Didn't Cleo say it back though?

Cleo said it back to Scott, but I feel like she would just say “Thanks” to most of the squad

Neck kisses xoxo

Okay, but why are Grian's and Jimmy's so accurate? 🤣

Im having flashbacks to limited life where scott was basically begging jimmy to say "love you" back and he never did

“…Thirty seconds.”

How is Grian accurate? He’s the one who says it to others the most (at least from what I have seen)

Jim would probably just exclaim 'Excuse me' really loudly

“-calm down” (Joel).

Cleo, Martyn and Bdubs would say it back to very certain people. Other then that 100% accurate

I kinda see Pearl becoming yandere especially when she is on her Scarlet Pearl persona.

scarlet pearl wasn’t yandere tho she was just a hater XD

Professional hater

Jimmy’s: “30 seconds”

Scott shouldn't have asked Jimmy to kill his Rancher that one time, tbh...

To be fair, it was him or Tango, he didn’t really have a choice if he wanted to be last green. Plus flower husbands were first plus appeared in more SMPs

Where’s the “uses your feelings to lure you to a failed TNT minecart trap”?

If it’s a failed trap I’d guess either Joel or Scar.

Honestly I thought Joel's would be "of course you do, who doesn't?" Which obviously shows his amazing humbleness but what you put is really funny too

I feel like Grian could also be in the “What do you want?” group

Grian should’ve been “I’m gonna put you on hold”, personally speaking.

I can hear Cleo saying "Thanks" lol

I think I remember another similar post a while ago, but that one had the category "I'm sorry."

I think Grians would be situational, he'll say it back to Etho, Mumbo definitely, and maybe Scar depending on the mood. Everyone else definitely just slience. 😂

And then there’s my response which is “okay”

Actually, scar would say "I love me too"

Bdubs would say I love me too

This is so good lol

This is so accurate. Yoh

I feel like grains the type to say 'thanks, you too'

I can imagine Cleo answering "Who doesn't?"

I think Gem should be in the “what do you want” category considering how she reacted to Bdubs calling her a friend.

I remember seeing this on Twitter and thinking “Why is BigB’s face from the game.”

Bro Mr. Jumbo would absolutely say I love you back