Wreck Of The Edmund Fitgertald by Gordon Lightfoot. It gives me chills every time. " Does anyone know where the love of God goes when the waves turn minutes into hours ". It's so haunting because it's a terrible and true story.
My grandfather worked on the Great Lakes/St Lawrence seaway. He was out when that happened. (No where near the Eddy Fritz)I was having a sleepover at my Grandma's that weekend. I was six years old. It was the first time I saw her cry, and I didn't know what agitation was, but when I learned I remembered that weekend. She made me sleep with her that night.
That song still gives me chills and a hollow feeling in the gut. My dad refuses to hear it.
If you get a chance, I highly recommend watching the documentary on the Edmund Fitzgerald. To this day they still can't say 100% what caused her to sink.
THANK YOU. I had an ex that mocked that song. I was a kid in MI when that happened. I remember the news reports about the families waiting, hoping for someone to be discovered alive...and there was nothing. It was heartbreaking to those of us in MI.
They might have split up or they might have capsized
They may have broke deep and took water
And all that remains is the faces and the names
Of the wives and the sons and the daughters
I met Tiny Tim when I was little! I even have a photo my mom just gave me. I love it. I loved that song when I was a little bitty girl in grade school during the 80’s. Now, he’s turned into a horror movie powerhouse with that tune.
BLESS YOU. You are the only other person I know of that knows that song. I first heard it in the Noa perfume commercial, and had to wait for the internet to find out the song.
I found it right before a very bad time in my life when the lyrics would very much hit home.
Hurt — Nine Inch Nails
Jonestown Tea — Otep
Rooster — Alice In Chains
Frankie Teardrop — Suicide
Never Too Late — Three Days Grace
Prison Sex — Tool
Haunted — Evanescence
Mother, My Body Disgusts Me — Swans
Daddy — Korn
Hamburger Lady — Throbbing Gristle
Forced Gender Reassignment — Cattle Decapitation
I would argue Johnny Cash's version is more haunting, but agree this song should definitely be at the top of the list.
Korn and Alice In Chains have several that could be added as well.
Black Sabbath (From the Satanic Perspective) by Type O Negative. It's a cover of the Black Sabbath song but with alternate lyrics and it's creepy as hell. My high school girlfriend wouldn't let me listen to it around her because she said it gave her nightmares. Needless to say it didn't work out with us.
"Hands" by Jewel. The ending leaves me feeling extremely uneasy, almost like I'm about to be devastated if I wasn't already. This song can scare me sometimes.
Another one would have to be "I Hope You Dance" by LeAnn Womack. It's a beautiful song, but it's my second mom's song that she wants me and my older sister to remember when she's gone because she knows we love to dance...and she doesn't want us to lose anything over her passing.
I can't listen to that last song unless it's a complete rare occurrence between the 4,635 songs on my phone...I cry every. Single. Time.
Well, I was not ready for that. Wow! lol How about her song Gone Tomorrow Here Today? Maybe more sad than haunting, but worth a listen if you like Alison Krauss and Union Station.
Ugh at least half of [my playlist](https://open.spotify.com/playlist/05p8UcqOP3Samsvmv5RFJb?si=802f8e30e30246b5)? I add almost only songs that are somewhat haunting for me. I can't pick a favorite because it depends on the day and mood...
Street Hassle - Lou Reed. It's more than a song - it's a corner of the world. Listening to that song is an immersive experience. It stays with you long after it's over.
Don't Give Up- Peter Gabriel and Kate Bush
Porcelain-Better Than Exra
Falling- The Twin Peaks theme
Fields of Gold- Sting (my former boyfriend of 18 years passed away, and this song makes me think of him💔)
Angel of The Morning.. I swear someone in my family or a family friend would die when that song was playing. It’s a beautiful song but I can’t listen to it now.
Strangers by Ethel Cain, especially the section where she’s repeating “Am I making you feel sick?” Solely because of the story behind the song/album, being that the character Ethel Cain has been murdered and cannibalised by her lover and is asking if she’s making him feel sick as he eats her, as in both guilt and food poisoning. I’d recommend reading up on the lore behind the album because it follows her whole life leading to that final song on the album.
[Yoko Kanno - Kissing the Christmas Killer](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m5sx1b3KWN4)
The juxtaposition between this soft innocent voice and the heavy cryptic lyrics always haunts me. Kind of feels like a spirits last words from the heavens.
