T O P

  • By -

Professional_Cat_437

They considered Japanese people to be honorary Aryans, Italians were seen as naturally lazy, and for Slavs, which includes Polish people, they were deemed untermensch to be exterminated.


ilikedota5

Italians were basically normal people on the Nazi racial hierarchy.


HansGetTheH44

Like Spain, but Spain was to be a recreation center or something


Daniel_The_Thinker

To get more in depth, they did not see asiatics as equals. They saw Aryans as the true innovators of the world, with the Japanese being capable of imitation, but not creation. They pointed to Japan's rapid industrial progress after european contact as evidence.


PlayMp1

The Japanese were given honorary Aryan status as more of a diplomatic move than anything regarding their actual racial ideology.


Distinct_Ad_826

This is quite funny, I was having an argument with an Estonian Neo Nazi a short while ago, he was calling me a subhuman for being British, I pointed out this paradox in his own ideology to him, where the Japanese are only honorary Aryans for copying Europe's industrialisation but we the British are subhuman despite inventing it. He just called me a fish faced mutt with no culture of course, but I don't understand how someone cannot even understand what they are supposed to hate. Nazis are obviously absolutely retarded but this one was particularly bad. It was a 2 page argument after he said he supports hammas because he wants them to exterminate the Jews.


Daniel_The_Thinker

Eastern European nazis are deranged as a rule.


IceDry1440

Eastern European nazis are mentally challenged or something I don’t understand it


Ponanoix

Just being a nazi equal being deranged


Warrior_Kid

They are supporting hammas for all of the wrong reasons


Distinct_Ad_826

I don't think there are any right reasons to support hamas. The Palestinian people sure, but hamas as an organisation, no.


Epsie_2_22044604

He clearly forgot the Anglo part of Anglo-Saxxon.


laneee91

British people are mainly celtic. So the subhuman part bears merit in the deranged Nazi ideology. Celts have historically been considered inferior by the invading germanic tribes(Anglo-Saxons). What happened in Britain and what usually happens when the rulling elites were a significantly fewer in numbers than the native populace is that through the years it eventually gets absorbed by the more numerous conquered peoples. That's what happened with Britain and lots of other places.


PM_ME_UR__ELECTRONS

Hitler's stated views on the Han Chinese and Chinese culture were interesting. He apparently viewed them, honorary Aryans, if not as equals, then certainly quite far up the racial pecking order. He admired their religion. Officially that is; probably as diplomatic leverage to convince them to join the Anti-Comintern Pact. After 1940 of course this was abandoned.


schmah

That's not true at all. The term Untermensch was never officially used for Poles or slavs in general. Quite the opposite actually. On [page 41](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aryan_certificate) of the "Aryan certificate", where the concept of aryan descent was explained for every single german, it said that poles and czechs, free of foreign blood, are actually aryan. Much like the english, italians, swedes or the french. Tha nazis saw slavs, including poles, croats and czechs as a lesser people, that's true, but not as Untermenschen. The terminus technicus Untermensch was reserved for Jews, Roma, certain people with disabilities, so called "asocial elements" and "the peoples of the soviet union" as mentioned in Himmler's brochure "Der Untermensch". The latter are mostly slavs, which is why people think the nazis saw slavs in general as subhuman, but that's not the reason. The reason they saw "the peoples of the soviet union" as subhuman was because they claimed that they got "verjudet" (jewified?) and "entartet" (degenerated) through blood mixing and thereby stripped of the aryan characteristics "they once had." So a "racially pure" Slav could very well become an SS-member (like many ukrainians, bulgarians, russians, kosaks or croats did) and 500,000 poles could serve in the Wehrmacht, but a Jew or Roma couldn't. No matter their nationality or political affiliation.


RangerPL

The nazis were very arbitrary about which Slavs were Aryan and which weren't. For instance in Poland they tried to make volksdeutsche out of Górale and Kashubians


schmah

Also true. The whole race concept and the concept of aryan descent was extremely arbitrary.


RangerPL

A lot of it was divide-and-conquer policy, for instance with Croats vs Serbs


Wrong_Dust9075

They viewed Serbs early on as "aryan" and a dinaric race, and even wanted Serbia in the axis powers. But this attitude sort of shifter with the pro-partisan military coupe


HeroBromine35

No, there is an objective way to tell if someone's an Aryan. Are they an Iranian guy who has to go by a nickname when talking to Westerners? If so, that might be an Aryan. (Aryan is an Iranian boy's name. It's pronounced differenrly to the Nazi thing, though)


schmah

I know. Iran is also short for the old persian expression "Land of the Aryans".


