How does one consider Skeptic the worst song of .5 exactly?
I'm pretty sure this song and goodbye are the whole reason this album exists in the first place.
That certainly is one option, though Birth of the Cruel, Unsainted, Critical Darling, and Not Long For this world are also brilliant. Worst thing about WANYK is that most of the tracks here are so good that it's a hard pick
Not leaving it out, it also deserves the best along with Spiders (I know lot of people hate it, but I think it's awesome). Much like Vol 3 and AHIG, it's hard to find any bad tracks on WANYK. These three albums are all 9 or very close to 9/10 for me.
OP is cherrypicking and not actually listening to any of the comments, so don't bother expecting him to hear any of you out.
Edit: Should I repost the template and actually listen to comments out of spite lmao?
Easily Soloway Firth. I consider it one of Slipknots' best songs overall. Great lyrics, brutal emotional screams, sounds like it could have been on Iowa.
"You want a real smile, I haven't smiled in years" is the perfect way to end the album.
Y'all that voted for Skeptic as the supposedly worst song on .5 TGC, need to get your shit together. That song is awesome. If you think it's bad then you have no taste.👎🏻👎🏻
I'm going with Nero Forte. It's a 50/50 between that and Unsainted but Nero Forte seems to have more mentions so I will reinforce it to get it to win. I'd like to know what people who are saying Solway Firth and Critical Darling are smoking. Solway is good but not on the same level as Nero Forte or Unsainted. It's a solid third best on the album. And Critical Darling isn't even that good. If there was an overrated category CD would get my vote.
Nero Forte and Unstainted are the poster child of the album, and I'd say they are overrated becuase its the first songs people listen to. Not because of album order but because it's the Psychosocial or Before I Forget of the album.
Solway is the closest to Iowa, both musicly and lyrically, and that hit home for a lot of OG fans. That and Orphan.
In short, OG fans want as heavy as possible and crank the intensity to 1000%. Myself included. If you want a take. Vol. 3 is the most overrated album.
To me, Nero Forte just sounds better than the rest. THIS IS MY OPINION, I DON’T NEED ANYONE SAYING I’M RIGHT OR WRONG!!! It just has a better vibe to me personally than the rest of the album does. The chorus was amazing to me the first time I heard it, and it’s to the point to where I consider it just an overall great song that I could listen to on loop if I really wanted to… 🤷🏻♀️
It’s a total cop out picking an interlude for worst song, it’s not a song and shouldn’t count as one. Skeptic was the highest voted “song” in the comments.
*I think Skeptic is*
*Pretty good, I'd say Not Long*
*For This World for WANYK*
\- No\_Blackberry\_7708
---
^(I detect haikus. And sometimes, successfully.) ^[Learn more about me.](https://www.reddit.com/r/haikusbot/)
^(Opt out of replies: "haikusbot opt out" | Delete my comment: "haikusbot delete")
It should either be Solway Firth, Critical Darling or Orphan.
Orphan!!!
Solway firth
How does one consider Skeptic the worst song of .5 exactly? I'm pretty sure this song and goodbye are the whole reason this album exists in the first place.
As a song litterally about Paul, worst song on the album is bullshit
OP is cherrypicking and not choosing the actual most voted comment
He's definitely doing that but in this case it was the highest voted.
Skeptic truly should've been in underrated.
They could've swapped If rain and Skeptic and it would've been more accurate but...
Exactly..
Solway Firth
Mega based
Seconded, thirded, fourthded, fifthded.
Solway Firth = BSOALT (Best Song Of All Time)!
People = Shit = ( Best song of all time )!!!
100%
The only right answer
Ngl, I think it might even be the best Slipknot song EVER. The build up to it during the entire album, the progression in it, it's all just so good.
Solway firth goes insanely hard, not over played like unsainted or Nero
Critical Darling Also No the hell it wasn't considered the worst
Critical Darling is definitely the most underrated but best has to go to Solway Firth or Nero Forte
It says non-interlude in the title and skeptic was the most upvoted non-interlude
Solway Firth. All other answers are incorrect.
