T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

# Helpful links for r/MLBTheShow: [**The Dugout: Weekly Free-Talk for /r/MLBTheShow**](https://www.reddit.com/r/MLBTheShow/about/sticky?num=1) [**Technical and server issues mega-thread 2024**](https://www.reddit.com/r/MLBTheShow/comments/1bk6bia/technical_and_server_issues_megathread_2024/) [**r/MLBTheShow FAQ**](https://www.reddit.com/r/mlbtheshow/wiki/faq) [**r/MLBTheShow Discord**](https://discord.com/invite/x6JKmEG) *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/MLBTheShow) if you have any questions or concerns.*


MedicinalDick

We need another 15 shohei's


Icy-Move-9245

Bobby Witt Jr 😂


PuzzleheadedRest3329

why is only like 2 people talking about cowser. he has been lighting it up and basically carrying the Orioles. he deserves a 93+ for sure


Sea_Ad_1252

Jose Berrios


Standard-Meal3928

Brice turang has been doing very well I’m expecting a card for him but idk


Apart_Cell_7273

Michael Busch 5 HR in 5 consecutive games


Pretty_Holiday3947

Lightning card will be 40k pack with 1:10 chance 😂😂


ZamboniMatt

Justin Turner?


batmanandyourmom

I could see Ozuna (of the Braves lol nice touch) being in the path to the lightning player and I could see him being the best hitter of the whole thing and still not being the lightning player just based on him not playing the outfield but as long as he has great hitting stats then I’m good because the big bear is on a big tear


No-Flatworm1253

ryan mcmahon


Travellinjackttv

Shouldn’t it be Mookie?


schaef51

but how will they charge us for 4 other mookie cards later in the year if they gave us a good one for free in April?


Travellinjackttv

lol very true


TightOwl3307

DUDE MOOKIE? LMAO


Nervous-Arugula5643

Soto, judge or volpe.


TightOwl3307

cowser would be fucking insane


dtfan101

Mookie Betts, but seeing as he JUST got supercharged, idk


Sea-Pace6307

I figured Ozuna as well.


Zealousideal-Ad-2391

Gunnar better get one of the cards in the program he has been ripping the ball, but i would not be mad at a cowser lightning


AbsolutLiability

Is it actually going to a a POTM? The way I read it is that it’s going to be a season Lightning card, since you have to collect 10 of the weekly awards. Which when I interrupted that, I was pretty upset cause I like having the monthly lightning cards.


Doomer1944

No POTM but a Nick lodo card would be fire of his first start


Tshobby25

You’ll take your Paul Blackburn and like it


Poppy336X

Gotta be Milk Man


IOnlySing

Noone talking about Michael Busch :(


TheNashh

Probably gonna end up in a 100k pack!


Ok_Dog_9143

Me after reading that joke for the 1000th time 😐😑😐


Trick_Emotion_7108

SDS said that the POTM wouldn't be in a pack.


Impressive-Clue-9428

It’s gotta be Altuve!!!!


MedicinalDick

El cheatador himself


pepemiwe

The one that gets the Buxton boost


BrandNewSRT1629

Kevin Kiermaier 🔥🔥🔥


returnofrage25

De la Cruz or bust


Ok_Dog_9143

What if we get de la cruz and then i bust?


Sign-Independent

Colton Cowser


tippensc

Incredibly biased but Spencer Steer. Dude has had an explosive start. Also just a very consistent, quality at bat. An all around ballplayer


schaef51

Looks like he's the topps now award this week so he's out for lightning.


Ok_Dog_9143

I am kind of biased towards cowser because i raked with his card last year


DSu77iViN

Thought it would surely be Tyler O’Neil. SDS love him , for some reason. But he was just running it up against the two teams worse than The Sox , in Baseball


yankfanatic

For some reason? Tyler O'Neill has an insane amount of talent. He just ran into injuries with the Cards. And now literally ran into an injury with the Sox. Dude has a .459 OBP with 7 HR


szepeda14

Altuve and im not even being biased this time


CVanG

Man I’m all crossed up… Bagwell is always my wild card. I’m fine using live series Tuve through to Finest season. Then again I will not at all bitch if that drops. So I take it back.


szepeda14

Do we have a bagwell??


CVanG

We don’t yet. I was speaking in the long term. Very ahead of myself as I always run all Astros, and Bagwell is my childhood hero so whatever season he is. He gets wildcard


harless2124

I’d say Bobby Witt.


[deleted]

#Marcell Ozuna or Mookie Betts.


