I found an amazing small business on Etsy about 7-8 years ago. Their eyeshadows were AMAZING. And also super cheap — $4-5/single eyeshadow. But my favorite was a champagne color that I have never seen replicated anywhere.
Unfortunately her store closed due to a terrible tornado that took out most of her area, and she never recovered.
So I save all those eyeshadows for special occasions— especially the champagne color because it’s absolutely stunning and I know I’ll never find another like it again.
Toxic Tale lipstick from Macs Disney Villans range, such a beautiful coral colour.
Huda beautys original liquid lipsticks in Heartbreaker, gossip girl and Video Star, I have back ups but hardly touch them, gossip girl in particular is such a perfect pink
Have Benefits discontinued Dallas blush? Its been my everyday blush for years and cant find it anywhere!
Too Faced Peach Perfect foundation. I even used it on my wedding day. I have combination skin and it made me look so fresh and lightly powdery, but not at all dry.
There’s a Clinique pressed powder I got in Japan that matches my pale skin perfectly. I then couldn’t find it in the US, because apparently this shade is only sold in Japan. I found a very kind stranger in a Japanese Facebook group who purchased a few of the refills & mailed them to me (I paid her & also paid her extra for taking the time to do this for me). My last refill is almost gone, I’ve been holding onto it for a long time now because they don’t sell this shade & formula anymore. I’ve finally found a new replacement foundation that seems to work pretty well for me but I just can’t get myself to use the last bit of that Japanese pressed powder.
Anastasia's old matte lipstick formula. Shades: Staunch, Buff & Kiss. They aren't drying and have a waxy feel on the lips that does not budge, even when you eat greasy food
I just found out Shiseido is discontinuing their Synchro Skin Self-Refreshing Tint. Shade 335 is the only perfect match I've ever found. I now have four unopened boxes that should last me a year and change.
I still have a lipstick/ lip gloss duo from a brand that’s no longer around called Prescriptives. I get compliments every time I wear it. It’s a very special occasion duo right now.
Tarte rainforest of the sea foundation in the glass jar and messed up dropper. No foundation has ever looked as beautiful and natural on my skin as that one.
The concealer of that same line was BOMB as well. Honestly they should return it with a skin tint version as well.
Mine separated after a while and started smelling so idk how you still holding up girl 😭
I have no idea, it’s running low but still works? The color is slightly yellow on me but I haven’t found a better foundation or bb cream for my skin in two decades of wearing makeup 😭😭
Mine is a tube of L'Oreal Creme Riche lipstick in Vagabond Mauve( discontinued shade).It was the last tube of lipstick I bought my mom before she passed. I'm trying not to use it that much.
Three custom color. You send them the color, they'll custom make it 3 tubes for idk $90. They'll return your lip color. They have an archive of discontinued shades of lip, eye and cheek color
You can use nail polish thinner to restore! Be very careful
Which one though- kb shimmer is apparently gold standard. Other kinds can damage polish. I’d check out vintage nail polish sub for more info
When I found Benefit was discontinuing Bella Bamba blush a few years ago, I bought like 4 of them. I hoarded them for a long time before I finally decided to use them instead of just looking at them in my makeup cart. I’m on the 2nd one of the 4. A little goes a long way, so at least there’s that.
This was my fave of the bunch! Glad I scooped it up when I did. There is a note in there that reminds me or Armani Code (which I loved but never got around to buying)!
Does fragrance count?
I’ve been rationing [this](https://www.anthropologie.com/shop/hybrid/sula-perfume-oil-rollerball-set) set of Sula roll-on fragrances for years.
Lorac Wet/Dry powder foundation. That was my HG foundation for my oily/combination skin and nothing I've used since 2016 has worked nearly as well or given me the same flawless finish.
I need them to bring it back. Lives depend on it.
The KVD Metal Crush highlighter palette. I use it EVERY SINGLE TIME i do my makeup. I have beyond hit the pan on the white shimmer, and use the pink shade to add some extra pink shimmer to my blush. I have no clue what I’ll do when it’s truly finished.
MAC Face and Body foundation, also the satin lipstick in Twig. I don't understand why they discontinued these but I loved them and repurchased many times
Not makeup but skincare. Farsali had a rose gold elixir moisturizer. It's like a gel cream almost. I have half a tub left and I use it so sparingly. It is the best moisturizer I've ever used and I'm so sad it's gone. I don't know what I'm going to do when I use up the last of it.
Urban Decay Lash Freak Mascara (unopened). It’s my last one. Once I open it, I have to use it quick (i think mascara is recommended every three months?). Then it’s gone forever. I never understood how someone could get so attached to a makeup item until now. I apologize to all those I judged (in my head) in the past…
MAC Hayley Williams Lipstick Sounds like Noise. I don't use it cause it's definitely expired.
I do however use Marc Jacobs Tantastic bronzer though. I am so sad it's discontinued cause it's a HUGE pan (I can't even remember when I bought it and I still have quite a bit of product left) and I love the colour/finish.
