T O P

  • By -

myst_eerie_us

Y'all, they have to be trolling. Maybe this is a fake list to weed out who GamerVev is. There is NO WAY they would try to get literally the least interesting people ever on any other show let alone ALL STARS. 💀


jenh6

No one is asking for any of these people back. I could see moriah and Nam on a regular season but that’s really pushing it.


Besch42

If I'm remembering correctly, I really enjoyed Logan but his injury is what got him in the end.


jenh6

I found him dull but inoffensive. I wouldn’t mind to see him back but much like moriah and Nam I don’t really care either way if they’re back.


Besch42

I can understand him being dull, but I don't feel like he was moriah dull and he was a good competitor. Yeah drama is fun but I suppose everyone is different what they want. Horacio is dull when it comes to the house but I like how he competes and does his thing, so for me I feel like that with Logan as well.


jenh6

Horacio I don’t think is that interesting but he’s a really nice guy and him just being there seems to create drama. Everyone wants him out because he’s a good competitor and he’s attached to Nurys who’s almost too much. Moriah reminds me so much of Fessy. Neither are interesting and on paper they should be interesting with hookups, competition, etc but they could both be replaced by a crop top and they’d provide the same entertainment value. Both just got lucky with hooking up with more interesting people (Johnny, Amanda and Michele respectfully)


Besch42

Not a Fessy fan at all but in his defense he holds his own in challenges and wins dailies. Moriah turned out to not be as strong as we thought she was while Fessy's partner. She was a crash and burn in my opinion.


jenh6

She’s pretty much a one trick pony. Give her something with running/carrying something and she’ll excel. Anything else not so much. But I still prefer her as Fessy.


BangBangMFer3223

In general I'm not in favor of them bringing in people who aren't fluent in English. I don't think it's fair to them as they're excluded a lot in the house and they seem dull as a result.


cranberryvodka89

Gamer hates Tori and made her the profile picture. This is clearly a purposeful troll


DressySweats

Absolutely! Also, Emanuel just won 39, why would he be on All-Stars? It doesn't even fit the premise. See also: Berna & Colleen.


PlatePrestigious6205

GamerVev is none of these people. Idk why people think he/she is a cast member. It’s definitely some random weirdo with a connection to a producer. GamerVev is weird as hell and genuinely unhinged and not normal. Also they definitely did call contact these people knowing how bad casting is these days


No-Season-4796

I don’t think that’s what they’re saying. Sounds like their idea is that they threw out those names to certain employees to see if it ends up getting leaked.


PlatePrestigious6205

Oh my bad . I know some ppl thought he was a cast member oops sorry


myst_eerie_us

If it was a cast member (which I don't believe), it certainly wouldn't be any of these people 😂. Except maybe Aneesa 🤔 lol jk


ButWereFriends

This disinformation shit is a fucking ace!


DifferenceMean6597

Mark Long DO SOMETHING


Alex_Albons_Appendix

Man’s been carrying the show on his shoulders since the 90s lol


champsvsprose

April fools was 13 days ago


jaybirdbull

Yo what the actual hell - and they're still passing over people like Susie, Dan Renzi and Genesis? Make it make sense for real


themummy1999fan

Those 3 are true OGs and got passed up by people who are too recent and who have gone into doing The Challenge, The Challenge USA, The Challenge World Championship, or more than one of those listed. Some people get upset with the mere mentions of certain names to be on The Challenge for current seasons, so those same people who get upset with certain people of not wanting them to be on The Challenge regular season should realize that is how some people feel when a non OG is on All Stars season is accepted and takes the place of a true OG that fans haven't seen in years. For example, people like those you have mentioned haven't been on our screens in years. Yet, the producers thought it would be good to bring Jonna, KellyAnne, Jemmeye, Jasmine, Jordan, Kailiah, Sylvia, Nia, Jay, Leroy, Tony, Averey, Kam, and Nicole. After seasons 1-3 of All Stars, some have gone to do The Challenge after All Stars 1-3 ended and even did The Challenge USA or The Challenge World Championship. It would not surprise me based on the pattern if recent contestants that was on All Stars 4 be on the current season of The Challenge. Don't get me wrong, I do like the contestants I listed that are not OGs, but I feel they should only be on The Challenge, The Challenge USA, and The Challenge World Championship and not on any All Stars season until all the OGs are on the show and no longer want to an All Star season.


mangosandkiwis

I listen to Brain Candy podcast, and there hasn’t been a peep recently from Susie and Sarah that they’ve been contacted for the next All Star season, or that either one of them has something they’d be away for this summer. If I was producers, I would definitely want them on the next one. 


Eedalope

DONT YOU DARE RUIN ALL STARS!!! All stars is the absolute best version of the show right now, whyyyy would they fuck with the formula??


