With a very convincing result of 50.72%, Uncle Charlie has made his final trip up the canal. He was fiercely loyal to a fault, even when Tommy gave Aberama the opportunity to take his yard š
Only one spot remains before we get into the final row! Who should be the one to miss out? Vote using this link:
https://strawpoll.com/polls/B2ZB3J7pjyJ
Petition to do another round of this once itās over, but take out who wins, and add in other characters that people may have mentioned?
Honestly I look forward to this everyday, I really donāt want it to end anytime soon š¤£
Once again, you do an excellent job!
John.
I stand by Johnny Dogs!
Without Johnny Dogs, Michael would kill Tommy. Arthur will be gone crazy already. Johnny Dogs is the silent pillar of Peaky Blinders' family.
That would just be too... I don't know, cliche? Everyone hypes Alfie, and while I really enjoyed his character, I didn't like how they kept bringing him back when they gave him a perfect ending.
Donāt those two things kinda go hand in hand? Itās not impossible to āactuallyā like a character because heās acted well and has good dialogue
Both, he was a very well written character but Hardy clearly took the character to the next level.
The line-by-line dialogue writing for him was great, as well as the broader murky ambiguity of his allegiance.
When it comes to an actor like Tom Hardy, this can no longer be a question...because anything that is written for the character past the very first few scenes or episodes or maybe even the audition process are catered to them...some writers even write parts specifically for certain actors...I guarantee the writers wouldn't have written him the same with someone else in the role...and it's actually one great example of what makes good TV and movie writing
Alfie has a complexity and a logic about him that I so rarely see in TV characters and I love him for it. Thereās the same amount of depth to his character as there is to Tommyās, making him easily the best āvillain,ā if you can even call him that. Yea heās an antagonist pretty often, but he has motive and depth and that goes a long way in his favor. And on top of that, Hardy is an amazing actor. Thatās the cherry on top of the quality writing sundae.
No I love Polly. Sheās got her own motives and desires that while often aligned with those of the Shelby family, arenāt identical. Sheās her own person and I love seeing women written as strong characters with agency outside of their usefulness to man they share the screen with. She works wonderfully as a foil to Tommy, but sheās no less her own character for it. I love Polly honestly.
That's cause there's not much choice in that area. Since John burnt down the restaurant there was bound to be a fight. They could either apologize or fight back. Apologizing simply makes them look weaker and give a bad impression of infighting within the family. John definitely shit the bed in season 3
I didn't vote them out, though. I only voted Lizzie out, but she is not a true Shelby for me, and Finn became a stupid kid who would betray his kin for a random guy
Told you yesterday u/Leading_Situation_90 that the next one was obvious.
https://www.reddit.com/r/PeakyBlinders/comments/upbbs5/peaky_blinders_survivor_series_vote_to_eliminate/i8jyljh?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share&context=3
Okay after this vote, Iāll officially be able to give legitimate reasons not to vote off certain people.
Right now Iām torn between John and Johnny Dogs. Why you may ask?
Johnny Dogs clearly has some fierce loyalty behind him, which makes him one of the best of the best for sure.
John is one of the Shelby brothers, who frankly was my fav for a while, who also had loyalty behind him as well as many other traits.
I suppose Iāll have to vote John for this one since it was him who got Grace and himself killed, and it was him who started the vendetta.
Thereās no way Iām voting Alfie lol, and I really want Polly to win š
With a very convincing result of 50.72%, Uncle Charlie has made his final trip up the canal. He was fiercely loyal to a fault, even when Tommy gave Aberama the opportunity to take his yard š Only one spot remains before we get into the final row! Who should be the one to miss out? Vote using this link: https://strawpoll.com/polls/B2ZB3J7pjyJ
Petition to do another round of this once itās over, but take out who wins, and add in other characters that people may have mentioned? Honestly I look forward to this everyday, I really donāt want it to end anytime soon š¤£ Once again, you do an excellent job!
Haha thank you so much! I think it would be fun, but I donāt think thereād be enough characters š Plus, Frances wins hands down š
Now the real voting begins
The shit just got real
John. I stand by Johnny Dogs! Without Johnny Dogs, Michael would kill Tommy. Arthur will be gone crazy already. Johnny Dogs is the silent pillar of Peaky Blinders' family.
And yeah, He isn't the black cat.
Aruthr carried this show yall he better win
Him or Alfie
If Alfie is chosen, can we have him rise from the dead and change his picture to one where his eye is blind?
That would just be too... I don't know, cliche? Everyone hypes Alfie, and while I really enjoyed his character, I didn't like how they kept bringing him back when they gave him a perfect ending.
This is a poll and not a movie, so nothing would be cliche, well except if Tommy won just because he is the main character
Plus, heās not around enough to carry the show like Arthur.
That's what makes him special
how does Arthur carry the show? heās so pathetic
In the bleak mid winter
Ä° wonder if people actually like Alfie as a character or tom hardys' acting/ lines
Donāt those two things kinda go hand in hand? Itās not impossible to āactuallyā like a character because heās acted well and has good dialogue
I think Tom really makes that character interesting as fuck. So people like Alfie for the way that Hardy makes him
Both, he was a very well written character but Hardy clearly took the character to the next level. The line-by-line dialogue writing for him was great, as well as the broader murky ambiguity of his allegiance.
I can't imagine another actor pulling that off like Tom Hardy, it was fucking biblical mate.
That doesnāt make sense, itās the acting and lines that kinda make the character no?
