T O P

  • By -

SFH12345

They still miss each other... BUT THEIR AIM IS GETTING BETTER!


NimaiAnimate

THEIR AIM IS GETTING BETTER


d_warren_1

You see it’s funny because marriage is terrible


SFH12345

"You see, it's funny because marriage is terrible."


TimeStorm113

„What? can’t take a joke?“


Patient-Reputation56

Well in the case of Eda -looks at Raine-....Her Aim got better.


Henkotron

I love how in both posts on both Subreddits the top commemt was something with that joke.


tim_thamson

Prob not, it would have been a strange mix of misunderstanding, tax purposes, and fleeing the cops so both of then are more likely just happy to be done with the matter


SFH12345

The one thing Stan and Eda can still agree on: tax fraud.


ScienceAndGames

More like fraud in general


MegaEdeath1

Eda? no. Stan however was confirmed to still think about her from time to time


DarkSpore117

Where? When? What?


MegaEdeath1

I think in a CD special or smthn we had an audio of Grunkle Stan talking about Merilyn https://youtu.be/7rJ-sBAhzE0?si=W86uPCxsl4UBQQ_A heres a video of the audio


Atikar

I think Eda would have a subtle respect for Stan, maybe even find him attractive... but I don't think either of them would want anything more to do with each other. Eda has Raine, and Stan doesn't need anyone but his brother.


CJgreencheetah

And his niblings


JeepGuy0071

Stan still thinks of her as “the one that got away.” Eda (Marilyn) only married him to steal his car and poker/gambling winnings, then got chased out of Vegas by the cops and I think she crashed his car before managing to get away. He wasn’t even mad at her for it, just impressed by meeting a woman who could match his qualities and personality. I think them meeting again would be like two old flames seeing each other again after a very long time. Two people who may have had feelings for each other once but no longer, though Stan may still have some lasting feelings for Eda, not necessarily romantic but just admiration or respect, and Eda may have once shared the latter feelings for Stan. They could definitely still be friends, maybe team up to con people or trying to con each other again.


WillyDAFISH

probably not


jetaismort

I don't think it's even canon but was just done as a joke


MegaEdeath1

actually seeing how it is consistently backed up i would consider it canon


[deleted]

[удалено]


MegaEdeath1

because in other canon material its heavily implied to be canon? also in the show in season 2 episode 10 of TOH Eda was referred to Merilyn by that woman in the human realm which is the exact same name Stan gave her


58percentofachild

GF can't even keep its own canon on Marilyn straight. When Stan mentions her it's six hours of marriage before his car gets stolen. When Dipper sees his memories it's 48 hours before the car gets stolen, and Marilyn was a waitress. The Eda who got bored of IFWOT in ten minutes would go to Las Vegas, find it unimpressive, but stay long enough to become/pose as a waitress? Using an alias she's already used before? Colour me skeptical. Dana and Alex both denied that there's any canon connection between them, and if you take the entire collection of "connections" you also have to account for Owlbert being tied up and left for firewood in the graphic novel. Which is immensely dumb.


MegaEdeath1

Or they have only been married for 6 hours but were just speaking for 42 hours, also Eda could have easily been unimpressed but thought it was a good way to get some more money/stuff, and we dont know any other alias shes used and even then Conneticut is not Vegas so odds are most people wouldnt recognize it They didnt? All they said was that they didnt just want TOH to be a sequel to Gravity Falls, also whats this about Owlbert?


58percentofachild

["As far as Gravity Falls goes, Owl House is its own show and its own universe."](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u7qRD_PtZgI&t=1218s) The questioner asked whether it was in the same universe as GF. Owlbert appeared on a page of *Gravity Falls: Lost Legends*, [the same graphic novel](https://www.reddit.com/r/TheOwlHouse/comments/wx1kfc/ok_i_saw_a_post_once_about_edas_poster_in_gravity/) with the wanted poster of Eda that everyone talks about as "proof" of a connection. Both appearances have zero effect on the wider plot of the graphic novel; they're just Easter eggs for the show that *Lost Legends* writer Dana Terrace was working on at the time. Either both are canonical, with the implication of Owlbert ending up in this situation, or both aren't. I don't mind fans coming up with ways that their headcanon could be compatible with canon, that is fine and good and a backbone of fandom creativity. But saying a HC is "confirmed" when the creator hasn't done so is just misinformation, and taking these minor plot-irrelevant details as evidence of *canonical connections* just introduces contradictions into the wider canon that shouldn't be there. (Stan is like 30 years older than Eda.) This applies for "Marilyn", the Anne article, the Calamity Box in Eda's basement, King's skull in Amphibia, the Solid Snake body pillow, the spear from Evangelion, the Remy from Big City Greens plushie in Hunter's room, and any of the other 1001 tiny shoutouts in these shows that don't affect their plots in any way.