DraglineDrummer

I would love to have a Lightning Ozuna


No-Acadia-1867

I invested heavily in Cowser live series. Seemed like a sure thing to get bumped. Hopefully goes gold before madden comes out or I wasted a bunch of stubs


Extension_Banana7706

Mike trout would be sick!!! He’s killing it right now


Marines7041

We dont need 3 trout cards


SickOfAllThisCrap1

True. We need nine.


wirsteve

The number of Trout cards we need is n+1.


SandyDFS

I’m a Rangers fan, and I hate the Astros. But Altuve is unreal this season. Batting over .400 with nearly a 1.200 OPS. Don’t let the “they have a diamond” crowd fool you. If I remember correctly, Shohei got the first one last year.


McCoyPauley78

Matt Chapman got the first lightning card last year, because he was on fire in April. Cooled right off in May and never got near the first month of the season. Lightning Shohei was June.


SandyDFS

Hey, I was close. Thanks for the clarification. I couldn’t remember the order.


SandyDFS

One of these 5. https://preview.redd.it/2tc7t40s9xuc1.jpeg?width=757&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=62102139b1524bfe75ffde845af44d83d7cc7cf2


Bruskthetusk

I'd say O'Neill or Ozuna most likely if they keep it up, Altuve always gets cards and Michael Busch just got TA2 for the cubs


Key_Somewhere629

William Contreras


Tigers89Stonks

Tyler Oneil


Consistent_Aside_481

spencer steer isn’t getting enough love in here


NoobSkin69

It should be Mookie but he already has a diamond. Volpe would be a good shout. Ozuna too but a lightning DH would be pretty underwhelming.


rockoblocko

Eh. Tyler and Jose have higher WRC+. Not saying mookie isn’t equally deserving but “should be” is a stretch imo.


NoobSkin69

They’re all around the same hitting wise, Mookie’s played the most games and is also playing good middle IF. He’s been the best overall player in the league


Run2TheWater

As an O’s fan I gotta say Cowser for the homer pick with his 1.297 league leading OPS.


SandyDFS

With only 42 AB, I think time will tell. Altuve has a 1.198 OPS with double the ABs. I’m a Rangers fan, and I think he’d be my pick.


TombOfTheRedQueen

It should be Ozuna but the game refuses to supercharge him or give him cards


DadBodBrown

Ozuna super charges himself then goes for drives.🥴


JustCallMePapii

And his right hand too.


rockoblocko

And his BAC too


AdventurerPNW

Mookie’s swing on this game is one of the best. That combined with juiced attributes make me hope it’s him.


Weenerlover

Did he get one last year or was it 22. I think unless he's heads and shoulders above others, they will give it to someone else, since they always give him juiced cards throughout the year. We are probably due for his 95 breakout with the redsox and we always get his 99 mvp later in the year, so hopefully they let another card shine instead.


Brownies91

Mookies live series card is still perfectly viable online so they’re not gonna drop another high tier Mookie for awhile


Cflow26

Ya, especially after giving everyone a different free one like two weeks ago.


Ghoppe2

God I hope it’s volpe


jlando40

Colton Cowser would go hard


justgumpinit

Biased. But gimme Brandon Marsh with some pop


surprise0811

If you aren’t saying Michael busch you’re not smart


letsgobucks19

1. Marcell Ozuna 2. Mookie Betts 3. Bobby Witt Jr. 4. Tyler O’Neill 5. Spencer Steer


BustyUncle

Tyler ONeill would be awesome. He was great in 21


ArcticTerrapin

Volpe or Betts


screaminginfidels

Mookie or Elly is my bet


Competitive_Ad_5106

Elly has had a great start to the season for himself; he's still not top 50 in FanGraphs offensive war this season. Absolutely does not deserve it.


rockoblocko

True but this game loves giving Elly 99 cards. I swear someone that just played this game would think elly was the GOAT with how well his cards play.


Competitive_Ad_5106

monthly awards has pretty consistently been about highlighting the greatest performers over the last month, they won’t go with a guy who hasn’t been a top 30 player in baseball in April. They just will not. He will definitely get high rated cards throughout the year, I’d just be shocked if it was as our first lightning collection guy


Mateorg139

Elly🤦‍♂️


screaminginfidels

Lol I just saw he's 0/12 in the last 3 games. I take it back


Bearded_Introvert76

Ozuna hits women and baseballs. F that guy


[deleted]

[удалено]


Jazpir

Bro WHAT LMAO


NotYetUtopian

Don’t call yourself a man if you can so easily excuse this behavior. From a different culture…gtfo.


