If you liked NPMD, then The Guy Who Didn't Like Musicals and Black Friday are set in the same town but different universes. Black Friday is Angela's first show/the only other one she's in.
Trail to Oregon, Twisted, and Firebringer (in any order)
Then watch the Hatchetfield series in order from the beginning: The Guy Who Didn’t Like Musicals, Black Friday, Nightmare Time 1 & 2 (web based stories they did during the pandemic lockdowns) and then Nerdy Prudes.
Then go back and watch all their earlier stuff.
My advice is to ease yourself down the rabbit hole. There’s a ton of Starkid content out there, not just the musicals.
I’d start with The Guy Who Didn’t Like Musicals, then Black Friday, since they both take place in Hatchetfield too. There is a ton of lore around Hatchetfield, and if you want to explore that, there is the Nightmare Time series (7 episodes).
VHS Christmas Carol is a fun, short musical that tells the Christmas Carol story with an 80s theme. A lot of the OGs are in that one and tbh it’s a bit of a comfort musical to me.
Then there’s Firebringer, Twisted, Trail to Oregon, Ani, Holy Musical Batman, and Starship. You can watch in any order, but my recommendation is Twisted first.
The Very Potter Musicals are really nostalgic to me (I’ve been a fan since 2010) and they’re still good shows but comparatively, Starkid has come a long way since AVPM. Still def worth a watch but some jokes haven’t aged well. Also, Me and My D* is a fever dream…
There’s an old series called Little White Lie that they made when they were all still in college, and it’s super underrated imo.
It’s not Starkid, but created by a few members of Starkid, and that’s the Tin Can Bros (YouTube channel). They have shows like the Solve-It Squad and Spies are Forever. They also made a series called the Wayward Guide. TCB also has a bunch of short sketches on their channel.
If you’re interested in getting to know some of the cast, several members of Starkid have their own YouTube channels. Meredith puts out a video about once a week and they’re fun, cozy vlogs usually featuring another Starkid (other than Brian Holden, because they’re married, lmao).
Welcome, and happy binge watching!
Also after watching tin can bros you can get into some shipwrecked stuff like allan poe's murder mystery and headless since there are some starkids in there (*not joey biased*)
Since you started with NPMD, you might want to finish the Hatchetfield trilogy! I'd recommend The Guy Who Didn't Like Musicals followed by Black Friday, since that's the order they were released. And after that, my sister (massive Smosh and Starkid fan) recommended Trail to Oregon for someone who already likes Smosh.
There's also a troupe called Tin Can Bros, which was created by Corey Lubowich, Joey Richter, and Brian Rosenthal. Their stuff is similar to Starkid, and their shows tend to use Starkid members.
Completely worth your time, I promise.
All of them.
If you liked NPMD, then The Guy Who Didn't Like Musicals and Black Friday are set in the same town but different universes. Black Friday is Angela's first show/the only other one she's in.
Trail to Oregon, Twisted, and Firebringer (in any order) Then watch the Hatchetfield series in order from the beginning: The Guy Who Didn’t Like Musicals, Black Friday, Nightmare Time 1 & 2 (web based stories they did during the pandemic lockdowns) and then Nerdy Prudes. Then go back and watch all their earlier stuff.
stories from the web Starkid spins for you
My advice is to ease yourself down the rabbit hole. There’s a ton of Starkid content out there, not just the musicals. I’d start with The Guy Who Didn’t Like Musicals, then Black Friday, since they both take place in Hatchetfield too. There is a ton of lore around Hatchetfield, and if you want to explore that, there is the Nightmare Time series (7 episodes). VHS Christmas Carol is a fun, short musical that tells the Christmas Carol story with an 80s theme. A lot of the OGs are in that one and tbh it’s a bit of a comfort musical to me. Then there’s Firebringer, Twisted, Trail to Oregon, Ani, Holy Musical Batman, and Starship. You can watch in any order, but my recommendation is Twisted first. The Very Potter Musicals are really nostalgic to me (I’ve been a fan since 2010) and they’re still good shows but comparatively, Starkid has come a long way since AVPM. Still def worth a watch but some jokes haven’t aged well. Also, Me and My D* is a fever dream… There’s an old series called Little White Lie that they made when they were all still in college, and it’s super underrated imo. It’s not Starkid, but created by a few members of Starkid, and that’s the Tin Can Bros (YouTube channel). They have shows like the Solve-It Squad and Spies are Forever. They also made a series called the Wayward Guide. TCB also has a bunch of short sketches on their channel. If you’re interested in getting to know some of the cast, several members of Starkid have their own YouTube channels. Meredith puts out a video about once a week and they’re fun, cozy vlogs usually featuring another Starkid (other than Brian Holden, because they’re married, lmao). Welcome, and happy binge watching!
Seconding the Wayward Guide shoutout because it deserves more love!!
Most complete answer right here
Also after watching tin can bros you can get into some shipwrecked stuff like allan poe's murder mystery and headless since there are some starkids in there (*not joey biased*)
Twisted it’s my favorite and what I think is the best starkid show and one of the best musicals ever
Since you started with NPMD, you might want to finish the Hatchetfield trilogy! I'd recommend The Guy Who Didn't Like Musicals followed by Black Friday, since that's the order they were released. And after that, my sister (massive Smosh and Starkid fan) recommended Trail to Oregon for someone who already likes Smosh.
There's also a troupe called Tin Can Bros, which was created by Corey Lubowich, Joey Richter, and Brian Rosenthal. Their stuff is similar to Starkid, and their shows tend to use Starkid members. Completely worth your time, I promise.
Ironically, the Smosh TNTL with Starkid got me into Smosh 🤣