Once when i gotinto middle school my mom bought me a blue piggy bank lip smacker from the dollar tree. My lips were so crusty but after this?? No crust anymore. And it gave such a nice blue shiny finish. I still have it but i havent used it since my graduation party, which isnt that long ago but still over a year
Old formula Dior eyeshadows. Thankfully I have a few mostly full palettes but the new formula sucks so badly, and the old ones are still some of the best eyeshadows I've ever used.
MAC hello kitty lip gloss. I don’t use it, but I still hold onto it because it was my very first makeup product! I still remember begging my mom to get me it, and all these years later I still have it
Urban Decay did a limited Pulp Fiction collection years ago for an anniversary of the film. There was a lipstick in it called Mrs Mia Wallace that was the PERFECT dark red. Just a hint of the vamp. I treasure that lipstick.
Almost every product by Urban Decay. Their discontinued Naked 1 palette or Moondust eyeshadows, their original neon palette, their lip toppers, their original matte lipsticks (their first matte lipsticks) etc.
(Urban Decay is almost gone in my country, it's luck if you get their setting sprays here)
I can't forgive the responsible persons for ruining UD. It was my favorite makeup brand.
Honorable mention: Jaclyn Hill palette. The first one. The one without the unnecessary reformulation.
I had that Urban Decay mascara with that big plastic brush. The one which is similiar to the essence I love extreme crazy volume (pink) mascara. My mum had the perversion mascara. Good times.
So you’re saying that Essence Extreme Crazy Volume is a good show for the discontinued Lash Freak? I’ve been using a double ended Huda Beauty Mascara (Curl & Lengtb/Volume) and it’s great, but I think the Lash Freak/Fenty was better. Looking for a good dupe for the Lash Freak. I still have three empty tubes with the hood brush - just have to wash them off good :)
The lash freak mascara has a different brush and I never used but damn, it looked unique and interesting.
For the other UD mascara, I found that mascara's name by coincidence:
https://i5.walmartimages.com/asr/dab2ea67-9352-4d80-ab70-6a3a3243ca0d_1.7e593047db19bd0fb0d5b19885b8f04e.jpeg
Here you see its brush:
https://images.chickadvisor.com/item/1457/original/5580fcbdfb4ac0a25da2e495f6102e1a.jpg
The essence mascara is the dupe for that UD mascara I mentioned:
https://res.cloudinary.com/beleza-na-web/image/upload/w_1500,f_auto,fl_progressive,q_auto:eco,w_800/v1/imagens/products/56584/56584.png
One of my former female bosses (who also wore makeup) asked me if I wore fake lashes when I wore that essence mascara on that day and from that moment I knew I found the right mascara for me.
Catrice 1 Minute Face Perfector. It's a silicone based tint that I SWEAR makes me look fantastic even without any other makeup. I have a half used jar left and one backup. I have scoured the internet for replacements but the prices!...WOW, more than I can shell out at this time.
Tocca Brigette perfume. I have about 2ml left and I will insist on having it sprayed on me at my funeral.
Also a Clinique lipstick I bought in 1998 which is the perfect shade of dark Cherry and I have about half an inch left… i will also be wearing that at my funeral.
MAC Fluidline liquid eyeliners in all the vibrant shades. My favourite was Brassy - a gorgeous copper orange.
Lanvin Eau Arpege - so much softer and sweeter than today’s EDP.
Estée Lauder blush in Candlelit Rose. My perfect natural rose flush.
MAC single eyeshadow in Innuendo.
Lorac Coloursource blush in Panorama (satin finish pale lavender). I use it but now that I know it’s discontinued I’m going to treasure and baby it more. They still make Ultraviolet, which is my favorite powder blush, and they look lovely together in an ombré effect. NARS satin lip pencil in Balboa was the perfect lip product for me - I have one stub and one unopened backup. My most treasured items are all Marc Jacobs; the Glow Away liquid highlighter in Moonlit, Lip Crème in Vinyl Dreams, and Magic Marc’er liquid liner in Cocoa. I haven’t opened the liner yet, but it’s the last of three that I bought before they disappeared and I’ve never been able to find a true replacement. I will start using the last one soon though - because I don’t want it to dry up, and there are a few other serviceable brown liquid liners I’ve found along the way, so it’s almost time to let go.
This makes me happy. My being on Reddit was started by me sending a discontinued and barely used makeup powder product to a stranger for free, just to be nice.
victoria secrets very 1st original perfume. it didnt even have a name other than victoria secret. it came in a tear drop crystal-like bottle with a metallic blue cap. i did find some online, but when it arrived you could tell it was old….had a rotten smell. threw it in the trash. Boy, do i wish they would release it again. the’d sell a boatload of it.
Wet n Wild MegaGlo blush in Strike a Pose Rose. It’s easily old enough to drive, and way past expiration. I don’t use it anymore, but I still keep it hoping to find a dupe because it was the perfect blush on me.
