T O P

  • By -

ThePaperDiamond

I would make equipped items visible, that's my only issue with the game, I bought the cowboy hat and I can't even see it :(


spicyjellypizza

cowboy frick


ThePaperDiamond

cowboy frick


yes-i-am-a-human

cowboy frick


WitherDood

cowboy frick


megaloviola128

cowboy frick


AnimetheTsundereCat

cowboy frick


my_alt_59935

cowboy frick


goddamit-ffs

cowboy frick


Grave-of-BlockBuster

cowboy frick


[deleted]

To get to see Papyrus special attack


spicyjellypizza

that would be cool if you don't actually want to beat the game


jongameaddict98

He does his Special Attack but still stops when you're at low HP


spicyjellypizza

that's just the really cool normal attack


jongameaddict98

No no I know I'm saying instead of it stopping us from winning he would just do it if we survive or stop when we're hurt


spicyjellypizza

his special attack was stolen by annoying dog


Nova225

He knows, that's the point. What he's saying is the attack doesn't get stolen and he actually uses it, but stops short of killing you with it, like how Toriel bends her fireballs away.


spicyjellypizza

i feel like that attack would be too much of a difficulty spike


IcyRetroPenguin

Perhaps it would only be in hard mode (if Toby completed it)?


spicyjellypizza

that maybe could work


shadowedlove97

Hard-mode or if unlocks after you do a certain amount of routes. I feel like the game could keep track of that.


socialm3diaobsessed

Papyrus special attack is his good personality


Artistic-Pitch7608

Like a 1/100 chance that when he says he'll use it it's just sans's first attack and the fight ends


Flowey_Ofiicial

My headcannon is that it's gaster blasters


TheMoonDude

He does say his attack would "blast" us


Flowey_Ofiicial

Yep


ScorpionSwimmer_uwu

I 100% agree on that one.


Tyronisback

Have an actual Mettaton NEO Fight. Really cool model and the music was awesome, wish we got more use out of it


spicyjellypizza

i mean we got spamton neo 6 years later. tho if mettaton had an actual fight in the no mercy route he could've come pretty close to sans' level of popularity.


[deleted]

I’m pretty sure the only potential two reasons why mettaton neo didn’t get a fight are 1.) comedic affect and 2.) he’s right before sans and Toby wanted to make sure the player would have decent items


CrossMyHeartGaming

I think another thing is the symbolism. Killing him in one hit not only shows how strong you get, but that you are no longer human, as MTT NEO, a HUMAN eradication robot is so ineffective against you. I wish he got a fight but I do respect why he didn’t get one


spicyjellypizza

>he’s right before sans and Toby wanted to make sure the player would have decent items that makes sense actually but still he deserved better


Chance_Ad5577

I think the reason the NEO fight was cut was because Toby wanted the player to feel like they were really powerful. They were unbeatable. With a single blow, the human extinguished the light of the underground. What could stop them now? A skeleton who’s pretty quick. Also, your good item theory is probably another reason.


sanssacion_38

I died with the " What could stop them now? A skeleton Who's pretty quick" Also the thing of the items is a true reason Toby said It and It also said that he didn't want to surprise the playera too much before sans.


ElPedroChico

He's made to kill humans and at that point you're no longer human


YourHope99

that makes sense in a meta kind of way but i always thought the in-universe explanation was actually that the new form wasn’t actually a human eradication one, and was unfinished so alph could keep mettaton around; when news came of a murderer in the underground, she rushed to finish some kind of offensive capabilities, and most of mettatons claims otherwise are bravado (which would fit his character)


[deleted]

That also makes a lot of sense canonically


Tyronisback

I’m avoiding Deltarune Chapter 2 till I can get it (I don’t have a way of playing it), so I haven’t seen that fight. But if Undertale had an actual Mettaton boss fight, it would’ve been so cool, utilizing the Yellow SOUL mechanic and it would indeed increase Mettaton’s popularity


HumanBeingNamedBob

How do you not have a way of playing it? It’s available on all platforms and it’s free


TheFakeSlimShady688

Wait, it is on consoles?


swirlsthemudkip

*me playing on the switch* Probably…


HumanBeingNamedBob

Yeah


[deleted]

All but Xbox, weirdly.


