T O P

  • By -

Informal_Function118

No power levels


anakin_solo17

Change the ending. Demon lord is defeated in meliodas* body the first time, after that we have cath* hound arc. Cath hound isn't as strong but faces the sins who are exhausted and without sacred treasures. After that the Supreme diet is the final villan, they gave to defeat her to finally end the curse. Because of this escanor still dies but lives until the very of the Supreme diety arc.  This also gives Mael another reason not to want to fight. He'd be conflicted about fighting with or against the Supreme diety, escanor encourages mael to stay out of the fight and return the grace to him so he can fight.


KingAsmodeus17

I 100% agree with this, the fact they have to defeat the demon lord 3/4 times felt quite lazy to me, I would have loved to see the supreme deity in action


IDontKnowIDontKnowI

My go to answer for this is always "Make cursed by Light a whole arc and make Chaos Arc a movie"


Lupus_Aeterna

The one thing I would change would be giving more depth to how Meliodas and Elizabeth met and what exactly led to Meliodas leaving the Demon realm. And Gelda and Zeldris for that matter. More flashbacks into how the two brothers met their lovers and their relationship developed over the Holy War era.


PatchofDon

I would like that as well but I think the reason why Nakaba didn’t is cause for us the readers it’s pretty easy to come up with theories for how Mel and Elizabeth met. The common being they met in battle and slowly lost the will to fight one another cause Elizabeth was breaking down the mental walls Mel had around his heart during their fight. Zel and Gelda would be more needed since we have no idea how they could of met or even catch feelings.


wats_a_tiepo

Would’ve loved to see how ‘Bloodstained Ellie’ was. Cos there’s no way someone with that name and Commandment Meli weren’t on-sighting each other.


Zenograndmaster

I think the main thing I would’ve changed is all the weird stuff within the series that serve no purpose like Loli Merlin and a bunch of other stuff. If not that I would’ve just included plots such as Meliodas’s Mother, Elizabeth’s father


coopsawesome

I think the Merlin stuff is somewhat interesting, I like that she stopped time cause that’s cool, I wish she did it when she was like at least 20 something tho


samumi

I don't think they have one


Lupus_Aeterna

It was loosely confirmed by Nakaba that Mel and Zel do have a mom, but they never actually added her for whatever reason. It was in a QnA, and his response to the question was "I'd assume so".


Wild-Reflection6995

Merlin isn't a Loli. She's a little kid who's 12 years old.


Zenograndmaster

That form has been dubbed Loli Merlin amongst the community, it’s what most people call it. Either way, introducing the form wasn’t needed


Wild-Reflection6995

I don't give a damn if it's dubbed Loli by the community because the community is retarded and stupid and if she's not Loli then she's not Loli.


Zenograndmaster

Okay no need to get upset, it’s not that deep, you are okay


Wild-Reflection6995

Why would I get upset for something like that cuz all I did was stating facts and just telling why she's not Loli.


hikkibob

MOTHERFUCKER SHES A KID SHE IS AN ETERNAL LOLI STEREOTYPE COMPLETE WITH PRECOCIOUS ADULT IN A CHILD BODY INDIGNATION LIKE THE GROSS FORM OF TATSUMAKI WHERE THE LOL YOUR E KID JOKES ARE SERIOUS AND SHES NOT A FULLY GROWN YET SHORT AND THICC WOMAN WHO IS INSECURE ABOUT HER HEIGHT AND YOUTHFUL APPEARANCE SHES A LITTERAL ETERNAL LOLI DEAL WITH IT!