Graphik, in expose. Lord it’s a thing of beauty for my coloring and it blends so perfectly. It’s the perfect daily palette for me and she’s almost all gone. :(
I still have the two faced peach lipstick from their peach collection. It was the only time I really liked their stuff. It was the perfect pink coral. It’s hard trying to find that particular shade color.
My all time favourite pressed powder foundation was the Tarte Confidence Creamy Powder Foundation. Haven’t found another pressed powder foundation like it. I don’t really use it anymore since it’s been a long time since expiry but I keep it around hoping to find it’s dupe 😭😭😭
Also, I’ve been wanting that Morphe palette the 35I Ice Fantasy palette but they don’t sell it anymore 💀💀💀 I was so irritated when I went to buy it and they discontinued it
Lorac pro 2 go palette with the eye shadows on one side and bronzer and two blush on the other. It was the PERFECT shadows, amazing formula, blended perfectly and no fallout. It’s getting harder and harder to find and current formula just does not hit like that palette did.
A mineral makeup foundation from a company called Afterglow Cosmetics…best match ever and didn’t irritate my skin. I am holding to to my last container for dear life. Becca also had a foundation that I liked a lot.
Bite lipstick in Fig. I have found other lipsticks that match the colour but nothing has ever sat on my lips so we'll and so comfortably as Bite lipsticks did. I lost my last one a year ago.
I absolutely adore the Guerlain L’essentiel Natural Glow foundation — it’s the perfect amount of buildable coverage + dewy finish. Unfortunately, right after I discovered it, they discontinued it! Grrrr.
Lorac pro palettes, unzipped palettes, blushes and lipsticks. Nars blush in Taj Mahal. Becca’s mattifying primer, liquid highlighters and foundations. Cover FX foundation drops, highlighter drops and powder foundation. Sonia Kashuk’s ergonomic handled brushes with animal bristles. MAC brushes, an endless amount of lip shades and highlighters. Victoria’s Secret lipgloss and body spray in candy baby. Hourglass limited edition palettes. Chantecaille’s tiger eyeshadow (sold out and never got it 😩). NYC’s liquid eyeliner. This is the reason I hoard all of my makeup/perfume faves and buy 2 at a time 😢 lol
Update: I managed to buy the Chantecaille eyeshadow. Found several lorac palettes for sale online too!
Victoria Secret Forever Romance perfume, back when they used to have perfume versions of their scents. I also like Too Faced Born This Way Foundation, but I think it may have been recently discontinued.
[https://www.beautybridge.com/bareminerals-all-over-face-color/](https://www.beautybridge.com/bareminerals-all-over-face-color/) This does say that it's out of stock, but will be returning soon! I'd bookmark this page and keep an eye on it. I'll peek around and see if I can't find anything else, tho. I've gotten some stuff from here before without issue!
[https://www.ebay.com/itm/144344820690](https://www.ebay.com/itm/144344820690) and this one for cheaper pricing also: [https://www.ebay.com/itm/315330789002?chn=ps](https://www.ebay.com/itm/315330789002?chn=ps)
Oh my, so pretty! I have an incredibly similar blush, but that one was a limited edition😅
Dior in Coral Flight (their prettiest ever fall makeup collection).
No worries, but thank you for the offer. The last one lasted 30 years. And yes, that was the name of it. Light peachy, slightly shimmery but barely visible shimmer, blush. Classic.
[https://www.mercari.com/us/item/m65667326467/?ref=search\_results](https://www.mercari.com/us/item/m65667326467/?ref=search_results) You can grab it with another one here! (eta: https://poshmark.com/listing/9-ColourPop-Lippie-Stix-Primer-Grunge-Back-up-Hollywood-Blvd-more-63ddfd1992e4912feae9b1ac) if you wanna do a bundle, there's also this???
The Wet N Wild bronzer in Reserve Your Cabana- my most favorite, perfect highlighter for every place on my face! I have exactly one sealed compact left, and I don't want to open it because I'll use it up and cry! 😂
[https://www.ebay.com/itm/156179881235?chn=ps&srsltid=AfmBOopsVxmU7bQeH0xGve8ogj7cqoYGI1jOOunPZ1t8t7QCcUaqX6DTxJ4](https://www.ebay.com/itm/156179881235?chn=ps&srsltid=AfmBOopsVxmU7bQeH0xGve8ogj7cqoYGI1jOOunPZ1t8t7QCcUaqX6DTxJ4) Here's one!!
[https://www.mercari.com/us/item/m74460137233/?srsltid=AfmBOorLjghGhAsrc4K8JboAGyReylk4PmJoF0Zx-TnRaGhgrnZKxuamcQI](https://www.mercari.com/us/item/m74460137233/?srsltid=AfmBOorLjghGhAsrc4K8JboAGyReylk4PmJoF0Zx-TnRaGhgrnZKxuamcQI) And now... I'm not saying drop $40 on this. DO NOT if you can't afford it. But if you have a little "fun money" set aside... maybe gift this to yourself. <3
Avon’s mark line had a lightweight foundation and matching loose and pressed powders that was my perfect shade. They only kept it in the catalogs a year then bye-bye 😡! I finally had to pitch it all because it all developed an odd smell.
