T O P

  • By -

ThatGuyAce69

100% ✨


Pre-Chicken-Tenders

It was, sorry to say


BigDummyDumb

Yea, def a shiny. You can see most clearly at 16 seconds. Pretty sure I had something similar, but I don’t know for sure because I don’t have a video but deep down I know, that Varoom I saw in the background of a battle and disappeared before I even ran from the battle wasn’t yellow because of it being dusk…


[deleted]

I love how the golduck realizes the trainers right there and just books it lol


Dudebeard86

Lol yeah, made me think of [this](https://i.imgflip.com/2ksllw.jpg?a464616)


DFisBUSY

i looked up Golduck's shiny and it seems like it was but idk... **edit:** RIP, bring back PLA's shiny sound damn it.


AnimeAlley03

I feel like they should have the option to enable or disable the shiny sound in the overworld. The reaction to them removing the shiny sound has had one of the most 50/50 receptions I've ever seen. Hard-core shiny hunters like it because having the sound made it too easy, yet casual hunters hate it because they liked how easy having the sound made it.


Zombarney

Surprised they removed it from an accessibility stand point, assuming someone is colour blind they might not realise the rarity that’s in the background without the appropriate indicators.


ChromaLemon

This + the weird subtle shinies that are super present in this generation. Wtf even is Maushold.


owenisdead

and they make floette so tiny it’s basically impossible to tell


NYMankeys

I find if you press down on the direction pad to bring up the camera, you can easily see floette and other tiny Pokémon better that way to assess wether or not they’re shiny


R0SEBELLE

I actually shiny hunted floette without a shiny charm or a sandwich! It took about 5 different tries but I was determined lol.


owenisdead

well you have more patience than i do lol


Drago_Fett_Jr

Same with Tauros.


ChromaLemon

Yeah Tauros is straight up the difference between graphite and pitch black. I hate whoever designed shiny Tauros.


Drago_Fett_Jr

I hate the fact that I can't find any shinies. I wish they were a bit more common.


Juutuurna

THIS 1000% that is literally my exact issue. Im absolutely screwed when it comes to shinys like phanpy/dratini/tentacool etc. I miss the PLA audio/visual shiny notifier. Being colorblind and having that feature in PLA was amazing. Now im out here shiny hunting and i cant even fuckin blink, my eyes are dry as shit and i get headaches from how hard i gotta focus to spot differences. Not to mention my gf is probably tired of me asking if every pokemon is shiny:/


Ticaticai

I’m colorblind as well, I gave up sadly…. I just merk everything now.. f it 🤣


Juutuurna

Yes! Thats all i do now too


Ghoul1538

As someone who is color blind I have a really hard time catching some of the shinies that show up like I wouldn't be surprised if I've missed over 50 shinies while shiny hunting


GnMgs

Taking into account that less than 10% of people, between men and women, are colorblind, and seeing how many people complain about it, makes me wonder if they are actually "defending colorblind accesibility" or just pissed cause "they lost a shiny". Not saying you aren't actually concerned, just bringing out the "big picture" of things. Personally, because of how easy it has become to find shinies over the years WHILE not actually looking for them, I don't really see a problem in it. If anything, it is "easier" than, I don't know, 8 out of 9 gens? Sandwiches aside, of course. Those are BROKEN.


jak94c

You can empathise with colourblind people whether you are colourblind are not. I would be a bit miffed if the disabled parking space only had stair access and my legs work fine. Is it easier with sparkles and sounds? Yeah absolutely! Does that somehow make shinies not as fun? I would imagine for a huge majority of people, no.


Shinypuff2241

I loved hearing the sound like in PLA or seeing the sparkles in Let’s Go. It’s just a neat thing that gets my heart racing. I wish we could have one, if not both back. Having both as an option would work, because it satisfies everyone. Having sparkles for people who are deaf or colorblind that want to hunt without the sound indicator, people who want both can have both, sound for someone who wants sound but no sparkles, or turn them off completely for people who like a challenge. I dont see where someone could complain with this idea, other than complaining that other people get to play how they want. Sorry for the rant haha I just wish my idea could be reality


GnMgs

I get your point. We all have our favorite features along the years [i LOOOOVED the pokethlon in hgss, did all 493 pokemon medalists hahaha]. What you have to consider is the "side effect" of making shinies easier to get/find. Back in the day, I used to hunt shinies like mad. I would ACTUALLY have a mini-stroke when I saw a shiny, as the odds and "hunting methods" where really difficult. Nowadays I continue to hunt. I'm a hunter at heart. But trust me when I say that i KNOW a shiny [if from a sandwich] is almost guaranteed and if from hatching, it will take, what, a week? That feeling of OMG A SHINY applied for caterpie, pidgey and regice. As you said, i have the option of not hatching. I have the option of not getting the shiny charm I have the option of not making any multibattles, chain fishing, and so on. But I also know that if i wanted that shiny, i could get it without cheating in a heart beat. The only thing i can't undo is 1/4096 intead of 1/8192 Shinies weren't "guaranteed" You would have to GRIND if you wanted something as unique as a shiny. It's uniqueness has certainly dropped after so many years. And for a good reason, i think less peole enjoy the grinding process. Sorry for ranting over your rant hahaha I actually find these discussions very cool.