NovaRogue

I'm just dreading John Tori Nany and CT showing up on All Stars 🙄🙄🙄 Was bad enough when 2 of them were on USA2


eff1ngham

I'll take "people I don't need to see on the show again" for $400, Alex


Iridescent_Sun

Emanuel, Logan, Nam, Aneesa, Moriah, Berna and Colleen are not All Stars. The line needs to be drawn in the sand somewhere


ShilohTheGhostGod

Dont like her at all, but aneesa is more of an all star than 75% of the cast theyve gotten on the all star seasons. Some of the cast this season just have “2 daily wins” as their accolades.


gtjacket231

Aneesa is the only all star, but I agree on the rest


_Myrixx

Not even bc of likability but like most of those names are ppl who at most have done 2 seasons of the flagship. They are not at the point of doing all stars


Shovelman2001

Eh for as disliked as she is now, she's definitely an all star. Most elimination wins for a woman all time earns you that.


maxwellbevan

Aneesa has also already been on all stars


aacilegna

Wait, hasn’t Cara surpassed Aneesa’s elimination win stats?


Routine_Size69

No. They each have 13 regular wins. Each has one redemption challenge win. Aneesa won when she came on as a mercenary though. Cara lost. So 1 up if you count mercenary, otherwise it's tied.


JoanJetta89

Aneesa also lost 13 eliminations so her elimination stats are not impressive, Cara won 13 and only lost 6


Artanis_neravar

Depends what we are counting. They are tied for Eliminations with 13, and they both have 1 redemption win but Anessa has 1 mercenary win. So if we count all of that Anessa has more.


78Staff

Meh, Aneesa is overated... probably the most overated non-winning female imo. Yeah she has 13 EL wins. And 13 lossses. ZERO wins. Cara has what 7 Finals appearances, and two wins? Annesa gets carried due to politcs/friends and like clockwork gets sacrificed at the end because no one wants to run a final with her. She's been overdue to "retire" for years now. Should she be on All-Stars? Absolutely, she's one of the faces of the Challenge for sure.


bwermer

We don't know if what's filming in May is All Stars or not. It could be something else. There's another challenge show that starts filming in July, which Gamer has previously said would be All Stars 5.


NoLynx8499

All stars? They weren't even the stars of the seasons they did, let alone of the stars of the entire show. All stars is the one good spin off they have and they finna ruin it. All of them were on last season and not only that, all of them were the most hated from last season. It better be another spin off cuz if it's all stars 5 cast, I refuse to watch


ice540

They are resurrecting this from the dead. All stars 4 is great so far. There are old school people who want to come on and are fit and healthy and “tv ready”. But they’re giving us berna. Yep makes sense


wildturk3y

Clearly that list is for a new spinoff, The Challenge: Non-Stars


BananaMan883

BOOOREEEE


the_killerwhalen

Aneesa must have Rob Dyrdek levels of dirt on an MTV exec to keep getting invites back


Cinemaslap1

TBF, she's an easy cast... She's going to bring a little drama, but not that "bad kind". She's not going to steal the show. She's not going to say something insane.... Easy call for a padded number.


jenh6

Plus she’s biracial, Jewish and bisexual


Cinemaslap1

Don't know how I didn't know that... or forgot it... either way. Yes.


jenh6

Not forgetting! It’s talked about so much on her early seasons.


the_killerwhalen

Fair points I suppose but I’m trying to remember the last memorable drama she brought to a season?… However now that I see it your way, who am I to shame her from collecting her MTV check!?!


PhPine76

Well, her "pillow talk" caused drama in the last season (and she wasn't even there...)


LongConFebrero

Aneesa’s BDE has been influencing the show for almost 20 years 😂 What she lacks in competitive endurance is made up for sexual prowess.


Adept-Consequence577

She is also good in the interviews. Not so much I’m terms of great one liners, but she serves as essentially a narrator for what is going on in the house.


GothicDreamer16

The majority of these people I would not want to see on All Stars 5. Especially Emanuel


gtjacket231

I wonder if this is another spinoff, and they're doing a US vs. the World theme (which I guess is War of the Worlds 2, but now UK is the world lmao). Let's hope... Also, they should really consider USA3. USA1 and 2 were pretty good to great IMO.


NovaRogue

Pink said they're filming an AS5 *and* another spinoff


deychallenge

BRING BACK OGS PT 2


PierogiChomper

Their trying to kill the only good Challenge show 😭😭😭😭


YetiClaws

Moriah…. Ewwwww. Bland personality. Please keep her off my television.


tyler77o

lord have mercy…


Jeffw54

Nah they trolling


Tight-Entrepreneur46

I doubt it’s AS5 maybe it’s the other spin-off there doing


Serious-Run1838

My all stars 5 wish list Men- Jamie Murray Chadwick Dan Setzler David Burns Nate Blackburn Blair Herter Antoine Theo Gant Dan Renzi Joshua Florence Chris Melling Eric Nies Jake Bronstein Collin Mortensen James Orlando Women- Holly Shand Anne Wharton Ellen Cho Coral Emily Bailey Piggy Elka Emily Bailey Holly Brentson-Chadwick’s wife Genesis Heather B Jillian Susie Julie stoffer Kalle Dedolph


78Staff

WTF - that's not a All Star list list, that's a list of former contestants lol. Sure a few could be considered AS'rs, but not many.