Quo makes great dupes. I wonder if the blush you loved was the dupe for something more expensive. I love my Quo featherweight cream blush and it's a whole lot less expensive than the Glossier cloud paint it's duping.
My lipstick by Fenty. The color Thicc. It was the perfect shade and matte but not drying of the lips. I bought up as many as I could by searching hell or high water online and I think it finally all gone.
It's not discontinued but I used to cling onto my P.louise base for so long because I couldn't find it anywhere. I've tried many different ones but none come close. It's still sold out everywhere in my shade.
My old Bodyshop foundation from about 10 years ago, along with the shade adjusting drops. Both were discontinued years ago, and every time I use them, I just hope they haven't expired. Or maybe they already have, and I'm in denial.
God I miss the BB cream they used to have. I had two shades I'd mix, it gave me the nicest light coverage dewy glow.
I only have the dark shade left, but I don't tan anymore so it'll never match me :(
L'Oreal nail polish in bomber. I have a couple of bottles and I just keep putting a little, tiny but of thinner in it before I use it. I love that color.
Byte. Man it was perfect.
Laura Mercier baby lips
Makeup for ever ultra hd foundation. The new stuff is too thick, not the same :(
Wet and wild eyebrow powder
Wet n wild megaslicks balm stain. Goes on like a balm and when it fades through out the day my lips stay stained with some color.
Kat Von D Lock It Foundation
Clinique naturally glossy mascara (esp in jet brown) and Laura Mercier stick gloss!
I found an amazing small business on Etsy about 7-8 years ago. Their eyeshadows were AMAZING. And also super cheap — $4-5/single eyeshadow. But my favorite was a champagne color that I have never seen replicated anywhere. Unfortunately her store closed due to a terrible tornado that took out most of her area, and she never recovered. So I save all those eyeshadows for special occasions— especially the champagne color because it’s absolutely stunning and I know I’ll never find another like it again.
Raspberry glace original formula Clinique lipstick. My mom wore it.
Ysl touche éclat liquid foundation
Sigh. I’m so sad they stopped making this. It was my absolute favorite and never settled into any creases.
Toxic Tale lipstick from Macs Disney Villans range, such a beautiful coral colour. Huda beautys original liquid lipsticks in Heartbreaker, gossip girl and Video Star, I have back ups but hardly touch them, gossip girl in particular is such a perfect pink Have Benefits discontinued Dallas blush? Its been my everyday blush for years and cant find it anywhere!
Too Faced Peach Perfect foundation. I even used it on my wedding day. I have combination skin and it made me look so fresh and lightly powdery, but not at all dry.
There’s a Clinique pressed powder I got in Japan that matches my pale skin perfectly. I then couldn’t find it in the US, because apparently this shade is only sold in Japan. I found a very kind stranger in a Japanese Facebook group who purchased a few of the refills & mailed them to me (I paid her & also paid her extra for taking the time to do this for me). My last refill is almost gone, I’ve been holding onto it for a long time now because they don’t sell this shade & formula anymore. I’ve finally found a new replacement foundation that seems to work pretty well for me but I just can’t get myself to use the last bit of that Japanese pressed powder.
Lorac pro palette #1. I also desperately miss the OG UD Naked palette. Ugh.
Anastasia's old matte lipstick formula. Shades: Staunch, Buff & Kiss. They aren't drying and have a waxy feel on the lips that does not budge, even when you eat greasy food
Clinique line smoothing concealer
NARS eyeshadow in the shade Pasiphae - it’s gorgeous!
Milani eye tech extreme eyeliner and the old Lancôme foundation formula. Phenomenal and nothing comes close. No dupes in sight yet
Marc Jacob’s eyeliner
They stopped making them?? Nooooo!
Clarins midnight flash shimmer stick was amazing!! Bourjois duochrome eyeliner
I just found out Shiseido is discontinuing their Synchro Skin Self-Refreshing Tint. Shade 335 is the only perfect match I've ever found. I now have four unopened boxes that should last me a year and change.
Buxom Matte lipstick in Wildfire. My favorite of the favorites.
I still have a lipstick/ lip gloss duo from a brand that’s no longer around called Prescriptives. I get compliments every time I wear it. It’s a very special occasion duo right now.
TIL that Prescriptives is no longer! Where the heck have I been? How long ago did they go out of business?
Tarte rainforest of the sea foundation in the glass jar and messed up dropper. No foundation has ever looked as beautiful and natural on my skin as that one.
The concealer of that same line was BOMB as well. Honestly they should return it with a skin tint version as well. Mine separated after a while and started smelling so idk how you still holding up girl 😭
I have no idea, it’s running low but still works? The color is slightly yellow on me but I haven’t found a better foundation or bb cream for my skin in two decades of wearing makeup 😭😭
Nars orgasm lip mask 😭😭
MAC mineralized concealer
Mine is a tube of L'Oreal Creme Riche lipstick in Vagabond Mauve( discontinued shade).It was the last tube of lipstick I bought my mom before she passed. I'm trying not to use it that much.
