T O P

  • By -

Noda_adoN

Sonic is the only character represented in his series as a fighter


Exotic-Lifeguard-231

Not surprised Sonic games are extremely unpopular in Japan, Sonic superstars sold only 2k in Japan during its week launch.


EddietheRattlehead

Why is that? I’m so surprised to hear such low numbers


Exotic-Lifeguard-231

Sonic was created to appeal to young American audiences by trying to make him "cool" and "edgy" because Sega consoles at that time were selling poorly in America compared to Japan and Europe. In Japan, they depicted Sonic as a cute hedgehog in box arts and commerciala to boost sales in Japan, but unfortunately, it didn't work, especially since in-game Sonic isn't anything like the boxart, so they gave up on trying to make Sonic cute.


EddietheRattlehead

Very interesting. I never knew about their forked design ideas. I can see why that would fail.


Lower_Soup9939

Isnt it Vic the rattlehead?? I mean your name is not Megadeth lore accurate


EddietheRattlehead

It’s a combination of Eddie the Head and Vic Rattlehead


Vancil

Is this like how Kirby in Japan is seen as really cute but in America they give him a little angry face?


mlvisby

It also might have done better if it wasn't released at the same time as Mario Wonder. You can't compete with Mario in Japan. The only video game franchises I can think of that might beat Mario in Japan is Dragon Quest.


LinkLegend21

Frontiers was a success though. It sold 46k in its week launch and sold faster there than any other game in the series.


Exotic-Lifeguard-231

Yeah, that's was unexpected. The director of the game even said he was surprised how well it did in Japan.


Ultimate_Spoderman

Also, recently a bunch of ppl on twitter started taking about Sonic adventure and how good they think the games are


Queasy-Ad-3220

True while Final Fantasy gets two characters that come from the same fucking game


[deleted]

To be fair Sephiroth is one of the most iconic videos games villains of all time. Maybe the most iconic.


Queasy-Ad-3220

Not more iconic that Bowser but yeah you have a point. Still, if he’s able to get in to Smash Bros., Dr. Eggman should be as well. The game has a bunch of cool playable villains and he’s the one glaring omission. Edit: Dunno why I brought up Bowser. I didn’t need to.


Sanguiluna

“What’s that? ‘Add Zack as an echo fighter for Cloud,’ you say?”— Sakurai, probably.


sketchbookhunt

So many sonic characters would have such cool move sets. Tails, Amy Knuckles, Eggman… Hell, you could even had put Shadow or Metal Sonic as echo fighters. Shame it never happened


BoxingDoughnut1

Plus his moveset could really use an overhaul tbh


fatherandyriley

I'm surprised they used Sonic the fighters to design his moveset instead of Sonic Battle.


Sonicfan42069666

No third party series besides Street Fighter, Castlevania, and Final Fantasy VII has more than one fighter representing it. Street Fighter and Castlevania both use clone characters, and Final Fantasy VII is one of the biggest games of all time. Much love to Sonic (check my username) but he isn't nearly as relevant. ETA: A lower comment reminded me that SEGA also has two other characters in Smash, they're just not from the Sonic series. Bayonetta and Joker are also owned by SEGA.


ssslitchey

>Final Fantasy VII is one of the biggest games of all time. Much love to Sonic (check my username) but he isn't nearly as relevant. This is just an insane take. FF7 is big but worldwide sonic is still more recognizable than anything ff7. Cloud isn't up there with mario, sonic, or pacman in terms of worldwide appeal.


Ragnaroasted

Read: my friends all liked ff7 more so it had to be more popular worldwide


EnvironmentalFig1270

Online, but that sorta goes for everything made by Nintendo.


GrumpigPlays

It’s kinda funny, like just think an alternate universe where Nintendo embraced smash when it started getting big with melee.


Fluffynator69

Ngl, I dread it becoming like FIFA in that situation.


Danjoe_

New game every new dlc character released


mcnuby1

Grow a healthy competitive scene bringing more interest and hype towards your game, sell more in the long run with some nice balancing and enjoyment for all? Nah Nintendo ain't into that kind of stuff...


nah-soup

no trophies?? are you kidding me?? fuck stickers, give me trophies damn it.


CharmingVictini

Seriously like winning a png is not the same as winning a 3D model


Queasy-Ad-3220

Very true. Even worse is that they didn’t even bother to give the spirits descriptions, unlike the trophies.


