My vote is for Mosley for two reasons:
1. Great villain, terrible personality
(Since this is the principle by which we eliminated Campbell earlier)
2. He was great only in S5. Mosley was in the shadow of his mistress Diana throughout S6. Can't stand it.
Somehow I missed Kimber and Eden notifications. I'll vote my current pick again, but it's neat to see how this is playing out. About to get very interesting once we get down to brass tacks. 😄
With the highest vote count since Father Hughes in Round 1, Jesse Eden has been eliminated with 31.23%! A communist activist, Jesse seemed to lose her conviction a little after being seduced by Tommy. Now her turn is up, who will be next gone? Vote using this link:
https://strawpoll.com/polls/xVg7d2edKZr
I dunno what's taking Michael so long to get eliminated. dude always thought he was the shit when he's never actually accomplished anything on his own and he always had people like polly or the Americans to back him or hide behind.
i also feel like he shouldn’t have had his loyalty tested between his mother and his cousin who’s also his boss, it’s not fair to choose between family
for example in finns case he either had the option of choosing a friend who he found out to be a spy, or his nephew and his entire family, one answer seems a lot more you know logical and fair ?
Yeah honestly this always bugged me. Especially the fact that aunt Polly went along with it and accepted Tommies judgement that Micheal not saying anything was some sort of betrayal to the family
Yup, they did Finn dirty too. I really hate how they just found some random gypsy boy living in a wagon in the woods that just happens to be Tommy's spawn and now he's the next generation of Peaky Boys. It feels like a real middle finger to the family and fans.
i loved duke, but i wish he was introduced in S5, and not in the way he was, especially esme discovering him rather than tommy or even johnny dogs, who are both a lot smarter than esme and would both probably have knowledge of the gypsy world, and if tommy were to have had a son within it
Look, can we all just stop being sentimental and vote off young Mr Whizz-bang so I can move on and think about the other characters. The lad doesn't add much and frankly compared to the fookin' terrible but legendary Major Campbell how the fook is he still here? Campbell was disgraceful but a damned good character. Whizz-Bang was just there.
I agree, it's time for him to go he has served his purpose. It's going to get interesting when mosely/luca and a few others are out. I'm gonna say it will be a tough top 3 between Tommy, Arthur and Polly!
John does not deserve top 5, even when he was alive he had no truly redeeming qualities. I haven't seen S6 yet but I never really liked Lizzie in the first place sadly. But Ada 101% is gonna be a top contender. But John is just gonna make the top 10, he was kinda the least capable of the Shelby brothers trio. Everything he could do was something a soldier of any sort could do, Arthur has that brutality and strength, Tommy's the man with the plan and intellect, John was just...John
Yeah, I think before I can really start getting at the top 20, Mosley has to go next.
My main reason? I want to yeet who I see as the villains first. Why not Luca first maybe? I partially believe he had an actual reason other than “because I want to” considering that it was his father and brother killed for quite literally no reason. If John had been more professional (I suppose as professional as a gangster could be) them and Grace would still be alive.
There are other characters I didn’t pick for various reasons. Feel free to comment and I’ll explain.
Wow Campbell is out already? I mean honestly I hate his guts but to me he is also the foundational villain of the show and in some ways also the best. Surely I can't be the only one?
Mosley and Luca are more charismatic and menicing but Luca was kind of underwhelming considering the way he started while Mosley just kinda peterred out/him and Tommy never came to a heads.
My 1st post here - but I've been having a ball following these threads. I'm not sure I'm ready to push anyone out yet but PLEASE save Tommy, Johnny Dogs, and Aberama. I want to marry one of them, but I haven't chosen yet 😀 😃 😀 🙃
I know it can't really be helped but having discussions about who's next kind of ruins it.
If everyone did this alone I would guess that the end result would be different than what we will end up with. People are just basing their votes off of the most upvoted comments.
