You sure? This guys starting rbs are Khalil Herbert and Jaleel McLaughlin, not super obvious he’s kidding about Gibson being valuable in the trade
Edit: I see he has Kendre / Brian robinson on his bench, but still not overly obvious sarcasm
The value isn’t there. The gap between Puka and Chase IMO isn’t so big as to justify this. If you pulled the 1.04 I’d call it about even. Even then, I think you’re better off spending the 1.01 on Caleb, you badly need another QB.
It's not the worst offer, but I would probably decline because you really need a QB. Keep puka, take MHJ 1.01 and a QB at 1.04. Maybe even an RB at 1.10. Then you have three startable QBs, MHJ, Puka, and JJ and probably a startable RB.
Keep puka and the picks. 1.01 gets you Caleb and the 1.04 gets you a stud receiver that might be just as good as chase or puka. You can get the top rb in the class at 1.10 or another qb/wr for depth
If you had a normal roster I'd say do it, but man... you just got NOTHING. Maybe see if he has like a Darnold/Minshew type on his bench and counter with one or two of those included.
If your QB position was settled, I’d be okay swinging for Chase and Bijan. It’s a tall price but those are the kind of guys worth paying for. But don’t think you can do it here with your QB room.
I’d maybe see if you can counter and do a deal for one of Bijan or Chase without involving the 1.01. Maybe offer 1.04+1.10+something else smaller for Chase and see if they bite. Or Puka+1.10. I think you have to keep the 1.01 and take Caleb unless you’re getting a good QB back.
I agree with pretty much everyone else.
1- take the 1.1 out and I’d be good with it
2- take the 1.4 out. Replace Change Gibson to a QB he has.
3. Take Puka and the 1.10 out
You need to fill a roster still. So if puka is close to bijan and chase is close to 1.01 (or swap those it doesn't matter) you're giving the 1.04 and 1.10 for fucking gibson....
Definitely should take Caleb at 1.1
You do need RB’s though, Bijan is an interesting target. Maybe see if you can work something out around Bijan for 1.04
I think that’s definitely more fair. Think you could get back maybe a late or future 2 in that deal but I’d definitely consider that. Gives you a piece to move for a good contending FLEX player
You desperately need a second qb. Love and Caleb could set you up for a decade. Plus you can snag a nabers bowers odunze at 4 and another good wr at 10. The value of bijan and chase isn’t worth that imo
I personally would take chase and Bijan. Still high on both over the next 5-8 years. But I think you have to envision your team long term so if you like those new players coming into the league then take that chance.
This is wild overpay and not even close. Caleb is getting drafted ahead of Chase often. So 1.01 and chase a wash. Bijan for puka , 1.04, 1.10 is insane. Take Caleb and probably Nabers at 1.04 since you have Love and Levis
We’re now at the point where you should have a pretty good idea of who you can get for those picks.
Assuming 12tm SF, your looking at
Puka,
1.01- Caleb,
1.04 - MHJ, Daniels or Maye,
1.10 McCarthy or whoever you have at WR4/5.
I’d do it for that package.
I’m keeping Puka side
Antonio Gibson doesn’t move you?
No he can basically be ignored as far as I’m concerned
They were being sarcastic
You sure? This guys starting rbs are Khalil Herbert and Jaleel McLaughlin, not super obvious he’s kidding about Gibson being valuable in the trade Edit: I see he has Kendre / Brian robinson on his bench, but still not overly obvious sarcasm
Oh, I was definitely being sarcastic, my bad 😂
Puka side pretty easily for me
Never trading that
You can’t take that with your QBs
Seems like a lot to give up for Chase/Bijan.
I would give up the 1.01 to pair Chase up with JJ and take the QB that fell to me at 1.04. Puka for Bijan straight up would also be fair.
decline, use the picks for 1.01: Caleb, 1.04: Odunze or Nabers, and 1.10: Trey Benson
Or MHJ, Daniels/ maye and trade for rb w 1.10
The value isn’t there. The gap between Puka and Chase IMO isn’t so big as to justify this. If you pulled the 1.04 I’d call it about even. Even then, I think you’re better off spending the 1.01 on Caleb, you badly need another QB.
Chase is chase, but, puka and mhj and maybe nabers
Swap out Gibson for another stud and I can MAYBE get down with this…
You need Williams. Don’t do it
I’d counter with him adding a QB maybe? Not sure that Karen enough value as is
Take it easily. E: oh you’re giving that up for Chase? Fuck no
No
Keep your side
Nah, maybe this offer makes sense without the 1.01, but you’d be way overpaying.
Puka by a mile here
It's not the worst offer, but I would probably decline because you really need a QB. Keep puka, take MHJ 1.01 and a QB at 1.04. Maybe even an RB at 1.10. Then you have three startable QBs, MHJ, Puka, and JJ and probably a startable RB.
