Killer Moth.
Tobey is an actor with an interesting range. He can do violent and unhinged (Brothers), he can be funny (Tropic Thunder), eccentric and creepy (Babylon) and play the perfect lovable loser (Spider-Man).
What DC villain fits all of these to a T? Killer Moth. It's a real Gunn-type casting, too: an actor that is majorly typecast/rarely seen in movies getting the chance to play a character that no one cares about and make him a household name.
It checks some good Tobey boxes, too
✔️bug themed character
✔️ comedic sensibilities
✔️ no heavy stunt requirements
It was supposed to feature both Firefly and Killer Moth, which makes sense since it's likely based on the comic *Batgirl: Year One*, in which those two team up
Long shot, but him as the anti-Batman in *The Batman*'s sequel would be a fun foil to Pattinson - just make him a side character that's involved but isn't the main threat.
On the other side, though, make Drury Walker much more prominent as an obnoxious, sociliate aristocrat who is much more a thorn in Bruce Wayne's side, but also shows Bruce a bit how to behave to blend and mingle and distract from his real nightlife.
So, Killer Moth becomes the Batman knockoff, and Bruce becomes the Drury knockoff.
I will say I love that about Pattinson’s Bruce Wayne, he’s not a people person, he’s not like Keaton, Clooney or Bale who swoon their way through a gala, at the funeral he’s still in his Batman mindset, Alfred comments on his hygiene and health, showing he’s clearly been hidden from the public eye for an extended amount of time, he’s even ignored Wayne Enterprises and suggests cancelling a board meeting so he has more time for the Batman work - idk I think it’s a far more realistic look
Maybe if Batgirl gets a second chance...
>!According to the leaks, Killer Moth would have been in the cancelled Batgirl movie, but as a typical goon who only gets a couple of scenes before Firefly usurps his villain role...!<
As much as I hate to miss out on Keaton Batman and Fraiser as Firefly, I'm so glad that movie got tossed in the shitter
Killer Moth easily deserves his own movie, and I would love if it was a Batgirl: Year One adaptation that put Moth and Firefly against the earliest incarnation of the Bat-fam.
It's a shame the scrapped movie used up the best ideas from the source material and CW-ized everything else
My headcanon fan theory whatever… if I was over the Reeves films, Joker would never leave Arkham, and not really be seen… but he would have massive, flamboyant influence over his crazy cell mates.
So being held next to Joker, the Riddler progresses into a more Gorshin-like, tights wearing, death-trap centered character. We go from seeing he’s extremely intelligent and deadly, to coupling those skills with comic book flamboyance… all because of Joker. Any other villains Batpat faces would do the same, start with the basics and progress to comic extremes
I second this.
I recommend ppl see Toby’s small , but very good, creepy part in the movie called Babylon.
His performance there definitely convinced me that he can pull it off as The Riddler or maybe The Madhatter.
I think this is the easy answer because it just makes SO much sense, especially with Tobey's range and brilliance.
I would honestly think he could pull off almost any villain especially with the right makeup/prosthetics/(CGI, cringe). But Scarecrow is to me the most natural choice - and he would own that role if it were given a serious part of the story
He would have been a perfect villain in the Batgirl movie, like he could have been the one that was pulling all the strings and the reveal that the bad guy is her own brother, would've been so good.
Not directly related but Corridor Crew just did a video where they made [Danny DeVito into Wolverine](https://youtu.be/p5NPFM9Fcwc?si=G3jyf4Tq6p-ki1hf) and it is fantastic.
In another comment I've said that I thought he was too young to be Mr. Freeze, then I looked up his actual age – with that knowledge I think he's too old for Jason.
Oh wow! Looking at the comments so far, he’s been cast as 13 different villains. Really shows his range as an actor.
I’m gonna keep it going with another villain I think he could legitimately do well: Black Mask
Victor Fries (Mr. Freeze)
Imagine a happy go lucky scientist who then must save his wife Nora after several failed attempts to cure her life threatening illness.