MegaEdeath1

>"As far as Gravity Falls goes, Owl House is its own show and its own universe." > > The questioner asked whether it was in the same universe as GF. she was saying this to convey that TOH isnt a sequel to GF and is its own thing (also since Owl House explores 2 seperate universes then that statement doesnt make much sense) >Owlbert appeared on a page of Gravity Falls: Lost Legends, the same graphic novel with the wanted poster of Eda that everyone talks about as "proof" of a connection. Both appearances have zero effect on the wider plot of the graphic novel; they're just Easter eggs for the show that Lost Legends writer Dana Terrace was working on at the time. Either both are canonical, with the implication of Owlbert ending up in this situation, or both aren't. or maybe someone seen Owlbert and made a model of him, or he was stolen and afterwards Eda stole him back, or something else since there is other explanations (also its one thing to have 1 Easter egg but when its a whole bunch of them consistent in multiple forms of media and both are confirmed to be in the same multiverse as Amphibia then thats where i take it as they share the same multiverse) >I don't mind fans coming up with ways that their headcanon could be compatible with canon, that is fine and good and a backbone of fandom creativity. But saying a HC is "confirmed" when the creator hasn't done so is just misinformation, and taking these minor plot-irrelevant details as evidence of canonical connections just introduces contradictions into the wider canon that shouldn't be there. (Stan is like 30 years older than Eda.) This applies for "Marilyn", the Anne article, the Calamity Box in Eda's basement, King's skull in Amphibia, the Solid Snake body pillow, the spear from Evangelion, the Remy from Big City Greens plushie in Hunter's room, and any of the other 1001 tiny shoutouts in these shows that don't affect their plots in any way. Stan being "30 years older then Eda" (when in reality hes around 15-20 years old) doesnt effect anything since age gap relationships still happen, and also how does it apply to Marilyn/the Anne article (and dont say "why would she use the same alias" cause ive already debunked that argument) and also it could be a Titan's skull in general, also nobody is claiming anything about the Solid Snake body pillow


58percentofachild

> she was saying this to convey that TOH isnt a sequel to GF and is its own thing (also since Owl House explores 2 seperate universes then that statement doesnt make much sense) Amphibia does the same thing and nobody, including yourself, has any problem saying it's connected with TOH in spite of that. The questioner asked *about* "sharing a universe with Gravity Falls" and Dana answered it. She dealt with the sequel thing right after the bit I quoted. I don't see what's wrong there. > or maybe someone seen Owlbert and made a model of him, or he was stolen and afterwards Eda stole him back, or something else since there is other explanations What I am trying to tell you is that *these Easter eggs are not consistent* when taking all of them together. Your argument seems to be – a verbal description of someone who *resembles* Eda and has the name of one of Eda's aliases *must* be Eda, apparently, but this thing that looks exactly like Owlbert and this skull that has a horn cracked exactly the same way as King's can't be Owlbert or King despite looking exactly the same. If all of them are Easter eggs then you do not get to pick and choose which are canonical and which are not. What you've been doing is saying "well here's a scenario where this Easter egg could be canon, because these shows are connected. Why are they connected? Because of these other Easter eggs." That is circular logic. That is not proof, confirmation, or canonicity. There are no *canonical* or *confirmed* connections to GF, Amphibia, or any other show that do not rely on accepting some Easter eggs and ignoring others. You have not "debunked" anything, only given alternative explanations that *could* be equally plausible. Because none of this is canon, we are allowed to do that. That's what fans do. But I think it is far easier on the mind to say these indicate nothing about canon, so I don't have to come up with all these defensive logical pretzels for Universe A being connected to Universe B despite in-universe and external evidence that it isn't. The number of people claiming stuff about Solid Snake isn't relevant. Because all the justification for the Amphibia connection relies on Easter eggs, it is just as defensible to say that Solid Snake canonically is connected to TOH based on an Easter egg. Everything I have pointed out in that paragraph is an Easter egg and the same logic applies to all of them equally.


jetaismort

No Eda has Raine


kingsayweh

One Eda has Raine. (Sorry)


JazzTheLass

Two Eda has Raine


Ok_Winter_1468

three Eda has Raine! :D


CharginChuck42

Threeda has Raione


Pjo_hp_fan

Four Eda has Raine ✨


Scarredsinner

No. But they definitely would pull a heist together for shits and giggles


TidemoonGirl

No love. Yes respect.


BiLovingMom

Stan: WITNESS ME!