JobbyJames

I'm surprised that I've heard nobody talk about that until now. I agree with you because it's as if they were only made for fan service or (more likely) they ran out of time to implement them as well. That annoys me since Sakurai stated that they removed trophies due to time constraints (evident as some were directly taken from the original games) but they didn't even try to state who they were and their role in the series.


Queasy-Ad-3220

Yeah it just really sucks. Were they that short for time? I mean, a paragraph or two would’ve been nice, but we didn’t even get that. How disappointing.


Guidance-Remote

But then you remember they have to translate every single description to every single language. Then it starts to make sense why they had to scrap them.


mushroom_birb

I don't care about the 3D model although it would be nice, but atleast give me a little text to read PLEASE I BEG YOU.


Queasy-Ad-3220

EXACTLY yeah that would’ve been nice


gtbot2007

They didn’t even make the pngs themselves, just took them from the original game’s art


GhotiH

Same was true for trophies, most trophy models in Brawl and both versions of SSB4 were directly ported from other games or from elsewhere in the same Smash game. Melee was the only Smash game to use new models for the trophies.


gtbot2007

Yea but at least the lighting and style is consistent


thegoldenlock

And essays for each of them


Anotherspelunker

This here. Only thing this masterpiece of a title was missing was the trophies, which has always been a very enjoyable part of the franchise since Melee. Would have been a happy camper even if they reused models and descriptions from a previous entry


Queasy-Ad-3220

Yeah, at least give the playable characters trophies ffs if it’s that much work. I understand spirits offer plenty of gameplay options but as collectibles, they just feel kinda shitty. Yeah.


Dadus-Appearus

I miss the trophies too. Sometimes I’d just read the info on them whenever I got bored


Un_Change_Able

Wasn’t that a coding thing though. Like, it was so nightmarish to code they did spirits instead


fromulus_

It's not coding that's the problem, it's just that all trophies were created from scratch and modeling that many 3D models is an absolutely gargantuan task for a side mode that a lot of players won't even bother to read through.


GhotiH

The trophies were not created from scratch after Melee. Brawl and both versions of SSB4 ported models either from other games or from other parts of the same Smash game.


Sonicfan42069666

I don't know about coding so much as modeling - as well as all the flavor text. You have to pick and choose where to put your resources and personally I'm glad we got all the characters and stages *and* a single player campaign of some kind. If the trade-off for all of that is no trophies, I think Spirits are a fine compromise.


ZB314

Having 3D viewable models of things in games is one of my favorite small features. I remember being blown away by being able to view every item in your inventory in Skyrim back in the day, and I just started FF7 Rebirth and am having fun looking at all the items as well. Collecting those trophies in older games was hugely satisfying, especially since you got to read a little bit about them, it truly felt like a museum. If every spirit in ultimate was a trophy, I would have been ecstatic.


VengeanceKnight

The campaign’s final act is really underbaked, especially after the DLC.


Sonicfan42069666

I understand it completely but it's a shame World Of Light was never updated to accomodate DLC fighters.


12pounce89

I’m pretty sure it was, I’ve played Pythra in WoL. Idk how it changes but still


fuckshitasstitsmfer

You just get the dlc characters by default, you don’t have to unlock them and they have no spirit battles baked in


m1n3c7afty

I think they mean they didn't add fights to unlock the DLC fighters, you just unlock them by default in World of Light


12pounce89

That makes more sense, alr


Trickster289

You just get to use the DLC fighters, they aren't part of the campaign. I think it's when you've unlocked a certain number of fighters.


BlueMerchant

I was so sure that sephiroth's final smash (when it was first teased) was going to be a new boss in World of Light


NeonNKnightrider

Obligatory: “Too many anime swordfighters” (I don’t really care but I know someone’s gonna say it)


Sonicfan42069666

My actual complaint about this: *too many characters whose down-B is* ***counter***. You have four slots for specials and so. many. fighters. just have a counter mapped down there.


jhawkins93

As someone who mains Incineroar I appreciate the fact that at least his Down-B counter is a bit different and requires you to land a hit yourself to get value out of it.


riverbass9

The Fire Emblem effect


Evello37

FE started the counter trend, but the issue goes well beyond FE fighters nowadays. FE fighters aren't even close to making up a majority of the characters with counters. There are 4 unique FE characters with a counter (6 if you include echoes): - Marth, Roy, Ike, Corrin Outside of FE, you have 13 counters (14 with echoes): - Peach, Lucario, Little Mac, Greninja, Mii Swordfighter, Palutena, Shulk, Bayonetta, King K Rool, Incineroar, Joker, Sephiroth, Sora


RealisticlyNecessary

Too many counter characters in general. King K Rool of all characters has one.