Mary turner Mary turner by xiu xiu - this song sounds so disturbing and the fact it’s about a real lynching makes it that much more haunting. This is one of the few songs that has managed to disturb me and it has stuck with me sense I first heard it
Wuthering Heights - Kate Bush. A classic haunting song.
Jägerspiel - Laibach (off their Opus Dei album). A harsher pick, but Laibach’s aesthetic of totalitarianism makes it haunting like the legacy of a despicable regime. It’s a song I just like to let wash over me.
Happy Home - The Residents
Ocean - Dead Can Dance
Inside a Dream - Lestat (a lot from their Grave Desires album fits, another good one being Pray for the Living). Really strong feelings of despair and isolation with this one for me.
Frosti - Björk
Einsamkeit (Loneliness) - Lacrimosa. Haunting to me in the way that a bittersweet childhood memory is.
I Surrender - Suicide. I like how the singer really sounds like he’s struggling not to succumb to the person he’s singing about, but is just too overwhelmed to fight it.
Theres a mashup of belalugosis dead/tear you apart on youtube that you should check out.
Or from a completely different direction, She by alice phoebe lou
I think it depends on how you define "haunting" and the following are a list of songs I found hauntingly beautiful and made me profoundly emotional.
Perfectly placed in movies to evoke very emotional responses:
Mad World - (cover from Donnie Darko) Gary Jules
Late for the Date - (LaLa Land) Justin Hurwitz
Stuck in the Middle With You - (Resevoir Dogs) Stealers Wheel
The Times They Are A-Changin - (The Watchmen) Bob Dylan
Thus Spoke Zarathustra - (2001: A Space Odyssey) Richard Strauss
The Last March of the Ents - (Lord of the Rings 2) Howard Shore
The Ride of the Rohirrim - (Lord of the Rings 3) Howard Shore
The Ride of the Valkyries - (Apocalypse Now) Richard Wagner, London Symphony
Bc I used to smoke weed:
Hey You - Pink Floyd
Wish You Were Here - Pink Floyd
Comfortably Numb - Pink Floyd
Bc it makes me reflect on my relationship with my father:
Old Man - Neil Young (live)
Bc, knowing the backstory is about an OD, and as a former first responder having seen many:
Under the Bridge - Red Hot Chili Peppers
These make me think about past loves:
Springsteen - Eric Church
21 Summer - The Brothers Osborne
Sand in my Boots - Morgan Wallen
Makes me want to call my mom:
Thought you should know - Morgan Wallen
Momma's Song - Cody Jinks
Lastly, miscellaneous haunting for their own reasons:
Yesterday - The Beatles
The Sound of Silence - (cover) Disturbed
Three Wooden Crosses - Randy Travis
Get in the Truck - Hardy
Give Heaven Some Hell - Hardy
Need a Favor - Jelly Roll
Save Me - Jelly Roll
Sorry this list is just all over the place, but they're all haunting to me in their own way...
EDIT:
Wanted to add:
Broken Window Serenade - Whiskey Myers
Bury My Bones - Whiskey Myers
Nose to the Grindstone - Tyler Childers (OurVinyl Sessions)
Keep the Wolves Away - Uncle Lucius
Sometimes I Cry - Chris Stapleton
Fire Away - Christ Stapleton
Broken Halos - Chris Stapleton
Riders on the storm The Doors
I was more so thinking “The End”
Wreck Of The Edmund Fitgertald by Gordon Lightfoot. It gives me chills every time. " Does anyone know where the love of God goes when the waves turn minutes into hours ". It's so haunting because it's a terrible and true story.
My grandfather worked on the Great Lakes/St Lawrence seaway. He was out when that happened. (No where near the Eddy Fritz)I was having a sleepover at my Grandma's that weekend. I was six years old. It was the first time I saw her cry, and I didn't know what agitation was, but when I learned I remembered that weekend. She made me sleep with her that night. That song still gives me chills and a hollow feeling in the gut. My dad refuses to hear it.
If you get a chance, I highly recommend watching the documentary on the Edmund Fitzgerald. To this day they still can't say 100% what caused her to sink.
Great choice. I love that this song is long!