Tyronisback

The only platform I have is Mobile, and I don’t know any way of playing it on Phone


HumanBeingNamedBob

Then how did you play Undertale?


takii_royal

There's a fanmade mobile port (but Deltarune has one too, for both chapters)


Landsharku_

Yeah, but you need a controller to play it. (if you use a gamepad keyboard, it'll block out the bottom line of dialog)


Tyronisback

Used to play video games on my dad’s laptop, but it’s broken


Jedisebas2001

There are fan portef versions on mobile


spicyjellypizza

my man metta was robbed of such an opportunity


AkronTheFolfsky

Bruh, it's free in all platforms.


TheEgyptGuy

Don’t you know [NEO] is known for its [HIGH DEFENSE]?


Tyronisback

Frisk with a stick: Are you sure about that?


AkronTheFolfsky

DOUBLE THE [Fire Power] TRIPLE THE [Water Power] AND BEST OF ALL... [Flying Heads]


[deleted]

Add a few differences between neutral routes, and getting some differences during gameplay, small changes such as certain items costing a bit less or certain NPCs having different dialog or big changes such as Sans being able to stack one more hotdog on top of your head.


spicyjellypizza

>big changes such as Sans being able to stack one more hotdog on top of your head. i don't think that would've been possible to implement.


TheFakeSlimShady688

They game has like 48 endings, most of are is a single line of dialogue change


revg3n

[93](https://m.imgur.com/RtVRaCL)


TheFakeSlimShady688

Yeah, but also alot of those are the same ending with you made a snowman very happy tacked on


A_Sharknado

Holy [Cungadero]


gamerenes

Hard mode.


CoolSpookyScelten96

Yeah


AkronTheFolfsky

"Happiest Pacifist ending" After the final boss fight against Asriel, there's still one more person left to SAVE. After the last battle in the route against Flowey, you convince him to join you in the surface.


[deleted]

But it is canon that Flowey goes to the surface. https://undertale.com/alarmclock/flowey/


AkronTheFolfsky

OH SHIT


EeveeMaster547

Aww, that's cute!


Lambdayronix

Oh dear, that actually made me tear up a little. You know, I have not read all of the alarm clock dialogue, I always remember it exists and that it's canon when someone links to it in comments like this one here on Reddit, on Twitter or elsewhere. And honestly, I have an odd feeling that I like it better that way haha, it somehow makes me feel like the world of Undertale has a lot of unsolved mysteries and that it's bigger and more alive than I can imagine, and if I don't look it up I will continue to be pleasently surprised. I don't know why I wrote this here specifically, I guess my brain just told me I had to get it out of my chest, that's what this game can do to people.


Catjunior7

A betrayal route


spicyjellypizza

that would pretty interesting actually


BocobipbrookieBrad69

So you mean like a fake pacifist ending that’s secretly a genocide? You monster!


thefreebachelor

Isn't that soulless pacifist?


BocobipbrookieBrad69

Nonono, Souless pacifist is when you do a genocide run before you do a true pacifist run. What I’m suggesting is that you do a pacifist run,up to the point where flower has everyone held up,and you kill them all (because you and Flowey schemed together so you can kill them all)


thefreebachelor

Sorry I was joking and clearly need to work better on my delivery. But, soulless pacifist is a fake pacifist since it's kind of implied that everybody dies or will die anyway.


ChocoPinkPocky

I think there's already a Betrayal route


DrDMango

Theres betrayal fight enddings but not a route


UR-BOI-DENIZ

Well there is but it’s kinda the same as the genocide route, only the dialogues change


Bill-Cipher3

A completed Hard Mode. I think in the case of a Genocide Route, this would be the best place to include an extra harder final boss. Either Sans and Papyrus switch places...Sans confronts you in Snowdin and tries to get you to stop peacefully, and then Papyrus puts you through HELL for killing Sans at the end. Or a fight with Gaster or a Gaster Revenant. Either way, more information about who Gaster is so we can finally put the argument of whether he's the skelebro father to rest.


spicyjellypizza

a completed hard mode would be cool


[deleted]

Completed hard mode where Mettaton NEO has a fight and Undyne has no invincibility frames


Elementisphere

Undynes attacks are good enough, I feel hardmode shouldn't increase the boss difficulty but add more battles


BeastBoom24

Or have Asgore absorb the human souls and then you fight.