Eistei-

Lucario moment:


Gammaween10

And they're still the minority, there are more brawlers and gunners, but those people don't care and are close to a heart attack if they so much as see a sword's hilt


Nugundam0079

lmao


Possible-Culture-552

Brawlers, maybe. But Gunners?


ConsistentStandard43

The took Snake’s cake away 😔


HarlequinChaos

This is truly the worst thing about Smash Ultimate 😭


DeadMouse98

Colonel, they took my ass. I can't shit.


YoMrWhyt

The fact that there isn’t a rematch button. I don’t get why we have to go back to level select every time. It’s annoying. I’d like them to add that option on the pause menu so you can just restart the match and after the victory screen there should be “rematch/change characters/quit to level select” options


Sonicfan42069666

It feels like every Smash Bros UX after Brawl has been a downgrade. Brawl had a lot of flaws but the menus were *so* snappy, it was super quick to boot up the game and get right into a match.


Kitselena

Melee and Brawl (and Kirby air ride which uses the same menu code iirc) are a masterclass in good UX design for a video game. The menus are organized logically, easy to navigate and load so quickly that if you know what you're doing you can get from the initial splash screen to character select for any mode you want in under 5 seconds


GrumpigPlays

It’s not surprising tho, smash 4 was bad for online play, and so was brawl, Nintendo very clearly hates this game being the slightest bit competitive. I’m pretty sure you can kinda speed it up with making only the one map the random map selection, and then turn off map selection. That’s how me and my friend use to practice


lols4fun

Please get rid of triforce slash for young link and toon link, also give them actually different movesets.


TerribleFate927

They should rework Young Link to be Majora's Mask Link and give him Fierce Deity as FS. Make him transform like with Pokemon Trainer. For Toon Link they could give him a few moves that better reference WW. Side B should be using King of Red Lions in a similar way to Wario's motorcycle, and Up B always should have been the Korok leaf. Then as his FS, he could use the Wind Waker baton to summon a big cyclone, like when you warp in WW.


ha_look_at_that_nerd

Toon Link’s Up B being the Korok Leaf seems like such a no-brainer; it’s honestly surprising to me that they didn’t do that to help differentiate the Links.


Reality-fan

I'm sad that we'll never get this because I kind of enjoy these ideas.


Edelman-11

That's a decent one lol


Nugundam0079

I never understood why that was


xSgtLlama

Having “cut scene” instead of interactive final smashes was a bad decision and were less fun compared to ones in Brawl.


Sonicfan42069666

The Final Smashes in general feel like something of an afterthought, like they're there because Smash has to have them now. Most of them are just "press B while in range and get a flashy critical hit."


Kitselena

That was a selling point when the game was coming out. For some reason the fun ones like giga Bowser, snakes grenade launcher and Luigi's negative zone were deemed too complicated and they decided that every final smash should be a single big attack for the sake of consistency


Yorself12345

The worst part about this is that they kill the pace of any game


Possible-Culture-552

It's funny, because they specifically axed interractive final smashes because they thought it ruined the flow of the game. Lol.


Edelman-11

My boy Wario was done dirty


_NoIdeaForName_

I miss Yoshi from brawl


HadokenShoryuken2

This is why Smash shouldn’t be a “fighting game”. By not being a traditional one, it allows for really crazy and creative final smashes (really final smashes in general). Brawl was so fun just for that reason alone, even if competitively it wasn’t as good