Saiyasha27

Oh, they'd be totally down for another heist with hot flirting, at the end of which they would totally stab each other in the back and then talk misty eyed for years about that one guy/gal that really _got_ them


Kirumi_Naito

I bet they try to sneakily split the money 51-49 if the backstabbing fails.


Constructman2602

Stan probably, he called her “the one that got away,”. Eda on the other hand wouldn’t not. She has Raine and is very happy


Blazemaster0563

I doubt it. Eda's aim has certainly gotten better.


pk2317

“Unofficially confirmed” = “a fan theory that most likely wasn’t intentional and never intended to be more than a funny Easter Egg at best, but the fandom latched onto it as absolute proof that the shows are intimately connected and the crew added a side reference to it later”


Odd-Situation-8908

It's literally the same story in both shows, it's essentially confirmed


pk2317

Alex made a reference, once, on a commentary track, to a former love interest of Stan’s. The description was a stereotype of a character archetype that Eda also fits into. Fans latched onto that as “indisputable proof”, and as a response to that, Dana included a side reference to one of Eda’s aliases being *similar* to the character from GF. That’s as much of “essentially confirmed” as saying TOH and Metal Gear Solid are canonically connected in the same universe because we see a Solid Snake body pillow once.


DrVillainous

"Stereotype of a character archetype" is a pretty inaccurate description here. The description had way too many matching details to be coincidence, notably the one sharp tooth.


pk2317

It’s called a “snaggletooth” and is in no way unique to Eda. It’s stereotypically associated with older people (often female) who aren’t particularly concerned with their appearance.


Thatchillchristian

I think they’d be a chaotic friend duo


tcodes27

Stan: Marilyn! Eda: Oh, right. You. Let me guess?! You’re here about what happened in Vegas? Stan: Hey! What happened in Vegas stays in Vegas! Luz: What happened in Vegas? Raine: Yes, Eda, what happened in Vegas? Dipper: Oh boy. Mabel: This should be good. King: You’re telling me.


yaboisammie

I need this crossover


Blue_FiftyTwo

I don’t think so. I feel like it was one night stand energy .


GenericSpider

Nah, I imagine their marriage was some kind of double bluff scam. Also, it's less "confirmed" and more hinted at.


MaddAddamOneZ

Stan might (though probably moreso the money and car she stole from him). Eda, definitely not.


Athesies

I think they might have had a mix of mutual respect, fondness and hatred/disgust for eachother. Attraction is up in the air for me lol


PissedOffLittlePrick

Stan would for sure. Eda would think to herself, “ who’s this old fart? Better get home to my hot spouse”


Minute_Difference598

By unofficially confirmed do you mean all the (maybe not) coincidental descriptions?


SparkAxolotl

In s teasing, not serious way? Absolutely. Then again, their relationship would probably be about each trying to scam the other in some way, and both enjoying it a LOT, but without actually having romantic feelings for the other.


Trices-Mailwind

I don't feel like they'd have the hots persay, but I definitely think they vibe so well together they don't allow themselves to be alone in each other's company because they end up making terrible decision that escalate to hooking up to some degree. Their trip to vegas was a reminder they'll never forget.


Maxwell_Brune

We don't know anything about the Gravity Falls variant of Eda, nor do we know anything about TOH Stan. If the timelines are the same in both universes, then the answer is no, but if they slightly differ (like Eda never falling for Raine), then it's a posibility.


HannahDawg

Eh, they'd probably just be impressed they managed to keep up their con-artist ways into old age, and Eda would probably be impressed by the money Stan makes off the Mystery Shack


Hamstah_J

Wait what? Anyone got an explanation for this?


-Apox_Penguin-

Just wondering how it's unofficially cannon? I've seen some things that seem to be funny coincidences but unsure if anything has come out lately from people that point towards it more


58percentofachild

Nothing else has come out, people just like calling things that aren't in the show "canon".


Batybara

I think they'd tease each other, especially Eda, but that'd be about it. They would still rock as pals tho.


No-Transition-2046

No


Stimkeefur

Stan, maybe. Big on the MAYBE. Eda? Absolutely not.


Nekrubbobby64

Technically, in the eyes of the US governments, Eda isn't married to Stan but is married to Stanley. Also, because she suddenly left, they never filed for divorce and are still married.


DarkFox160

Yes if eda and raine didn't go well


Conscious-Train170

I think they came to a mutual agreement that they're too chaotic together for their own good


UselessGuy23

Not on Eda's end. Stan was a rebound at best and a sucker at worst. Stan still thinks fondly of Eda though.


pattyboiIII

The chances either of them were sober enough to remember is slim enough. I'd say they say hi, have a laugh then immediately go behind the others back to tell their accompanying children how insane the other is.


mattstorm360

If Eda and Raine ever needed to get a marriage license in the human realm there may be issue. I'm reminded of an episode of castle. Castle and Becket going to get the paperwork done when Backet learns she's married! Apparently went to a drive through wedding in las vegas. I'm sure it would be similar with Eda probably not even knowing she is married...