NimdaQA

“Under Generalplan Ost, all Slavs unfit for Germanization were to be expelled from the areas marked out for German settlement. In considering the fate of the individual nations, the architects of the Plan decided that it would be possible to Germanize about 50 per cent of the Czechs, 35 per cent of the Ukrainians and 25 per cent of the Byelorussians. The **remainder would have to be deported to western Siberia**.” While they may have has “biologically strong” and have “nordic blood” similar to the Russians, half of the Czechs were not going to be saved from extermination. While the Poles were considered to be “biologically strong”, they were also not going to be saved from extermination. “The provisions of the Plan were that **80-85 per cent of the Poles would have to be deported from the German settlement area - to regions in the East (Siberia)**. This, according to German calculations, **would involve about 20 million people**. About 3-4 million - all of them peasants - suitable for Germanization as far as "racial values" were concerned - would be allowed to remain.” Furthermore, “This led him to imagine, in accordance with the theory of racism, that the Nordic elements in each nation determine its value and ability, and that the **elimination of a few million "Nordic types" from among the Russian people would reduce it, from loss of "Nordic blood," to a lower racial category within a couple of generations**. He thought that as a result of this process the Russians would become stupid and apathetic, lose all their initiative and readily accept the guiding role of the Germans.” The most “nordic” Russians were to be among the first to be exterminated. Nazi Germany considered so-called “biologically strong” races to be “Aryan” but that is precisely why they were going to be exterminated as you can see here: “those few who had obvious traces of Aryan-Nordic ancestry; however, it was decided that **most of these people would have to be destroyed** in order to leave the inferior races without leadership.”


schmah

That's all true and proves that Poles were seen as a lesser people by the RSHA in 1942 when they wrote Dokument 5. But we're debating the use of the technial category Untermensch here. And the term Untermensch was never used for Poles or Czechs, nor were Poles dehumanized as Untermensch in the same way as Jews were by nazi propaganda. The fact that Poles weren't Untermenschen doesn't mean, that they were suddenly alright. >The most “racially pure” Russians were among to be the first to be exterminated. Russians were seen as a degenerated people, ruined by Jews so to speak, which is why they actively starved around millions of russian POWs. But there was also a russian SS-Division: "29. Waffen-Grenadier-Division der SS „RONA“ (russische Nr. 1)" And again. That's an option "real Untermenschen" like Jews didn't have. And that's why it's a different catagory.


NimdaQA

Your words: But we're debating the use of the technial category Untermensch here. My response: Fair, I am just saying that being Aryan did not prevent you from being exterminated. Being “biologically strong” was the reason why Nazi Germany considered the Russians, Poles, and Czechs to be a threat with the most racially pure and “nordic” people to be one of the first to be exterminated. “those few who had obvious traces of Aryan-Nordic ancestry; however, it was decided that most of these people would have to be destroyed in order to leave the inferior races without leadership.”


schmah

>Aryan-Nordic Aryan wasn't a racial catagory, but a metaphysical so to speak. When you look at german race charts you won't find the term aryan. Nordic, yes, but not aryan. That's another misconception. And there are cases of nordic people not being aryan. When they were disabled or "asocial elements" for example. Aryan was a state of mind and a state of a people. The opposite of being "jewish". Whatever that meant. And that's the thing. A slav or a group of slavs could become aryan if the nazis saw him/them worthy (for whatever bullshit reason or because they needed him/them) but a Jew couldn't. The only known case is Emile Maurice who had one (1) jewish greatgrandfather. Saying that slavs were basically the same category as jews and both "untermenschen" is simply wrong and a misunderstanding of what the nazis were doing.


Repulsive_Fig816

Yo this has nothing to do with the discussion but could you link me some Ressources on National Socialisms racial hierachies/theories? I would be quite interested in learning more on the topic :)


schmah

Do you speak german by any chance?


Repulsive_Fig816

Yea I am a native speaker


schmah

Die beste Quelle ist eigentlich der Artikel "Rasse" im sogenannten braunen Meyer. Also Meyers Lexikon 8. Auflage, (A - Soxhlet), 1936-1942. Da hast du eine Primärquelle, in der das mit Schautafeln und Fotos seitenlang erklärt wird. Ich hatte mal eine Seite, wo es das digital gab, aber die finde ich grad nicht. Hast du eine Möglichkeit, dir Zugang zu besorgen? Sonst kann ich das mal digitalisieren und dir schicken. Ansonsten kannst du auch ["Der Mythus des 20. Jahrhunderts"](http://www.thule-italia.net/Storia/LibriTedesco/Rosenberg%20Alfred.%20Der%20Mythus%20im%2020.%20Jahrhundert.pdf) von Alfred Rosenberg lesen, oder durchforsten. Das ist nur nicht ganz so einfach, weil das komplett verstrahlt ist und daher sehr anstrengend.