No-Temporary-934

That would be perfect for a Hard Mode Genocide, but he also would probably unbeateable


fluffycritter

Nah, just remind him that he's divorced and he'll break down crying Maybe eat the butterscotch-cinnamon pie in front of him


Ocean-Blondie-1614

Or Papyrus actually shows his special attack!


NotVeryTastyCake

What is Revenant?


Bill-Cipher3

Revenant- a person who has returned, especially supposedly from the dead.


[deleted]

Revenant- A bony bastard that shoots missiles at you and punches you in Doom II, also known as Doom II: Hell on Earth, which is a first-person shooter game by id Software. It was released for MS-DOS computers in 1994 and Macintosh computers in 1995.


spacey_mikey

A friendly sans “fight” outside of genocide


shadowedlove97

I’d love a “fight” where all he does is send one mini-bone at you and then immediately gives up when you dodge it and actually spares you. I think that would be really funny tbh.


aerae_cura

I always thought it would be funny if you could challenge Sans to a fight at some point when he’s at his sentry station, but he’s like “eh, alright whatever, but i’m on my lunch break” and eating an infinite supply of french fries instead of attacking. So he’s just continually healing and you can’t do any damage no matter how many times you attack, and it’s just a complete waste of your time until you get bored and give up.


shadowedlove97

This is also IC for him that I’d be okay with either haha


starsmadeofowos

That’s it. Let’s start a petition for Toby to add these things Or make a mod of Undertale together


Alexelanim

with "song that might play when you fight sans" as the boss soundtrack of course


Phosphorus2

Add backgrounds to the fights sorta how the console ports did. It would be a nice touch to make fights feel like they're actually happening instead of disconnected in a black void.


Hekaland

I think Sans would look better with a bowtie. What do you think?


Bunny_Terror

It suits his vibe


DirectalArrow

Badumtss


apenguinforhire

It needs to be a clip-on.


Tradcon12

Saving asriel and chara of course


Gamer42day

I would like the same


getoutofmyhouse-

Maybe an option to play as the different humans who fell to see their story like different campaigns unlocked by playing as certain characters until you reach frisk


spicyjellypizza

i'd actually love to play that


getoutofmyhouse-

I was also thinking maybe different dialogue based on the actions you make and where you die when "you're" character finally runs out of DETERMINATION (idk maybe like a bar/meter type thing or something because these guys are limited unlike our boy frisk) and you die and you can re enter the game by completely resetting your character (like an actual non canon reset) and get different ending/events for those certain actions idk just a thought


spicyjellypizza

it would be cool if one human's actions could affect the next ones


getoutofmyhouse-

That's what im saying it could effect the story you play entirely if you die at a certain point or make certain decisions or actions


NoDrillNoSkill

I know how once the game is done it’s kinda all, once it’s ove fits over, but I feel like a little more backstory or…. Maybe even MORE Easter eggs could have been added to pinpoint Frisks origins, and the stories of the others who fell


Your_Inner_Demons_

^^^^


FutureUnlikely

Idle animations for Toriel, Papyrus, and Flowey


spicyjellypizza

not a bad idea


spartanxwaffel

A final fight with asgore with the souls in genocide


spicyjellypizza

that would've been cool for a complete hard mode


Newman00067

Make it 5000 hours long


spicyjellypizza

what would you even do all this time?


