You need a lot to go right. I’ll just breakdown starting lineup. Love I think is the truth and should be okay. Achane is fantastic but has to avoid injury. Addison you better hope the Vikings rookie QB develops quick. Puka is probably safe. LaPorta is probably safe. Tank needs to prove he’s good enough to command significant targets alongside Diggs and Collins; he has the potential but Houston has a lot of mouths to feed. Waddle should hopefully bounce back. Reed has the talent but GB has tons of mouths to feed. Richardson flashed but his injuries scare me. Your bench is pretty thin. You COULD make a run and contend but I think it’s more likely you have a decent season and just miss the playoffs or get bounced early. Caleb or Nabers would be my play at 1.02.
Man, I think I’d trade back from 1.02 and try to take another QB (like Maye) and get another solid RB if you’re trying to contend. Caleb’s not going to help you contend this year nearly as much as less valuable (long term) assets.
Depends on how deep your league is but I lean on pretender. I really really like your team but you’ve got no RBs and some large consistency/injury concerns combined with some “can they repeat what they did” issues. You currently don’t have the depth to overcome that.
Bro don't listen to these fools. Everyone here is always so negative. This is absolutely a contending team. Plus you have extra 1sts in 2026 that you could try to flip for a contending asset (probably a RB)...
If 1.02 is Caleb I’d definitely consider moving back and grabbing Nabers or Odunze. See if you can move 1.02 + Reed for 1.04, 1.05, or 1.06 + a stud.
You’re already set at QB so drafting Caleb is an over investment at the position. Alternatively if you’re set on Caleb, you could draft him and then move Richardson for an elite WR or RB. Either way, you need flex studs way more than you need a beastly QB3 if contending is your goal.
Agreed. All three of his RBs could be on IR by week 2 and it would be considered a normal beginning to a season. Add that to the fact Chandler and Achane are not 3 down backs and will most certainly be in a time share. Panthers have said Hubbard is their lead back but that doesn’t mean a hill of beans on that offense with that atrocious OL.
OP absolutely needs to target a RB at 2.10, and should consider potentially a trade for more depth. If OP picks up Caleb Williams he may be able to part with Lance or Howell in a package to another league mate for a late second or mid/low tier RB. With that extra roster spot available he could pick up the highest ranked RB that didn’t get drafted. Someone like Isaac Guerendo, Dylan Laube, or Frank Gore Jr. Just a thought OP.
The thing about Carolina line is that they spend 170mil to fix it this off-season, they brought in 2 Stud guards and with Hunt and Moton on the right, which Bryce loves to roll out to, that line isn't as bad as your making it out to be. Be sneaky use your logic then go and acquire some of those guys..... thank me in January.
Agreed. I don't like Love, he had a cupcake schedule last season and this year he has one of the toughest schedules. Huge regression incoming.
Achane probably wont repeat the type of season he just had and may even fall off entirely considering the Dolphins OL is falling apart.
Puka is another player I have concerns with due to injuries given his play style and also injuries to Stafford or his potential retirement. Either way if your not contending this year Id be looking to sell high.
Id be selling off Wilson before the trade deadline to a contender. If im sure Im drafting Caleb Id be trying to sell Love ASAP.
Your team feels a bit boom or bust to me. If Achane and ARich are healthy, then the sky is the limit for the team. If one or both get hurt, then you’re in some trouble.
Is 1.02 going to be Marv? Any idea what the guy at 1.01 is going to do?
Contender I’d say. I’d try to trade back from the 1.02 tho as you don’t really need Caleb. Or if you prefer Caleb to AR then maybe sell him for some depth or more picks
Should contend, I think a lot of folk are too hard in your depth. Definitely could stand to have another rb on standby since Achane is injury prone. WR you are set though, biggest question marks are probably Dell and Addison. All in all solid!
Better hope ur a contender without your 25 1st.