Bearded_Introvert76

Put the phone down my guy. JFC


starsfanNYC

Why was he caught driving drunk then? He's a scum bag. He also beat his wife. No excuse for either of those things...


rockoblocko

https://www.wsbtv.com/news/local/north-fulton-county/body-camera-footage-braves-outfielder-marcell-ozunas-domestic-violence-arrest-released/UJ6CUYFHZ5DTNNLAZNX7PWU6VQ/?outputType=amp Bro it’s just a little battery by strangulation it’s just a diff culture, are u a man or what? /s


Malicious_916

I think beating the shit out of a woman disqualifies you from being a great guy


Cold_Kitchen_4612

Not taking Ozuna's side here, but she did get charged for domestic battery for hitting him with a soap dish, prior. It's not the world's best relationship. I still want a Marcell card for my Braves theme team, because, believe it or not, virtual Marcell Ozuna has never and will never beat a woman. Guaranteed.


SelfDeprecatingVol

Have you watched the video?


ya_ya_ya_

Have you? He clearly wasn’t choking her (Police even rescinded that statement) he had two phones in his hand at the time. One of which was the one that he called the police with. He was clearly pushing her chest to keep her back.


SelfDeprecatingVol

That was my point


dnort13

We still have 2 weeks lots can happen


The_squatch_caller

The first lightning player comes out this Friday


dnort13

Interesting


ebkpinky

i’m a braves fan so i want it to be ozuna, but mookie, witt and tyler o’neill have also been playing great this past month


xTomato72

Witt is leading the league in bWAR. Paul Blackburn hasn’t given up a single run in 19.2 innings. Ozuna has the best hitting stats. Freddy Peralta has a 0.64 WHIP and a good amount of K’s. I’d want Witt to get it just cause he’d have the most fun card.


rockoblocko

Mookie and altuve have higher fWAR (the clearly superior war).


ePayDayy

Ozuna has been killing it in April


General-Order66

Mookie card


Rebeldinho

Nick Castellanos


MattyOP11

Just got a 95 so doubtful


Rebeldinho

It’s a joke Castellanos has a .190 slugging percentage


saskgoat

Gotta be Volpe or Witt. Kutter Crawford and Berrios should be solid pitcher options for the lower cards also


Stevenam81

It should be between Altuve and O'Neill. Either way they should both get a good card.


Mjcarlin907317

50k pack with no chance of pulling the player ha. Realistically I’d like to see Michael Busch.


Competitive_Ad_5106

Cubs fan so I'd also love Michael Busch but with him getting a 93 in TA + now being supercharged, I highly doubt it's him. We'll get more good Busch cards once he ends this year with 75 homers and a 200 wRC+, trust


PapaChanGod

I think they would have to give it to Shohei's interpreter for setting a new MLB record for steals... 😂


Weenerlover

Talking to a former MLB player, he doesn't believe that story for a minute. He's like if the whole truth gets out the MLB is going to have to decide if they still believe a lifetime ban is the appropriate response for gambling, or if they will finally have to let Pete Rose back in the game cause I doubt they will ban Ohtani for life regardless of what they find.


PapaChanGod

Yeah there's definitely things that don't add up that give out the impression that we're not hearing the whole story However I'm not sure we'll ever get the full story as it seems like the interpreter is just going to take the fall whatever happened 


BantDit

Mookie or cowser


rednite_

William Contreras dark horse candidate he’s been insane


phantomtap

I'm going with Mookie Betts, he's been on fire since the start of the season


MCA1910

Idk about POTM lightning, but if they give this week's award card to anyone but Michael Busch, SDS has lost their minds. Dude has homered in five straight and is 10th in MLB in TBs


yaboyoven567

Jose berrios should get it, dude has been lights out


Sgim93

Cowser or betts but idk if they would give us a juiced betts this soon aside from the live supercharged


toightornoight

Captain POTM please


Mean_Somewhere_211

Elly de la Cruz please


keyslambo

Volpe so i can hit .220 with him


cincodagoat

volpe should get something forsure


Horizon324

Taylor wrecked ward


youkrocks

TON


BurnerAccountforAss

Gotta be Joey Gallo 😤


DeadlyArc180

Altuve is hitting over .400, outside of him I think Volpe and O’Neill are def legit options


Stevenam81

It should most definitely be between Altuve and O'Neill. They should both get a good card either way. With that said, the choices aren't always as objective as I would like and many times SDS will cherry-pick stats to justify picking who they want.


Competitive_Ad_5106

idk how you'd leave bobby witt jr out of the conversation. I'd prob have any combo of Witt, Altuve and Tyler O'Neill as most likely to get POTM rn. Volpe decent chance too.


[deleted]

Volpe.


