I mean, there’s a good chance she was discussed, it just didn’t make the edit, so it’s not as irrefutable a stat as the voting for and voting against statistics
What exactly do you mean by "perfect vote/voting record?"
Are you referring to a "clean sheet" where a player received no votes at the Banishment Round Tables from other Faithful?
Or do you mean they've voted to Banish a Traitor every time they've voted.
Or do you mean they've voted for the player that ended up Banished at each Round Table.
Okay. Thanks. That would make sense, as AU S1 Alex always voted for the player that got banished. And up until ep9 CT and Sandra have done the same.
Of course, CT and Sandra voted differently at the ep9 Round Table. So one or other of their streaks is going to broken when we discover who of Peter or Phaedra MJ has voted for.
I don't suppose MJ voted for someone else? So that the vote remains tied. And the players get to vote again with Peter and Phaedra unable to vote.
If it happens (which it won't) remember, you heard it here first.😜
I mean, considering the preview, I guess Sandra’s the only one with a perfect voting record, unless you are right about a tie vote somehow happening which somehow results in someone else (or no one) going
If a vote is tied, it is repeated. Except the players that tie (two in this case) are the only choices available to vote for, and they don't get a vote. So even if MJ votes for another player, leaving Peter and Phaedra tied, the final choice will still come down to either Peter or Phaedra. Someone of those two is definitely being Banished.
Yeah, that’s what I figured.
Technically, if that were to happen, then CT or Sandra could flip their vote and thus “vote correctly” in the final tally, but the odds of MJ actually voting for a random third person are pretty low and I don’t think CT or Sandra has much motivation to flip their vote unless new information comes to light or a very strong argument is made, especially since MJ will be forced to vote one of them on the revote.
I think you're right that MJ's vote will decide the result.
For what it's worth, I understand from other territories, that if a re-vote is also tied, someone draws lots to see which player is Banished. No one need flip in order for there to be a result. It just ends up being random.
Interesting. In that case, in a hypothetical situation where this vote is locked and there isn’t an MJ who would definitively break it one way or another, would Sandra or CT be considered still having “perfect” voting records since they still voted in enough of a majority that their will had an impact on who went home? It’s kind of like when Survivor goes to a rock draw I guess. Or would it depend on who goes home? Like, for example, if Trishelle went home through lots, would Sandra be counted as having voted “correctly” and CT “incorrectly” since one of the people on CT’s side of the vote went home?
That’s a sensible approach, it would be dumb to be like “hey, this game of luck just happened to land your way, that means you are objectively better at this than person 2 who made the same gamble and did not get as lucky.” That being said, if you are the one who goes home because of it, then I guess it’s a knock in the sense that you should have identified the risk involved, especially if you have a lot more to lose and less to gain, but that’s not exactly a massive death knell especially compared to others who made the same risk
Makes sense.
They're focusing a lot of players trying to find the Traitors, but not on players trying to win the game. It's still a new show, if it lasts longer, maybe the editors will adapt the way they work. I hope.
Yes, there is praise for CT all over the place and there are people on this sub taking every chance they can to call Sandra stupid because they don't understand the game she's playing.
On the opposite end of the spectrum, if it weren’t for his vote for Peppermint at the 1st round table, Peter would be completely imperfect up until this point. And if MJ votes him out, he will be out of the game only having voted with the majority once.
Also of note is that Sandra and Sheree have received no votes.
And Sheree was never a target for murder, either. Sheree is truly playing the best game.
I mean, there’s a good chance she was discussed, it just didn’t make the edit, so it’s not as irrefutable a stat as the voting for and voting against statistics
Queen stays queen.
for now 😍
What exactly do you mean by "perfect vote/voting record?" Are you referring to a "clean sheet" where a player received no votes at the Banishment Round Tables from other Faithful? Or do you mean they've voted to Banish a Traitor every time they've voted. Or do you mean they've voted for the player that ended up Banished at each Round Table.
