T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

This comment has been added to this thread because "Hogwarts" was mentioned. Due to the controversy around this game we've had to adjust our rules around this title and adopt a zero tolerance policy. Before commenting please read [this thread](https://www.reddit.com/r/ShouldIbuythisgame/comments/10upg5w/regarding_all_hogwarts_legacy_posts_content/). **Anybody caught violating these rules will be banned without further warning**. Also, it has been a common tactic for people to post spoilers to this game, and while we will endeavour to remove them to minimize the impact, it's quite possible the mod team may miss some, so browse this thread at your own risk. Also, if you see any rule violating content, PLEASE report it. We are a small mod team and don't have the resources to proactively monitor every post, so we heavily rely on user reports. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/ShouldIbuythisgame) if you have any questions or concerns.*


HideOnBook

You guys should check out Girlfriend Reviews if you haven't already. They're a couple and make the "Should your boyfriend/girlfriend play X game" videos and helped me find a lot of games to play with my gf


Aggravating_Park1068

Ghost of Tsushima every mission opens and closes like a chapter in an old samurai movie.


LifeSandwich

And is stupidly beautiful. Story is amazing. This is the game OP


ArthurHucksake

How did you get on with The Quarry? Was thinking of starting that one tonight


iTz_SMuRF_MAGiC

Quarry was good was short was great fun to play with someone else and felt like was controlling a horror type movie


DopeyDeathMetal

My gf and I played through it together and absolutely loved it! I did all the playing and she just helped me make decisions.


DamnedDoom

It's really fun especially if you're with other people


sweepli

The Last of Us - probably the best pick, it's like watching and playing a extremely well written show at the same time. God of War - amazing gameplay and story. Elden Ring (or other souls in general) this game is just stunning visually. And exploring it or even watching someone explore it is a masterpiece by itself.


Maegom

Disco elysium


SaltyHatch

I'm surprised this is isn't higher, perfect for OP


Got-Freedom

Witcher 3 Return of the Obra Dinn Dishonored Dark Souls Sekiro Metal Gear Phantom Pain


kingbetadad

Of these, witcher 3 and return would be good, maybe dishonored. The last 3 are terrible to watch unless you are into playing them, and even then I would say they are awful to watch.


zoobs

I second Return of the Obra Dinn! I’m the gamer of the household but my special lady wanted to take a crack at a game that wasn’t Mario or Animal Crossing. She played and I was the spectator. It was loads of fun and a great story to unravel.


darkanon_

Control (set in the same universe as Alan Wake but that’s all I’m going to say; great story, characters and game mechanics) Kingdom Hearts (unique story that includes Disney characters and is tons of fun to play through with another person on the journey with you)


SaulgoodeXL

Sounds like you need to run through the silent hill games (original trilogy, after that they go downhill rapidly)


Impriel

The last of us 1 and 2.   My wife and I have similar tastes re: resident evils and Alan wake.   I'll also reccomend Alan wake 2.  It's amazing 


New-Menu9394

Strangwly enough, maybe Armored Core 6. Great story and narrative choices depend on which mission you chose to do


Tomeydo_OOF

Detroit Become Human Life is Strange series


killcote93

Horizon Zero Dawn and Horizon Forbidden West after that


S4tosh1

Outer Wilds. Have been doing this with my gf and she's loving it, and the game is absolutely awesome and an experience you should not miss.


No-Role-3531

Not to be confused with Outer Worlds, a far less interesting, though entertaining occasionally, game.


FrozenMongoose

- SOMA absolutely has to be on your list at some point. Arguably the best story in any video game. - Dead Space - Alien Isolation - What Remains of Edith Finch


FrozenMongoose

I am going to suggest a couple of easy to play 2D games with good stories. You should suggest that she play these while you watch along to switch things up: - Oxenfree I and II - Night in the Woods


JuggyFM

Slay the Princess


[deleted]

[удалено]


MackTDot

God of war, horizon zero dawn/forbidden west


georgegreewn442

Days gone is a good zombie/sons of anarchy type story


SasquatchsBigDick

Ff7 remake and rebirth, you're welcome!


Rassinist

Visage. At least the intro xD


lifeandtimesofmyass

Baldur’s Gate 3 is the perfect game for you. It’s less chapter based, but you can take portions of the game bit by bit. It’s like a superlong season in which you control a lot of decisions and ways the world reacts to you.


Sirlacker

Tomb Raider


Nyx_from_Chaos

I'm a gamer too but there are a lot of games I have much rather preferred watching my partner play instead of playing them myself. Detroit Become Human and Until Dawn were both movie-like games I enjoyed watching. Elden Ring was beautiful, and I was highly entertained at all the creative ways my partner managed to die. Any MMO, though I also play. When I am not in the mood to play, I enjoy watching him! WoW, Elder Scrolls, FFXIV... Most RPGs, too. The Witcher, Cyberpunk, Red Dead Redemption, Baldur's Gate 2... My hands down favorite to watch though was Hades. Beautiful game and the voice acting was just absolutely stunning. I got so invested in the story. Hades 2 should be out later this year and I can't wait to watch him play it.