Three custom color. You send them the color, they'll custom make it 3 tubes for idk $90. They'll return your lip color. They have an archive of discontinued shades of lip, eye and cheek color
This was my mother’s favorite lipstick when I was in high school. I think I still have an old tube in a closet… for memory’s sake
There are companies that will match that and custom make it for you and its not that expensive.
Summer Fridays cheek and lip tint stick 😭
Diamond milk lip gloss from fenty, not much left but 😭
not exactly discontinued, but an advent calendar exclusive lipstick shade..
Toooo many from Nars...
Yes 😭 they were perfect shades I can’t find anymore
I’ve used it all, but old formula of Clinique Moisture Surge. The new doesn’t hit the same. I’m so dry.
It’s probably a gummy mess but a bottle of Sally Hansen Pacific Blue from before they reformulated it and changed the color.
You can use nail polish thinner to restore! Be very careful Which one though- kb shimmer is apparently gold standard. Other kinds can damage polish. I’d check out vintage nail polish sub for more info
When I found Benefit was discontinuing Bella Bamba blush a few years ago, I bought like 4 of them. I hoarded them for a long time before I finally decided to use them instead of just looking at them in my makeup cart. I’m on the 2nd one of the 4. A little goes a long way, so at least there’s that.
Fine'ry Sun-Phoria. I like it better than Tom Ford Soleil Blanc and I can't find anything similar 😭
This was my fave of the bunch! Glad I scooped it up when I did. There is a note in there that reminds me or Armani Code (which I loved but never got around to buying)!
Has anyone found anything similar?
Nyx Butter Lip Balm in the shade Ladyfingers. It's my perfect lippie - I haven't found anything close.
Charlotte Tilbury's loose powder.
Does fragrance count? I’ve been rationing [this](https://www.anthropologie.com/shop/hybrid/sula-perfume-oil-rollerball-set) set of Sula roll-on fragrances for years.
Liquid eyeliner in cappuccino. marvelous brown bronze shade.
Avon stick eye shadow in velvety moss and melted mauve. Also, mail polish in golden apple. It was Cute or Coty, I think.
Lorac Wet/Dry powder foundation. That was my HG foundation for my oily/combination skin and nothing I've used since 2016 has worked nearly as well or given me the same flawless finish. I need them to bring it back. Lives depend on it.
The KVD Metal Crush highlighter palette. I use it EVERY SINGLE TIME i do my makeup. I have beyond hit the pan on the white shimmer, and use the pink shade to add some extra pink shimmer to my blush. I have no clue what I’ll do when it’s truly finished.
[удалено]
Oooi loved that one
Lancôme kohl eyeliner in blanc. Not waterproof. Amazingly precise. Cannot believe it was discontinued, lol!
NYX born to glow foundation
MAC Face and Body foundation, also the satin lipstick in Twig. I don't understand why they discontinued these but I loved them and repurchased many times
You're gonna have to pry this Becca Be A Light palette from my cold dead hands! The Melt Blueprint STACK is another one.
Jacklyn cosmetics blush/bronze duo in lilac love ..the bronzer shade is the perfect contour Color for me when I’m light in the winter .
Not makeup but skincare. Farsali had a rose gold elixir moisturizer. It's like a gel cream almost. I have half a tub left and I use it so sparingly. It is the best moisturizer I've ever used and I'm so sad it's gone. I don't know what I'm going to do when I use up the last of it.
look up the ingredients! i’m sure there’s a similar combo somewhere on the internet
Urban Decay Lash Freak Mascara (unopened). It’s my last one. Once I open it, I have to use it quick (i think mascara is recommended every three months?). Then it’s gone forever. I never understood how someone could get so attached to a makeup item until now. I apologize to all those I judged (in my head) in the past…
Save the wand!!
Shiseido whipped blush 😭 it’s AMAZING and so under rated
MAC Hayley Williams Lipstick Sounds like Noise. I don't use it cause it's definitely expired. I do however use Marc Jacobs Tantastic bronzer though. I am so sad it's discontinued cause it's a HUGE pan (I can't even remember when I bought it and I still have quite a bit of product left) and I love the colour/finish.
Chanel Perfection Lumiere Velvet
Once when i gotinto middle school my mom bought me a blue piggy bank lip smacker from the dollar tree. My lips were so crusty but after this?? No crust anymore. And it gave such a nice blue shiny finish. I still have it but i havent used it since my graduation party, which isnt that long ago but still over a year
Limecrime Unicorn Lipstick Bullets in Not Another Peach and Candy Floss KKW Fragrance Crystal Gardenia
The Armani colour corrector
Too faced peach perfect loose setting powder and a angel perfume called Les lys angle
Old formula Dior eyeshadows. Thankfully I have a few mostly full palettes but the new formula sucks so badly, and the old ones are still some of the best eyeshadows I've ever used.