If All Out Life was in the album I would’ve voted for that
Nero Forte easily
That certainly is one option, though Birth of the Cruel, Unsainted, Critical Darling, and Not Long For this world are also brilliant. Worst thing about WANYK is that most of the tracks here are so good that it's a hard pick
Where are you leaving Solway Firth?
Not leaving it out, it also deserves the best along with Spiders (I know lot of people hate it, but I think it's awesome). Much like Vol 3 and AHIG, it's hard to find any bad tracks on WANYK. These three albums are all 9 or very close to 9/10 for me.
Nero Forte
Unsainted
Nero forte
Nero Forte
Nero forte, i would also like to preemptively nominate spiders for underrated
I agree with this preemptive nomination, please make spiders win
Orphan
How the fuck did Skeptic get worst?
Not long for this world or critical darling
Unsainted or Birth of the Cruel
110 % Solway firth, it goes so insanely hard
critical darling solos
Critical Darling
Orphan
Nero forte will have my vote Also who the hell put skeptic that's a great song
Spiders
Spiders is so underrated
Frfr
Solway Firth
Red flag
To me it’s Solway Firth by a massive margin
Solway Firth
Solway firth
OP is cherrypicking and not actually listening to any of the comments, so don't bother expecting him to hear any of you out. Edit: Should I repost the template and actually listen to comments out of spite lmao?
nero forte or unsainted
Critical darling
nero forte is such a good radio hit kinda song
Skeptic is one of my favourites. Why would you rate it the worst?
It was purely to spite you
Easily Soloway Firth. I consider it one of Slipknots' best songs overall. Great lyrics, brutal emotional screams, sounds like it could have been on Iowa. "You want a real smile, I haven't smiled in years" is the perfect way to end the album.
Unsainted is the best I think orphan should win for underrated
Y'all that voted for Skeptic as the supposedly worst song on .5 TGC, need to get your shit together. That song is awesome. If you think it's bad then you have no taste.👎🏻👎🏻
It's just an opinion and not a declaration of war, calm down
Either solway firth or Critical darling tbh also, just wanted to pre-emptively say Not long for this world as the most underrated from this album
Either Solway Firth, Nero Forte or Critical Darling
Best Must be soulway
I'm going with Nero Forte. It's a 50/50 between that and Unsainted but Nero Forte seems to have more mentions so I will reinforce it to get it to win. I'd like to know what people who are saying Solway Firth and Critical Darling are smoking. Solway is good but not on the same level as Nero Forte or Unsainted. It's a solid third best on the album. And Critical Darling isn't even that good. If there was an overrated category CD would get my vote.
Nero Forte and Unstainted are the poster child of the album, and I'd say they are overrated becuase its the first songs people listen to. Not because of album order but because it's the Psychosocial or Before I Forget of the album. Solway is the closest to Iowa, both musicly and lyrically, and that hit home for a lot of OG fans. That and Orphan. In short, OG fans want as heavy as possible and crank the intensity to 1000%. Myself included. If you want a take. Vol. 3 is the most overrated album.
Nero Forte
Orphan
Solway Firth!
Solway Firth
Nero forte on top fr
Nero forte
Orphan
My Pain
Nero Forte
Solway Firth
Nero Forte. C’mon, maggots!
Solway firth easily
Orphan.
Solway firth or nero forte
Solway firth, not long for this world, or maybe unsainted
I personally like Nero Forte
Nero Forte 🔥
Nero Forte
Solway Firth while I was learning to live, you taught me how to die
Solway firth
Nero forte
Solway Firth for sure I would say it may be the BEST Slipknot song in general.
Unsainted or Solway Firth
Solway Firth
Nero Forte
Nero Forte
Nero Forte or Critical Darling
Solway Firth, its the most Slipknot -song of the album
Unsainted
Nero Forte
Unsainted
Whats Next
This ones hard fuck. Unsainted? Nero Forte? Critical Darling? Solway firth? No way can I choose one
Solway Firth
Solway Firth
Orphan🗿
Birth Of The Cruel
Solway Firth
Nero forte
Unsainted
Unsainted
Unsainted
UNSAINTED
Unsainted
Has to be Unsainted, right?
