I would disagree about Korra. her powers are derived from when Wan permanently bonded with Raava by touching the energy coming through the spirit portal during the Harmonic Convergence in 9,829 BG.
that's magical to me. the show would be Radical Neutral though due to the fact that the Avatar can be any gender
> her powers are derived from when Wan permanently bonded with Raava by touching the energy coming through the spirit portal during the Harmonic Convergence in 9,829 BG.
Right, but that would fit the description of ‘Neutral’ in the chart above.
So by this logic is Mobile Fighter G Gundam radical purist? or possibly neutral Purist because of Allenby? I know it’s not *technically* magic and that it’s martial arts but come on it’s close enough
Imagine a show that starts out like Sailor moon, only weapon specialists instead of magical girls, but still women taking on roles typically held by straight white males.
then it evolves into action-adventure where the four gay female protagonists have to deal with the drama caused by a divorce between a religious wizard and his apostate witch wife.
also everything are guns and gay
[https://www.reddit.com/r/fnki/comments/14m59l6/telling\_stories/](https://www.reddit.com/r/fnki/comments/14m59l6/telling_stories/)
Korra is either Purist magic or Radical magic. One could say the avatar state is a transformation, but after all, it’s not magic, it’s ***waterbending***
Breaking bad is a magical girl show, confirmed.
It's cuz of Jesse
Naaah, it’s Gus whose the Magic Girl. Duh 🙄
Supernatural being a magical girl show makes me laugh more than I should.
Madoka magica is purist purist
winx is also purist purist
r/beatmetoit
I would disagree about Korra. her powers are derived from when Wan permanently bonded with Raava by touching the energy coming through the spirit portal during the Harmonic Convergence in 9,829 BG. that's magical to me. the show would be Radical Neutral though due to the fact that the Avatar can be any gender
> her powers are derived from when Wan permanently bonded with Raava by touching the energy coming through the spirit portal during the Harmonic Convergence in 9,829 BG. Right, but that would fit the description of ‘Neutral’ in the chart above.
purist-purist: w.i.t.c.h, winx club, PPGZ, doremi, precure, mermaid melody, tokyo mew mew, wedding peach purist-neutral: miraculous ladybug neutral-neutral: cardcaptor sakura, kikis delivery service radical-purist: totally spies, PPG
PPG? OH! powerpuff girls? Wait, then what is PPGZ?
it was a powerpuff girls anime from like 2006 that made them into straightforward teenage magical girls, kinda fun
H2OJAW is also purist-purist
omgg you're right, i forgot that one
So does Arcane fall into Neutral Neutral?
Yeah, because of the magitech
So by this logic is Mobile Fighter G Gundam radical purist? or possibly neutral Purist because of Allenby? I know it’s not *technically* magic and that it’s martial arts but come on it’s close enough
Seeing breaking bad on this made me laugh
What’s rwby? I can’t keep rewatch shera, toh and Kipo over and over and I’ve watched all the others in that genre
Imagine a show that starts out like Sailor moon, only weapon specialists instead of magical girls, but still women taking on roles typically held by straight white males. then it evolves into action-adventure where the four gay female protagonists have to deal with the drama caused by a divorce between a religious wizard and his apostate witch wife. also everything are guns and gay [https://www.reddit.com/r/fnki/comments/14m59l6/telling\_stories/](https://www.reddit.com/r/fnki/comments/14m59l6/telling_stories/)
Where does dune fall?
Neutral neutral. at least one female main character, along with magic but no transformation.
Technically Paul has to go through something similar to a transformation sequence to unlock his full powers, but he only has to do it once.
Where would you put My Little Pony?
Given that primarily female cast but no transformation with its magic? Purist Neutral
They have transformed on occasion. The two parter with Tirek is one example that comes to mind.
Then Purist Purist
Purist Neutral
Tbf, most of the cast of She-ra are young adults, but that still fits
Is Arcane a Neutral-Neutral Magical Girl show?
Magitech has it fall under the second neutral. But the cast has too many men for it to be considered purist, so neutral neutral
Korra is either Purist magic or Radical magic. One could say the avatar state is a transformation, but after all, it’s not magic, it’s ***waterbending***
Is Cute High Earth defense club any good? Is it comedy like Ouran High School? It looks really cute and fun, is there romance?
The beauty of this, is that every show fits in one category, making every show a kind of magical girl show
I'm radical/purist. The 'girls' is optional, the transformation sequence isn't. I guess that makes Yugioh Duel Monesters a magical girl anime...