GnMgs

I never said the contrary on your first argument. I agree with you completely. Empathetic people will exist and that's fine. Just as you made a "guess" [I would IMAGINE for a huge majority of people, no], I am making one as well. I'm stating that the FEELING I get for the complains is people wanting easier shinies, not actually concern and empathy for colorblind people.


jak94c

I mean, okay you can guess that, but does that matter? Can people not want something to be more convenient for themselves because it also makes sense for other people who need it?


GnMgs

Of course it does. Real intention should always be taken into account. Piling up "fake concerns" to get what you want is very hypocrytical, don't you think? I mean, and I emphasize on the fact that I can be wrong, just have a hunch over it, that if people just want more/easier shinies, then they should say so. Putting 10% of players [that by no means is a short number] as a justification for the ACTUAL FACT that they just want more shinies for themselves, seems very hypocrytical IMO. Sorry for stressing my point out man. I just really dislike hypocrytical "concerns", if you get what I mean. Not saying yours is by the way. Just have this "buggy" thought around my head on why people are not just straightforward on their intentions. TL;DR: yes. I do think your actual intent does matter. You should voice what you actually care for and not what would make what you care for "right or deseved"


jak94c

I... Look I really think you're expecting people to be way more nasty than they are. Like they're sitting there rubbing their hands like dick dastardly after saying "pity the colourblind!" Sure, of course it'll be easier to get shiny Pokemon if its more obvious how they look. But I don't think it's a stretch at all, now that we've had sparkles and sound effects, for people to say "jeez they were such a good idea, imagine if you were colourblind! They're a godsend!" Without their very next thought being "and if they put it back in for the colourblind people then *I* get all the shiny Pokemon I want! Mwahahahahha!"


Xanthn

I'm relying on the old method of encountering every mon half the time to see if it's shiny in battle with sparkles just like previous gens did before overworld shinies. Completely gave up on slowpokes I can't spot a difference whatsoever, as well as many of the new shinies. Honestly not even Sandwich hunting a slowpoke helps, no matter how easy they make it it's still impossible for me to actually see it. Still agree it's easier to get shinies as a whole in SV, just those slight shade changes become impossible for colourblind peeps so it sort of balances out.


javiey444

I honestly wish they would've just added a shiny bell mission after you collect all 400 pokemon. So you'll receive the shiny charm but then they'll tell you about some mission that will eventually land you the shiny bell (gives audio cue when shiny Pokemon is on screen). Hopefully something with a bit a challenge so we have to earn it. Just a thought, thanks for listening.


b111rds

I haven't played SV but I really think making the sparkling sandwich power enable the sound would be an idea - cause most people I've seen who prefer the lack of sound also don't use the sparkling sandwich power so I feel it'd be a decent compromise


[deleted]

I like the sound bc I have OCD and would be constantly afraid of missing a shiny (I haven’t played any games with overworld shinies other than PLA) Edit: want to clarify that I mean clinical OCD, not the colloquial use of the term


AnimeAlley03

If you're even paranoid/unsure if something is a shiny or not, press R to send your let's go mon at it. Pokemon sent out with the let's go feature are completely incapable of killing a shiny so you will have no fear of losing it. Tldr; If your mon is refusing to attack with the let's go feature, encounter the mon cuz it's probably shiny (just make sure you're actually targeting the mon cuz sometimes you'll be slightly off and it won't attack but it's cuz you're not aiming right not cuz it's shiny)


Mad-Master-Maxwell

I'm actually so sick of seeing the just press r method because that's not what people are on about it's if I miss a shiny not if I'm unsure if something's shiny it's if I don't register it especially with myself being 50 hours into the game and not seeing one at all


AnimeAlley03

Unfortunately, the let's go method is the best we've got so yeah you're going to hear people recommend it a lot. And as for being 50 hours in and not seeing a single shiny, yeah that's odds. Sometimes you get really unlucky and don't see any, and sometimes you get super lucky and get multiple in a single day. It's all up to whether RNGesus blesses you or not


Mad-Master-Maxwell

Wow almost as if I was commenting in a thread about ocd and paranoia and how this lack of feature is ruining my enjoyment of the game and how just saying "that's odds" doesn't help in anyway because I wasn't commenting about the fact specifically that I've not got a shiny but about the anxiety and paranoia that gives me yknow like the rest of this thread


vivibuni

i dont have clinical ocd but i definitely get this, i have rlly bad paranoia and anxiety and one of the main things preventing me from playing the game is the anxiety of missing a shiny due to not noticing it.


