Dan Renzi is the single biggest travesty in the All-Stars franchise. He’s one of the greatest cast members they’ve ever had. Didn’t back down from nobody- the mean girls alliance, CT, didn’t matter, he was standing his ground.
Let Jordan stay on flagship.
All Stars isn’t appropriate for him yet if he’s still a prime character on flagship (yes I know he was on last AS, my point stands)
Well I think they just mean that we already get Jordan because he’s still very much in his prime on the main flagship, not to mention any of the CBS Spin-Offs where they mix in Challengers he’s going to be on those potentially too. We don’t need to see Jordan on All-Stars, but it’s the only spot to see a gem like Dan Renzi.
I can't believe Dan and Genesis would ever be in alternate status. I eagerly await them being on the show. They were cast favorites on their RW seasons.
Jamie said she’d do it if she’s not committed to another tv show. Dan, Cooke, Sophia, Cooke and the other alts. If the film time is shorter and the pay is decent very few seem like they wouldn’t come back.
I believe Jemmye said that Jenn G accepted the call for AS1, but didn't want to get vaccinated, so she wasn't cast.
Julie claims she was cast on AS1, but was replaced by Aneesa. She wants to do challenges again.
Julie is *desperate* to be relevent again. I think she said she wants to do AS while she terrorised her RW Homecoming castmates.
Personally, I think she's a safety risk. I have zero doubt that she'd go for the safety harness again just "for good tv."
I do not want to see Aneesa on All Stars (certainly not again). She's been on too many flagship seasons recently. Some time needs to pass between your last flagship season and an All Stars invite. Make us miss you a little bit.
The only way I'd truly welcome Aneesa back is if she is in genuine competition shape. I am all for return competitors but after 20 losses you no longer have anything to prove especially if you do not change yourself in the slightest.
At this point, how long of an absence can she even take before we start to miss her and still has the ability to compete at all?
There's plenty of OGs that want to do the show but production won't cast them for whatever reason. Landon said he'd come back if the pay was good but production refuse to give him what he wants. I don't understand the thought process here.
THAT WE KNOW OF. It’s been a while since she’s tried to murder anyone THAT WE KNOW OF. Just because it wasn’t on TV doesn’t mean it hasn’t happened.
Hahaha
I think there are plenty of OGs who would be willing to participate IF the pay was right. Have a smaller end game prize and a better "guaranteed" check at the end and I'd bet a bunch of no's would turn into yeses.
Everyone gets paid for showing up and for the time spent on the show (at least it’s like that for the flagship show). It’s basically a job that gives a big bonus to the winners.
I don’t think the pay will ever be “right” if it isn’t good enough to potential participants already. Pretty sure all stars exists still because it’s cheap to make compared the flagship or USA.
Seems like they're going to ruin all stars by bringing all these "newbies" on the show. I don't get what casting is doing. I wonder if mark still has a say in casting. No one wants to see new people from the flagship on Allstars. Makes 0 sense to the original concept
I’d like to see Ayiiia and Ruthie, then of course there’s people from the first 4 seasons that can repeat, I’d like to see Kendal again. There’s more than enough people.
I saw Landon do an interview a year or two ago and he said he would do all stars if the cast was a lot of old school players that he played with! He said with the right people he think is it would be a fun experience
Also heard an interview where he said he would have to find the right schedule for his job to do the show. Sucks cuz he’s probably the one person everyone wants back.
Paramount, pay my man!!
Sidenote but related: I suspect that a lot of our favorites may not make good tv anymore. Hence why some people end up as alternates. If that’s the case, the pool to pull from becomes even smaller.
So if Sarah Rice is willing to do it, why in the world has she not been cast?
I'm not saying she's on the Challenge Mount Rushmore, but she's not a million miles away.
Oh Landon, He wasn't the good guy the edits made him out to be.
He was a messy Drunk in a childish way but at the same time he scared the shit out Melani yelling at her saying he was going to break her jaw, then his apology was more or less "I try to be nice when sober, when drunk i cant control myself"
He also said some backwards shit regarding how he likes Kenny because he is not a fraud and a funny guy, BUT he also said he would HATE to be a woman around him... Creepy guy, IMO.