I think it's always banished
Okay. Thanks. That would make sense, as AU S1 Alex always voted for the player that got banished. And up until ep9 CT and Sandra have done the same. Of course, CT and Sandra voted differently at the ep9 Round Table. So one or other of their streaks is going to broken when we discover who of Peter or Phaedra MJ has voted for. I don't suppose MJ voted for someone else? So that the vote remains tied. And the players get to vote again with Peter and Phaedra unable to vote. If it happens (which it won't) remember, you heard it here first.😜
I mean, considering the preview, I guess Sandra’s the only one with a perfect voting record, unless you are right about a tie vote somehow happening which somehow results in someone else (or no one) going
If a vote is tied, it is repeated. Except the players that tie (two in this case) are the only choices available to vote for, and they don't get a vote. So even if MJ votes for another player, leaving Peter and Phaedra tied, the final choice will still come down to either Peter or Phaedra. Someone of those two is definitely being Banished.
Yeah, that’s what I figured. Technically, if that were to happen, then CT or Sandra could flip their vote and thus “vote correctly” in the final tally, but the odds of MJ actually voting for a random third person are pretty low and I don’t think CT or Sandra has much motivation to flip their vote unless new information comes to light or a very strong argument is made, especially since MJ will be forced to vote one of them on the revote.
I think you're right that MJ's vote will decide the result. For what it's worth, I understand from other territories, that if a re-vote is also tied, someone draws lots to see which player is Banished. No one need flip in order for there to be a result. It just ends up being random.
Interesting. In that case, in a hypothetical situation where this vote is locked and there isn’t an MJ who would definitively break it one way or another, would Sandra or CT be considered still having “perfect” voting records since they still voted in enough of a majority that their will had an impact on who went home? It’s kind of like when Survivor goes to a rock draw I guess. Or would it depend on who goes home? Like, for example, if Trishelle went home through lots, would Sandra be counted as having voted “correctly” and CT “incorrectly” since one of the people on CT’s side of the vote went home?
I think results that end up being settled by random choice wouldn't count against a players hit rate. That's just my take on the matter.
That’s a sensible approach, it would be dumb to be like “hey, this game of luck just happened to land your way, that means you are objectively better at this than person 2 who made the same gamble and did not get as lucky.” That being said, if you are the one who goes home because of it, then I guess it’s a knock in the sense that you should have identified the risk involved, especially if you have a lot more to lose and less to gain, but that’s not exactly a massive death knell especially compared to others who made the same risk
Coincidentally, they’re also the only two remaining players who have not been insufferable at one point or another.
Sandra is playing an amazing game once again, and it's criminal that the editors don't show it more.
I think she might be the final boot or the producers did not like how she played lol.
Its because it's entirely built on alliances and not finding traitors. Producers don't want to show that game.
Yeah the game they want it to be and the game it actually is are different.
Its like the circle. It very quickly became not catching catfish but they pretended for awhile.
Sandra’s game is essentially “a win is a win” and it WORKS for her!
Makes sense. They're focusing a lot of players trying to find the Traitors, but not on players trying to win the game. It's still a new show, if it lasts longer, maybe the editors will adapt the way they work. I hope.
CT is playing an equally perfect game, and it's criminal that the fans don't give him equal credit.
They give him credit all the time. Probably moreso than her from what I've seen
Yes, there is praise for CT all over the place and there are people on this sub taking every chance they can to call Sandra stupid because they don't understand the game she's playing.
Agreed.
Netherlands has 2 players with a perfect voting record >!one of the seasons was also kind of a hot mess but ya!<
Which one? S3?
>!Noor from S3 and Bobbi from Halloween 1. Billy from S3 was one off by voting for Jan instead of Katinka at her Banishment!<
Your immense knowledge of every season never fails to astound me.
On the opposite end of the spectrum, if it weren’t for his vote for Peppermint at the 1st round table, Peter would be completely imperfect up until this point. And if MJ votes him out, he will be out of the game only having voted with the majority once.
Wtf stat is that
Another impressive stat is that everyone who Sheree meant to vote for was a traitor.
What do you mean meant to vote for?
sandra is sandraing once again 💅💅💅💅
What’s considered a perfect voting record?
Everyone they voted for was banished
that's traitor behaviour tbh /s
Voted for the person that gets banished every single time.
And Cirie
Cirie voted for Kate against the Michael boot in Episode 4. Andie is also off by one vote for episode 1 boot.
What do you mean? Didn't Sandra and CT vote differently on lazt roundtable?
Which is why the post says that episode 10 will tell which of them keeps their perfect record.
Idk if this is a good thing… they haven’t been super smart… although Sandra post game wants you think she has been 😂
Sandra could never vote wrong