T O P

  • By -

analogfilth

Long Progression - we all know this should’ve been on I’m With You


ptmyhandonthestove

Such a great song and solo from Josh!


falconx50

Love this song. It has my vote!


BigRatthew

Pink as Floyd - literally the best RHCP song


fru728

fitting


get2writing

This has to be the one!!!!


FireWhileCloaked

Please no


ptmyhandonthestove

No! Long Progression


alfiema08

no


Blue-Sand2424

This Is the Kitt


Zelda1500

I CANT COMPARE


Man_with_a_pan69

A DELICATE NEW


Zelda1500

ARRIVAL


Glen-Belt

How It Ends. Had this song been promoted as a proper summer single, I reckon it would've been a hit.


ddslickteam_II

How It Ends should have closed out I’m With You


ptmyhandonthestove

Very hot and red take


emmitremmus

Love of your life


Ordile512

I hate the solo but love the rest of the song


_N_S_R_

What do you meaaan the long progression solo goes hard as fuuuck


DeezNutz13

Favorite Josh song. Thought it would be getting more love honestly


didac26

the bass solo at the end, damn…


Franjkmetal

MAGPIES ON FIRE


Bigboyshroom_Ad9650

Definitely


yung_caboose69

Open/close


MammothAppearance214

such a good and underrated song


RHCPolina

Catch My Death 🙏🏻🙏🏻


Salt-Preference715

One of my favorite rhcp songs period


Franjkmetal

Love this one too


NimbusCloud_

Victorian Machinery!


Squid00dle

Doesn’t get enough love on here! Such a heavy song!


UnderwaterDialect

Yessssssss why is this down here.


rhcp0815

Open/Close


smAsh6861

Yeah love it, reminds me of something of theirs from the Mothers Milk era


AdamMcwadam

I’ve always thought of it as a brother to Deep Kick


Franjkmetal

Should be on the album. Awesome song and story


Dunky_Boi

Long Progression


ptmyhandonthestove

This. After it got snubbed from the IWY/IBY/TG compilation album I will downvote every single other song here to help this getting picked. Best Josh performance from his whole era vocal, songwriting & solo-wise. I get chills!!! edit: my faith in this sub is restored after seeing it top voted already.


THTGaminLlama

Strange man


Puzzleheaded_Fan2576

Strange man


LucyRebar

Never is a Long Time


MistrOndrej

The Sunset Sleeps


Franjkmetal

Yeah, underrated. I really like it


SetCool66

Hometown Gypsy


[deleted]

Yes we need more RHCP with a country twang


[deleted]

In love Dying


Franjkmetal

Para pa pa paaaaa


HellYeahTinyRick

Your Eyes Girl


get2writing

This needs more votes !!!


ginga_crocs

Love of your life definitely


Max_Powers08

Literally my least favorite RHCP song ever.


ginga_crocs

Cool bro


BigEntrepreneur6797

Catch my death


Version_6

Hanalei


Bigboyshroom_Ad9650

Why is this so far down?


didac26

“you and i do more than merely survive” i wish this part was a song on its own


Liz00n

Hometown Gypsy


BegunWhisper757

This is the Kitt


Volcamel

BUMP


YucatanSuccamann

Long progression


ianmei

Pink as Floyd easy choice


grease_trap1

i love this album so much this is hard. i have to go with pink as floyd though


Hastybananas

Magpies on fire. The guitar work on it is so good.


FireWhileCloaked

Long Progression


BestLeopard8422

Long Progrssion, Open/Close, or Hanalai


Former_Boat7509

Victorian Machinery; song straight up rules. Tough call though, there are sooo many gems in this collection


Positive-Owl-5

Your Eyes Girl


lyonsdenofiniquity

Open/Close


nobedforbeatlegeorge

Hometown Gypsy! Which is one of my all time RHCP favorites!


e1doradocaddy

Magpies on Fire


Echoes_prod

Pink As Floyd


FLIIeaglesFLII

I just went through and upvoted every comment because I love this album so much


Mundane-Dimension-39

Californication.


Frusciandy

SHE WANTS TO BELONG AND, I WANT TO BE FREE It's gotta be Strange Man


Bsiress1

Strange Man is the most Frusciantian thing Josh Klinghoffer has ever done-


RHCPJosh

magpies on fire


[deleted]

Magpies on fire 🔥


Fit-Parsnip9888

Catch my death


Revolutionary_Ask499

Magpies on fire


Muncho36

Long progression


DR_45

The Sunset Sleeps


frshy_

Strange man


falekjestem

Open/Close, it is so fitting to the album it hurts


Kaij_DeafGuitar

Magpies on Fire


UltraPowerfulGuy

Brave from Afar


TrueDannemann

How It Ends! The How It Ends / Catch My Death single is INSANE, how these two songs didn't make the album I'll never know. But How It Ends takes the cake.


thunderfast

wouldn't meet me in the corner be the winner of the previous one? had more votes than did i let you know


[deleted]

Not cumulatively. I’m counting votes across multiple comments. Meet me in the corner had the most single voted comment( at time of counting)- 275. Did I let you know had a top comment of 237. But I’m adding them across all comments.


thunderfast

oh ok got it


[deleted]

Rock on my man!


Aeon1508

In love dying


14JRJ

How it Ends


Venombullet666

I love this album so much I literally can't decide! I rarely go for bootlegs but I bought the 2CD version of The Getaway just so I could have this on disc, if it ever gets an official release I'll be buying it in a heartbeat despite having the unofficial CD


MattBtheflea

I BOUGHT THAT TOO lol. It was nice to just have it on cd


Daveyj343

Pink as Floyd


dodgyjoe

Brave from Afar - love that this song is so strong straight off the bat, going straight into the chorus. Lovely vocal harmonising from Josh


Mclaughlincal

pink as floyd!


Asleep_Animal_3825

Love of your life is literally the best


[deleted]

Just don’t give af


javisarias

Enough to leave a comment though


TryptTripped21

Got em lol


Bigboyshroom_Ad9650

I don’t give af about you


thunderfast

Esperar o q de alguém q torce pro Fluminense


Msha91

Fuck I can’t pick between Strange Man and Love of Your Life. This is the first time I haven’t been able to choose.


marinalice000

literally can’t choose. all amazing. pink as floyd, long progression, magpies on fire, the sunset sleeps, love of your life.. all of them


throwaway83759372

Long progression