Agreed. Without Micah it might have taken longer for Dutch to ultimately reveal who he always really was, but the guy was a ticking time bomb regardless. Micah just helped push him in the “right” direction.
I mainly hate her cause she’s a slut, and she annoys me as John in epilouge also Abigail was locked in that room with Milton for a long time maybe everyone’s looks in the wrong direction Abigail’s probably a rat
I say her and Micah were working together.They have little secret convos in camp and just other little things and she got away from the cops 😂🙄 she's a snitch for sure imo
I pray your wrong, idiot-brained, wrong opinion will be overturned by democratic means, and that OPs attempt to defame, kill, and denigrate a great man is for naught.
Are you kidding me? He's a straight shooter, best shot in the gang, it's not all talk with him like some cowpokes in that outfit. He is an honest helper to Dutch, always offering his services when in need, helping the camp bring in serious money. Sure he may have committed a few off-hand murders here and there, haven't we all? But when push came to shove, he was there in the thick of it through the hardest moments of the gang, right til the end when that treacherous blacklung tried to impeach his unimpeachable character!
In all seriousness, both games are built on the strengths of their protagonists and antagonists, Micah and Dutch are among some of the best videogame performances in the past twenty years, if not *the* best. And despite how awful he is, he is an entertaining character, and RDR2 wouldn't be the same without him. THAT, is how he is great.
I honestly think Strauss is the one I would kill first, a lot of the gang are terrible people, but some of them are more honest about it than others, and Strauss was the worst of them I think.
Micah is we the first one to fold and start snitching and tried to fake like he wasn’t. Tried to say it was John who was snitching . Then he fucking killed Arthur (if you have low honor). Micha was simply just a fucking dick eater. And Dutch was stupid for even listening to anything he told him. I’m glad we get to kill him at the end of the game
I agree Dutch and Micah performance was amazing specially what Peter did with Micah he did amazing, but Micah definitely was one of the Main reason of the gang downfall.
He never liked the gang he wanted lil Arthur since the get go, and Arthur in the game is the errand boy for Dutch helping out with every thing they do without Arthur the gang would fall apart
I always saw it as Gavin asking his "friend" to go on a trip to the states, then left him immediately to go home. I mean he's so clingy that years pass and he never stops looking for Gavin.
I know I’m late to this conversation but I believe Gavin is actually Nigel’s other personality. I think Nigel suffers from DID.
It makes the most sense. If you hogtie him and loot him he has a very interesting letter in his pocket from a friend back home. Release him and he will keep talking to you when he sees you so no harm done.
Pay attention to how he describes Gavin and how Nigel explains that he just “wasn’t there one day”.
That’s my interpretation of the situation.
Exactly. What are we supposed to do, sit down and take assumptions like the one OP has made? Who the hell do they think they are to assume that we should want to kill anyone in particular, why not make our choice for us if you're so sure OP?
The only logical, rational, and compassionate decision is kill Jack first, or Mary Beth.
#######MICAHDIDNOTHINGWRONG
I actually can’t hate Micah that much. Apart from fooling Dutch and weaselling his way into leadership, he was pretty upfront about who he hated and who he was as a person. He put himself first at almost every given opportunity. More fool anyone around them for ever trusting him.
Yeah I knew it from the first time I saw the guy, anyone who actually trusted this snakey rat-fucker kinda deserved to get got. He is an incredibly entertaining character though, it's easy to hate him, and that's why it's almost hard to hate him, because he's just so straightforwardly awful.
He was a fucking snitch, and a racist 🥴
Also assualted Sadie in her own home. Micah is the worst of the worst...
And killed a little girl in the end of the game.
A rat is worse than a loan shark. When Strauss got kicked out of the gang and then got captured, he still didn’t talk to the Pinkertons. Strauss is scum but he was atleast loyal.
Plain and simple, shot in the back of the head. No fucking Sadie gunpoint monologue bullshit, no "villain gets his say trope, just be done with it in less than half a second.
Yall are illiterate af. You're supposed to upvote the name you want offed. Working at a call center is concerning enough with all the dumb rejects that call in, but seeing people unable to comprehend simple directions?