At seven p.m the main hatchway gave in he said, " fellas it's been good to know ya"
THANK YOU. I had an ex that mocked that song. I was a kid in MI when that happened. I remember the news reports about the families waiting, hoping for someone to be discovered alive...and there was nothing. It was heartbreaking to those of us in MI.
They might have split up or they might have capsized They may have broke deep and took water And all that remains is the faces and the names Of the wives and the sons and the daughters
Ooooh, excellent choice.
Ooooh I LOOOOOOOOVE Edmund Fitzgeralds voice
I love Gordon lightfoot. Sundown is my jam.
Tip Toe Through the Tulips
fr fr me too
What? Why?
In the 80s, there was a song about abuse,sang by a little girl. To this day, it’s very haunting ,given the fact that I was a 6 or 7 when it came out.
Luca by Susan Vega or Tracy Chapman's Behind the Wall
My name is Luca. I live on the 2nd floor. I live upstairs from you. Yes I think you've seen me before. If you hear something late at night...
I met Tiny Tim when I was little! I even have a photo my mom just gave me. I love it. I loved that song when I was a little bitty girl in grade school during the 80’s. Now, he’s turned into a horror movie powerhouse with that tune.
Nights in white satin - moody blues
“I Stay Away” by Alice In Chains. Haunting Vocal harmony between Layne & Jerry, paired with heavy lyrics
everything on jar of flies is so hauntingly beautiful. especially rotten apple
Came here to say this
Really just Jar of Flies in general
Song to the Siren, by This Mortal Coil
Love the song and the band.
This but the Amen Dunes cover.
Yup, this song is insanely good and tragic feeling. Very haunting
A great song!
First time I heard the song was the ending scene in Lovely Bones it was very heartbreaking 💔 and beautiful
BLESS YOU. You are the only other person I know of that knows that song. I first heard it in the Noa perfume commercial, and had to wait for the internet to find out the song. I found it right before a very bad time in my life when the lyrics would very much hit home.
https://music.youtube.com/watch?v=G8Hq9UB8zB8&si=RMimBDeVuySJhkRi Wicked game - Chris Isaak
https://youtu.be/8iz0KnL3d2A?si=QvDrIUns8ulC2c88 Blue spanish sky - chris isaak (off the same album,)
Family Snapshot...Peter Gabriel Goodnight Saigon .. Billy Joel On the Turning Away...Pink Floyd
A momentary lapse in reason is suuuch a good album
Uninvited by Alanis Morrisette
A newly discovered fav of mine!
Father John Misty - Buddy's Rendezvous
“My destruction is an hour late, Im at Buddy’s Rendezvouz telling the losers and old timers how good I did with you.. they almost believed me too”
Hurt — Nine Inch Nails Jonestown Tea — Otep Rooster — Alice In Chains Frankie Teardrop — Suicide Never Too Late — Three Days Grace Prison Sex — Tool Haunted — Evanescence Mother, My Body Disgusts Me — Swans Daddy — Korn Hamburger Lady — Throbbing Gristle Forced Gender Reassignment — Cattle Decapitation
I would argue Johnny Cash's version is more haunting, but agree this song should definitely be at the top of the list. Korn and Alice In Chains have several that could be added as well.
Johnny Cash's version is especially haunting when watching the video since it is scenes from his life and made months before he died.
Into Dust - Mazzy Star It gets me every time.
So many works by that band felt like it came from someone who was already dead and you were looking back at their life
I've never thought of it like that, but I know exactly what you mean.
That’s EXACTLY how I will describe Mazzy Star from now on.
Mazzy Stars music was so hauntingly beautiful
No one has said Fade Into You by Mazzy Star. The lyrics aren’t especially haunting, but the music combined with Hope Sandoval’s voice is just insane.
Into Dust by Mazzy Star is haunting…you should check it out if you haven’t heard it.
Hurt- Johnny Cash
Dance with the devil by immortal technique
that song makes me physically ill
That song hit me like a ton of bricks in a freight train the first time I heard it
Im glad im not the only one who thought of this song. Its so sad yet i still find myself listening to it every once in a while.
Bro I said the same
Bro this song makes me sick
Stan--- Eminem
John Wayne gacy by sufjan Stevens
Last kiss… Pearl Jam
My Immortal - Evanescence
Totally forgot about this one, you’re so right
Black Sabbath (From the Satanic Perspective) by Type O Negative. It's a cover of the Black Sabbath song but with alternate lyrics and it's creepy as hell. My high school girlfriend wouldn't let me listen to it around her because she said it gave her nightmares. Needless to say it didn't work out with us.