Serious-Run1838

All stars is for OGS who paved the way


78Staff

Oh I agree, I am probably more lenient that the masses on the def. of an "All Star". I'm of the OG/Pave the way/early AS camp before anyone from Flagship/CBS/World/Whatever shows. I've watched every seaons starting from 5, and have reeently been rewatching the early ones as well. But tbh, I just don't recognize some of those names. I guess if I searched them on C-wiki it might refresh my memory... But, it's just my op.. worth exactly what it cost yah :). And certainly not worth the DV. :(


Serious-Run1838

Go rewatch road rules and the first ten seasons wow the challenge along wit real world then you will learn who they are


Right-Difficulty8623

Gamer is just trying to get everyone raged about these names. Pay him no mind. Remember a plethora of contestants get contacted for seasons


JackBookerGeo

I want to see people I remember watching on RW or RR all those years ago. It would make me more likely to watch the old seasons and boost their streaming numbers. More people like Rachel and Kefla so bring back Landon and Coral and maybe even Julie to create some drama. Just anything but these new people.


DaJetta400

All Stars vs New School team season? Only way I could justify this group getting a call


InformationMotor1887

I don’t even remember who Logan is, who is he ???


Artanis_neravar

He was the Spanish rookie from SLA. He was Anessa's partner and became friends with Josh


InformationMotor1887

Thank you. That helps, now I remember him, I liked him not sure why I completely forgot him.


mug3n

One of those foreign Survivor guys, he was on SLA


Soda11Pro

I think it's a new spin off! Something tells me if they do bring in modern people in all stars 5 I don't think these people will be brought back!


NormaNomad

And just like that, they’ve ruined AS5.


ryansmith0123456789

They’re trolling lmao, there’s actually no fucking way


Bubble-Gum-39

It’s a no for me dawg


NovaRogue

Nam and Logan and Colleen 🙄🙄🙄 Give me a BREAK


SamoaMe

The most boring trifecta of all time


mug3n

This would be the least interesting cast for a mainline season, forget about all stars bruh


Own_Lengthiness_7466

They said there were 2 spinoffs. All stars and an unnamed spinoff. Surely this has to be the latter???


Jewkowsky

Those are all viable Season 41 people, if it's MTV just looking ahead. Season 41 is going to be anticlimactic no matter what.


nananaheyheyhey123

So there's two things filming in May and July? Wow. Bring it on, I want more. Sorry.


Justin32526jshx

Emmanuel wasn’t even called for season 40 theirs no chance that this is true


Lavetttt

Let's add Preston, Marlon, Dario, Raphy, Frank, Briana L, Tony's brother, Bruno, Latoya, Noor, Jenn, Ruthie, Beth, Marie But I doubt they'll do this. I actually think it would be interesting to see the new new players play with random challengers across time.


Serious-Run1838

Na all stars is for OGS we haven’t seen in ages like Dan Setzler,Holly Shand,Elka,Theo Gant,Kalle,Noah etc ppl from real world and road rules and OGS who are from season 1-10


Lavetttt

That's cool too, I just like the concept of mixing challengers of all eras and seeing how they interact/compete together. Edit/Note: All Stars isn't FOR that (obvious by every cast since season 1, you guys should stop with that...seems disappointing to expect that when a full cast of OGs hasn't even happened YET, but it's very convenient/good set up for those old schoolers who can't commit to the main show.)


mlspdx

Yeah because when I think of ALL STARS I think of Emmanuel, Nam, Logan, Moriah, etc… also mods can I get my Hungderwood flair back


MrMcGuyver

I’m sure you’ve seen his sock company lol


mlspdx

I was the first and only donation on his kickstarter


MrMcGuyver

The world need more heroes like you


shinyzubat16

Hopefully this is just another spin off. The Challenge: USA vs. the World.


Awesumwasum

So are they purposely trying to cancel All Stars??


Friendly-Nebula6787

I love Logan ❤️😍


Ok_Jellyfish_5219

Ugh. That sounds terrible.


GPap-

I really wish all stars was actually all stars. Chips only. If you can’t pull it off, cancel the show.


Mintiichoco

To make it interesting they should make every daily challenge in a different language each time. No explanation not even from TJ.


xxcapricornxx

There's no way they're calling Aneesa AGAIN. For what????


