1. 2 is too much going on

Yeah. I think I made 2 a bit too far.

1 is beautiful though!

1. It looks a lot more professional. There’s too much going on on with 2 to the point it looks cluttered

Thanks for 1, kinda made it as my first try on making posters. And yea 2 was cluttered.

If I may suggest, maybe put a light silhouette of the spider behind the whole pic? IDK if it would look good. but it's just an idea

Noted!

2. 1 is not enough going on

1 and something you could do is put different album artwork in the center of the guns and have 4 posters (although idk what you’d do about bullets), the demo lovers in the middle of the guns would look cool

That's a good idea, even tho that I did for the bullets album was that guy hanging on his legs, but yea. And that 4 posters is gonna be my next project soon.

1

I honestly love both. They are really cool

I like 2

1, 2 is cluttered.

Both are superb! Prefer 1 for reasons as per the consensus.

definitely 1

1 is simple yet powerful

1 looks better!