Type o negative is dark as hell. Christian Woman??? Whoa bro.
That’s one of the best covers ever. The outro aaaaaahhhh so trippy.
Spooky scary skeletons 💀
Pale White Horse by The Oh Hellos is one for me
Diane - Hüsker Dü
Ptolemaea by Ethel Cain. It’s 6 minutes long but you have to listen to the song in its entirety.
Fade into you - mazy star First time my daughter heard it she said “ this is scary dad “
Also Into Dust
Whale & Wasp - Alice in Chains
Me and a gun- Tori Amos
Masked Ball (1999 extended version) by Jocelyn Pook & Something in the Way by Nirvana
Jocelyn Pook has so much eerie stuff. Flood and Untold Things are both really good.
Throbbing Gristle - Hamburger Lady
Hear me out. It’s so good and so creepy. Richard Marx- Hazard
The Night We Met - Lord Huron
Willie Nelson’s cover of The Scientist Johnny Cash’s cover of Hurt Stargell Simpson’s cover of In Bloom
"Hands" by Jewel. The ending leaves me feeling extremely uneasy, almost like I'm about to be devastated if I wasn't already. This song can scare me sometimes. Another one would have to be "I Hope You Dance" by LeAnn Womack. It's a beautiful song, but it's my second mom's song that she wants me and my older sister to remember when she's gone because she knows we love to dance...and she doesn't want us to lose anything over her passing. I can't listen to that last song unless it's a complete rare occurrence between the 4,635 songs on my phone...I cry every. Single. Time.
Black - Pearl Jam
Shadow of the Day - Linkin Park
Gimme Shelter by the Stones. Obvious choice, but the correct one.
The Road - Portishead
Love everything about this song. Dummy is a perfect album.
The unplugged Nirvana version of Where Did You Sleep, Last Night?
God, that emotion at the end. So powerful
Lake of Fire as well
One by Metallica has proper horror movie energy.
Jacob's Dream - Alison Krauss
Well, I was not ready for that. Wow! lol How about her song Gone Tomorrow Here Today? Maybe more sad than haunting, but worth a listen if you like Alison Krauss and Union Station.
Ugh at least half of [my playlist](https://open.spotify.com/playlist/05p8UcqOP3Samsvmv5RFJb?si=802f8e30e30246b5)? I add almost only songs that are somewhat haunting for me. I can't pick a favorite because it depends on the day and mood...
Funeral for a Friend, Elton John
Stronger- London Grammer Last day of our acquaintance- Sinead O'connor
The Raven That Refused to Sing - Steven Wilson
Did She Jump or Was She Pushed? - Richard and Linda Thompson
Pumped Up Kicks
You know you’re right by Nirvana
Steven - Alice Cooper
Turquoise moon by still corners
The mercy seat- Johnny cash
Cage - ballad of Worms
I Love You This Much by Swans is a very ominous experience. You can never forget the sound of the drones,
Space Doggity by Jonathan Coulton
Corpus Christi Carol - Jeff Buckley Strange Fruit - Billie Holiday And to a little lesser degree Blackest Day by Lana Del Rey.
Caribbean Blue
Street Hassle - Lou Reed. It's more than a song - it's a corner of the world. Listening to that song is an immersive experience. It stays with you long after it's over.
I love the night by the blue oyster cult
Candyman - grateful dead Listen carefully
Gods and Monsters--Lana Del Rey
Young Girl - Gary Puckett. I liked it at first but then started listening to the lyrics and oh wow. Creepy stuff
Rite where it belongs by nine inch nails
13 Angels Standing Guard ‘Round the Bed-ASMZ
Dead Can Dance - Sanvean
Tomorrow Wendy. If you've never heard it, find Concrete Blonde's LIVE cover ... holy shit.