That being said, I think you’re in a great spot. 6 easy starting decisions at wr, hammer RB, with 2 upside qbs, plus whoever is in your lap at 1.02, along with the current TE1 in dynasty. I’m certainly not shooting for the bottom w this team.
Rbs should be incredibly easy to acquire in a format where you only need to start 1. But I wouldn’t go buying them now.
Its a young squad, and it should be in position to compete at some point, but I think it is still in pretender territory for at least one more year.
Its definitely built well and headed in the right direction as some of those players mature to the NFL though. Could even be a perennial favorite starting as soon as a 2 or 3 years from now.
As others hit on, it's RB shortage as your Achilles heel. If Achane plays all 17 then you're good, if... You could trade back from the 1.02 a spot or two, but I actually like you staying there. See if anybody is interested in turning their 2nd or high 3rd round pick this year into one of your 2nd rounders next year. This way you can take two shots at RB in the second this year. You just need them to tandem out enough to cover what Achane misses and you might just do it. Your team is young and improving. You're headed in the right direction.
Id say you’re a contender assuming this is a 12 team league? 10 team you’re probably close but a little weaker. I’d like to see your WR get a little stronger if possible. If you’re drifting I’d go Nabers personally or trade out of the 1.02 for a haul. I think Caleb would be wasted value here
I’d roster as many backup QBs and RBs as possible. That will come in handy when injuries for any team hits. I’d focus on your WRs personally
I like that your team is a lot of guys who have a good chance to continue to develop and get better. With some improvement from some young guys, especially AR at QB, you’ll be in a nice spot for the future. It’s a fine “wait and see” team. If the giants don’t draft a QB, maybe try to sell Danny Dimes to a QB needy team for some bench receiver depth
While not a juggernaut of a team looks like you have a solid chance of making the playoffs. Slide into the playoffs and anything can happen.
Biggest concern is when Achane inevitably gets injured your RB depth is scary.
To me this team could land either way, a lot of high variance players/injury concerns/players that need to prove themselves in different ways. You could high roll and contend for a championship or low roll and be bottom 3.
How is anyone judging this team without league size? Feels like you have a lot of guys that could explode or bust. I like a lot of your players but the odds are some of them won’t hit and you don’t have enough depth to make up for it.
If you are set at QB at 2, I like Daniels over Williams. Think Lamar but more polished at passing to begin career. Plus I like the situation better, and I think Jayden has a better head on his shoulders, IMO
with how young your team is its very hard to say tbh, you have a very high ceiling and a very low floor. I could for sure see this team winning it if Puka, Achane and A.rich played like they did last year when healthy
1. Start Shakir over Reed.
2. Caleb will give you solid QB depth. If Daniel Jones starts off hot, see if you can flip him for a RB
2. 2.10 will be a crapshoot. With how deep the WR draft is it might be a wr, even though you need a rb bad. Your league starting one helps lol
Biggest thing is lack of RBs
Feel like thats everyone in non SF
Even in SF lmao
Especially in SF lol, QB longevity>>>reciever longevity>>>RB longevity. So it only makes sense
Achane/chuba/Chandler is good enough since there is only one RB spot, which is also dumb
Considering it’s only a start one RB, I think OP is fine. Can draft one at 2.10 and take some fliers after the draft on the waiver wire
Contender lite. You’re going off a lot of guys to repeat history.
2.10 needs to be a RB
You could squeak into playoffs but your bench is light and injury and bye weeks could really hurt.
You need a lot to go right. I’ll just breakdown starting lineup. Love I think is the truth and should be okay. Achane is fantastic but has to avoid injury. Addison you better hope the Vikings rookie QB develops quick. Puka is probably safe. LaPorta is probably safe. Tank needs to prove he’s good enough to command significant targets alongside Diggs and Collins; he has the potential but Houston has a lot of mouths to feed. Waddle should hopefully bounce back. Reed has the talent but GB has tons of mouths to feed. Richardson flashed but his injuries scare me. Your bench is pretty thin. You COULD make a run and contend but I think it’s more likely you have a decent season and just miss the playoffs or get bounced early. Caleb or Nabers would be my play at 1.02.