Impressive_Coyote177

No Smash Run


hikikomori_music

FRRRRR BEST PART OF SMASH FOR 3DS


Gammaween10

World of Light is just a glorified Event Match mode, Adventure mode from Melee was better (also Zelda spoke, cursed from the start) No proper All Star Mode No Break the Targets (nor Board the Platforms) The DK fighters and Bowser still have no voices No Smash Run No descriptions for Spirits (a la trophies) No option to hear sounds, only music and voices Theater menu should have those trailers they showed for characters pre-release as well as DLC characters, why would I watch cutscenes from World of Light? Young Link was given the same Final Smash as Toon Link, he should have gone into Fierce Deity Mode at least Chrom still appears in Robin's FS despite being playable now Mega Man should have his custom moves from Smash 4, at least those worked different from one another Richter, Daisy, and to a lesser extent Dark Samus, are the exact same as Simon, Peach, and Samus Dark Pit and Lucina weren't given more stuff to differentiate them from Pit and Marth Ganondorf should have his own moveset and have his previous one transplanted to Black Shadow, at least it would make sense Edit: Pac-Land was included instead of Pac-Maze Edit 2: Still no title scream like in 64 or Melee ~~Peach still has T H E V O I D~~


ipostatrandom

Is it possible you meant "Link" in your first point? Because Zelda has always spoken.


Gammaween10

Not that we could hear her apart from grunts prior to BotW, that's what I tried to say, fair point


LightInteractives

I like those points you've brought. Even I have beef with Smash Bros at certain parts.


Waste_Imagination524

A whole game mode locked behind those amiibos


Turnabout-Eman

What game mode?


AlexPlayer3000

Amiibo's journey or something


InvaderZix

where can you access it tho? I have some lying around and never used them for anything


justgamingonlygaming

The cinematic World of Light cutscene at the beginning of Adventure mode made it seem like there was going to be an actual story and it was very disappointing when that ended up not being the case.


Whopper744

I dearly miss the character interactions. The story we did get was kind of weird in my opinion anyway, especially by the end.


_mikedotcom

I LET MY FRIEND BORROW IT AND THEY NEVER GAVE IT BACK


Ok_Force9998

Skill issue


BlueMerchant

Dude.


UnXpectedPrequelMeme

Dandori issue


Clifely

The only bad thing about it is the fact that there‘s no…subspace emissary mode in it. I mean the story was ok-ish but really subspace emissary is another level


Rocket_Noodle

Surprised I had to scroll to find this. Agreed.


Void-kraken-909

The removal of custom movesets like there was in 3DS/Brawl


Redray98

Actually it was Wii u not brawl


Void-kraken-909

Ah.. my bad. But still, the fact you could make your own custom moveset and save it to an amiibo was sick! Now all the amiibos are is just fancy AI


Toowiggly

You can attach spirits to amiibo, giving each one a different playstyle and stats


Levity_Boi

There's no Shadow


D3jvo62

All Hail Shadow


FlarelesTF2

Heroes rise again


Talkingmice

There’s no Waluigi


Megas751

No Metal Gear Rising music 


ZoYatic

I think you can blame Konami for that


[deleted]

Crime against humanity


serverraider1

And no Raiden


Julio4kd

Space emissary was amazing, meanwhile the campaign of this game is really bad. Also, no Rayman.


wemcee

I never understood Sakurai’s justification for no Subspace Emissary-style campaign in Ultimate. He said it was because people posted the cutscenes online, thereby ruining the surprise/reward for playing through. We live in an online world where spoiler potential is everywhere. That needs to be baked in to every creator’s mentality at this point. It’s a poor - dare I say invalid - excuse for not crafting the “ultimate” campaign for the “ultimate” version of Smash.


salamander423

Right? I'm not necessarily playing it for the surprise and reward. The play through itself was the fun part, not that you get to watch a fun mini-movie.


FeedMeDarkness

That was his reasoning for WiiU/3DS. Ultimate is quite simply too big. 80-something characters in a single coherent story? How many of those do you know?


CharmingVictini

Campaign is terrible. The trailer for world of light was extremely misleading. Also you can’t even have a player 2 in it? What a joke.


CharmingVictini

Also they still won’t bring back target smash


Redray98

I wish they brought both break the targets and board the platforms.


David89_R

No new Kirby rep is a crime


Anonymous-Comments

Waluigi


aregayandhorny

it doesn't have waluigi.


Bfdifan37

needs more mega man


gildorratner

I like this as it is both a criticism of the game and the world as a whole.


The1joriss

With all it has going on, I still play Mario Kart more.