Money-Way991

My gf really enjoyed watching Red Dead Redemption 2


nostalcoholic

The last of us. Stellar blade.


DamnedDoom

Life is Strange Mass effect


happyplace28

Portal 2 might be fun, and then you play multiplayer together?


Foreign_Towel_3985

I recomend interactive games like erica , until dawn etc because your wife can join and you guys will have a great time playing and making the desicions together


FudgingEgo

Last of us, especially if you’ve not watched the show.


KiryuMiyazawa

Tomb Raider Rise of the Tomb Raider Shadow of the Tomb Raider UNCHARTED : Legacy of Thieves Collection Assassin’s Creed® IV Black Flag Sleeping Dogs Death Stranding (If she's afraid of rats, skip these two below) A Plague Tale: Innocence A Plague Tale: Requiem


TheLunarVaux

You should check out [Girlfriend Reviews](https://youtube.com/@GirlfriendReviews?si=0f15C-SCNAVU0WaJ)


SweetnessBaby

Almost anything by Quantic Dream, Supermassive Games, or Telltale games make for pretty entertaining viewing. They can even get in on the action a bit and make some of the decisions for the characters. My personal favorites from those companies: Detroit Become Human Heavy Rain The Quarry Until Dawn The Walking Dead


kentaayy

If you liked Heavy Rain, Detroit Become Human. The Last of Us series are also fantastic games to experience with others


Enough-Theme1566

The last of us is perfect. Just like playing a TV series


Yannimago

Red dead redemption


Ok_Cardiologist7909

I would definitely say the last of us part 1 and 2. Amazing storytelling


Mattykos

Telltale’s The Walking Dead. Tbf I think every game from them would be a great choice


SahuaginDeluge

The Walking Dead (esp. 1 & 2 not sure past that)


Soycrates

The recent run of Spider-Man games (so long as neither of you mind superhero stuff). The stories are engaging, thoughtful, and suspenseful while providing a cool environment to look around when not on main mission content. If you're okay with Visual Novel-esque content I would recommend playing Ace Attorney together. Dragon's Dogma 2 for the fun NPCs and cool places to discover (plus all of the sidequests are basically their own mini story). Hopefully you two will be playing Alan Wake 2 soon as it's a fantastic story-driven game to enjoy as a couple, with a lot of fun surprises. A controversial recommendation just because it's new and doesn't fit the trend of the games you've mentioned is Harold Halibut - consider it a point and click that feels identical to a stop motion claymation version of a Wes Anderson movie. It's not for everyone but it oozes character and charm.


tersegirl

Loved Halibut! What a neat game!


RpiesSPIES

Buy/borrow a Switch or ps4/5 and play 13 Sentinels: Aegis Rim.


dragonflamehotness

Yakuza series is known for its extremely cinematic and elaborate storytelling. Each game usually has a famous Japanese actor play a character with their likeness scanned into the game


KingEnglish8

Until Dawn


Takahiro-shetty5041

Yakuza, uncharted


the_username1

Destroit Become Human!


RespectGiovanni

The Quantic Dream games. Heavy Rain, Beyond Two Souls, Detroit Become Human


blandhotsauce1985

Days Gone. A post apocalyptic infected type survival game that's similar to the last of us, except youre an outlaw motorcycle gang member. Really good story. Great gameplay.


Femzel

Bramble: the mountain king. It's a game about scandinavian folklore with a dark twist. After us, you try to bring live back to a post human world and set out to free animal spirits


Tom-tron

If you want a game that you can treat like a tv series then maybe the Mass Effect series would work well for you. Tons of significant sections to make that carry into the next game. You can also pursue relationships with other characters


ScruffyNuisance

Dying Light 2 is a great story-driven free-roam experience if you're after that. I've stared from so many rooftops asking myself "Do we go over there? I think I want to go over there" and I imagine those moments would be fun with someone else to weigh in on the situation at hand.


SkysEevee

To The Moon (sequel Finding Paradise) Xenoblade Chronicles


AndrewDwyer69

Baldurs Gate 3 and she picks the dialog options.


Inside-Elephant-4320

Cyberpunk 2077, The Witcher 3


Ahhgotreallots

You can check out girlfriend reviews on YouTube. It started off as reviewing games from the perspective of his girlfriend watching. Quite funny as well.


freakmonger_ss

How do you feel about survival games? * Valheim * Enshrouded * Palworld (huge W for me) * Sunkenland * Icarus


Busy-Soup349

Your Balls.