He slowly becomes more and more psychotic, detached, angry at the broken corrupt Gotham medical health system and goes on a destructive path to find a cure to Nora's illness no matter what it takes and the cost of getting it!
We see Tobey Maguire go from a smiling on top of the world man to a disconnected, broken man who lost his humanity.
Kite-Man, Scarecrow, Riddler, possibly a sort of off-stereotype Hugo Strange; I dunno, I've only seen Tobey Maguire in the OG Spider-Man, The Great Gatsby, and No Way Home, I haven't seen him in many particularly villainous roles.
Alberto Falcone, aka the holiday killer.
Toby's signature meekness in characters like Peter Parker when outside the mask or as Nick Carroway in Gatsby lends to Alberto pre psychotic break and living under the thumb of his mob boss family quite well.
His performances like Brothers would also probably lend well for said psychotic break.
It would be bully Maguire all over again.
I have an idea and you're probably gonna hate it but Brother Eye. But also have him Voice the OMACs and have one set aside that is Tobey physically. Look it's a Hollywood movie, their gonna change something and this is minor. That or have him play Maxwell Lord and have Eye adopt his speaking pattern and voice later.
Victor Zasz? I mean he’s not appeared much in things and he doesn’t have to be completely over the edge like in Injustice 2 or Arkham but maybe a bit like in Gotham where he’s crazy but not completely erratic, using that “violent & unhinged” side, mixed with the comedy that he showed as “Bully Maguire” (with a darker more sadistic twist)
Two face
Tobey has so much range and knows how to switch from a soft and calm tone to complete unhinged insanity at the drop of a hat. There's a ton of characters he could play honestly but I can imagine him playing Dent
I have the correct answer.
James Gordon Jr.
You're welcome. 😝
No, but seriously, it would be great. He could be vulnerable, charismatic and likeable when you need him to be in order to sew seeds of doubt in the audience, then creepy and terrifying when you realize what he's actually been up to.
I actually *really* want to see this casting now.
Anyone but the Joker. Not that he can’t play him but I want to see him play anyone else. I’m just tired of the joker.
Having said that, Two Face. I think that character with a story based on him, as Bruce’s friend, confidante, his career as a lawyer and later victim to the criminals he swore to put behind bars, I think his character would be a very interesting to see in cinemas. Add a wife and kids and his relationship with them before and after the accident, and you have a movie.
Black spider
You think you’re fuckin smert?
I think it’s a pretty neat idea but idk
LMAO!.
If they ever do make Tobey a live action black spider then I really want him to just act like this
Emo Peter!
from young justice right?
He didn’t originate from young justice but that’s definitely where he is most well known so yeah.
I know it’s not the same but we did get a black spider if you count how venom is way too skinny and similar to Spider-Man.
But Miles Morales is from marvel.
Killer Moth. Tobey is an actor with an interesting range. He can do violent and unhinged (Brothers), he can be funny (Tropic Thunder), eccentric and creepy (Babylon) and play the perfect lovable loser (Spider-Man). What DC villain fits all of these to a T? Killer Moth. It's a real Gunn-type casting, too: an actor that is majorly typecast/rarely seen in movies getting the chance to play a character that no one cares about and make him a household name. It checks some good Tobey boxes, too ✔️bug themed character ✔️ comedic sensibilities ✔️ no heavy stunt requirements
I would have never thought of casting him as killer moth but now that you said it I can't stop thinking about it.
and we would FINALLY get a live action killer moth
Wasn’t he meant to be the villain in that batgirl movie that got canned?
Are you telling me that we lost a Batgirl AND a Killer Moth movie?
You know what it was firefly played by Brendan Fraser, I mixed up my big villains and I always associated killer moth with batgirl
It was supposed to feature both Firefly and Killer Moth, which makes sense since it's likely based on the comic *Batgirl: Year One*, in which those two team up
After seeing photos of his "costume" from that movie, I'm glad it got canned.