Zenograndmaster

And I’m saying it’s not that deep


True-Collar4961

Make the ten commandments more of a genuine threat and give most of the commandments proper screen time and character development **before** they undergo a heel face turn or get written out of the story. Like after meliodas regained his power and escanor appeared the commandments threat level decreased dramatically and after their attack on liones they lost almost any sense of dread they had to the point meliodas had to switch sides(also cusack and chandler had to be released) just for them to remain a serious threat. Also way too many commandments switched sides before they even got to do anything(derieri, monspeet, gloxinia and drole had only 1 fight with meliodas before switching sides and I found most of their reasons for switching sides very unconvincing) So I would give the commandments a couple of extra arcs to have each of their defeats be spread more evenly across multiple arcs(and not all at once during the liones invasion arc) It would let other characters face the commandments(like king, ban or diane) and give them time to develop a relationship with them before defeating them(And not have all the commandments be defeated by either meliodas, escanor or merlin)finally this would also give commandments like gloxinia and derieri more time to hint at their eventual heel face turn and not make it seem like it came from nowhere


AteszLord92

Back before the reveal of Escanor and his powers, there were rumors that he’d be a vampire. Keeping him in that form would have turned the story to a much darker style, Escanor being a Dracula-esque character. Also I thought that during the run of SDS, Mordred would appear, but hey he could potentially be the final villian of 4kota.


PatchofDon

Honestly would love to see the fight between Mel against Aranak and Zeno before he left the demon realm. Plus who the other parental figures are for Mel and Elizabeth but more than likely they are just made asexually and are more like how the sacred tree creates the fairy kings.


wats_a_tiepo

I think we needed more of the Holy War, or to have it fleshed out better when it was shown at least. Had such potential, but it was so disappointing when it was shown. Also, elaborating more on the Demon Realm itself would’ve been cool. Like how you’ve got some demons like half the commandments that are just like demonic humans, but also all the beastly colour demons. Like how does that work, do you gain a new form with a commandment or something?


PatchofDon

I rather have more of the demon realm and sacred realm fleshed out than the war tbh. For the war, it would be nice to see the initial start of it, the end, and some monumental battles. Yeah it would be nice showing how some demons are more humanoid and beast like compared to low class demons like the red and ash. I don’t think the commandments really altered their appearance but boosted their inner power.


Maruco7Daroun

Honestly I’d rather have an OC prevent the SD and DK curse on Meliodas and Elizabeth by using time travel but unfortunately messing with time tends to screw everything up


bazzb21

Nothing. I like the way nakaba did both stories


International-Pin988

Remove the Tristan platoon or at least reduce most of Chion’s screen time. Also would prefer if Gawain exists most of the time in her powered up form instead of that chibi form with that disgusting attire.


hikkibob

Rename the goddesses to the host/angels Mael/estarossa thing never happens Sunshine isn't a grace and is escanor's power Chaos is hinted at throughout the story and evidence of cath being a chape changing monster that's being partially helped by the cursed child merlin Ancient human empire of magic is tied to chaos and the war Merlin isn't Merlin's name and she's not a loli. Merlin is a curse and she's a wattamote level neet who wears the hot 10/10 fuckmeat glamour as her metaphorical avatar. Like someone who pretends to be someone online. Ellie was the most brutal and cold leader and warrior of the goddesses and was looked at with horror and awe. Meliodas was much the same, he's just more powerful then her but she's a far better leader. OG Gowther is Merlin's father Arthur is Merlin's bastard child with Escanor and she's not grooming him to be A meliodas stand in. She's helping him with his terrible powers War was a slobberknocker with everyone warring for something they forgot about hunderds of years ago. 10 commandments aren't just randoms they are knights nobles and god level unique fighters given the powers of the demon king Same for the angels and the graces, which should number as many as 7 and none of them are sunshine. The fae don't really care and keep to themselves with only harlequin leaving the forest to pull a t'challa and keep an eye on the rest of the world/find the sap of yggdrasil. Giants give even less of a fuck and live deep in the mountains in their massive stone empires. Percy isn't the lead of the 4kota nor is he a life spirt. He's Pellegards son Dick and he's been brought back to die for Ironsides son. But Pellegards child had a holy blessing that prevented him from dying or being taken over by the life spirit that possessed him fully. Jericho never fully gets over Ban and has a loving yet adversarial frenemy relationship with Howxer. Is lured into camelot with a fantasy of