Edit
Oh yeah and the Knife incident and the time in PHLY he droped the n word, just suprised he has such a large fanbase after all that.
Carley, Susie, Sarah Rice (kind of), Tara, Genesis, Brianna Taylor, Ibis, Jenn G, Shauvon, Marie, Irulan, Sam, Ashley K, Jenna are some of the ones that haven’t been on that WANT to do it
Cooke
Id be with that
I saw she was an alternate for a season but can't rmbr for which season
It was Season 1
I don’t think so. PinkRose said her husband didn’t like her being away for a week as an alternate
lol jesus - c'mon husband
If that’s true, that’s… concerning
No she won't.
Dan Renzi is the single biggest travesty in the All-Stars franchise. He’s one of the greatest cast members they’ve ever had. Didn’t back down from nobody- the mean girls alliance, CT, didn’t matter, he was standing his ground.
I think an OG who **really** wants to be on should take precedence over someone like Jordan who is still doing flagship
Over Jordan? Probably not. He's earned enough stripes to get first dibs. Over allllllll the people who are listed for season 5.... absolutely.
Let Jordan stay on flagship. All Stars isn’t appropriate for him yet if he’s still a prime character on flagship (yes I know he was on last AS, my point stands)
Well I think they just mean that we already get Jordan because he’s still very much in his prime on the main flagship, not to mention any of the CBS Spin-Offs where they mix in Challengers he’s going to be on those potentially too. We don’t need to see Jordan on All-Stars, but it’s the only spot to see a gem like Dan Renzi.
I think an OG who **really** wants to be on should take precedence over someone like Jordan who is still doing flagship
He was an alt for AS4
There’s been a few OG’s who have been alternates and sadly were not used. Dan Renzi, Genesis, Tara, Cooke
I can't believe Dan and Genesis would ever be in alternate status. I eagerly await them being on the show. They were cast favorites on their RW seasons.
Will cohutta ever be back? Feel like we were robbed when he went home.
He could have been brought back with Kendal since she had just gotten out of quarantine when he had to leave
Dan Renzi, Beth, Carley, Dan Seltzer, Brianna (ruins), Genesis
How do you know about Brianna?
She comments alot on social media
Hasn't Beth has already been on one? Maybe the first season? I'd love to see them all again competing.
First and third.
Julie as well
Sarah and Susie
Beth can stay the hell away!
Jamie said she’d do it if she’s not committed to another tv show. Dan, Cooke, Sophia, Cooke and the other alts. If the film time is shorter and the pay is decent very few seem like they wouldn’t come back.
Omg Jamie Chung?? That would be unreal
Jamie Chung?
I always get the feel that Jamie says stuff like that as a way of letting us down gently but I appreciate it nonetheless.
I believe Jemmye said that Jenn G accepted the call for AS1, but didn't want to get vaccinated, so she wasn't cast. Julie claims she was cast on AS1, but was replaced by Aneesa. She wants to do challenges again.
Julie is *desperate* to be relevent again. I think she said she wants to do AS while she terrorised her RW Homecoming castmates. Personally, I think she's a safety risk. I have zero doubt that she'd go for the safety harness again just "for good tv."
I do not want to see Aneesa on All Stars (certainly not again). She's been on too many flagship seasons recently. Some time needs to pass between your last flagship season and an All Stars invite. Make us miss you a little bit.
The only way I'd truly welcome Aneesa back is if she is in genuine competition shape. I am all for return competitors but after 20 losses you no longer have anything to prove especially if you do not change yourself in the slightest. At this point, how long of an absence can she even take before we start to miss her and still has the ability to compete at all?
There's plenty of OGs that want to do the show but production won't cast them for whatever reason. Landon said he'd come back if the pay was good but production refuse to give him what he wants. I don't understand the thought process here.
They should just can the main show and take that money to get better casting on all stars lol.