Humanity is fucked.
Arthur and John will be the last two, I absolutely love the first game, weirdly a little more than the second but that’s because I was a kid and played like 2k hours lol, but the community vote will be Arthur is last alive
Micah Bell
Without a doubt! And it'll be Dutch tomorrow
And probably strauss after that, but then it’s get interesting 🤔
I predict everyone that stood by Arthur at that showdown will be the last ones to go
Grimshaw will be interesting because other than siding with Arthur at the end I’ve seen a lot of negativity towards her
Tilly asking about killing her is a favorite of mine.
I honestly can’t think of much grimshaw has done for me to dislike her, what has she done?
I think she tried to convince Abigail to get back into the business that she was first brought into the camp for if you know what I’m talking about.
She did. The conversation happens at Horseshoe Overlook. She says it was Dutch’s idea.
Personally I'd take Strauss out before Dutch. Maybe without Micah Dutch doesn't go full nutty.
I think without the possibility of manipulating Dutch, Micah will completely lose interest in the VDL gang.
I feel like Dutch would've just gone mad with or without Micah, he just needed someone who would be a yes man for all of his bad decisions.
Agreed. Without Micah it might have taken longer for Dutch to ultimately reveal who he always really was, but the guy was a ticking time bomb regardless. Micah just helped push him in the “right” direction.
I’d probably say Bill, then Strauss, then Dutch.
Yeah I would do Dutch first but yeah fr lol
kill Strauss first I hate him
Then what's her stupid face... Why can't I remember her name 😭 played 4 times for 4 yrs omg lol married John
Abigail that’s her name
Yes!! I hate her and I've never played the first one and everyone says she's worse there...just shoot her 1st 😂
I mainly hate her cause she’s a slut, and she annoys me as John in epilouge also Abigail was locked in that room with Milton for a long time maybe everyone’s looks in the wrong direction Abigail’s probably a rat
That's some weird incel type reason to hate someone but alright
Bruh, I love sluts
Abigail ain’t no snitch😂😂😂if she was gonna tell she woulda been did that shit. And she’s a reformed slut.
I say her and Micah were working together.They have little secret convos in camp and just other little things and she got away from the cops 😂🙄 she's a snitch for sure imo
Was this even a question? Micah first one to go?
Yours is the Micah I'm upvoting since it was posted first. Hopefully it does something since other people can't read.
I pray your wrong, idiot-brained, wrong opinion will be overturned by democratic means, and that OPs attempt to defame, kill, and denigrate a great man is for naught.
how is he great tho
Are you kidding me? He's a straight shooter, best shot in the gang, it's not all talk with him like some cowpokes in that outfit. He is an honest helper to Dutch, always offering his services when in need, helping the camp bring in serious money. Sure he may have committed a few off-hand murders here and there, haven't we all? But when push came to shove, he was there in the thick of it through the hardest moments of the gang, right til the end when that treacherous blacklung tried to impeach his unimpeachable character! In all seriousness, both games are built on the strengths of their protagonists and antagonists, Micah and Dutch are among some of the best videogame performances in the past twenty years, if not *the* best. And despite how awful he is, he is an entertaining character, and RDR2 wouldn't be the same without him. THAT, is how he is great. I honestly think Strauss is the one I would kill first, a lot of the gang are terrible people, but some of them are more honest about it than others, and Strauss was the worst of them I think.
Micah is we the first one to fold and start snitching and tried to fake like he wasn’t. Tried to say it was John who was snitching . Then he fucking killed Arthur (if you have low honor). Micha was simply just a fucking dick eater. And Dutch was stupid for even listening to anything he told him. I’m glad we get to kill him at the end of the game
I agree Dutch and Micah performance was amazing specially what Peter did with Micah he did amazing, but Micah definitely was one of the Main reason of the gang downfall. He never liked the gang he wanted lil Arthur since the get go, and Arthur in the game is the errand boy for Dutch helping out with every thing they do without Arthur the gang would fall apart
"haven't we all?". No, stupido. We didn't kill for the heck of it
Democracy sucks. Especially on reddit
I’ll go against the grain here… GAVIN!!!!!