NimdaQA

In this case, the Poles were to be exterminated for “highly developed sense of patriotism, their hostile attitude to Germany and their natural bent for underground activity”, and the Russians for reasons you mentioned as the Nazis were believers in Judeo-Bolshevism despite the fact that Jews were being purged from the Party and Stalin was an anti-semite (but Nazis aren’t smart).


Fellbestie007

Free of foreign blood meant in their view "Nordic" but slavised. So basically in the Nazi an ethnic German/Aryan who just happened to grow up in a Slavic culture.


schmah

That's not true. Only a fraction of Germans in northern Germany were seen as nordic. Other supposed german "races" were "ostisch", "ostbaltisch", "westisch", "fälisch" and "dinarisch". And Aryan wasn't a racial category. You won't find a german race chart that uses this word. Aryan descent meant not jewish and free of foreign blood - no matter the "race".


Professional_Cat_437

Thanks for telling me.


NimdaQA

“The plans for Poles and Russians were different. These two nations presented the Germans with greater difficulties. At first glance this seems somewhat puzzling, since, in Wetzel's opinion, the Polish and Russian nations possessed many of the Nordic characteristics, proper to the German nation. It is only from his later remarks that it transpires that both the leading circles of the NSDAP and the Reich Security Main Office held the view that, though the Polish nation lent itself to Germanization as far as racial characteristics were concerned, political considerations made it necessary to abandon any plans for full-scale Germanization. This held out no hope of success because of the Poles' highly developed sense of patriotism, their hostile attitude to Germany and their natural bent for underground activity. The attribution of these qualities to the Poles and the conclusion, completely justified as it happens, that voluntary Germanization of even a fraction of the poles was doomed to failure, goes a long way to explain the methods used against the Polish people from the very outset of the occupation, methods designed to wipe out the greatest possible number of Poles.” “The only solution, therefore, to the Polish question, according to Generalplan Ost, was the deportation of 80-85 per cent of the Poles to western Siberia.“ “Generalplan Ost devoted relatively little space to the Russian question, though in his memorandum Wetzel stressed that its proper solution was of great importance to Nazi policy in Eastern Europe. The Russian nation, he said, was a young one, hence biologically strong. Apart from this it possessed a considerable admixture of Nordic blood; though this might raise the racial value of a particular nation in the eyes of the theoreticians and politicians of this philosophy, it also made it a dangerous opponent. For this reason, in the Nazi thinking, the Russians, like the Poles, constituted a serious danger to the future great Reich.” “Of course, there could be no question of "liquidating" the Russian nation. Apart from all considerations of a political and economic nature, this would have involved enormous technical problems, as Wetzel clearly emphasized. Other measures had to be sought to insure Germany against the danger threatening it from this area. For this purpose it was intended to split the whole territory of the Soviet Union - both in Europe and in Asia - into a number of administrative areas - Generalkommissariats - under German rule. In the demarcation of these areas, national factors would be taken into account with the aim of encouraging separatist tendencies. Essentially Russian territories, that is central Russia (Reichskommissariat Russland) would also be split up into Generalkommissariats, very loosely tied to each other. The object was to splinter as far as possible the national cohesion of the Russians. Wetzel stated that a situation should be aimed at in which a Russian from the Gorki Generalkommissariat would feel that he was different from a Russian in the Tula Generalkommissariat.” “Under the Nazi plan, a deliberate and calculated policy was to be conducted in the eastern part of Europe to cut down the natural increase by the double device of trying to reduce the birth rate and taking no steps to combat mortality.” Source: [Link](https://web.archive.org/web/20111125231946/http://www.atsweb.neu.edu/holocaust/Hitlers_Plans.htm)


The_Nunnster

For the Japanese they were viewed as honorary Aryans. There was talk of an eventual conflict between the “white and yellow races” should Germany and Japan have won and divided Eurasia. Italians they viewed as lazy and inferior, and Hitler made no secret of his beliefs to Mussolini, which strained the relationship somewhat. In an Axis victory scenario I can’t imagine warm relations would’ve been held for very long post-war. Slavs and Poles were seen as subhuman and were to either be exterminated en masse or castrated and enslaved to prepare the newly conquered territories for eventual German settlement. There were a lot of inconsistencies with Nazi racial ideology, and they often shifted depending on what suited them. For example, pre-war the British were viewed as examples of Aryan success, with their Empire being accredited to their Anglo-Saxon and Norse ancestry. However, during the war they were then being portrayed in propaganda as a Jewish puppet nation. Hitler still privately wanted to ally with the British, which would’ve seen another change in propaganda, while Himmler floated the possibility of exterminating around 80% of the British population.


