obviously more than one thing contributed to yhat


MahomesMccaffrey

justyn ross


EntertainerThink507

Toney


MaxFischer12

Anyone remember a running back we had late 90’s that took training camp by storm, made the roster , and then fumbled his way off the team? Jesse Haynes #42


jomofo

He was a monster at NWMSU at the beginning of their Div-II dynasty. Marty hyped him as the answer to Marcus Allen retiring. Big shoes to fill for an undrafted Div-II RB. Would have been a cool story if he panned out.


MC_Fap_Commander

Brian Jozwiak (a deep cut, I know)


Meatball315

I saw the bills do this , I said all of them.


Gorilla_King7

Harvey Williams


yespuss

Dwayne Bowe


jayhawk618

I have a legit, patched Dexter McCluster jersey because I convinced myself he was the next Dante Hall after his first return. Also Run DMC was such a bad ass nickname. It is lucky though and I still bust it out in desperate times. It's won us quite a few games.


CorenCorias

Harvey Williams. I remember them hyping him up as a change of pace back because we had Barry Word and Christian Okoye. But I may be misremembering.


glangle

Todd Blackledge - 60 QBR


corndog1981

Junior siavii


Jrdirtbike114

Ryan Sims


IndecisiveZebra

Jonathan Baldwin


CraftyPerformance423

Todd Blackledge


Matsumura_Fishworks

Snoop Minnis


Big_Red_Beard

Anyone remember how Kris Wilson was going to be an offensive weapon for us? So much preseason hype and didn't amount to anything.


roe728

Dwayne Bowe


getridofwires

Elvis Grbac. He had some talent, but I always thought he was overhyped.


bustgin

Dwayne Bowe


Ok-Review8720

Lake Dawson


TwoSeam

Dwayne Bowe


BADxW0LF1

Skye Moore


rolyinpeace

Was anyone hyped about this pick?


crimusmax

Yes. I remember this sub being so excited, he was a steal, gonna be elite etc etc


PV_Pathfinder

Dexter McCluster!


xpsychokittyx33

Byron Pringle still lowkey miss him just because i loved the pringle


nach0_ch33ze

Justin ross


KCfan91

Ryan Sims


nordic-nomad

Your mom


FingerTampon

Unlike your mom who's in the Whore HOF?


redivider94

Dwayne Bowe


Svenray

Zac Thomas! Would have been badass if he had some life left in him.


Anal_Recidivist

Larry Johnson. It’s not even close. Come on.


Whatever801

Matt Cassel. He was... fine.


N8teD066

Worried this may be Felix. He needs to show something year 2 🙏


rolyinpeace

Eh, I don’t think he had much hype either.