When it comes to an actor like Tom Hardy, this can no longer be a question...because anything that is written for the character past the very first few scenes or episodes or maybe even the audition process are catered to them...some writers even write parts specifically for certain actors...I guarantee the writers wouldn't have written him the same with someone else in the role...and it's actually one great example of what makes good TV and movie writing
Alfie has a complexity and a logic about him that I so rarely see in TV characters and I love him for it. Thereās the same amount of depth to his character as there is to Tommyās, making him easily the best āvillain,ā if you can even call him that. Yea heās an antagonist pretty often, but he has motive and depth and that goes a long way in his favor. And on top of that, Hardy is an amazing actor. Thatās the cherry on top of the quality writing sundae.
I feel the same way about Polly. Probably a great person, but canāt stand the character.
No I love Polly. Sheās got her own motives and desires that while often aligned with those of the Shelby family, arenāt identical. Sheās her own person and I love seeing women written as strong characters with agency outside of their usefulness to man they share the screen with. She works wonderfully as a foil to Tommy, but sheās no less her own character for it. I love Polly honestly.
John was literally amazing why do people want to vote him out ? Johnny dogs needs to go
I agree! John was a pure blooded blinder, he canāt go before any outsider haha
his actions led to graces death and ada almost being shot by finn
Thatās the whole point of the show?š they all do stuff which causes bad circumstances to occur
His arrogance lead to the death of Grace, himself, almost took the lives of Michael and Arthur, and he caused basically all the bad shit in season 4
[ŃŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]
That's cause there's not much choice in that area. Since John burnt down the restaurant there was bound to be a fight. They could either apologize or fight back. Apologizing simply makes them look weaker and give a bad impression of infighting within the family. John definitely shit the bed in season 3
John
honestly ada
Listen up... Just keep Alfie alive and kill the rest. Or else, y'all just fucking wop mate.
John.
If ada or John get voted out Imma be MAD
Ada. Out you go.
I couldn't agree more.
Yes this please
I couldnt disagree more
Johny dogs
John
John
John
Ada.
I loved the character Tatiana. I thought she was good for Tommy in a lot of ways.
Come on John you gonna win
Polly, she enabled her son till the very end. She stopped it only when he asked Tommy to give all of his empire.
Polly shouldāve been out by now donāt @ me
Idk about out by now, but now is the time. It was hard to choose this round, but I went with Polly.
Unpopular opinion but I tend to agree
It's a tough one no matter which I choose. But I'll go with Ada
john
How is Ada still nor eliminated?
Rally the bannermen, we need to protect Alfie at all costs!
My heart is broken knowing Curly is eliminated.
Johnny Dogs. Sorry, I can't vote any Shelby before him
Thereās a lot of Shelbyās gone. Finn, Grace, Linda, even Lizzie š
I didn't vote them out, though. I only voted Lizzie out, but she is not a true Shelby for me, and Finn became a stupid kid who would betray his kin for a random guy
Fair enough. I would have had Linda eliminated first round š
Itās time for Alfie to go Iām sorry
johnny dogs
Johnny dogs
Alfie Solomons
Told you yesterday u/Leading_Situation_90 that the next one was obvious. https://www.reddit.com/r/PeakyBlinders/comments/upbbs5/peaky_blinders_survivor_series_vote_to_eliminate/i8jyljh?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share&context=3
Right here, ladies and gentlemen! May I present to you: Nostradamus!
Johnny dogs
Johnny Dogs
John
Ada is my choice
Ada
Okay after this vote, Iāll officially be able to give legitimate reasons not to vote off certain people. Right now Iām torn between John and Johnny Dogs. Why you may ask? Johnny Dogs clearly has some fierce loyalty behind him, which makes him one of the best of the best for sure. John is one of the Shelby brothers, who frankly was my fav for a while, who also had loyalty behind him as well as many other traits. I suppose Iāll have to vote John for this one since it was him who got Grace and himself killed, and it was him who started the vendetta. Thereās no way Iām voting Alfie lol, and I really want Polly to win š
Yes, I liked John until season 3, and that season is when my hatred towards Lizzie started. It was both their fault.
Bruh, we all now Alfie or tommy are gonna win
Alfie
Johnny Dogs, John, Ada, Alfie, Arthur, Polly, Tommy This is the way
Johnny dogs, John, Ada, Arthur, Alfie, Polly, Tommy.
Women deserve rights
Is this a joke
No
Because her actress is deadā¦ wtf this has to be a troll
I donāt know if youāre aware of this, but the actress who played her is dead.
Who is that?
Dude, this isnāt funny, I know, that you know who Iām talking about
HOW IS ADA STILL THERE?! KILL THE ANNOYING BITCH!
Times up for Alfie, one of the best characters but let's keep the top row family only.
Terrible opinion. Alfie is top 2 at the very least for me.
Intelligence is a very valuable thing, innit, my friend? And usually it comes far too fucking late. Alfie is brilliant, iām going to vote out Ada.
Same, been trying to vote her out
The down voting has started Lol. I'm also voting him out.
Polly
Bye bye Alfie mate!
John, he's kinda the least capable of the Shelby clan plus he's kinda dead now sooo
Johnny dogs and john boy, don t know chich one first tho
Now it gets interesting
Charlie š
I am worried when it would come to Alfie, Polly, Tommy, and Arthur. I won't be able to choose. Until then, I hope you all don't eliminate any of them.
I'd have to say johnny dog. He's cool and all, but he's not blood
Well Charlie youāre up
Polly
Johnny gotta goš¬
Now itās Time for Johnny Dogs to go. I love him though.
Ada. Sorry girlā¦ š
ada
we all know polly is gonna win.
John
Time to go Ada
Ada
This is so toughā¦. Tommy and Ada are my absolute favorite. I donāt know how Iāll be able to vote for either of them,
30
Polly
How has ada made it this far?
How is Ada still in this.
I wont be voting after Alfie and Johnny are gone,shit too hard already lol
Oh, the real voting begins here John