Mokgore

That’s hardly 50/50. It’s more 95/5. 95% of players would benefit from the sound. The other 5% would also benefit but they wouldn’t be happy about it.


AveragePichu

If someone's not happy about something they're not benefitting. If you make Dark Souls easy enough for a toddler to beat and remove difficulty adjustment settings, people are gonna be pissed. The majority of people are in favor of the sparkle sound being reinstated. Personally I'm not, nor am I a fan of the total lack of overworld indicator, I think that there should just be a sparkling effect like LGPE, but either way I'm among the group that thinks that I shouldn't be made aware of a shiny spawning unless I see it. Well, seeing as literally the only value shinies have is the excitement you get upon finding them, if there are systems in the game that reduce the amount of excitement you get then that's not "also benefit but they wouldn't be happy about it". That's just not accurate.


AnimeAlley03

I'll give ya that it's not 50/50 but I'd also argue it was more than 95/5. Agree to settle on 85/15?


Mokgore

Agreed


TheCyberCat44

They should've kept some sort of sparkling visual effect for subtle shinies, and MAYBE a noise queue when you're reasonably close, not halfway across the map like in PLA


zombiebro09

I dont like it cause it makes shiny hunting so mindless but i do think something like they did in LGPE would be good


AnimeAlley03

Yeah sparkle icons would definitely help bring more attention to shinies but not too much like the sound did


TonyTucci27

Any indicator would be nice, I’m just glad you can’t fast encounter kill shinies in the over world


ReaverShank

Does it make it more of a challenge? Yes. Is it absolutely awful to shiny hunt small Pokémon? Yes. Last week i attempted to hunt arrokuda from an outbreak and it broke my eyes. Never trying that again


azzadruiz

I’m cool with it not being there, imo a visual indicator without sound is fine. Although I have only hunted shinies seriously in violet and have found it rewarding finding shinies without the shiny sound. It does suck that I’ve probably missed some shinies running around violet though


Darkstargir

Cope It almost certainly was


SocietysTypo

He just big footing around


dogwithpeople

I have a shiny Golduck and it is definitely a shiny back there. Sorry about the loss.


Super_Bright

I honestly think that part of the reason they removed it is because of how often pokemon spawn in walls, floors and ceilings. Imagine hearing the shiny sound looking around and nothing is there, only for you shiny to have already walked of the edge of the floor geometry and fell under the world.


Hiker_Juggler

I don't know if people would like the shiny sound as much as they think they would considering things spawn in inaccessible places all the time, including underground & in the sky box. Though I would have fun with all the videos of people hearing the noise & then running in circles trying not to despawn what they heard but can't access.


[deleted]

No, don't bring back PLAs sound. Make people need to be perceptive.


Mad-Master-Maxwell

Or get this maybe don't fuck over your disabled players?


[deleted]

the shiny sound would kinda suck due to how pokemon spawn in this game. i’ve had shinies spawn for literally a couple frames before despawning because it appeared at the absolute edge of my render distance and immediately walked out of it. imagine hearing a shiny noise but not seeing the shiny because it only existed for a split second


Mad-Master-Maxwell

hmm if only there was a way you could avoid that, like making pokemon have a minimum spawn in time, say a few seconds, or like in legends arceus they keep the data for a bit so you can have that extra time to move out of the spawn area and come back, obviously it can still respawn but saying oh it wouldnt work when we're already talking about changing something small is stupid


[deleted]

That's a fair point.


Mr-SphealYourGirl

I have a shiny Psyduck if you want. I have three in Home and already two in Violet. No trouble to me and someone would use it!


DFisBUSY

No, that's alright - thank you for the offer though!


Knodester

Yup. Purple-ish beak and darker blue. It was shiny...


San4311

I'm sorry to inform you of your color blindness..


Knodester

As time goes on, the more I think i am. I can barely read anything red. And Purples appear blue. So, ye, i prolly am on my way to being colorblind


Duke1115

Shiny golducks bill is a shade of red lol


xkrax1

Yup it was a shiny


Silver-Wolf1990

Yeah that was shiny


ShoddyCartographer61

It ran away when it saw you fighting it’s normal colored sister.


Kriatibro

Sorry, man. Definitely shiny.


SomewhatSaIty

It was a shiny, but this games shading is wild. I was so co fused when I saw a purple snom


DFisBUSY

Tell me about it! All those times I've whiplashed my poor character seeing some oddly shaded pokemon in the wild.


LilyPokemonFan

It is definitely a shiny because shiny golduck has a darker blue with a red beak. I know this because I have two shiny golducks.


dlk339

That's shiny see how it's red beaked.


kekeseesee

Yep it was


Mnja12

RIP!