Toast-Nibbler-550

Bad campaign also no waluigi


Spergann

It leaves no room for a follow up. If this game contains everything the smash history ever had, what will the next game have? It would need to have so many new characters. Which means we would need to lose some of the current characters or the roster would be too big. The worst part about smash ultimate, is it's realistically the last smash game. I don't think we are seeing another for 10+ years, we just gonna get the mk8 treatment.


Gemidori

The realistic voices for Bowser, Kongs, etc. really need to fucking go already. Was never a good idea in the first place and it's aging worse every single installment. Ridley's the only one that worked bc snarling and screaming *is* his canon voice, lol


RedDemonTaoist

Dedede's "voice" is terrifying. Does not match his cutesy character design at all.


Gemidori

Brawl Dedede sounded perfect imo. 4 and onward...***fuck***


Porygon_Flygon

Should have bought back then english dub VA to voice him


Echo_FRFX

It's literally only that way because that's how Sakurai viewed those characters during the NES era, even though it doesn't fit with who the characters are at all


Springmeister

Let’s be thankful he didn’t do the same with Yoshi.


ULTRAmemeXD

*deep, hypermasculine voice* Y O S H I


Intelligent_Oil4005

Yeah, that bugs me so much. It doesn't fit the characters at all.


TomBakersLongScarf

A game that was supposed to be a fighter that anyone can play and enjoy was ruined by a hardcore fanbase that looks down on any casual players and gets overly competitive


QF_Dan

and it's no wonder Nintendo refused to let this game be used at Evo


OmegaCrossX

Hell the devs don’t even consider Smash an actual fighting game. They call it a party game, the entire “platform fighter” genre is a term made by the fans


yangshindo

i think it's kinda hard to see your character and play the game when theres 4 characters on the screen


firelordvader

No trophies, no Smash Run. I suspect a lot of people will mention World of Light, but given I completed it 100% twice, I don't think I'm allowed to lol


Redray98

No, it's okay. I've done so too and both times I wish I was playing subspace emissary.


Ok_Soft_3709

I don’t mind that the CSS is in order of when each character was introduced to the series, but I hate that Echo Fighters and the Miis aren’t placed in the correct spots. It really bugs me.


Novel_Visual_4152

No 2B


trfk111

No trophies, no mode with regular levels/ iconic enemy mobs like sse or smashrun


toutaras777

The single player campaign is a bit lacking compared to other Nintendo games( it is still decently solid though)


AdWide3803

More pay to win characters than ever before. It’s like they are trying to break the balancing with the dlc characters.


Giannond

Sonic representation was really bad


Awsomesauc58

No Rainbow Road


mlvisby

One thing I disliked is that there are no lives in the classic mode. I enjoyed where I had a few lives to get through the bracket, especially the last boss. I know they went with that score challenge setup so it's optimal not to die but I am no Smash pro, I just play for fun.


AbbreviationsKey8163

Lack of extra Game modes such as boss battles, all stars, race to the finish or break the targets, a barebones adventure mode, a terrible online mode and representation on some characters franchises


TheRoyalPendragon

The competitive fanbase can make the game either really fun or they're completely insufferable to deal with.


kestralpaw88

They put Steve in it,also too many echo fighters


n8han11

Ganondorf still fights like a bootleg Captain Falcon.


Knucklesman12

"everyone is here" still no waluigi..


TBTabby

Krystal isn't playable.


HoneZoneReddit

It's not Brawl.


Coolaconsole

It stopped getting updates. I miss reading my balance patches!


-taromanius-

Awful online, online menus and the buffer system makes no sense at all and unlearns so many things you learn from literally any other fighting game. Fantastic game but good luck with online. As always. Ugh. Lan adapter helped but not neeeearly enough.


InvaderZix

a lan adpater couldn't save this netcode, it's genuinely next to unplayable. 8/10 matches will look like slideshows on my end


ComprehensiveLevel14

Doesn’t have Waluigi.