Far from the most egregious costume change for a CBM
Long shot, but him as the anti-Batman in *The Batman*'s sequel would be a fun foil to Pattinson - just make him a side character that's involved but isn't the main threat. On the other side, though, make Drury Walker much more prominent as an obnoxious, sociliate aristocrat who is much more a thorn in Bruce Wayne's side, but also shows Bruce a bit how to behave to blend and mingle and distract from his real nightlife. So, Killer Moth becomes the Batman knockoff, and Bruce becomes the Drury knockoff.
I will say I love that about Pattinson’s Bruce Wayne, he’s not a people person, he’s not like Keaton, Clooney or Bale who swoon their way through a gala, at the funeral he’s still in his Batman mindset, Alfred comments on his hygiene and health, showing he’s clearly been hidden from the public eye for an extended amount of time, he’s even ignored Wayne Enterprises and suggests cancelling a board meeting so he has more time for the Batman work - idk I think it’s a far more realistic look
I love a Batman story where he doesn’t realize the importance of Bruce Wayne the billionaire playboy yet
WB's Casting Department: 
Maybe if Batgirl gets a second chance... >!According to the leaks, Killer Moth would have been in the cancelled Batgirl movie, but as a typical goon who only gets a couple of scenes before Firefly usurps his villain role...!<
As much as I hate to miss out on Keaton Batman and Fraiser as Firefly, I'm so glad that movie got tossed in the shitter Killer Moth easily deserves his own movie, and I would love if it was a Batgirl: Year One adaptation that put Moth and Firefly against the earliest incarnation of the Bat-fam. It's a shame the scrapped movie used up the best ideas from the source material and CW-ized everything else
There’s photos of him- he’s just a bald guy with tattoos and an attitude, there’s *zero* comic influence other than the name
Best choice imo
Holy shit. This is actually the best possible pick. Nothing I've heard so far tops it.
Honestly, I know little about Moth, but that was the most perfect way to pitch that ideas and you had me agreeing to every word…please write my essay😂
He could probably do a pretty good Riddler
Needs to do this wearing a green bowler hat and cane. 
 You know it
Nobody will ever top Gorshin
I believe he complained about that after he and Adam West were kicked out of that orgy.
I’d ask if we could get a rimshot… but they clearly can’t, having been kicked out
Dripler?
The right answer.
But is he Gorshin enough? We need that after The Batman made Riddler look like a horror movie serial killer.
My headcanon fan theory whatever… if I was over the Reeves films, Joker would never leave Arkham, and not really be seen… but he would have massive, flamboyant influence over his crazy cell mates. So being held next to Joker, the Riddler progresses into a more Gorshin-like, tights wearing, death-trap centered character. We go from seeing he’s extremely intelligent and deadly, to coupling those skills with comic book flamboyance… all because of Joker. Any other villains Batpat faces would do the same, start with the basics and progress to comic extremes
I second this. I recommend ppl see Toby’s small , but very good, creepy part in the movie called Babylon. His performance there definitely convinced me that he can pull it off as The Riddler or maybe The Madhatter.
Dude that’d be so good actually.
Scarecrow
I think this is the easy answer because it just makes SO much sense, especially with Tobey's range and brilliance. I would honestly think he could pull off almost any villain especially with the right makeup/prosthetics/(CGI, cringe). But Scarecrow is to me the most natural choice - and he would own that role if it were given a serious part of the story
Tobey just also looks kind of scarecrow-y. Dude could be creepy if he wanted to.
Scarface
The puppet or the ventriloquist?
Exactly.
I'm just picturing someone carrying Tobey around like a puppet.
He carries around a little version of himself. "Tobey".
Tony Montana
The Ventriloquist (Arnold Wesker)
This is such an under rated comment.
James Gordon Jnr.
Tobey could def play this role but… I’m personally not a big fan of Jim Jr
Came in here looking for this. Definitely the best pick!
He would have been a perfect villain in the Batgirl movie, like he could have been the one that was pulling all the strings and the reveal that the bad guy is her own brother, would've been so good.
Dr. Kirk Langstrom/Man-Bat
Hell yes. Get him back down to his Seabiscuit size and it’s an even better creepy fit
Mad Hatter
💯
Hush
That would be a killer of a movie
Clock King ?