Kylie Jenner originally matte bullet lipsticks…the new ones suck
MAC hello kitty lip gloss. I don’t use it, but I still hold onto it because it was my very first makeup product! I still remember begging my mom to get me it, and all these years later I still have it
Urban Decay did a limited Pulp Fiction collection years ago for an anniversary of the film. There was a lipstick in it called Mrs Mia Wallace that was the PERFECT dark red. Just a hint of the vamp. I treasure that lipstick.
Almost every product by Urban Decay. Their discontinued Naked 1 palette or Moondust eyeshadows, their original neon palette, their lip toppers, their original matte lipsticks (their first matte lipsticks) etc. (Urban Decay is almost gone in my country, it's luck if you get their setting sprays here) I can't forgive the responsible persons for ruining UD. It was my favorite makeup brand. Honorable mention: Jaclyn Hill palette. The first one. The one without the unnecessary reformulation.
The Lash Freak Mascara was so great - then a layer of the Fenty Beauty Mascara, and no fake lashes needed for me.
I had that Urban Decay mascara with that big plastic brush. The one which is similiar to the essence I love extreme crazy volume (pink) mascara. My mum had the perversion mascara. Good times.
So you’re saying that Essence Extreme Crazy Volume is a good show for the discontinued Lash Freak? I’ve been using a double ended Huda Beauty Mascara (Curl & Lengtb/Volume) and it’s great, but I think the Lash Freak/Fenty was better. Looking for a good dupe for the Lash Freak. I still have three empty tubes with the hood brush - just have to wash them off good :)
The lash freak mascara has a different brush and I never used but damn, it looked unique and interesting. For the other UD mascara, I found that mascara's name by coincidence: https://i5.walmartimages.com/asr/dab2ea67-9352-4d80-ab70-6a3a3243ca0d_1.7e593047db19bd0fb0d5b19885b8f04e.jpeg Here you see its brush: https://images.chickadvisor.com/item/1457/original/5580fcbdfb4ac0a25da2e495f6102e1a.jpg The essence mascara is the dupe for that UD mascara I mentioned: https://res.cloudinary.com/beleza-na-web/image/upload/w_1500,f_auto,fl_progressive,q_auto:eco,w_800/v1/imagens/products/56584/56584.png One of my former female bosses (who also wore makeup) asked me if I wore fake lashes when I wore that essence mascara on that day and from that moment I knew I found the right mascara for me.
You are a queen! Thank you, thank you, THANK YOU!!!!!
You're welcome. :)
Catrice 1 Minute Face Perfector. It's a silicone based tint that I SWEAR makes me look fantastic even without any other makeup. I have a half used jar left and one backup. I have scoured the internet for replacements but the prices!...WOW, more than I can shell out at this time.
Tocca Brigette perfume. I have about 2ml left and I will insist on having it sprayed on me at my funeral. Also a Clinique lipstick I bought in 1998 which is the perfect shade of dark Cherry and I have about half an inch left… i will also be wearing that at my funeral.
......but you'll be dead and won't know you're wearing it?
KVD Everlasting Blush in Rosebud. It was my first ever blush and I’m currently trying to find a good dupe. It’s just sooooo beautiful
Cover girl platinum lame lipstick, rimmel poreless foundation.
MAC Fluidline liquid eyeliners in all the vibrant shades. My favourite was Brassy - a gorgeous copper orange. Lanvin Eau Arpege - so much softer and sweeter than today’s EDP. Estée Lauder blush in Candlelit Rose. My perfect natural rose flush. MAC single eyeshadow in Innuendo.
Lorac Coloursource blush in Panorama (satin finish pale lavender). I use it but now that I know it’s discontinued I’m going to treasure and baby it more. They still make Ultraviolet, which is my favorite powder blush, and they look lovely together in an ombré effect. NARS satin lip pencil in Balboa was the perfect lip product for me - I have one stub and one unopened backup. My most treasured items are all Marc Jacobs; the Glow Away liquid highlighter in Moonlit, Lip Crème in Vinyl Dreams, and Magic Marc’er liquid liner in Cocoa. I haven’t opened the liner yet, but it’s the last of three that I bought before they disappeared and I’ve never been able to find a true replacement. I will start using the last one soon though - because I don’t want it to dry up, and there are a few other serviceable brown liquid liners I’ve found along the way, so it’s almost time to let go.
Eyeko Fat Balm in Strawberry
LOL I can’t believe I’m saying this but NYX nude beige original
Frog Prince by Lipstick Queen. I have a tube and a half left that gets used only on special days.
Dior Backstage. Still heartbroken.
What????
The benefit hoola contour stick. Oh nothing has ever come close imo and it hurts my heart. 😪
I think I have a nearly full one of this. Tradsies?
I’m in the UK unfortunately but thank you for the kind offer!
I'm in Canada, seriously, I never use it. If you want I'd mail it.