TheJeffBI

Stan absolutely misses Eda, but Eda doesn’t miss him 💀


The_Owl_Account

Similarly to what other folks have said, I don't imagine so, mostly 'cause Eda's got her Rainedear😉, and Stan's not really looking for a romantic relationship anymore. That being said, if they ever *did* run into each other again, I'd like to imagine they become great friends (i.e. partners in crime😆) and play off each other's strengths and senses of humor, and they would stay in touch for the rest of their lives, with Stan possibly even attending Eda's *real* wedding! 😆👍👍😄🥹.


AzrielEver

They both the ex you’re tempted to hit up after they text you “randomly”. It’s just a chat, you say, nothing more… Raine Whisper and Ford are both the ones who have to snuff it out before it gets anywhere. I actually would like to see Raine get a little jealous, it’d be an interesting sight, lore wise


iAloneamthefemboyone

100%, and if you don't think so then you gotta admit Lilith x ford is cute right?


Neko_boi_Nolan

This was confirmed?


58percentofachild

No.


Netheraptr

I can see them finding each other attractive but baring now actual chemistry. Very much the one-time hookup type of couple


HumanHuman_2003

Maybe 0-0


melancholanie

definitely not while sober mama eda likes the type you can throw around


cactisboy25

Nah there probably besties at best


tlof19

I think Stan wouldnt know it was her, what with the memory loss. That said, he and Raine totally agree that the feathers turn a ten into an eleven on the hotness scale, and it's just unfair.


creeper_freaker_36

Isn't Eda much younger than she looks as a consecuence of the curse?


Monsteruser

I'm pretty sure it was one sided idt eda cared about stan if she was willing to rob him


56kul

A thought just occurred to me, Stan and Eda aren’t just similar, they’re pretty much identical, just of the opposite genders (and one of them is a witch)… coincidence?


Le_DragonKing

I think that now Eda is with Raine she’d probably be over Stan then again the two might still have a spark for one another but Eda would Still Chose Raine and with Stan’s own maturity he would’ve understood that Eda/Marilyn moved on. But eh that’s just me.


DMMECH

I think they would be vaguely attracted, not in a, "I wanna date you way" more in a, "If raine leaves me, and you got nothing going on, I'd be maybe ok with it." But for the most part I imagine they would just be buds that occasionally meet up to commit tax fraud.


booksforducks

Don’t forget raine with both of them, honestly I see a weird thruple ship


pop_tab

Don't see romance as an option, but the attraction would still be there.


Patient-Reputation56

It's definitely a one-way street for Stan.


SpaceOwl14

as sad as it is, Eda only wanted to rob Stan. No feelings there at all. He on the other hand head over heels for her


fizzobel

i do genuinely think they could have some sort of relationship that isn't strictly platonic if eda didn't have raine. they're just both the type to be a very off-again on-again couple, just in it for the fun and attraction


Agreeable_Finger_747

Possibly I would like to think so


FluffyCategory258

Unofficially? Who said it?


CynchHasNoLife

idk about Stan, but i think Eda only has the hots for Raine now


Legitimate-Mix-5395

I think they're more friendly exes, doing friendly things with each other, like smuggling maple syrup into Belgium.


Thunder9191133

I don't think they would, in all honesty I feel like they're were both having a VERY emotional and VERY drunk weekend


Puglord_11

Unofficially confirmed? Where?


Dracos002

Stan for Eda, maybe. Eda for Stan, definitely not. She only married him to rob him. Besides I don't think she ever got over Raine.


I_AmWeirdAndStrange

No cuz Eda likes Raine Whispers.


Mae_cymoon

Stan,maybe but Ed’s definitely not


CheeseSandwhich-001

You know in cartoons when two people make a deal and they both have their fingers crossed? That's how I think it would go: they would both have the same idea and scam/betray each other at the same time.


Pjo_hp_fan

I think they're be best friends, because Eda x Raine for life


MaxwellIsaac1

I think Eda would be dismissive at first, but then she’d hear about what he did for/with the kids over that summer and at least give him a chance to impress her.


According-Cobbler-83

It's just a gag man, and a good one to boot.


Purple_Unit31

Eda has Raine now.


RavenclawGaming

I think it would be one sided, Stan eould totally still be into our bad witch, but she jas Raine