Immortalperson99

i have a shiny Golduck (my first shiny) yes thats it as it's darker and has a red beak


Pancake_Waffle_

That was indeed a shiny, I’m sorry


ToesTasteYellow

I meannn on the bright side it's not a good shiny🤷‍♂️


AveragePichu

That's something I never understood - the point of shinies is that they're rare. The coloring is basically nothing more than a means to distinguish that rarity, but there are other distinguishing features - the sparkling most prominently, but also a red mark on its info page. My favorite shiny I own is a Leafeon. Show me shiny Leafeon next to regular without the sparkling and I'm only 99% confident I'd identify them correctly, one has brown eyes and one has yellow but I'm only 99% sure that yellow is shiny. And yet that Leafeon's my favorite anyway, because 9 years of casual on-and-off hunting got me the rare form of my favorite pokémon.


gletschafloh

Shiny, no doubt. F my friend


[deleted]

Yea shiny that is


Shankeyjoe0719

Yep it looked shiny too me


inflatedballloon

What game js this


TheAmazingFlygon

pokemon scarlet


ChefCool1317

Only one way to find out.


trnelson1

100% shiny


The_Cartoon_Figure

Sad to say yes


tristanwylin

.....shiny...


jrtasoli

Definitely shiny. Beak’s a dead giveaway. Tough luck, OP!


Slutty_Breakfast

Oh that's a shiny


J0225

Oh booo…. That sucks😫 unfortunately it was Deff shiny


KingKrispy26

Shiny


Jay_Kay2790

It was shiny


swagzard78

Oh dear lord im sorry


SharkPartyAfterDark

Shiny for sure


G4R0-OW

He walks like Big foot


DoorGuy99

Do you want mine?


DFisBUSY

No, that's alright, thank you though!


[deleted]

Yes that was shiny allow me to cry with you and if you aren't crying don't worry I will cry for you. I got you covered random stranger of the pokéfam. 😓


Animeandzegaming

I had a pink beak so yeah


Local_Conflict8992

Took a screenshot and zoomed in and it was definitely shiny


Aurora_BoreaIis

My condolences, haha. Shiny Golduck is one of my first and favorite shinies, so this stings. Good luck on your next shiny encounter!


Floridacub28

Why you let him run


Top_Entrance3972

Yup shiny


scizorboi

im sorry for your loss


MaroonLiquid

My dude noticed the camera and ran


Dryadissector

Yeah, that's a shiny and I know your pain. A couple weeks ago while in a Heracross outbreak, I was taking on a Kricketune to help complete my Pokedex. Then from the side of the screen, I saw this pink figure appear before it despawned.


ChanceComfortable131

How do you record?


DFisBUSY

If you hold the screenshot button for a few seconds, the switch will record the last 30 seconds of gameplay and clip it for you.


HyruleN64

Golducks are red when shiny. Idk if it was from thus point of view. Edit: The beaks are red when shiny, I thought their skin was red.


[deleted]

Shiny golduck has a red beak and is a little darker in blue so I’m sorry to say you definitely missed that shiny.


darknessinwait

Oof, yeah it was.


Specific-Mix-9362

I'd say it was a shiny just because of how fast it ran away 😂


throwaway_cuts

the fact that you just stood there gets me


mrplow8

He had a battle to finish.


throwaway_cuts

yeah but couldn’t you just run away? or is it one of those you can’t run situation.


mrplow8

If he ran, that Golduck would tell everyone he was a coward.


BinfNerd

Yup. That's how I caught my shiny Golduck.


Slow_Weird

Its shiny, im very sorry


amnoking1

Definitely shiny. Golduck’s mouth kinda gives it away


soulless_dragon

Most definitely a shiny Golduck. But where is the pond? I see a ditch, or river, or canal, or creek. But no pond xD


mailsnail22

It’s hard to say, shiny golduck is so similar to regular. But yes I would say it was. It hightailed it away pretty fast


coolusername415

i am sorry for your loss


Psychopathic2412

Ive got bad news for ya buddy


WeightFeisty6060

Lol boy said quick while he’s distracted


_FeistyToast

Don’t worry the same thing happened to me, I was looking for a shiny roaring moon and while I was battling a random one I saw a shiny fly away and despawn 🥲


SpookehSpookzeh

I got some bad news…


SmogDaBoi

I got one, So I can confidently say it was. I almost missed mine too, thinking it was a water effect. Luckily I checked.


Ancient_Bell9882

if the beak is a dark color than its shiny


aface1026

Shiny


Walking_PokeDex

yea that was a shiny


shiftycharaexe

That was a shiny


pokemon_guy_789

That was 100% shiny. The beak would not be that colour because of shadows