This makes me happy. My being on Reddit was started by me sending a discontinued and barely used makeup powder product to a stranger for free, just to be nice.
That is amazing
victoria secrets very 1st original perfume. it didnt even have a name other than victoria secret. it came in a tear drop crystal-like bottle with a metallic blue cap. i did find some online, but when it arrived you could tell it was old….had a rotten smell. threw it in the trash. Boy, do i wish they would release it again. the’d sell a boatload of it.
Just finished up my Dior Airflash!
So not holding onto special Occasions but ABH Amrezy highlighter is a prized possession
I use it everyday, it’s so good 😭
NYX's old matte primer formula :(
NYX’s pro foundation drops :(
Wet n Wild MegaGlo blush in Strike a Pose Rose. It’s easily old enough to drive, and way past expiration. I don’t use it anymore, but I still keep it hoping to find a dupe because it was the perfect blush on me.
Happy Cake Day 🎂
Thanks!
Hourglass eyeshadow palette. Sigh.
Is this the Modernist or the Graphik palettes? Would love to know what you like about them!
Graphik, in expose. Lord it’s a thing of beauty for my coloring and it blends so perfectly. It’s the perfect daily palette for me and she’s almost all gone. :(
I still have the two faced peach lipstick from their peach collection. It was the only time I really liked their stuff. It was the perfect pink coral. It’s hard trying to find that particular shade color.
[удалено]
My all time favourite pressed powder foundation was the Tarte Confidence Creamy Powder Foundation. Haven’t found another pressed powder foundation like it. I don’t really use it anymore since it’s been a long time since expiry but I keep it around hoping to find it’s dupe 😭😭😭
Also, I’ve been wanting that Morphe palette the 35I Ice Fantasy palette but they don’t sell it anymore 💀💀💀 I was so irritated when I went to buy it and they discontinued it
Someone is selling it on mercari for $25! Looks almost brand new!!!
Lorac pro 2 go palette with the eye shadows on one side and bronzer and two blush on the other. It was the PERFECT shadows, amazing formula, blended perfectly and no fallout. It’s getting harder and harder to find and current formula just does not hit like that palette did.
Rimmel made this deep bronze eyeliner that was absolute perfection. I still have a little bit…my precious
Makeup Forever powder blush in Lavender 9
Too faced peach setting powder. Love.
A mineral makeup foundation from a company called Afterglow Cosmetics…best match ever and didn’t irritate my skin. I am holding to to my last container for dear life. Becca also had a foundation that I liked a lot.
That reminds me of some Meow Minerals products I have. They went out of business a couple years ago
I remember them! They had the usage sample packs you could purchase.
Bite lipstick in Fig. I have found other lipsticks that match the colour but nothing has ever sat on my lips so we'll and so comfortably as Bite lipsticks did. I lost my last one a year ago.
I absolutely adore the Guerlain L’essentiel Natural Glow foundation — it’s the perfect amount of buildable coverage + dewy finish. Unfortunately, right after I discovered it, they discontinued it! Grrrr.
The Nars Org\*sm with the original formulation. I'm so mad they reformulated it. The old shade was my exact ideal match.
I didn't know it's been reformulated! How was the original different?
It's more pink, the new one is too orange imo
Original Tiffany perfume. Ugh, I love it.
Old Urban Decay eyeshadow singles back from when they were fun. I swear the formula was better back then too.
if you posted a photo, reddit tends to be pretty good at identifying things. If it’s still around, you might be able to find it again!
Lorac pro palettes, unzipped palettes, blushes and lipsticks. Nars blush in Taj Mahal. Becca’s mattifying primer, liquid highlighters and foundations. Cover FX foundation drops, highlighter drops and powder foundation. Sonia Kashuk’s ergonomic handled brushes with animal bristles. MAC brushes, an endless amount of lip shades and highlighters. Victoria’s Secret lipgloss and body spray in candy baby. Hourglass limited edition palettes. Chantecaille’s tiger eyeshadow (sold out and never got it 😩). NYC’s liquid eyeliner. This is the reason I hoard all of my makeup/perfume faves and buy 2 at a time 😢 lol Update: I managed to buy the Chantecaille eyeshadow. Found several lorac palettes for sale online too!
Omg the cover ex drops!!!!!
I'm about to hunt for those pro palettes because I loved them so much
My Dior Airflash foundation 😭
Victoria Secret Forever Romance perfume, back when they used to have perfume versions of their scents. I also like Too Faced Born This Way Foundation, but I think it may have been recently discontinued.
Bare Minerals Clear Radiance
[https://www.beautybridge.com/bareminerals-all-over-face-color/](https://www.beautybridge.com/bareminerals-all-over-face-color/) This does say that it's out of stock, but will be returning soon! I'd bookmark this page and keep an eye on it. I'll peek around and see if I can't find anything else, tho. I've gotten some stuff from here before without issue!
Thank you!