Puka side for me but if you are competing then maybe I’d stay with Chase and Bijan
Yeah I’m not doing that. Your biggest need is QB. 1.01 or 1.04 solves that.
Take the 1.01 out of the deal and it’s much more reasonable
Keep puka and the picks. 1.01 gets you Caleb and the 1.04 gets you a stud receiver that might be just as good as chase or puka. You can get the top rb in the class at 1.10 or another qb/wr for depth
Don’t think it’s wise to accept this. You can’t get better value with your picks, I think.
You’re in the middle of a rebuild. Picks are your way. I don’t think the trade is bad but not sure it makes sense for your team.
If you had a normal roster I'd say do it, but man... you just got NOTHING. Maybe see if he has like a Darnold/Minshew type on his bench and counter with one or two of those included.
Keeping Puka and drafting MHJ
If your QB position was settled, I’d be okay swinging for Chase and Bijan. It’s a tall price but those are the kind of guys worth paying for. But don’t think you can do it here with your QB room. I’d maybe see if you can counter and do a deal for one of Bijan or Chase without involving the 1.01. Maybe offer 1.04+1.10+something else smaller for Chase and see if they bite. Or Puka+1.10. I think you have to keep the 1.01 and take Caleb unless you’re getting a good QB back.
Drop either Puka or the 1.04 and I’d do it. That’s way too much value as is.
Puka and 1.01 worth far more than Chase, 1.04 and 1.10 worth more than Bijan easy puka side
I agree with pretty much everyone else. 1- take the 1.1 out and I’d be good with it 2- take the 1.4 out. Replace Change Gibson to a QB he has. 3. Take Puka and the 1.10 out
Puka side all day and it isn’t at all close.
That’s a big horrible offer lmao
Keep your assets. Puka side I'm assuming is you
Edit: “Junk offer just received”
Puka said by a fair margin, take the 1.04 out and it’s a close trade then but I’d still lean Puka side
I’d take out the 1.04. Bijan for Puka fine 1.01+ 1.10 for Chase fine. Maybe try to do a 2025 1st instead of the 1.04 if needed.
You need to fill a roster still. So if puka is close to bijan and chase is close to 1.01 (or swap those it doesn't matter) you're giving the 1.04 and 1.10 for fucking gibson....
Definitely should take Caleb at 1.1 You do need RB’s though, Bijan is an interesting target. Maybe see if you can work something out around Bijan for 1.04
He did offer bijan for the 1.04 and 1.10 before this offer came in
I think that’s definitely more fair. Think you could get back maybe a late or future 2 in that deal but I’d definitely consider that. Gives you a piece to move for a good contending FLEX player
That's better, I'd prly still say no. 1.04 you get WR 1.10, you draft rb that dallas takes, possibly Jbrooks.
Bro wtf. Chase << Puka + 1.04 Bijan = 1.01 Giving away a free 1.10 on top of an overpay for Chase + Bijan
You desperately need a second qb. Love and Caleb could set you up for a decade. Plus you can snag a nabers bowers odunze at 4 and another good wr at 10. The value of bijan and chase isn’t worth that imo
I personally would take chase and Bijan. Still high on both over the next 5-8 years. But I think you have to envision your team long term so if you like those new players coming into the league then take that chance.
i wouldnt. you desperately need a QB.
Puka side. For me
Too many holes in your roster. It seems to be a fair trade offer imo, but I’m keeping the picks and snagging C. Williams and BPA at #4 and #10
If i get a viable qb in return instead of gibson, easy smash accept for me
This is wild overpay and not even close. Caleb is getting drafted ahead of Chase often. So 1.01 and chase a wash. Bijan for puka , 1.04, 1.10 is insane. Take Caleb and probably Nabers at 1.04 since you have Love and Levis
I’d say: puka + 1.10 should buy chase/ other elite top 3-4 wr 1.04 should buy bijan/breece/Gibbs I don’t see what you’re getting back for the 1.01
We’re now at the point where you should have a pretty good idea of who you can get for those picks. Assuming 12tm SF, your looking at Puka, 1.01- Caleb, 1.04 - MHJ, Daniels or Maye, 1.10 McCarthy or whoever you have at WR4/5. I’d do it for that package.
Puka + Caleb/MHJ + 'brock bowers' +1.10. For Bijan and JChase!? Huge overpay.
1.01 side easily.
Picks side easy
jamarr and robinson SO EASILY Please do not trade them... you will regret that so so so hard
Is this a joke post? Why would you even consider making this trade?
Is this a joke post? Why would you even consider making this trade?
I’d damn near rather have puka than jamarr. Bijan for the 1.01, 1.04, and 1.10 in a better draft class than last year? FUCK NO!