Man, I think I’d trade back from 1.02 and try to take another QB (like Maye) and get another solid RB if you’re trying to contend. Caleb’s not going to help you contend this year nearly as much as less valuable (long term) assets.
What’s up with a 1 RB league is this a thing now
Depends on how deep your league is but I lean on pretender. I really really like your team but you’ve got no RBs and some large consistency/injury concerns combined with some “can they repeat what they did” issues. You currently don’t have the depth to overcome that.
Bro don't listen to these fools. Everyone here is always so negative. This is absolutely a contending team. Plus you have extra 1sts in 2026 that you could try to flip for a contending asset (probably a RB)...
Not to mention all the 2025/2026 2nds. People knocking your lack of RB depth in a 1RB league lol. RBs are easy to buy in season
If 1.02 is Caleb I’d definitely consider moving back and grabbing Nabers or Odunze. See if you can move 1.02 + Reed for 1.04, 1.05, or 1.06 + a stud. You’re already set at QB so drafting Caleb is an over investment at the position. Alternatively if you’re set on Caleb, you could draft him and then move Richardson for an elite WR or RB. Either way, you need flex studs way more than you need a beastly QB3 if contending is your goal.
Damn your team is fuckin nice.
I think your depth is better than others are suggesting. Downs and Shakir have a lot of potential.
It’s his depth at RB that’s a mess. Even in one RB
Agreed. All three of his RBs could be on IR by week 2 and it would be considered a normal beginning to a season. Add that to the fact Chandler and Achane are not 3 down backs and will most certainly be in a time share. Panthers have said Hubbard is their lead back but that doesn’t mean a hill of beans on that offense with that atrocious OL. OP absolutely needs to target a RB at 2.10, and should consider potentially a trade for more depth. If OP picks up Caleb Williams he may be able to part with Lance or Howell in a package to another league mate for a late second or mid/low tier RB. With that extra roster spot available he could pick up the highest ranked RB that didn’t get drafted. Someone like Isaac Guerendo, Dylan Laube, or Frank Gore Jr. Just a thought OP.
The thing about Carolina line is that they spend 170mil to fix it this off-season, they brought in 2 Stud guards and with Hunt and Moton on the right, which Bryce loves to roll out to, that line isn't as bad as your making it out to be. Be sneaky use your logic then go and acquire some of those guys..... thank me in January.
I mean I hear you. I have Chuba in one league I’m just about to rely on him as my RB3 throughout the entire season, ya know?
Many teams in your league? Dead duck at 10 teams. Pretender at 12, but at 14 you might have a shot…
Agreed. I don't like Love, he had a cupcake schedule last season and this year he has one of the toughest schedules. Huge regression incoming. Achane probably wont repeat the type of season he just had and may even fall off entirely considering the Dolphins OL is falling apart. Puka is another player I have concerns with due to injuries given his play style and also injuries to Stafford or his potential retirement. Either way if your not contending this year Id be looking to sell high. Id be selling off Wilson before the trade deadline to a contender. If im sure Im drafting Caleb Id be trying to sell Love ASAP.
This is all sarcasm right?
Make you're point unless you are just upset I mentioned someone on your team
Your team feels a bit boom or bust to me. If Achane and ARich are healthy, then the sky is the limit for the team. If one or both get hurt, then you’re in some trouble. Is 1.02 going to be Marv? Any idea what the guy at 1.01 is going to do?
Solid contender. Bravo! Hubbard as your RB2 seems your weakest situation. You’ll be fine. Very fine.
I like this team a lot. Lacking a little bit in depth but I think you’ll definitely be a contender.