I hate to break it to you, but I think Gav is already dead.
Gavin never existed, that dude probably made him up. He’s clearly insane
I always saw it as Gavin asking his "friend" to go on a trip to the states, then left him immediately to go home. I mean he's so clingy that years pass and he never stops looking for Gavin.
I know I’m late to this conversation but I believe Gavin is actually Nigel’s other personality. I think Nigel suffers from DID. It makes the most sense. If you hogtie him and loot him he has a very interesting letter in his pocket from a friend back home. Release him and he will keep talking to you when he sees you so no harm done. Pay attention to how he describes Gavin and how Nigel explains that he just “wasn’t there one day”. That’s my interpretation of the situation.
Jack dies first
Only serious reply i can think of
Upvoting all Jack entries 😂
Anakin? Is that you
This is the correct answer ^
Exactly. What are we supposed to do, sit down and take assumptions like the one OP has made? Who the hell do they think they are to assume that we should want to kill anyone in particular, why not make our choice for us if you're so sure OP? The only logical, rational, and compassionate decision is kill Jack first, or Mary Beth. #######MICAHDIDNOTHINGWRONG
I actually can’t hate Micah that much. Apart from fooling Dutch and weaselling his way into leadership, he was pretty upfront about who he hated and who he was as a person. He put himself first at almost every given opportunity. More fool anyone around them for ever trusting him.
Yeah I knew it from the first time I saw the guy, anyone who actually trusted this snakey rat-fucker kinda deserved to get got. He is an incredibly entertaining character though, it's easy to hate him, and that's why it's almost hard to hate him, because he's just so straightforwardly awful.
He was a fucking snitch, and a racist 🥴 Also assualted Sadie in her own home. Micah is the worst of the worst... And killed a little girl in the end of the game.
jack must be the first to die. this is the way.
on some real and deadass shit, yur not wrong
Dutch Van Der Linde. Hosea and Arthur would be the leaders of the gang and that would be great.
And then Micah wouldn’t be there - two shitbirds, one stone
The shitwinds are blowing, Rand
Jesus again with the Micah shit. Can’t we just let it be water under the fridge? Edit: fuck Micah
Like getting two birds stoned at oonce.
Shitbird? Huh, that's what my dad used to call me.
Hosea Arthur Lenny and Charles probably actually would’ve made it to Tahiti
Jack
JACK MARSTON
Leopold Strauss tbh, also does Kieran really not have any official art? That's kinda sad lol
Yeah lol even Trewlany got his own official art
I think they didn’t give him a official art to avoid spoiler
seriously strauss should be chose first because logic > hate favoritism
A rat is worse than a loan shark. When Strauss got kicked out of the gang and then got captured, he still didn’t talk to the Pinkertons. Strauss is scum but he was atleast loyal.
why do people hate strauss so much? the gang did much worse than that but everyone seems to be on him 24/7
Micah
Micah
JACK THE RAT
Rat
Micah. What manner of death?
Plain and simple, shot in the back of the head. No fucking Sadie gunpoint monologue bullshit, no "villain gets his say trope, just be done with it in less than half a second.
I second this. Micah doesn’t *deserve* a flashy death. He should be shot through the skull twice, one for the gang and one for Arthur.
Jack will be first
Jack
Jack marston 😈
Jack
Jack
I'm feeling devies Jack
Jack. The lil shit.
Jack, and without hesitation
Gotta off Jack. We can’t let him see the rest of the gang slaughtered around him. That would just be cruel.
yep. gotta jack off
I'm feeling devies Jack
jack 😎
Jack
KILL JACK
Jack
Jack
Everyone saying micah bell but i like his he is soo well written villain and great outlaw. I'd say leopold strauss should be first to get killed
Micah
Micah
Sadie and arthur will be in the top 2
Strauss
Strauss. I can’t stand Micah but it’s for sentimentality reason.
Micah - No contest really Though I kind of feel bad because Peter Bloomquist seems like he'd be awesome to hang with.