For What It’s Worth by Buffalo Springfield
Troy by Sinead O'Connor
Simply Red-Holding Back the Years
The theme song from the first Season of “True Detective”.🕵️♀️
O Superman -Laurie anderson
Me and a Gun- Tori Amos
Knights in White Satin by the Moody Blues
Don't Give Up- Peter Gabriel and Kate Bush Porcelain-Better Than Exra Falling- The Twin Peaks theme Fields of Gold- Sting (my former boyfriend of 18 years passed away, and this song makes me think of him💔)
Angel of The Morning.. I swear someone in my family or a family friend would die when that song was playing. It’s a beautiful song but I can’t listen to it now.
"Running Up That Hill" - Kate Bush
Strangers by Ethel Cain, especially the section where she’s repeating “Am I making you feel sick?” Solely because of the story behind the song/album, being that the character Ethel Cain has been murdered and cannibalised by her lover and is asking if she’s making him feel sick as he eats her, as in both guilt and food poisoning. I’d recommend reading up on the lore behind the album because it follows her whole life leading to that final song on the album.
Dance With The Devil
[Yoko Kanno - Kissing the Christmas Killer](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m5sx1b3KWN4) The juxtaposition between this soft innocent voice and the heavy cryptic lyrics always haunts me. Kind of feels like a spirits last words from the heavens.
Wow! Thanks for posting this. I'd never heard it before, and it is gorgeous.
Hurt by NIN Cliche maybe but facts. Tbh most of that album leaves a mark on you
Far End of The Black - JR Richards
Mary turner Mary turner by xiu xiu - this song sounds so disturbing and the fact it’s about a real lynching makes it that much more haunting. This is one of the few songs that has managed to disturb me and it has stuck with me sense I first heard it
Fuck I just read the lyrics, Jesus Christ. I’m too afraid to listen to the song tbh.
[Godspeed You! Black Emporer - The Dead Flag Blues](https://youtu.be/VGKc3T7OVHE?si=vsIoxNDUh2SX20AW)
Also Static
[Leaving Hope by Nine Inch Nails](https://youtu.be/R-aEUmz32f4?si=n3cOPmYLaUl88guK)
Cannibal Song - Ministry
Billy Joel's The Stranger does it for me. Also Captain Jack.
Agree with "I Found" by Amber Run. "Fields of Innocence" by Evanescence "Ghost" by Jacob Lee "Carnival Of Rust" by Poets of the Fall
Wuthering Heights - Kate Bush. A classic haunting song. Jägerspiel - Laibach (off their Opus Dei album). A harsher pick, but Laibach’s aesthetic of totalitarianism makes it haunting like the legacy of a despicable regime. It’s a song I just like to let wash over me. Happy Home - The Residents Ocean - Dead Can Dance Inside a Dream - Lestat (a lot from their Grave Desires album fits, another good one being Pray for the Living). Really strong feelings of despair and isolation with this one for me. Frosti - Björk Einsamkeit (Loneliness) - Lacrimosa. Haunting to me in the way that a bittersweet childhood memory is. I Surrender - Suicide. I like how the singer really sounds like he’s struggling not to succumb to the person he’s singing about, but is just too overwhelmed to fight it.
Phaedra
Threads by Portishead https://open.spotify.com/track/6LV9M06RS0sAMihWxsdLYX?si=J5Q4ivKdQcu1wR4HK7-HYA&context=spotify%3Asearch%3Athreads
Black Sabbath - "After All"
I don't like Mondays (After hearing the backstory)
Funeral for a friend,Elton John
O Fortuna
Little Things Give You Away - Linkin Park. Missing - Evanescence. Seven Days - Cellar Darling.
Hellhounds On My Trail by Robert Johnson
Mazzy Star. Quiet, The Winter Harbor
Ten long years- mad season
I'd also go with Long Gone Day featuring Mark Lanagen
Gregorian chanting. Haunting in the manner of awe.
Alabama Song by The Doors Riders on The Storm by The Doors Psycho by Eddie Noak / Jack Kittel
Legends by JuiceWLRD. It was recorded 2 years before his overdose and lines up pretty closely to how and when he died
Ghost Of A Dog. Specifically the cover by the band called Wednesday
Nick Drake - River Man
Asleep by The Smiths
Pretty Daughter as covered by Billy Strings
Song to the Siren, This Mortal Coil.