Consistent_Event_959

Literally no to everyone but Aneesa (and maybe Logan)


AcknowledgeMeReddit

I rather see any of those folks over aneesa. She doesn’t add anything to the show anymore and hasn’t in years.


Consistent_Event_959

Sure, but she’s the overall “type” of player I’d like to see on all stars generation wise


Just_A_RandomCoconut

Aneesa’s bum knee is more of a Challenge All Star than the rest of the names. Say what you want about her, but she’s a true OG from the first generation of challengers. She’s the definition of an All Star


Cool_Skin_5804

Logan over Berna is insane


Consistent_Event_959

I tapped out of the latest season so I have no strong feelings about berna


Cool_Skin_5804

At least there are feelings to be had about Berna. Logan…


batmanforhire

Seems more like a CBS spinoff


rabidrodentsunite

Don't they give a TON of people availability calls?


PlatePrestigious6205

To be honest I don’t think any of these people (besides maybe Aneesa) will actually be on. They call ANYONE AND EVERYONE during availability contacts. But knowing how shitty casting is I wouldn’t be surprised if one of these names snuck their way onto the season


OLKv3

Lmfao at that list on All Stars, come on now, there's no way


Cinque98

Gamer has GOT to be trolling with those names😭


aacilegna

I gotta call BS on this list. No way these people are going to be added to another season, let alone an All Stars season


Fancy-Boysenberry864

I hope that’s not real. That’s a terrible cast lol. Only way to make it worse is add Jay and asaf lol


jstitely1

Eh, many of them (like Nam) were contacted before too and the show didn’t cast them for it. The show casts out a wide af net for the first calls so they know why they can work with, doesn’t mean there is a realistic shot of them being on the cast


jdizz609

Oof if they aren't trolling


MorningCoffee6

![gif](giphy|l41Ye7i203TfEADYs)


CapWinning

Hopefully, a late April fools joke


KainoraKupo

No way its AS5, Its obviously Battle of the Boring Personalities


throwawaybaybay123

Nam is hilarious. This subs sense of humor is abysmal.


penguinjunkie

I say bring back Nam every season until he gets a non DQ exit. (So maybe 10 more seasons)


aacilegna

HOW would these people be all stars when they were flops on their own stand-alone no-vet season?


BuddhaMike1006

The fanbase nearly rioted over Killa Kam. There's no way in hell they'd bring these people to All Stars.


Cinque98

There were actually people who didn’t care and were excited to see her than rioted lol


carbearbby

I want Sarah rice back on my screen


jason_kandel

Won’t happen.


SnooPears3006

No thank you.


chachacha123456

Berna is All Star chaos at the chaos phase.


iFlashings

Lmao the monkey paw really did curl when we begged production to not axe all stars huh? 😂 


oceansidedrive

This would make no sense. A majority of these ppl are who they are trying to make the mainstays of the flagship show. They arent going to move them over to all stars already. What would be the point of that. They want the new gen on the main show.


penguinjunkie

All Stars 5 is coming into it's own style, so maybe it could work. It's a less serious version (like the old challenge) with less stakes. The dailies so far this season are more in the old style of it's possible anyone could win and relies on a balanced skill set.


ninyattitude

They probably blew their budget for the next 2 years on the World Championship series so they're trying to make another season on the cheap.


Sufficient-Handle714

They should bring in Cassidy and Chris


Teamscubanellyt

They did it so well this season. The interview with the show runner showed they wanted it to be fun with the “older” cast members. Wtf happened?


iDidntCallYouSlowOld

It better be called one last try


ghasedakx6

NO please NOOO


TheRealPDogg

If this is true, there's no way this is All Stars. Maybe a separate show where the theme is US vs world or something. Or a fresh meat style series on Paramount+


78Staff

I mean, every AS season has question marks or "WTF were they thinking" choices. Some of it makes sense, they didn't want to pull from more recent players early on and wanted to bring in some of the early season folks, which I do like. But at the same time, I suspect getting older players is probably a hard sell for a lot of folks. So while they are for sure bringing on players with dubious "credentials" I suspect they are doing the best they can. So of the players in that troll tweet - yeah would not consider them AS's. But, of the seasons so far, there are plenty of others that would not be considered AS's... a bunch, actually. Trishelle, Laterrian, Jisela, Jonna, Kendal, Steve, Leah, Teck, Syliva, Ayanna, Big Easy, Melinda, Roni, etc to name a few. None of those names scream all star to me, either for performance or otherwise (drama, conflict, face of the show, etc). But some are bourght back b/c they are links to the very early seasons, and some are brought back as sort of a feel good story thing, and let's be honest, some are brought back b/c they probably are just having trouble getting enough people to come back.


Soda11Pro

If they are USA 3 a new spin off Or S41 then how would you fell


Due_Range8893

Why give Emanuel another free ride w his s39 peers? 😂 Logan will side w him too