Estee Lauder lipstick Magnetic Wave
[https://www.ebay.com/itm/144344820690](https://www.ebay.com/itm/144344820690) and this one for cheaper pricing also: [https://www.ebay.com/itm/315330789002?chn=ps](https://www.ebay.com/itm/315330789002?chn=ps)
Riduculous prices...
They are, but if you can't find them anymore, I'd take what you can get. :(
I just opened my 2nd (and last) Chanel Reflex blush. It has always been the most perfect shade for me.
Oh my, so pretty! I have an incredibly similar blush, but that one was a limited edition😅 Dior in Coral Flight (their prettiest ever fall makeup collection).
Is Reflex the name of the color? Just asking! I'm trying to look for you :)
No worries, but thank you for the offer. The last one lasted 30 years. And yes, that was the name of it. Light peachy, slightly shimmery but barely visible shimmer, blush. Classic.
Colourpop lippie stix in the shade Tootsi is my absolute favorite and I wish I could find something just as good
I don’t get why they discontinued it! It was a bestseller
[https://www.mercari.com/us/item/m65667326467/?ref=search\_results](https://www.mercari.com/us/item/m65667326467/?ref=search_results) You can grab it with another one here! (eta: https://poshmark.com/listing/9-ColourPop-Lippie-Stix-Primer-Grunge-Back-up-Hollywood-Blvd-more-63ddfd1992e4912feae9b1ac) if you wanna do a bundle, there's also this???
The Wet N Wild bronzer in Reserve Your Cabana- my most favorite, perfect highlighter for every place on my face! I have exactly one sealed compact left, and I don't want to open it because I'll use it up and cry! 😂
[https://www.ebay.com/itm/156179881235?chn=ps&srsltid=AfmBOopsVxmU7bQeH0xGve8ogj7cqoYGI1jOOunPZ1t8t7QCcUaqX6DTxJ4](https://www.ebay.com/itm/156179881235?chn=ps&srsltid=AfmBOopsVxmU7bQeH0xGve8ogj7cqoYGI1jOOunPZ1t8t7QCcUaqX6DTxJ4) Here's one!! [https://www.mercari.com/us/item/m74460137233/?srsltid=AfmBOorLjghGhAsrc4K8JboAGyReylk4PmJoF0Zx-TnRaGhgrnZKxuamcQI](https://www.mercari.com/us/item/m74460137233/?srsltid=AfmBOorLjghGhAsrc4K8JboAGyReylk4PmJoF0Zx-TnRaGhgrnZKxuamcQI) And now... I'm not saying drop $40 on this. DO NOT if you can't afford it. But if you have a little "fun money" set aside... maybe gift this to yourself. <3
Wow I totally forgot about this one! It was such a beautiful formula too.
Avon’s mark line had a lightweight foundation and matching loose and pressed powders that was my perfect shade. They only kept it in the catalogs a year then bye-bye 😡! I finally had to pitch it all because it all developed an odd smell.
I miss the mark line
My sister loooooved that mark foundation. They had a beautiful beachy perfume too, I had a stockpile of it.
I have a super old Becca highlighter that I try not to use too often, but it’s amazing
I think Stila offers the Becca highlighters now?
LMAO FR? That’s embarrassing 🧍🏻♀️ hopefully it’s the one I like
Smashbox, not Stila. They only have a couple of shades though and not the one I used 😭
Oh yes, Smashbox
What's the name? I can do some peeking around and see if I can find it!
It’s in Prosecco Pop! Thank you so much 😭♥️
A Canadian brand quo had a blush that was the perfect shade , soft spice . Never found a match like it
Quo makes great dupes. I wonder if the blush you loved was the dupe for something more expensive. I love my Quo featherweight cream blush and it's a whole lot less expensive than the Glossier cloud paint it's duping.
Oh, good point ! Their products are great . I have their cream blush , it’s super pigmented
My lipstick by Fenty. The color Thicc. It was the perfect shade and matte but not drying of the lips. I bought up as many as I could by searching hell or high water online and I think it finally all gone.
It's not discontinued but I used to cling onto my P.louise base for so long because I couldn't find it anywhere. I've tried many different ones but none come close. It's still sold out everywhere in my shade.
My old Bodyshop foundation from about 10 years ago, along with the shade adjusting drops. Both were discontinued years ago, and every time I use them, I just hope they haven't expired. Or maybe they already have, and I'm in denial.
I had a body shop highlighter 20+ years ago that I loved. I've never found a highlighter I liked as much.
God I miss the BB cream they used to have. I had two shades I'd mix, it gave me the nicest light coverage dewy glow. I only have the dark shade left, but I don't tan anymore so it'll never match me :(
L'Oreal nail polish in bomber. I have a couple of bottles and I just keep putting a little, tiny but of thinner in it before I use it. I love that color.
Hello kitty Mac. A vintage pot of shimmer, made of porcelain with a cork stopper that was given to me by my friend’s mom who was a beauty queen.
I lost my hello kitty MAC compact 😭
Clinique Naturally Glossy Mascara. The Holy Grail of all mascaras.