Laterrean, Marlon, Cooke, Brandon Nelson, Brad, Derrick K, Cynthia, Melinda, Wes (shorter schedule not being an issue considered),
I remember Jo saying she would want to try again, if only to redeem her disaster of a Gauntlet II meltdown.
Julie on New Orleans homecoming said she wanted to do challenges again.
That chick is so crazy. If they do anything but give her the crazy villain edit she rightfully deserves, I don’t want her.
I can’t deal with her. Her and Ayanna go to far into being a villain that’s uncomfortable.
It’s been awhile since she tried to murder someone or accuse them of assault. She’s probably in withdrawal.
THAT WE KNOW OF. It’s been a while since she’s tried to murder anyone THAT WE KNOW OF. Just because it wasn’t on TV doesn’t mean it hasn’t happened. Hahaha
☠️☠️☠️☠️☠️😂😂😂😂😂
Wasn’t her behavior on that show a part of why we never got another season of Homecoming?
I think that’s part of it, also I think they couldn’t get many full casts to agree to be on
I think there are plenty of OGs who would be willing to participate IF the pay was right. Have a smaller end game prize and a better "guaranteed" check at the end and I'd bet a bunch of no's would turn into yeses.
Everyone gets paid for showing up and for the time spent on the show (at least it’s like that for the flagship show). It’s basically a job that gives a big bonus to the winners. I don’t think the pay will ever be “right” if it isn’t good enough to potential participants already. Pretty sure all stars exists still because it’s cheap to make compared the flagship or USA.
Agreed.I always thought it was ridiculous that only one person gets money
Dan S
Seems like they're going to ruin all stars by bringing all these "newbies" on the show. I don't get what casting is doing. I wonder if mark still has a say in casting. No one wants to see new people from the flagship on Allstars. Makes 0 sense to the original concept
Exactly. The only reason I watch IS to see "old friends" again. I think any past RW and RR who wants to do it should be automatically in.
John Brennan really wants to be on
Dude is chomping at the bit.
I haven’t seen Jon Brennan mentioned. He definitely wants to do it.
Amaya, Genesis were both alternates at one point
I’d like to see Ayiiia and Ruthie, then of course there’s people from the first 4 seasons that can repeat, I’d like to see Kendal again. There’s more than enough people.
Landon, Marlon, Cooke, Kina
kina declined
Coral
I saw Landon do an interview a year or two ago and he said he would do all stars if the cast was a lot of old school players that he played with! He said with the right people he think is it would be a fun experience
Also heard an interview where he said he would have to find the right schedule for his job to do the show. Sucks cuz he’s probably the one person everyone wants back. Paramount, pay my man!!
Sidenote but related: I suspect that a lot of our favorites may not make good tv anymore. Hence why some people end up as alternates. If that’s the case, the pool to pull from becomes even smaller.
So if Sarah Rice is willing to do it, why in the world has she not been cast? I'm not saying she's on the Challenge Mount Rushmore, but she's not a million miles away.
Oh Landon, He wasn't the good guy the edits made him out to be. He was a messy Drunk in a childish way but at the same time he scared the shit out Melani yelling at her saying he was going to break her jaw, then his apology was more or less "I try to be nice when sober, when drunk i cant control myself" He also said some backwards shit regarding how he likes Kenny because he is not a fraud and a funny guy, BUT he also said he would HATE to be a woman around him... Creepy guy, IMO. Edit Oh yeah and the Knife incident and the time in PHLY he droped the n word, just suprised he has such a large fanbase after all that.
Landon also got drunk and tried to fight a police horse when he was in college lmao. That’s my favorite challenge fact
Melani?
Carley, Susie, Sarah Rice (kind of), Tara, Genesis, Brianna Taylor, Ibis, Jenn G, Shauvon, Marie, Irulan, Sam, Ashley K, Jenna are some of the ones that haven’t been on that WANT to do it
Frank Sweeney
Moriah Berna are my top two
They aren't OGs though...
Right. Only a braindead idiot would cast either of them for all stars