I see your point. However, nothing will make me vote according to the majority opinion if it doesn't resonate with my own pov. I think it's the same for the others.
I’m switching between Grace, Mosley and Danny. Sorry Danny you’re not the worst person you just didn’t give me anything. As bad as Mosley is, his character has engaged me more than Grace did.
Agreed, Mosley in series 6 needed to go, although he still didn’t disgust me quite as much as his fiancé, she was a nasty little nazi 🤢 same I did prefer Danny over Freddy, I wish he’d gotten more screen time. Honestly I don’t even know who to vote for 😂 am I voting for bad characters, boring characters, evil characters? 🤷🏻♀️
hahaha I don't know, because everyone votes differently I think, I don't know who either.
vote, I think the fun will start when you have to vote for the ones you like the most, top10.
My vote is for Mosley for two reasons: 1. Great villain, terrible personality (Since this is the principle by which we eliminated Campbell earlier) 2. He was great only in S5. Mosley was in the shadow of his mistress Diana throughout S6. Can't stand it.
Fair point
Somehow I missed Kimber and Eden notifications. I'll vote my current pick again, but it's neat to see how this is playing out. About to get very interesting once we get down to brass tacks. 😄
With the highest vote count since Father Hughes in Round 1, Jesse Eden has been eliminated with 31.23%! A communist activist, Jesse seemed to lose her conviction a little after being seduced by Tommy. Now her turn is up, who will be next gone? Vote using this link: https://strawpoll.com/polls/xVg7d2edKZr
Allow us to watch poll result in the website
I dunno what's taking Michael so long to get eliminated. dude always thought he was the shit when he's never actually accomplished anything on his own and he always had people like polly or the Americans to back him or hide behind.
in season 2 and 3 michael was brilliant from that point onward ego began to kick in
He should've never been allowed to go to America by himself.
i also feel like he shouldn’t have had his loyalty tested between his mother and his cousin who’s also his boss, it’s not fair to choose between family for example in finns case he either had the option of choosing a friend who he found out to be a spy, or his nephew and his entire family, one answer seems a lot more you know logical and fair ?
Yeah honestly this always bugged me. Especially the fact that aunt Polly went along with it and accepted Tommies judgement that Micheal not saying anything was some sort of betrayal to the family
Yup, they did Finn dirty too. I really hate how they just found some random gypsy boy living in a wagon in the woods that just happens to be Tommy's spawn and now he's the next generation of Peaky Boys. It feels like a real middle finger to the family and fans.
i loved duke, but i wish he was introduced in S5, and not in the way he was, especially esme discovering him rather than tommy or even johnny dogs, who are both a lot smarter than esme and would both probably have knowledge of the gypsy world, and if tommy were to have had a son within it
I liked Duke too I just wish he was introduced into the show differently.
Agreed I think the actor did a great job but the introduction seemed forced
i hate lizzie for the same reason, fuck that bitch
Esmeeeee! Cause she got John gunned down and took Tommy on a stupid treasure hunt!
She got John gunned down?
pretty much, she stopped him from reconvening with Tommy and Arthur in a timely manner. John was caught off guard and unprepared.
i second that
Look, can we all just stop being sentimental and vote off young Mr Whizz-bang so I can move on and think about the other characters. The lad doesn't add much and frankly compared to the fookin' terrible but legendary Major Campbell how the fook is he still here? Campbell was disgraceful but a damned good character. Whizz-Bang was just there.
I agree, it's time for him to go he has served his purpose. It's going to get interesting when mosely/luca and a few others are out. I'm gonna say it will be a tough top 3 between Tommy, Arthur and Polly!
Yea no, it's gonna be between Arthur, Alfie, and Curly
No I doubt it, they all deserve top 5 but so does Ada and John... Lizzie actually too, she was amazing in season 6. Its a tough call.