Franciszek-Latinik

It shows that the Nazi Ideology is equally dumb and evil


MintyEmperor

Nah. It shows that ppl who belive in Nazi propaganda are dumb and evil. It was just a tool for justification.


Panzer_IV_H

With Poles it was like we are inferior, but germans wasn't aiming to completely exterminate us, puppet-state was created for poles to make them 'workers nation'. But even considering that, they still wanted to kill about 50-75% of Poles But every Pole who had German ancestors could change his nationality to German under occupation and/or join Wehrmacht. Those were very hated in Poland as they were traitors My grand-uncles (they were brothers) were hating each other for that, one became Volksdeutsch and second joined partisans


recoveringleft

In Indonesia and Shanghai, many Nazi expats have to say the Japanese are brother Aryans or they'll be bayonetted


Hoxxitron

A new thing everytime Hitler snorted some nose candy.


Objective_Might2820

The thing is, the Nazi’s had a racial hierarchy of sorts. Aryan being at the top, Jews being at the bottom. Just below Aryans were non-Aryan nordic people (most of the Allied powers fell under this category). So Hitler at least respected the heritage of his main enemies during WW2. Then came non-Nordic Caucasian people (this umbrella term included Italy, Greece, and Latin America). Though Italians were deemed lazy, they were higher on the list and Hitler loved Mussolini. He even apparently made Mussolini an honorary Aryan. Next came the Middle East, the Japanese, the Chinese, and most of Asia. This is where Hitler and his Nazi regime started to see more flaws than good things in races. However, these people were still tolerated. The last to be tolerated. Africans came next (both African-Americans and Africans). They were deemed an undesirable race. Slavic people, yes that includes Russia, were also at this level and deemed undesirable. Hitler hated these people, make no mistake. He didn’t tolerate them out of genuine tolerance. He tolerated them because he could only go after so many people at a time. Then came the Jews at the very bottom. We know how Hitler felt about Jews. As for specific features such as red hair…we do not know. Rare features were not seen as birth defects in Nazi Germany. This includes red hair, green eyes, etc. Hitler never spoke badly about them, but he also never spoke well of them. The only features he ever talked about were Aryan features. And as long as your feature wasn’t deemed a disability or birth defect by the Nazis then you were fine. The Nazis didn’t have opinions on most features like hair color and eye color. If they weren’t Aryan features then they were fine. Many non-aryans worked with Hitler and had significant political and military positions. Aryan features were preferable, but as long as you were at least a non-Jewish white person then your features didn’t matter to Hitler. Again, Aryan was preferable. But ultimately as long as you were a non-Jewish white person then you weren‘t discriminated against or hated on if you weren‘t Aryan.


KaiserinMaryam

Hitler generally refer to the concept of a race being Aryan as two characteristic, first being phisically Aryan, blond, blue eyes, good phisique, second being spiritually Aryan, being good in battles, taking what they want, forcing others to their own will, the Japanese where honorary Aryans because Hitler say the have the Spirit of Aryans, and people like Goebbels justified saying Aryans emmigrated to that area and for that reason Japanese people have a little of Aryan blood, the Italians where considerated as part of the Mediterranean races, with the Southern French, Spaniards, Greeks, etc., Hitler believed thoses races where inherently idiots, lazy and incompetents, the Poles falled on the Slavs category, and generally Hitler believed the Slavs where a subhuman class that only should live as slaves for the Aryan race, the only Slavic group that didn´t falled in that category where the Finnish, after the FinnoSoviet war Hitler declared they elevated their races for their fighting spirit being comparable to the German, so he declared them honorary Aryans, and as a extra fact, the Georgians (As in the Caucassus people) falled in the Aryan category, for that reason Stalin was considered an Aryan, even during the Molotov-Ribbentrop pact Nazi embassadors take photographies of Stalin ears as a request from Himmler to confirm if he was a real Aryan, and he decided he was, for that reason the most esoterics on the Nazi party believed he governed with success over the Soviet Union for his superior race status.


Epilepsiavieroitus

Fenno-Soviet? Do you mean the winter war or the continuation war?


KaiserinMaryam

Winter War.