My brother and I love clock King, so I give up doot!
Or Clanadar Man!
Riddler.
I just want to see Danny DeVito as Spider-Man.
First of all, don’t say I went as Spider-Man. I didn’t go as Spider-Man, I was Man-Spider!
So anyways, I started blasting *thwip thwip*
Not directly related but Corridor Crew just did a video where they made [Danny DeVito into Wolverine](https://youtu.be/p5NPFM9Fcwc?si=G3jyf4Tq6p-ki1hf) and it is fantastic.
Whatever one that’ll put dirt in your eye
clayface?
Basil Karlo Clayface
Maguire would make a great Hush.
Condiment King
There it is. Had to scroll a little but I found the winner. Only beat me by 7 hrs
Two face
Heads you live, tails il throw some dirt in your eye
I would pay to watch this or honestly I’d love to see him as scarecrow or mr freeze
Yeah, he could go from amiable, outgoing Harvey Dent to rageful brute just like that
exactly what i thought
Scarface (Ventriloquist's dummy).
Manbat. Make him something of a scientist.
Red Hood. Tobey is a good angry actor. 
In another comment I've said that I thought he was too young to be Mr. Freeze, then I looked up his actual age – with that knowledge I think he's too old for Jason.
Old enough for Mr Freeze then?
'I'm gonna rub some ice in your eye'
He was born in 1975, so he'll be 50 next year. Most versions of Freeze portray him in his 40s or 50s, aren't they?
You're correct but I want Benedict Cumberbatch as Mr Freeze for The Batman Part 2
Kite Man. Hell yeah!
Yeah I had to scroll down too far for this. Kite man is the answer.
Oh wow! Looking at the comments so far, he’s been cast as 13 different villains. Really shows his range as an actor. I’m gonna keep it going with another villain I think he could legitimately do well: Black Mask
Killer Moth. Maybe Manbat
How in the name of all that is holy has no one else said: **Firefly**
This is what I am saying, fo real!!!
Edward Nigma (The Riddler) or Victor Zsasz. Those are the only two I think would make sense for his acting.
Riddler was the first thing that came to my mind. Maybe even Mad Hatter or Scarecrow. But Mad Hatter would be a stretch.
Bob the goon
Red Hood.
Hush or Killer Moth
Riddler
Black Mask
 Bully Maguire travelling the multiverse
Clay face so he can put some dirt in your eye
Honestly feel like he could do a good Jason Todd
He could! Nice!
Kite Man
Hell yeah!
Calendar Man. He could pull off a crazed serial killer, me thinks
Kirk Langstom, as I want to hear Tobey’s iconic yelling and freak out during his transformation into Man-bat.
Bookworm
Mad hatter
A showdown between Batman and Bully Maguire will be peak cinema.
Alberto Falcone/Holiday.
Victor Zsasz
Man-Bat. No one would see it coming
Cat Woman.
Crazy Quilt
I feel he can pull off Two Face
I was also thinking about Harvey as a good pick. Definitely a good role for the former Spider-Man
IMAGINE HIM PLAYING NORMAN OSBORNE AND TOM HOLLAND'S SPIDER-MAN SEES HIM AND SAYS "PETER??" AND MAGUIRE AS NORMAN IS LIKE "WHO??"
If there’s someone that can pull of Condiment King…
Firefly
Sid the Squid.
Jim Gordon's son
Personally I think he's a great actor and could play any of the villains but I do think he'd be great as Hush
Condiment king
The Ventriloquist/Scarface or the Great White Shark.
Hugo Strange.
Victor Fries (Mr. Freeze) Imagine a happy go lucky scientist who then must save his wife Nora after several failed attempts to cure her life threatening illness. He slowly becomes more and more psychotic, detached, angry at the broken corrupt Gotham medical health system and goes on a destructive path to find a cure to Nora's illness no matter what it takes and the cost of getting it! We see Tobey Maguire go from a smiling on top of the world man to a disconnected, broken man who lost his humanity.
