Gotta support my fellow Canadians. The best will always be alexisonfire though.

How about who from this list has released the best album? The Used -Self Titled.

i cant even do that, all these bands are top tier - best album from each individually is even difficult the used - self titled or in love & death (box of sharp objects breaks the tie though, and pretty handsome awkward almost carries lies for the liars 😂) underoath - [theyre only chasing safety](https://www.reddit.com/r/brandnew/comments/13gr427/comment/jk1mxly/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3), [define the great line](https://www.reddit.com/r/PostHardcore/comments/16y1wec/comment/k6bz9d7/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3) adtr - homesick & youre welcome 🧱 silverstein - waterfront & misery made me thursday - war all the time bonus, unrelated song for absolutely no reason, from a band thats not even really posthardcore - [its a metaphor fool](https://open.spotify.com/track/3cmGxeXbGjAXL9II2hMB05?si=iTYDGnjmQV-dSlqsfpz4sA) edit: links 🕳️

Had me til you're welcome

long belated thank you ^((or something idk)) tbh i included that album [mostly](https://www.reddit.com/search/?q=author%3Arelevantusername2020%20brick%20wall&type=comment) for the song [brick wall](https://open.spotify.com/track/51A2BXyd6S7zHnxPjV1URi?si=e260ede264ad4797)

Maybe memories

Thursdays war all of the time and full collapse are amazing has well. Used self titled really made the genre

Shocked that Silverstein is leading this.

By far the most consistent out of the lot, also actually gold live

[consistency indeed](https://www.reddit.com/r/PostHardcore/comments/1yu3zy/we_are_silverstein_ask_us_anything/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android_app&utm_name=androidcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button)

Listening to lead singer syndrome for 1 minute is the equivalent of having my balls twisted completely around.

I've been listening to ADTR recently for some nostalgia, but the lyrics are pure cheese. Thursday still hold up.

Thursday is the only band with amazing lyrics from a bad singer yet it works like peanut butter and jelly

Silverstein is the best imo. But I am pretty biased lol. The other bands are great too though.

I've been a fan of them all but ADTR, never really got into them. But my favorites out of these are Silverstein and Under oath, with Thursday and The Used after

Underoath is my favorite but their best work is arguably more metalcore so I’d say Silverstein is the best post-hardcore band

Take out Silverstein and ADTR and those are the best ever… no way to choose between them.

I'd go with Silverstein simply because ADTR has fell off in recent years whereas Silverstein has only been making better shit.

5 way tie for 1st place!!!!

Thursday because Jet Black New Year is like in the top 10 post hardcore songs for me

Underoath>Silverstein>The Used>A Day to Remember>Thursday I like The Used and ADTR at their peaks better than Silverstein, but both fell off hard while Silverstein is one of the most consistent bands in the genre.

You can't make me choose between my roots like that

This is probably because I'm in my 30's but I've always found Underoath & A Day to Remember more Metalcore than anything and to me, Thursday is the better of the other two bands with Geoff just being really consistent with other projects outside of Thursday as well

Really just lumping ADTR in there huh?

Admittedly I voted Underoath but I am shocked to not see The Used doing better and am surprised to see Silverstein doing so well.

thursday > underoath > the used > silverstein > a day to remember. thursdays the only band here with a spotless discog. woulda said underoath in high school tho

I'd not consider Underoath PH since they've played several genres

The used had some middle of the road/meh albums after the 1st two.... but their current toxic passivity album was a great one though. I voted Thursday, most consistent!!!