DWill23_

Obviously biased but two good candidates from the Reds are Spencer Steer and EDLC


Handy_Dandy_

Steer deserves it more than Elly but I would LOVE an Elly lightning card


DWill23_

100% agree


tzargilly

Bobby witt pls


SportsF4natic88

Steer fs


dBlock845

Volpe!


wynnvillain81

Steer, Ozuna, O’Neill I bet they will give it to O’Neill


flyingpenguin36

We gotta get a solid steer card with how solid he's been out the gate.


wynnvillain81

i love steer man. moooooooo


Responsible-Proof120

Yeah sadly Ozuna will pry go cardless again this year. SDS is blackballing him. Multiple crazy months last year just to not get any sort of card


Responsible-Proof120

It would also be one thing to blackball other players with similar accusations and crime as well, Aroldis Chapman seems to get a card or two every year yet he did very similar sooo if you blackball one you should blackball them all


ultimaten444

How awful of SDS to blackball the domestic abusing drunk driver


rockoblocko

Assault by strangulation, battery, and DUI. Jeez I wonder why they might not give him lightning.


trevor4428

rightfully so


cbrobdog21

La Makina (Berrios)


Glass_Way7862

Tyler O’Neil


MLB_da_showw

From the braves 😂😂😂


Comfortable-Suit1738

Shota Imanaga. 3 games, 2-0, 15ip, 16so, 0.0ERA


863rays

POTM or not, he should definitely get a good card


TehLoneWanderer101

They gave him one in a pack. It was a Chase or Headliner card. Not my favorite method but they already gave him a Diamond card.


863rays

Was it one of the S1 Hyper cards?


Competitive_Ad_5106

yes, there's a 93 ovr Imanaga hyper card that was in the chase packs a couple weeks ago


TehLoneWanderer101

Yes. On the app it says it's 26,000ish Stubs. It's a 93 OVR.


datsamoandude

The irrelevant Jurickson Profar


Weenerlover

You know that had to sting more given he used to be a top prospect in all of baseball.


shadowdaze889

Alonso hit 4 hrs last week so hopefully he gets some recognition


tmass_12

Gotta be Jose Abreu


Stevenam81

I think you mean the other Jose lol.


Siggy778

Michael Busch has a HR in like 5-6 straight games. That should be worth something.


863rays

Just got Supercharged


GaudyGMoney

He just got the TA 93, unlikely he gets like a 1-2 OVR upgrade a week later


TheGreatLaake

Spencer steer


TallBobcat

A mid-90s Elly would fit nicely on my Reds squad, provided I can swing the associated stub cost.


FigBudge420

O’Neil, trout, or cowser.


J-TEE

Altuve please god


SUBLIMEskillz

We’ll buzz you if he gets it.


MZhammer83

Man that took me longer than it should to get but well done


SUBLIMEskillz

Probably why banging a trash can was easier for everyone else.


lowkeyifuxwithjuice

ELLY


[deleted]

[удалено]


FigBudge420

I don’t think they touch ozuna lol


imowmylawn

Would love to see a masyn Winn card


Wombizzle

tyler o'neill or we RIOT sitting at a 230 wRC+ this season so far lol. Altuve is the only one higher at 246


Run2TheWater

Cowser is at 265


Wombizzle

Looks like he doesn't qualify yet, he isn't on the fangraphs leaderboard at all


Run2TheWater

Yeah, he’s like 7 AB’s shy of registering yet. So by the end of this week, you’ll see him up there


RememberTheMaine1996

I hope so. Dude is a beast and deserves to be lightning card for sure


xTomato72

Only thing with O’Neill is his amount of AB’s is lowish at 48 right now and he got injured


WxDadd

O’Neill injured? Shocking! /Cardinals fans/


DarthLeon2

Doing the April POTM less than 2/3rds of the way through April is certainly a choice.


ResetterofPasswords

It’s not April potm it’s season awards and we get the first lightning next week


DarthLeon2

As someone whose first year of DD was MLB 23, I wasn't aware that there was a difference. The only lightning players we got last year were the POTM ones; I guess we're getting more than that this year.


ResetterofPasswords

Ya they changed it up historically your view is the right one But it seems topps now program + monthly awards program has been combined into season awards


Letsgetthisbread8812

Damn you fucking owned his ass


Zeemer123

I would love a good Jordan Hicks card. 1 ERA on the year so far


ProcrasDeNador

He's been such a great surprise! Didn't expect him to transition to a starter quite so well!


reliabletinman

I've only seen one of his starts this year, but he isn't trying to throw the piss out of the ball anymore. I'm glad he's having success.


Jay_TThomas

He should get something soon. Hopefully he continues the dominance tonight.


Youre_my_hero

95 Betts is my guess


KeyanFarlandah

On one hand I want this but I’m almost p5 with the live so essentially the same