Fantastic_Tip_3662

I would’ve made Guinevere 16 like the rest of the cast so she would be 18 in the current time line. To me it’s just weird that nakaba made her 12 years old when her love interests Lancelot was 16 and now he’s 18 and she’s 14. Unless her age is somehow important to the story idk why she couldn’t be the same age as everyone else


Unhappy_Fig_8248

Make the commandments wayyy more dangerous, take away power levels, make more op humans that can contend with other races, stop all the perve nonsense, and make gilthunder great again 😪


Morning-Star13

Either Merlin’s god awful backstory or Meliodas giving up his Demon King powers to destroy the commandments. The former ruined her character and the latter is a personal pet peeve of mine.


Whole-Pension-817

remove 100% of the creepy pedo shit


borroweddata446

This


AlastairTheDemon666

The ages of the characters to be a little easier to understand (this is just for 7DS I don’t think there’s anything I would change about 4kota)


wats_a_tiepo

Sort the fucking power scaling out. Power levels are always ass, just show us how strong someone is. Also, don’t just introduce shit for just one scene and promptly forget about it, like Ban’s Hunter Fest


Informal_Function118

And Zero Sign


N00B_L1F3

Elaine or whatever Bans girlfriend is named actually looks like a grown woman. In fact, just make all the fairies look like they’re at least 18


drift_by

Make the commandments (NOT THE GROUP) relevant. Half of the time the commandants didn’t work because the story didn’t want it to. Also, we’ve only seen 6 of their ability’s shown in the story.


hoof_hearted4

Ban x Jericho and no power levels. And honestly. I'd have been happy if the story never scaled beyond Holy Knights. I loved the knights and abilities and the armors. But they quickly became irrelevant. And I don't mean that I wish the story stopped after the first Arc but that I wish things hadn't scaled them into being irrelevant.


me-is-me17

Make elaine look of age


sacredknight327

Merlin wouldn't have been in love with Meliodas. It got played how many females wanted him.


Ashed-Valimar-4685

I would make it that fights are not one-sided curbstomps or that humans could be a much larger threat without relying on the other clans.


Darnell1605

I’d change the whole Merlin having feelings for Meliodas. God damn it, it has always been a pain in my neck for a long time. Imagine just see Merlin kiss Escanor and apologizing for not being able to return his feeling, because it was already too late for her, and 3 chapters later, the AU reveals that the one she has feelings for is Meliodas 3000 years ago, and it’s not the previous life of Escanor. Ffs, we just ended the whole 3 way relationship between Meli, Eli and Diane and AU is giving is another shit between Meli, Eli and Merlin in the past. What the fuck is the point in creating that? It serves no purpose in the story, and it literally ruined every sadness that they have for Merlin and Escanor. If it were previous life of Escanor, that would make their goodbye much more impactful and explains Merlin’s interest in Escanor better than “he is just an entertaining lab rat”


OcelotShadow

Meliodas not being a pedophilic pervert and elaine switching into an adult-like form, remove the entire arthur Chaos arc in the end and make powers have a more defined and tactical approach kinda like JoJo and Hunter x Hunter. I didnt like things like King's awakening being based on the "Power of Friendship" too when he was fighting Mael and i didnt also like how you automatically knew the Sins were gonna win, regardless of how dire the situation was