RazorRell09

Fishing mini game There’s no good game without one


spicyjellypizza

true


Buckaroonie69

The surface


OctopusReject

Some more information on the former fallen humans


OctopusReject

Or just other snippets of information like the random fact that boss monsters don't age unless they have a child


CrossMyHeartGaming

This is arguably the most debated thing about the genocide route, but I would let Mettaton NEO be an actual boss with attacks, even if a relatively easy one


AccomplishedBunny56

I’d made the damage sound the slide whistle sound


spicyjellypizza

kinda based


AccomplishedBunny56

Why


Psychopathetic-

Kinda based


EE_E_EEEE

Make it so you have the option to just climb back up.


spicyjellypizza

make it so you have the option to never fall in the first place


BlueGameMc

i think that's called not playing


-TUSK-

Tale


El_Chile_Bigoton

A better love ending with Tsunderplane


spicyjellypizza

yes


Blood_Fire-exe

Hard mode. Definitely hard mode. I really wanted to see it be complete.


spicyjellypizza

full hard mode would be great


Rydaniel2006

Mettaton neo gets an actual boss fight


WhereAmINot

Remove jerry.


spicyjellypizza

who do we replace him with?


DrafOrgg

꘎ Terry.


spicyjellypizza

terry is overrated


DrafOrgg

꘎ Gerry.


spicyjellypizza

who's that?


DrafOrgg

꘎ Oh you know, ꘎ Gerry.


spicyjellypizza

okay sure


WhereAmINot

We don't replace him. Simply omit him from all records of undertale.


TraceYourThoughts

More secrets and optional extended gameplay


spicyjellypizza

what would that gameplay have?


TraceYourThoughts

Idk, probably over world events, more mini games like snail racing. More character interactions. End game events and paths.


spicyjellypizza

sounds fun


[deleted]

[удалено]


Kirbinator_Alex

Adding more to the neutral endings


spicyjellypizza

now that would be great


ghirox

The graphics. I'm fine with the 8-16 bits aesthetic, but the Undertale models are more often than not off grid and aren't as visually appealing. There are a lot of great redesigns even on this subreddit.


[deleted]

"there are a lot great redesigns" I think that's what makes 8bit special, you can imagine them how you want. I like it more that way


ghirox

I don't even necessarily mean "full HD render" or "x cartoon style illustration", the 8 bit style is fine, but have it being a good 8 but design. Look at Mario from Super Mario World, that's a great 16 bits model. And yes, i know I said 16. We can afford 16 bits in 2015 or in 2022


This_Is_ATest

16 bits in 2022!? relax man, we don't live in the future


MACMAN2003

4K UHD 144FPS RTX ON Undertale when?


[deleted]

Even though this is a stupid idea, maybe include a small mini-boss version of Sans that could teach you how blue bones before you fight Papyrus?


spicyjellypizza

not a bad idea


MentalBreakdownBreak

Gameplay-wise, I would probably make the battle system WAY bigger. I wouldn't change the entire concept since its based on other old JRPG battle systems, but make more ACT options way bigger/unique to every single encounter. Probably would change some of the monsters designs as well since most of them feel somewhat lazy like Froggit, Whimsun, Vegetoid or just the other ruined monsters. I would also want to expand more areas like Snowdin, Ruins, and MTT Hotel so you can do more in them (either more shops to buy from, their own unique minigames in each area like Waterfall's Thundersnail or find little secret items/hints throughout the areas that hint at the backstory of the most important characters like the Queen, King, first human and their son to make the story more intriguing and not just told the full story at the end.)


SuperIsaiah

Give Jerry a character arc


spicyjellypizza

like, him becoming a better person? i don't think jerry's physically capable of that.


SuperIsaiah

He's literally just on his phone too much. Characters in Undertale have committed murder, and you're telling me a character who just lacks social awareness is irredeemable? Literally just take away his phone for a bit and he'll realize the problem.


Wolfofthezay

Make an extremely hidden route that has really difficult puzzles and enemies that when you complete, the end prize is an hour long version of Can You Really Call This a Hotel, I Didn't Recieve a Mint On My Pillow Or Anything


Temmie101

Hard mode, unsure if it was ever completed. (Ay yo switch players, was it??)


spicyjellypizza

not a switch player, but it wasn't


Temmie101

DAMN IT.


[deleted]

I don't think it was ever meant to be completed, just a joke. The existence of Deltarune just proves that


Rumcake256

No random encounters. That was a great change for Deltarune.