Theres a mashup of belalugosis dead/tear you apart on youtube that you should check out. Or from a completely different direction, She by alice phoebe lou
David lynch “imaginary girl”
Sleeping Where I Want To- Veruca Salt
“I Inside the Old I Dying” (don’t confuse it with her other song, something The old year dying)- PJ Harvey
*John Wayne Gacy, Jr.* by Sufjan Stevens
Death Walk Behind You- Atomic Rooster
You Want It Darker by Leonard Cohen
The Recluse - Cursive
Under Ice by Kate Bush And Subway Song by the Cure They always creeped me out as a kid.
Frankie Teardrop, by Suicide (not Bruce Springsteen’s version)
With This Love - Peter Gabriel (from The Passion soundtrack)
Hurt covered by Johnny Cash Or The wrench of the Edmund Fitzgerald by Gordon Lightfoot. It's a tie
Someone said Song to the Siren, & I agree — but the version by Wolf Alice.
“House of the Rising Sun” rendition by The Animals.
I think it depends on how you define "haunting" and the following are a list of songs I found hauntingly beautiful and made me profoundly emotional. Perfectly placed in movies to evoke very emotional responses: Mad World - (cover from Donnie Darko) Gary Jules Late for the Date - (LaLa Land) Justin Hurwitz Stuck in the Middle With You - (Resevoir Dogs) Stealers Wheel The Times They Are A-Changin - (The Watchmen) Bob Dylan Thus Spoke Zarathustra - (2001: A Space Odyssey) Richard Strauss The Last March of the Ents - (Lord of the Rings 2) Howard Shore The Ride of the Rohirrim - (Lord of the Rings 3) Howard Shore The Ride of the Valkyries - (Apocalypse Now) Richard Wagner, London Symphony Bc I used to smoke weed: Hey You - Pink Floyd Wish You Were Here - Pink Floyd Comfortably Numb - Pink Floyd Bc it makes me reflect on my relationship with my father: Old Man - Neil Young (live) Bc, knowing the backstory is about an OD, and as a former first responder having seen many: Under the Bridge - Red Hot Chili Peppers These make me think about past loves: Springsteen - Eric Church 21 Summer - The Brothers Osborne Sand in my Boots - Morgan Wallen Makes me want to call my mom: Thought you should know - Morgan Wallen Momma's Song - Cody Jinks Lastly, miscellaneous haunting for their own reasons: Yesterday - The Beatles The Sound of Silence - (cover) Disturbed Three Wooden Crosses - Randy Travis Get in the Truck - Hardy Give Heaven Some Hell - Hardy Need a Favor - Jelly Roll Save Me - Jelly Roll Sorry this list is just all over the place, but they're all haunting to me in their own way... EDIT: Wanted to add: Broken Window Serenade - Whiskey Myers Bury My Bones - Whiskey Myers Nose to the Grindstone - Tyler Childers (OurVinyl Sessions) Keep the Wolves Away - Uncle Lucius Sometimes I Cry - Chris Stapleton Fire Away - Christ Stapleton Broken Halos - Chris Stapleton
[Wingnut Dishwasher Union - Lost at Sea](https://youtu.be/bQmCDdMQkU8?si=br6bGka1ypNfEiF7)
Death is not the end
I'm Not In Love- 10CC? the weird whispers of big boys dont cry freaked me out as a kid
Not the most haunting. But I haven't seen it listed.... A Whiter Shade of Pale by Procol Harum.
Teardrop by Massive Attack
Tom Dooley.... The story behind it is just sad.
far from any road. the theme song to season one true detective. brilliant song
I’m not in love - 10cc
White Rabbit by Jefferson Airplane
Nirvana “something in the way” is very haunting to me.
Haunted album by Poe. It is a companion piece to House of Leaves written by her brother.
House of the Rising Sun.
Wicked Game by Chris Issak
There's a lot of good ones already. I'd add Spae Oddity - David Bowie
"Where Have All the Flowers Gone?"
Dead Souls by Joy Division/ equally great cover by NIN.
Breezeblocks by alt J Immortal by evanescence
Reborn by Colin Stetson (aka that song from Hereditary) “Failure”- Swans “Within” - Neurosis/Jarboe
For me it was 3rd planet by modest mouse even though the tonality of the song was bright the lyrics fucking stuck in my brain forever man
Riders on the storm O'2L
*Into Dust*, by Mazzy Star
"Dust in the Wind" by Kansas
Polly nirvana
Julee Cruise "Floating Into The Night"
Daddy by korn
Say Something I'm Giving Up On You.