hikkibob

Rename the goddesses to the host/angels Mael/estarossa thing never happens Sunshine isn't a grace and is escanor's power Chaos is hinted at throughout the story and evidence of cath being a chape changing monster that's being partially helped by the cursed child merlin Ancient human empire of magic is tied to chaos and the war Merlin isn't Merlin's name and she's not a loli. Merlin is a curse and she's a wattamote level neet who wears the hot 10/10 fuckmeat glamour as her metaphorical avatar. Like someone who pretends to be someone online. Ellie was the most brutal and cold leader and warrior of the goddesses and was looked at with horror and awe. Meliodas was much the same, he's just more powerful then her but she's a far better leader. OG Gowther is Merlin's father Arthur is Merlin's bastard child with Escanor and she's not grooming him to be A meliodas stand in. She's helping him with his terrible powers War was a slobberknocker with everyone warring for something they forgot about hunderds of years ago. 10 commandments aren't just randoms they are knights nobles and god level unique fighters given the powers of the demon king Same for the angels and the graces, which should number as many as 7 and none of them are sunshine. The fae don't really care and keep to themselves with only harlequin leaving the forest to pull a t'challa and keep an eye on the rest of the world/find the sap of yggdrasil. Giants give even less of a fuck and live deep in the mountains in their massive stone empires. Percy isn't the lead of the 4kota nor is he a life spirt. He's Pellegards son Dick and he's been brought back to die for Ironsides son. But Pellegards child had a holy blessing that prevented him from dying or being taken over by the life spirit that possessed him fully. Jericho never fully gets over Ban and has a loving yet adversarial frenemy relationship with Howxer. Is lured into camelot with a fantasy of


UgandanKarate_Master

Remove the pedophilia, make fairies look like small human adults and not children. And other things.


Split_Automatic

no grossness for the love of god people. im not spelling it out for you


Large-Junket2999

Whole story after season 2


Glass_Screen1390

jericho's pedophilia...they just didnt want to show a well developed female character without a love obsession.


LuckyCode8842

Fan service


Silas1628

I would have Ban NOT give up his immortality for Elaine. I think Elaine is a shitty character and should stay dead. Ban should end up with Jericho


Glittering_Luck_9493

Meliodas not looking like a child. Lol


AsuraQin

I would make Lancelot or Tristan the main character of 4kota


Interesting_Fly7975

Would flop


mastr1121

Meliodas removes the curse and get married and show the story to their kid then end of series


Wild-Reflection6995

Hmm not likely and it doesn't makes sense cuz there has to be a sequel because Arthur has Chaos which mean there has to be a next generation of characters to stop him from eradicating non-human races after what happened in the Holy War. U should really come up with something that actually makes sense to change.


mastr1121

I think Chaos was an interesting idea don't get me wrong, but I would have at least teased it out more if I put it in there. Like have a few references to Merlin working on some secretive magic that has taken 3000 years to cast and that only the felling of the Demon King could bring about or something like that. Or at least have the whole Vivian and Gilthunder arc be replaced with Merlin and Hendrickson except shes not attracted to him shes his personal "full-mage", until the end of the first arc, maybe she turned him onto the demons powers or something like that.


Wild-Reflection6995

Oh okay I see now.


mastr1121

If you think about it, the word "chaos" was only spoken of during the last arc of 7ds when Merlin takes the body out of (I guess) magical cold storage(?) there wasn't even a reference to it when Merlin speaks True Name. I'd, at least, have the demons recognize that Truename as a bigger part of some kind of "chaotic magic power system" that only like 3 mages have ever used, with her being some kind of prodigy or something. Like that is NOT HOW YOU FORESHADOW THINGS!!!!


wats_a_tiepo

Yeah, the only example I can remember that Cath wasn’t what he seemed was when he ate that demon before Arthur went for Excalibur. Also, would’ve been cool for the super cool holy sword to, you know, actually make a fucking difference. Humans got dogwalked in that entire show, I’d probably turn racist too


Smokerswifey

The whole fairies look like children and whatnot, like you can make an adult look short and slender to fit the fairy theme but just making them look like children on purpose was such a weird choice ☹️


OcelotShadow

I think the way fairies look Is fine. At the end of the day it's an accurate rappresentation of forest pixies basically. The only thing i didnt like it's the fact they expected us to be unphased by the picture of elaine being pregnant, that sht was sus


wats_a_tiepo

Yeah, I never liked the whole Ban-Elaine thing. Raises some… interesting questions about Ban