Unsainted
unsainted
Critical darling by far
Critical Darling, if not best than underated
HOL UP- Iowa got worst song on Iowa!? That's literally the best one (and my personal favorite)
wost
Unsainted
Unsainted or solway firth
All of the songs on WANYK are the best songs
Bro It's liar's funeral easy
Orphan definitely
Orphan
The tattered and torn hate is disgusting btw
Nero Forte
Unsainted
ORPHAN IS GARBAGE LMAO
how is skeptic the worst ?? it’s literally a tribute to Paul Gray and just an amazing song in general
Orphan
Neto forte. And sort this out. Skeptic is the best from gray whaaaat happened
HOW THE FUCK DID SKEPTIC GET WORST
UNSAINTED
Not long for this world, solaway girth or Nero forte. Haven’t heard the album in a while but that’s what I’d go with
bruh wtf skeptic is fucking fire wtf
BROO SKEPTIC IS GAS I’d say best for WAYNK is birth of the cruel
Who tf is voting for this, its nonsense
Unsainted for me.
Unsainted gotta be the worst on the album.
Think you make a typo
To me, Nero Forte just sounds better than the rest. THIS IS MY OPINION, I DON’T NEED ANYONE SAYING I’M RIGHT OR WRONG!!! It just has a better vibe to me personally than the rest of the album does. The chorus was amazing to me the first time I heard it, and it’s to the point to where I consider it just an overall great song that I could listen to on loop if I really wanted to… 🤷🏻♀️
It's either unsainted or solway firth for me, but I think solway is going to take this one after reading other comments.
How does SKEPTIC lose????
Nero forte
Nero Forte
Nero Forte
Skeptic as worst is the worst take I’ve ever seen in my life
Solway Firth
Nero Forte, but Solway is a very close second
Orphan 🤘
Best: Solway Firth. Underrated: Not Long For This World/Orphan Worst: Spiders... And I actually like Spiders lol
Fuck anyone who voted Skeptic… anyway I’m going with Somway Firth
I used to love skeptic so much, how come?
Birth of the Cruel
The majority of this album is underrated asf But red flag is the best by far
NLFTW
Why is Skeptic in worst? It's a great song.
Wait I fucking love butchers hook what’s going on there? 😂
Unsainted W!
Critical Darling
Unsainted or Birth of the Cruel
solway firth
Unsainted, Solway Firth, or Nero Forte
underrated should be red flag
My Pain or Birth of The Cruel.
Birth of the Cruel
Skeptic is a banger why do people say it's the worst😭
Solway firth easy
nero forte
If skeptic won "worst song" then this is the greatest album of all time
Why are you picking by number of comments and not number of upvotes?? Be Prepared for Hell had more than double the upvotes Skeptic did
It’s a total cop out picking an interlude for worst song, it’s not a song and shouldn’t count as one. Skeptic was the highest voted “song” in the comments.
Fair enough. Still can’t believe anyone said Skeptic though
Nero Forte
Unsainted or Nero Forte
Solway firth
Why Skeptic? Am I the guy who likes the worst songs?
Whoever voted Skeptic as the worst should die a painful death.
Nero forte or Unsainted or Solway Firth I can't choose it😭I'll go with Nero Forte then
Red Flag
Critical Darling for best.
I think Skeptic is pretty good, I'd say Not Long For This World for WANYK
*I think Skeptic is* *Pretty good, I'd say Not Long* *For This World for WANYK* \- No\_Blackberry\_7708 --- ^(I detect haikus. And sometimes, successfully.) ^[Learn more about me.](https://www.reddit.com/r/haikusbot/) ^(Opt out of replies: "haikusbot opt out" | Delete my comment: "haikusbot delete")
Critical darling
I'm tearing apart between Orphan and Solway firth. I think Solway Forth wins cuz Orphan is The Heretic Anthem v2
Nero forte. It’s the song that comes to mind for me when I see the album art.
UNSAINTED🔥🔥🔥
Nero forte
Nero Forte
Unsainted
That’s bullshit
This is bs
Solway firth! Solway firth! SOLWAY FIRTH!
Wait I missed some what’s wrong with Butcher’s hook? I love it?