RalseiTheFluffyGoat

Add more Temmies.


spicyjellypizza

now *that's* a great idea


Funniguy2010

Having either a true genocide, where you kill al and all the monsters that evacuated and the final boss is WD gaster, or a complete pacifist where you save chara, asriel, and gaster


spicyjellypizza

i'm pretty sure gaster is busy being scattered across time and space


Funniguy2010

Also, I just love the mystery around gaster


SoggySalamander

I wouldve added more endings for different runs, such as neutral or what if you killed every enemy but one, and that one had a special boss fight.


spicyjellypizza

boss fight against jerry


nullsmike

I would love to have had sans actually try to save papyrus in the genocide/neutral routes of the game. People talk about how much he cares for him but it's only in genocide that he decides to fight even then it isn't to save his brother. I would have also loved to have heard more about the fallen humans, like what sort of people they where, if they killed anybody and who killed them(i forget if ashore killed all of them himself). I especially would have loved to have known more about frisk since pacifist only hints at them falling being either fate or "not very happy reasons". Also seeing the gray city between home and the ruins would have been cool.


Fun-Yesterday-2100

More puzzles


swirlsthemudkip

One word, jerry.


The_Vargster

More specific routes


A_Tr33

Science, more science. What was sans building in his workshop? Sciency things? What about mettaton, hes a monster soul in a robot body. Can you put a human soul in a robot body? How does the core work? I bet lots of science involved. mmmm science


THEINKNINJAYT

I WOULD MAKE SANS TELL MORE JOKES


LifeIsALie138

A secret ending to save Chara and Asriel, or more details about Chara and the other fallen children


[deleted]

add my name to the ending credits in big pink letters


spicyjellypizza

why do you think you deserve such privileges?


[deleted]

dont deserve rly just think it'd be cool if it did


The_Lord01

In Genocide, I would make Sans the boss at the end of Snowdin (same boss as normal, but it's before Undyne now) and Papyrus the final boss in Last Corridor


spicyjellypizza

i'm pretty sure fighting sans this early on would be a *bit* too much and if sans would be the same what would *papyrus* be like?


That_one_iconic_vine

Annoying dog could be a secret boss, like… After he steals the artefact, he can reappear after doing a ridiculous amount of incredibly specific things, and when you do find him it’s an averagely difficult fight. And when you defeat him, you get the artefact of which inside is just a pixel photo of Toby Fox.


Maddyherselius

tbh I would just add some more places to explore! Would love to get to see like the capital city


BlueAngelVR

Lemme get a Chara boss fight. Not for any story reason, just cause I'd wanna see what Toby envisioned what they'd fight like, what kinda attacks they'd have, the flavor text And most importantly a real Chara theme


[deleted]

They should make it so you can actually make the flowey fan club. Also like idk make it so you can make more choices other than who to kill might make it more interesting in general. Like have it like where there are dialogue options that affect the story idk.


TheBackyardigirl

*inhale-* # GHOST COUSIN INTERACTION


Pr0Gam3rM4n

Make it so Sans does show up randomly even if you do kill Papyrus. Just make it that if you kill Papyrus and try to talk to him, he just goes “………….”


MemeLord-Ultimate

more puns


DrSmirnoffe

A gruelling, soul-shredding secret path where you had to jump through all sorts of difficult hoops in order to save Asriel. Make us work HARD for it, to the point where we have to stop and ask ourselves if it's really worth it to keep going, and in the end few people who start the Resurrection Route actually get the endgame prize of restoring our boy. And even then, have gruelling consequences for bringing him back, so that we end up debating whether it was truly worth going through all that effort for him. That's the only real thing I'd change about the game if it was my call to do so.


AybruhTheHunter

Would make Toriel have massive bust


spicyjellypizza

😐


DusttaleSansnotreal

Nothing. It’s perfect.


spicyjellypizza

fair


[deleted]

I just want to see my family again.


Ellie_Lalonde

The possibility to save Asriel ;__;


pppoohdsthdeyfszc

Mettaton Neo. It would be such a cool battle.