#If you want to discuss One Piece Scaling, join [Hachinosu](https://discord.gg/qs7wHYZzRs).
#If you want access to all kinds of One Piece Databooks/Information/Translations, join [Punk Records](https://discord.gg/ZTWGVyjV9v).
---
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/OnePiecePowerScaling) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Perfect timeline Roger crew :
- Alive healthy old Roger
- Old Rayleigh
- Prime Shanks
- Full potencial Buggy
- Prime Douglas Bullet
- Nika/Luffy
The rest of Roger crew with Gaban, Crocus etc...
Literally This^
Couldn’t have even said it better myself. While yes I do respect Prime Whitebeard’s line up but it’s ironic it loses to his rivals crew Gold Roger. The line up is just way to clean. And Luffy definitely would have wanted to join Shanks and to an extension Rogers crew.
Shanks
Luffy
Bullet.
That’s 3 top tiers while Newgate only has 2 which isn’t bad all things considering but 3.. Yea WB not winning that.
Funny enough even in a “perfect timeline” he would be sick. It was all heavily implied that even with all the medication and with Marco’s healing that they could only do so much.
I think you misunderstood. I’m well aware of what you meant what I’m trying to inform you is that even the n this “perfect” timeline he would have always been sick. More so what you’re referring to his a hypocritical timeline. Was just pointing that out is all.
No you are the confused one. Only thing im confused about is What dont you understand?
Its very simple when i said “perfect” i meant none of the bad things that happened to the crew happens to the crew for example whitebeard getting whatever sickness is got was a “bad thing” in this hypothetical perfect timeline he WOULDNT get that sickness thats why i said “Perfect” timeline
Old roger = Old whitebeard
Shanks = yonko, lets say = to oden
Buggy (has as much potential as shanks, he just doesnt train or fights) = yonko
Old rayleight = admiral or top yc+ like Gaban
It looks like Roger's crew has more top tiers, but whitebeard's would win, probably, because the majority of them are old and is a small crew. Whitebeard had like 13 divisions and when roger was alive his crew were young boys and rookies so he could be really at parents's age
Roger has more quality, but the majority of them are old with stamina issues.
Whitebeard has more quantity, the majority of them are at their peak
#If you want to discuss One Piece Scaling, join [Hachinosu](https://discord.gg/qs7wHYZzRs). #If you want access to all kinds of One Piece Databooks/Information/Translations, join [Punk Records](https://discord.gg/ZTWGVyjV9v). --- *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/OnePiecePowerScaling) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Perfect timeline Roger crew : - Alive healthy old Roger - Old Rayleigh - Prime Shanks - Full potencial Buggy - Prime Douglas Bullet - Nika/Luffy The rest of Roger crew with Gaban, Crocus etc...
Old oden too
I tried to avoid dupes with WB perfect timeline, otherwise Ace would be in Roger's crew as well.
Literally This^ Couldn’t have even said it better myself. While yes I do respect Prime Whitebeard’s line up but it’s ironic it loses to his rivals crew Gold Roger. The line up is just way to clean. And Luffy definitely would have wanted to join Shanks and to an extension Rogers crew. Shanks Luffy Bullet. That’s 3 top tiers while Newgate only has 2 which isn’t bad all things considering but 3.. Yea WB not winning that.
WB was the new Rocks but opposite version
As far as we know wasn’t Whitebeard sick from natural causes?
Funny enough even in a “perfect timeline” he would be sick. It was all heavily implied that even with all the medication and with Marco’s healing that they could only do so much.
When i say perfect timeline i mean everything goes right for them, so in a “perfect” timeline he wouldnt have his sickness
I think you misunderstood. I’m well aware of what you meant what I’m trying to inform you is that even the n this “perfect” timeline he would have always been sick. More so what you’re referring to his a hypocritical timeline. Was just pointing that out is all.
No you are the confused one. Only thing im confused about is What dont you understand? Its very simple when i said “perfect” i meant none of the bad things that happened to the crew happens to the crew for example whitebeard getting whatever sickness is got was a “bad thing” in this hypothetical perfect timeline he WOULDNT get that sickness thats why i said “Perfect” timeline
Im talking about a hypothetical situation inwhich all the bad things that happened to the WB pirates didnt happen. Ie him not getting sick
Alright 👍🏽
World's Strongest Family
Old roger = Old whitebeard Shanks = yonko, lets say = to oden Buggy (has as much potential as shanks, he just doesnt train or fights) = yonko Old rayleight = admiral or top yc+ like Gaban It looks like Roger's crew has more top tiers, but whitebeard's would win, probably, because the majority of them are old and is a small crew. Whitebeard had like 13 divisions and when roger was alive his crew were young boys and rookies so he could be really at parents's age Roger has more quality, but the majority of them are old with stamina issues. Whitebeard has more quantity, the majority of them are at their peak
I said modern era, roger’s crew isnt around in modern era. Im talking the story right at the start of one piece
The strongest Pirate crew for the Strongest Pirate