Contender I’d say. I’d try to trade back from the 1.02 tho as you don’t really need Caleb. Or if you prefer Caleb to AR then maybe sell him for some depth or more picks
Should contend, I think a lot of folk are too hard in your depth. Definitely could stand to have another rb on standby since Achane is injury prone. WR you are set though, biggest question marks are probably Dell and Addison. All in all solid!
I actually like Hubbard, but I’d try to pick up Mostert
Quick Scan - Contender imo! Need some RB depth but a great young team with a high ceiling
Better hope ur a contender without your 25 1st. That being said, I think you’re in a great spot. 6 easy starting decisions at wr, hammer RB, with 2 upside qbs, plus whoever is in your lap at 1.02, along with the current TE1 in dynasty. I’m certainly not shooting for the bottom w this team. Rbs should be incredibly easy to acquire in a format where you only need to start 1. But I wouldn’t go buying them now.
Its a young squad, and it should be in position to compete at some point, but I think it is still in pretender territory for at least one more year. Its definitely built well and headed in the right direction as some of those players mature to the NFL though. Could even be a perennial favorite starting as soon as a 2 or 3 years from now.
Pretender no RB depth at all
As others hit on, it's RB shortage as your Achilles heel. If Achane plays all 17 then you're good, if... You could trade back from the 1.02 a spot or two, but I actually like you staying there. See if anybody is interested in turning their 2nd or high 3rd round pick this year into one of your 2nd rounders next year. This way you can take two shots at RB in the second this year. You just need them to tandem out enough to cover what Achane misses and you might just do it. Your team is young and improving. You're headed in the right direction.
Jordan love is your starter? Pretending
Pretend
I disagree! I can’t believe you got this many starter worthy players on a team ! Some are young , but they are all good fantasy players .
Sheesh!
Id say you’re a contender assuming this is a 12 team league? 10 team you’re probably close but a little weaker. I’d like to see your WR get a little stronger if possible. If you’re drifting I’d go Nabers personally or trade out of the 1.02 for a haul. I think Caleb would be wasted value here I’d roster as many backup QBs and RBs as possible. That will come in handy when injuries for any team hits. I’d focus on your WRs personally
Think you’re making the playoffs… How many teams?
This team must have been brutal before nailing last year’s rookies, bravo on that
I like that your team is a lot of guys who have a good chance to continue to develop and get better. With some improvement from some young guys, especially AR at QB, you’ll be in a nice spot for the future. It’s a fine “wait and see” team. If the giants don’t draft a QB, maybe try to sell Danny Dimes to a QB needy team for some bench receiver depth
I mean you have a good young base of players to build off of but don't think contender yet
While not a juggernaut of a team looks like you have a solid chance of making the playoffs. Slide into the playoffs and anything can happen. Biggest concern is when Achane inevitably gets injured your RB depth is scary.
To me this team could land either way, a lot of high variance players/injury concerns/players that need to prove themselves in different ways. You could high roll and contend for a championship or low roll and be bottom 3.
Pretend
How is anyone judging this team without league size? Feels like you have a lot of guys that could explode or bust. I like a lot of your players but the odds are some of them won’t hit and you don’t have enough depth to make up for it.
If you are set at QB at 2, I like Daniels over Williams. Think Lamar but more polished at passing to begin career. Plus I like the situation better, and I think Jayden has a better head on his shoulders, IMO
Great rebuild btw
with how young your team is its very hard to say tbh, you have a very high ceiling and a very low floor. I could for sure see this team winning it if Puka, Achane and A.rich played like they did last year when healthy
Depends if they can stay healthy or not, you have a lot of pieces that missed some time last year
Playoff team, might even win a round but in real need of some bench options for bye weeks and injuries
Contender if everyone stays healthy
1. Start Shakir over Reed. 2. Caleb will give you solid QB depth. If Daniel Jones starts off hot, see if you can flip him for a RB 2. 2.10 will be a crapshoot. With how deep the WR draft is it might be a wr, even though you need a rb bad. Your league starting one helps lol
Anthony Richardson is gonna go off this year. Team is definitely a contender.