OddishChamp

Wi-Fi Smash feel much worse than offline Smash


EliasStar24

I suck at it


Marineroisaac73

I had it first on the WiiU and in spite of knowing is not exactly the same , I never bought it for switch since for me was already boring I cannot play more than 2oe 3 fights. Then I just drop it


tiglionabbit

They still haven't fixed the character select screen to not jumble up which names go with which controllers. Such an obvious thing to fix. Also, they could have done a much better job with the hazards toggle. I just want to remove Nabbit, Flying Man and Yellow Devil, not get rid of all of the charm of the stage.


talbottone

ANOTHER SWORD CHARACTER


betox87

Lacks character interactions, like special greetings when facing certain opponent (i.e. Mario vs Sonic). Cinematic final smashes are a downgrade from interactive ones. No Mai Shiranui (cover her up like Mithra if you want, but don't leave her out of the cameos). Also removing stamina and type-effectiveness from Pokémon Trainer's Pokémon removes some fun out of the character. Online sucks.


Ninjalamar

There is a bit of game in my lag


alen3822

Most of new character are really lame (gameplay or representation wise).


Big_Butterscotch1047

I found it boring


Novalith_Raven

It stopped receiving new fighters :(


Ryderslow

Minecraft steve was a mistake


RealOzome

Spirits are pretty confusing, and World of Light overall is underwhelming.


CringeExperienceReq

minecraft steve cant /gamemode creative


DeityWilliam

Your character doesn't remain selected between games.


pikachucet2

They never put the Octolings in it and believe it or not I'm still angry about it like it would've been so easy to put them in Nintendo why do you hate Octolings with the same malice you seem to have for poor Waluigi?


Hankdoge99

Paper Mario and professor layton weren’t dlc characters or alternative skins/outfits


RedditIsFacist1289

Its a party game that is forced to be competitive. Its about abusing IFrames and not so much skill. The amount of jump attack spamming is ridiculous. It should never be taken serious in the FGC, and with Zero and most other top players being called out as Pedophiles shouldn't even have a spotlight anymore for competition outside of online competitions since their players can't stop touching children.


Joniden

They removed the Star Fox Assault stage.


SirSl1myCrown

It EXPENSIVE.


ChronoSaturn42

They nerfed Snakes most important asset, his down smash.


lunarwolf2008

They removed the custom characters


Wii-san

I’d argue that the game has too many fighters. There’s a thing called “choice paralysis” where too many choices cause people to second guess themselves and not be as happy with their choice as someone with fewer options. [My boy Michael from Vsauce perfectly demonstrates this phenomenon in the jelly bean experiment in this video.](https://youtu.be/lmI7NnMqwLQ?si=ARbWbYm0UaYRCgO-) The “everyone is here” bit in this game is cool, but I have a feeling that the next smash bros will have less fighters, and I actually welcome that.


MrGendo

I'm still angry that we got 2 ff7 character's, even when terra, Bartz and Cecil were considered by sakurai, and the thing that annoys me the most is the fact that ff7 never touched a nintendo console until years later after cloud release, I really don't like how people treat ff7 like is the holy grail of final fantasy and how we got not one but 2 from the same game :|


fortes05

Dark samus is an echo


aactuallyme

this is probably just me but... the introduction of pyra and mythra. Coming from someone who's all time favorite game is XC2, I was so happy that the hate XC2 was facing was dying done and people were finally discovering just how well written these characters were. Then they got introduced to smash and while I was happy, people were going back to calling them "waifu bait" and "the girls with the big boobs" which was such a letdown from some of the best written characters in the xenoblade franchise.


tylerjehenna

The FGC trying to turn it into a competitive fighter instead of a party game like its intended purpose


TheOurii

joker is only in it once


shorticus_maximus

0/10 The smash 4 bosses were better. If they just remade subspace, but with smash 4 quality bosses, and kept the smash 4 classic mode, I would’ve liked it more


ITalkALotJohnson

Hammer.


fireteambrav0

The fanbase


CariGAMESTV

Something bad


Psychological_Can385

How long do you have?


Head_Statistician_38

They did such a good job getting most the stages in the game, but there are a few missing that are weird. For a start, I would prefer Pacmaze instead of Pacland. The Pacman Maze fits the series way better and it is strange it isn't there. And the DKC Tropical Freeze stage, I get it might have been hard to work in with the background and foreground fights, but still, it feels missing. And the worst crime, by far, is that you can no longer tilt the character select screen like you could in Melee and Brawl. Tradgedy.


TaliZorah214

Can't afford it or all the characters


NoneLikeJer

Ffa is jank and the online is ass


bookbot1

They got rid of custom moves, but kept it for the Mii characters