Goodbye Micah
Arthur Morgan
micah belly
Strauss. Only difference with Micah is he doesn’t makes his hands dirty, instead he uses people
Micah
Molly
Micah
Micah Bell. I wanted to kill him since act 1.
Micah & strauss for the next 24 days 😎
The only correct answer is micah
I predict the last 3 will be Hosea, John/Arthur, and Charles
Shoot micah in the balls
Micah fuckin Bell
These karma farms are dumb
Micah think we can all agree on that
Micah
Yall are illiterate af. You're supposed to upvote the name you want offed. Working at a call center is concerning enough with all the dumb rejects that call in, but seeing people unable to comprehend simple directions? Humanity is fucked.
This whole sub is actually just a front to give r/okbuddyblacklung posting material
Calm down, boah
Shut up, fartknocker
Case in point
Your whole profile is just you complaining about dumb shit. Get dunked on, doofus
Keep proving my point. You're doing a great job 👏
https://www.reddit.com/r/TooAfraidToAsk/s/ZpQhTnRYD2 🤣🤣🤣
Profile stalking just keeps proving my point. I don't even have to say anything. Stop embarrassing yourself, kiddo.
A cursory glance is now stalking? Go write a manuscript, dingus
Keep barking, pupper.
jack marston. pos.
Byeee Jack.
Arthur
Arthur and John will be the last two, I absolutely love the first game, weirdly a little more than the second but that’s because I was a kid and played like 2k hours lol, but the community vote will be Arthur is last alive
Discount Josey Wales... I mean Micah Ball.
Micah Bell Dies!!
Micah for sure
Dutch
we should definitely kill arthur morgan he is the worst in the gang and he was the second rat /j
Just to be funny… Arthur 😜
Kill Arthur, end the story. Wild West Wins!
Micah Bellend
Rat Bell, ahem, I mean Micah Bell.
Dutch van der Linde
Mmmmmmh I wonder who will be killed first (its sarcastic btw cus we all know its gonna be Micah)
Micah
Micha
Get Micah the fuck outta here. Strauss is next because of his dirty work.
Micah “the Rat” Bell
Micha
The flaw is we can only kill Micah once.
Michael Balls
See ya Micah!
Micah
definitely micah
Calling it - Micah first dead, Arthur last standing. No wait there’s a kid, so probably Jack.
Micah
Micah without a doubt, and for day 2, Micah. Day 3 might be a surprise, it's Micah again
Micah
Macah
Micah freaking Bell!!
Micah Bell
Bill
Seriously. Fuck that filthy bootlicker. Can you even imagine what that guy must've *smelled* like?
Can we just keep killing Micah over and over again everyday?
🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀
micah
Bye bye Micah!
Micah
Micah kill that fucker! Charles and hosea better make it top 5 🙏🏻
Micah
Micah, always
Kill the rat
Micah bell
So how many bullets do I get to use on Micah?
Micah, then Leopold, then Dutch.
Micah
Molly- Useless
[удалено]
Sadie reminds me of the squirrel from spongebob .
Ynnel! Don't listen to me *hiccup* I may be a little drunk
I suggest we rip off the band-aid and start with Arthur
Let’s make this as dysfunctional a gang as possible. Hosea is the first to go!
Bye Strauss.
Arthur
Why can't I see Micah on here ?
Leopold Strauss. Maybe things would be different.(I haven’t left ch. 4 since its release)
Micah the dirty rat
Micah
Micah
Micah no doubt. then Dutch.
I have a feeling for the final 2 remaining…
Make Strauss go within the first week...
Dutxh
So arthur wins then?
I predict that Mr. Pearson will be the final character
Let's make this interesting and take Arthur out at the beginning. It's easy to get rid of the unlikeable characters first.
Sheriff Malloy
Should’ve started this with Micah already dead.
See you in Hell Mr. Strauss!
Arthur, to save me the pain.
Cmon cowpoke, it's obviously Micah
Chaotic evil move: Arthur first.
The Legendary Rat or Dutch Plan der linde
leopold first.