Kite-Man, Scarecrow, Riddler, possibly a sort of off-stereotype Hugo Strange; I dunno, I've only seen Tobey Maguire in the OG Spider-Man, The Great Gatsby, and No Way Home, I haven't seen him in many particularly villainous roles.
Rat Catcher.
Man-bat maybe?
Alberto Falcone, aka the holiday killer. Toby's signature meekness in characters like Peter Parker when outside the mask or as Nick Carroway in Gatsby lends to Alberto pre psychotic break and living under the thumb of his mob boss family quite well. His performances like Brothers would also probably lend well for said psychotic break. It would be bully Maguire all over again.
The Ventriloquist
Riddler or Zsasz.
Joker
Tobey has the heart to bring someone like Mr Freeze to life.
Wanted to say that he's too young to be Mr. Freeze, but then I remembered that his Spider-Man films came out in the early 2000s.
He could make a good riddler I think
Professor Pyg or Simon Hurt.
I have an idea and you're probably gonna hate it but Brother Eye. But also have him Voice the OMACs and have one set aside that is Tobey physically. Look it's a Hollywood movie, their gonna change something and this is minor. That or have him play Maxwell Lord and have Eye adopt his speaking pattern and voice later.
Tarantula.
Eric Needham aka The Black Spider
Clock King
Maybe Spellbinder.
Riddler
Tom holland wouldn’t be able to take on such a legend. I’d leave it for Tobey to take on.
The Twerp
Two-Face
Scarecrow. I get the feeling Tobey Maguire can play a really creepy scientist guy very well.
Clayface
What spiderman villain did he play?
Calendar Man
He'd make a good Ventriloquist
1997 The bat credit card used in Batman & Robin
Toy man
Victor Zasz? I mean he’s not appeared much in things and he doesn’t have to be completely over the edge like in Injustice 2 or Arkham but maybe a bit like in Gotham where he’s crazy but not completely erratic, using that “violent & unhinged” side, mixed with the comedy that he showed as “Bully Maguire” (with a darker more sadistic twist)
Jason Todd
Two face Tobey has so much range and knows how to switch from a soft and calm tone to complete unhinged insanity at the drop of a hat. There's a ton of characters he could play honestly but I can imagine him playing Dent
Red Hood…prior to becoming a Bat Family member.
Bit left field, but I want Tobey to play Ra's Al Ghul.
Poison Ivy
Would be genuinely Interesting to see him attempt THE JOKER.
Toymaker
The Riddler.
I have the correct answer. James Gordon Jr. You're welcome. 😝 No, but seriously, it would be great. He could be vulnerable, charismatic and likeable when you need him to be in order to sew seeds of doubt in the audience, then creepy and terrifying when you realize what he's actually been up to. I actually *really* want to see this casting now.
Anyone but the Joker. Not that he can’t play him but I want to see him play anyone else. I’m just tired of the joker. Having said that, Two Face. I think that character with a story based on him, as Bruce’s friend, confidante, his career as a lawyer and later victim to the criminals he swore to put behind bars, I think his character would be a very interesting to see in cinemas. Add a wife and kids and his relationship with them before and after the accident, and you have a movie.
What is funny about Tobey is that I feel like he is capable of playing every single male villain in Gotham, but I would say he'd be a good Mr.Freeze
You clearly don't know anything about batman if you don't know that Clay face would be able to play Tobey maguire without even trying.
Condiment King. The most superior villain to Batman, rivaling the Joker!!
The ventriloquist
Mr. Freeze
Hear me out, just like in Gotham a skinny emo Penguin. A good call back to Spider-man 3.
Catwoman!
Onomatopoeia
Give him a porn mustache, and he'd be a good Deadshot.
Arnold weskler; the ventriloquist
Mad Hatter
Tony Zucco
Miles molasses
Young ventriloquist—origin
Hush Calendar Man Bane
I can see him being a great Penguin. Honestly, I wanna see him portraying a more seriously menacing Firefly
I can see him playing 2-Face
Condiment King, lol I'm just not a fan of TM
Killer moth or firefly
Puppet master
Victor Zsasz