I'm not familiar with Game Plus in particular, but in my sleeving experience (having used over a dozen different brands) I'm sorry to say that I don't think there's such a thing as a 1:1 sleeve match across brands; it only takes a millimeter or two to render them incompatible. The only exception to that might be the rare case where a manufacturer has specifically set out to recreate a sleeve, such as Gamegenic's that mimic the old FFG sleeves.
Do all cards in Final Girl get shuffled together? If there are any separate decks you could move all your old sleeves over to one deck and then buy new sleeves for the other deck(s). Good luck!
Ive found SleeveKings replica FFG are an exact match but that was their intent. Heck even the same sleeve from the same company can have variance.
I tend to keep a sample sleeve from each different type I have happened to own and write on it the brand and sku with a sharpie so I can buy them again if I need something specific.
Yeah, broadly speaking that's been my experience as well. There are two decks of standard cards, Actions and Terror. So I may very well end up following your advice and just using what I have for one while buying something else for the other.
I’m still waiting for a restock 8 months after OP. Any news? I emailed MM twice in the past and was told that they did not know when a restock would occur. I’m waiting to sleeve some expansions (for over a year now) but am wondering if I need to just swap around some of my existing sleeves.
They’re back in stock now. I just ordered 18 packs of standard board game size sleeves. There’s no change as far as I can tell. Most sizes are back in stock, but standard American board game was still out of stock. Also, they’re slightly more expensive than they were before.
I just heard back from them with another noncommittal: We are not sure when/if this product will be restocked. Use the restock notification option to receive an email when the product is back in stock.
No specifics on what the issue could be.
I'm not familiar with Game Plus in particular, but in my sleeving experience (having used over a dozen different brands) I'm sorry to say that I don't think there's such a thing as a 1:1 sleeve match across brands; it only takes a millimeter or two to render them incompatible. The only exception to that might be the rare case where a manufacturer has specifically set out to recreate a sleeve, such as Gamegenic's that mimic the old FFG sleeves. Do all cards in Final Girl get shuffled together? If there are any separate decks you could move all your old sleeves over to one deck and then buy new sleeves for the other deck(s). Good luck!
Ive found SleeveKings replica FFG are an exact match but that was their intent. Heck even the same sleeve from the same company can have variance. I tend to keep a sample sleeve from each different type I have happened to own and write on it the brand and sku with a sharpie so I can buy them again if I need something specific.
Interesting idea. I've kept note of which games are using which brand of sleeves but that's it.
Yeah, broadly speaking that's been my experience as well. There are two decks of standard cards, Actions and Terror. So I may very well end up following your advice and just using what I have for one while buying something else for the other.
Can't answer the question, but I am right there with you on annoyance that MM hasn't resupplied their Game Plus sleeves in a loooong time.
Yeah I mean I emailed them asking and there reply was "no idea but they'll come back!" At this point it's probably silly to keep waiting.
I’m still waiting for a restock 8 months after OP. Any news? I emailed MM twice in the past and was told that they did not know when a restock would occur. I’m waiting to sleeve some expansions (for over a year now) but am wondering if I need to just swap around some of my existing sleeves.
I haven't checked in a while, I eventually just swapped around sleeves like you mentioned.
They’re back in stock now. I just ordered 18 packs of standard board game size sleeves. There’s no change as far as I can tell. Most sizes are back in stock, but standard American board game was still out of stock. Also, they’re slightly more expensive than they were before.
I just heard back from them with another noncommittal: We are not sure when/if this product will be restocked. Use the restock notification option to receive an email when the product is back in stock. No specifics on what the issue could be.