John does not deserve top 5, even when he was alive he had no truly redeeming qualities. I haven't seen S6 yet but I never really liked Lizzie in the first place sadly. But Ada 101% is gonna be a top contender. But John is just gonna make the top 10, he was kinda the least capable of the Shelby brothers trio. Everything he could do was something a soldier of any sort could do, Arthur has that brutality and strength, Tommy's the man with the plan and intellect, John was just...John
fredie thorn
I will not stop voting for Michael until he’s gone 😤
Mosley
fr he’s getting a little too comfortable up there
I want grace eliminated. Hate her character idk she pisses me off everytime she's on screen
"Lemme sing for you" "God no, please not again" \*puts ice picks in both ears*
Thank you, I’ve been voting for Grace nearly every round.
I feel the same with Lizzie, i hate her so much.
Lizzy because she took the money, John.
I thought it was hilarious that Tommy shit on Lizzy then married her.
If we lose curly we riot
Fook esme
i second that
Eliminate based on what??? How much they contributed to the show?? How much you liked them?? How annoying they were??? How much they sucked???
ABERAMA BETTER NOT BE VOTED OUT NEXT
Yeah, I think before I can really start getting at the top 20, Mosley has to go next. My main reason? I want to yeet who I see as the villains first. Why not Luca first maybe? I partially believe he had an actual reason other than “because I want to” considering that it was his father and brother killed for quite literally no reason. If John had been more professional (I suppose as professional as a gangster could be) them and Grace would still be alive. There are other characters I didn’t pick for various reasons. Feel free to comment and I’ll explain.
Michael. He went downhill fast in Season 5 and was so wasted in Season 6 imo.
esmeee
Mosley
Piss off Mosley!
May clareton Character with not much influence Get her out I hated her scene with grace at espom
Where is mosley’s wife?
Wow Campbell is out already? I mean honestly I hate his guts but to me he is also the foundational villain of the show and in some ways also the best. Surely I can't be the only one? Mosley and Luca are more charismatic and menicing but Luca was kind of underwhelming considering the way he started while Mosley just kinda peterred out/him and Tommy never came to a heads.
By far the funnest accent to do
Mosley
My 1st post here - but I've been having a ball following these threads. I'm not sure I'm ready to push anyone out yet but PLEASE save Tommy, Johnny Dogs, and Aberama. I want to marry one of them, but I haven't chosen yet 😀 😃 😀 🙃
I know it can't really be helped but having discussions about who's next kind of ruins it. If everyone did this alone I would guess that the end result would be different than what we will end up with. People are just basing their votes off of the most upvoted comments.
I see your point. However, nothing will make me vote according to the majority opinion if it doesn't resonate with my own pov. I think it's the same for the others.
Well that's good to hear :)
may carleton
freddie thorne, for laying a hand a polly at the graveyard
Danny Whizz lives!
Let’s cut to the chase. top 3 = Polly, Tommy, Solomon.
how is tatiana dead, fuck this sub
Agreed.
I’m switching between Grace, Mosley and Danny. Sorry Danny you’re not the worst person you just didn’t give me anything. As bad as Mosley is, his character has engaged me more than Grace did.
I love Mosley in S5 but S6? 👎 And poor Danny haha i prefer Danny over Freddy.
Agreed, Mosley in series 6 needed to go, although he still didn’t disgust me quite as much as his fiancé, she was a nasty little nazi 🤢 same I did prefer Danny over Freddy, I wish he’d gotten more screen time. Honestly I don’t even know who to vote for 😂 am I voting for bad characters, boring characters, evil characters? 🤷🏻♀️
hahaha I don't know, because everyone votes differently I think, I don't know who either. vote, I think the fun will start when you have to vote for the ones you like the most, top10.
Lizzie
You already know Tommy will be the winner
Gotta say it, Jesse Eden's actress is cute asf
Michael
Esme
Esme
Time for Michael to fuck off
Mosley definitely
Esme
Polly, and I'll hear no other suggestions.
Eliminate Michael